Kosta Shatrov1,2, Camilla Pessina1, Kaspar Huber3, Bernhard Thomet4, Andreas Gutzeit5,6,7, Carl Rudolf Blankart1,2. 1. KPM Center for Public Management, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland. 2. Swiss Institute for Translational and Entrepreneurial Medicine, Bern, Switzerland. 3. Hirslanden Klinik St. Anna, Lucerne, Switzerland. 4. Corporate Office, Hirslanden AG, Glattpark, Switzerland. 5. Department of Radiology, Paracelsus Medical University, Salzburg, Austria. 6. Department of Chemistry and Applied Biosciences, Institute of Pharmaceutical Sciences, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland. 7. Institute of Radiology and Nuclear Medicine and Breast Center St. Anna, Hirslanden Klinik St. Anna, Lucerne, Switzerland.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Kaizen-a management technique increasingly employed in health care-enables employees, regardless of their hierarchy level, to contribute to the improvement of their organization. The approach puts special emphasis on frontline employees because it represents one of their main opportunities to participate directly in decision making. In this study, we aimed to (1) understand the experiences of nurses in two hospitals that had recently implemented kaizen, and (2) identify factors affecting the implementation of the technique. METHODS: By means of purposeful sampling, we selected 30 nurses from different units in two private acute care hospitals in Switzerland in May 2018. We used the Organizational Transformation Model to conduct semi-structured interviews and perform qualitative content analysis. Lastly, originating from Herzberg's motivation theory, we suggest two types of factor influencing the implementation of kaizen-hygiene factors that may prevent nurses from getting demotivated, and motivational factors that may boost their motivation. RESULTS: Nurses generally experienced kaizen as a positive practice that enabled them to discuss work-related activities in a more comprehensive manner. In some cases, however, a lack of visible improvement in the workplace lowered nurses' motivation to make suggestions. Nurses' attitudes towards kaizen differed across both hospitals depending on the available managerial support, resources such as infrastructure and staffing levels. CONCLUSIONS: From our findings, we derived several coping strategies to help health practitioners implement kaizen for the benefit of their organization and employees: Strong managerial support, appropriate use of kaizen tools, and a greater sense of team cohesion, among other factors, can influence how effectively hospital teams implement kaizen. To reap the benefits of kaizen, hospital managers should promote the exchange of opinions across hierarchy levels, allocate the necessary resources in terms of personnel and infrastructure, and show nurses how the technique can help them improve their workplace.
BACKGROUND: Kaizen-a management technique increasingly employed in health care-enables employees, regardless of their hierarchy level, to contribute to the improvement of their organization. The approach puts special emphasis on frontline employees because it represents one of their main opportunities to participate directly in decision making. In this study, we aimed to (1) understand the experiences of nurses in two hospitals that had recently implemented kaizen, and (2) identify factors affecting the implementation of the technique. METHODS: By means of purposeful sampling, we selected 30 nurses from different units in two private acute care hospitals in Switzerland in May 2018. We used the Organizational Transformation Model to conduct semi-structured interviews and perform qualitative content analysis. Lastly, originating from Herzberg's motivation theory, we suggest two types of factor influencing the implementation of kaizen-hygiene factors that may prevent nurses from getting demotivated, and motivational factors that may boost their motivation. RESULTS: Nurses generally experienced kaizen as a positive practice that enabled them to discuss work-related activities in a more comprehensive manner. In some cases, however, a lack of visible improvement in the workplace lowered nurses' motivation to make suggestions. Nurses' attitudes towards kaizen differed across both hospitals depending on the available managerial support, resources such as infrastructure and staffing levels. CONCLUSIONS: From our findings, we derived several coping strategies to help health practitioners implement kaizen for the benefit of their organization and employees: Strong managerial support, appropriate use of kaizen tools, and a greater sense of team cohesion, among other factors, can influence how effectively hospital teams implement kaizen. To reap the benefits of kaizen, hospital managers should promote the exchange of opinions across hierarchy levels, allocate the necessary resources in terms of personnel and infrastructure, and show nurses how the technique can help them improve their workplace.
Authors: Ryan M Collar; Andrew G Shuman; Sandra Feiner; Amy K McGonegal; Natalie Heidel; Mary Duck; Scott A McLean; John E Billi; David W Healy; Carol R Bradford Journal: J Am Coll Surg Date: 2012-06 Impact factor: 6.113
Authors: Carol VanDeusen Lukas; Sally K Holmes; Alan B Cohen; Joseph Restuccia; Irene E Cramer; Michael Shwartz; Martin P Charns Journal: Health Care Manage Rev Date: 2007 Oct-Dec
Authors: Steve New; Mohammed Hadi; Sharon Pickering; Eleanor Robertson; Lauren Morgan; Damian Griffin; Gary Collins; Oliver Rivero-Arias; Ken Catchpole; Peter McCulloch Journal: PLoS One Date: 2016-04-28 Impact factor: 3.240