Katherine M Reitz1, Patrick R Varley1, Nathan L Liang1,2, Ada Youk3,4, Elizabeth L George5, Myrick C Shinall6, Paula K Shireman7,8,9, Shipra Arya5, Edith Tzeng1,2,10, Daniel E Hall1,2,3,11. 1. Department of Surgery, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. 2. Division of Vascular Surgery, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. 3. Center for Health Equity Research and Promotion, Veterans Affairs Pittsburgh Healthcare System, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. 4. Department of Biostatistics, Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. 5. Division of Vascular Surgery, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California. 6. Department of Surgery, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, Tennessee. 7. Department of Surgery, University of Texas Health San Antonio, San Antonio, Texas. 8. Department of Surgery, South Texas Veterans Health Care System, San Antonio, Texas. 9. University Health System, San Antonio, Texas. 10. Department of Vascular Surgery, Veterans Affairs Pittsburgh Healthcare System, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. 11. Wolff Center, UPMC, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Assess the relationships between case total work relative value units (wRVU), patient frailty, and the physiologic stress of surgical interventions. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Surgeon reimbursement is frequently apportioned by wRVU. These subjective, procedure-specific valuations generated by physician survey estimate the intensity and time for typical patient care services. We hypothesized wRVU would not adequately account for patient-specific factors, such as frailty, that modify the required physician work, regardless of procedural complexity. METHODS: Using National and Veterans Affairs Surgical Quality Improvement Programs (2015-2018), we evaluated the correlation between case total wRVU, patient frailty (risk analysis index) and physiologic surgical stress (operative stress score). RESULTS: Of 4,111,371 (86%) cases, the correlation between total wRVU and operative stress was moderate [ρs = 0.587 (95% confidence interval, 0.586-0.587)], but negligible with frailty ρ = 0.177 (95% confidence interval, 0.176-0.178)]. Very high operative stress procedures [n = 34,047 (1%)] generated a mean total wRVU of 55.1 (standard deviation, 12.9), comprising 7%, 2%, and 1% of thoracic, vascular, and general surgical cases, respectively. Very frail patients [n = 152,535 (4%)] accounted for 9% of thoracic, 9% of vascular, 4% of general, 5% of urologic, and 4% of neurologic surgical cases, generating 21.0 (standard deviation, 12.4) mean total wRVU. Some nonfrail patients undergoing low operative stress procedures [n = 60,128 (2%)] nonetheless generated the highest quintile wRVU; these comprised >15% of plastic, gynecologic, and urologic surgical cases. CONCLUSIONS: Surgeon reimbursement correlates with operative stress but not patient frailty. The total wRVU does not adequately reflect patient-specific factors that increase the physician workload required to render optimal care to complex patients.
OBJECTIVE: Assess the relationships between case total work relative value units (wRVU), patient frailty, and the physiologic stress of surgical interventions. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Surgeon reimbursement is frequently apportioned by wRVU. These subjective, procedure-specific valuations generated by physician survey estimate the intensity and time for typical patient care services. We hypothesized wRVU would not adequately account for patient-specific factors, such as frailty, that modify the required physician work, regardless of procedural complexity. METHODS: Using National and Veterans Affairs Surgical Quality Improvement Programs (2015-2018), we evaluated the correlation between case total wRVU, patient frailty (risk analysis index) and physiologic surgical stress (operative stress score). RESULTS: Of 4,111,371 (86%) cases, the correlation between total wRVU and operative stress was moderate [ρs = 0.587 (95% confidence interval, 0.586-0.587)], but negligible with frailty ρ = 0.177 (95% confidence interval, 0.176-0.178)]. Very high operative stress procedures [n = 34,047 (1%)] generated a mean total wRVU of 55.1 (standard deviation, 12.9), comprising 7%, 2%, and 1% of thoracic, vascular, and general surgical cases, respectively. Very frail patients [n = 152,535 (4%)] accounted for 9% of thoracic, 9% of vascular, 4% of general, 5% of urologic, and 4% of neurologic surgical cases, generating 21.0 (standard deviation, 12.4) mean total wRVU. Some nonfrail patients undergoing low operative stress procedures [n = 60,128 (2%)] nonetheless generated the highest quintile wRVU; these comprised >15% of plastic, gynecologic, and urologic surgical cases. CONCLUSIONS: Surgeon reimbursement correlates with operative stress but not patient frailty. The total wRVU does not adequately reflect patient-specific factors that increase the physician workload required to render optimal care to complex patients.
Authors: Mira Shiloach; Stanley K Frencher; Janet E Steeger; Katherine S Rowell; Kristine Bartzokis; Majed G Tomeh; Karen E Richards; Clifford Y Ko; Bruce L Hall Journal: J Am Coll Surg Date: 2009-11-22 Impact factor: 6.113
Authors: Daniel E Hall; Shipra Arya; Kendra K Schmid; Mark A Carlson; Pierre Lavedan; Travis L Bailey; Georgia Purviance; Tammy Bockman; Thomas G Lynch; Jason M Johanning Journal: JAMA Surg Date: 2017-03-01 Impact factor: 14.766
Authors: Courtney J Balentine; Aanand D Naik; David H Berger; Herbert Chen; Daniel A Anaya; Gregory D Kennedy Journal: JAMA Surg Date: 2016-08-01 Impact factor: 14.766
Authors: Elizabeth L George; Daniel E Hall; Ada Youk; Rui Chen; Aditi Kashikar; Amber W Trickey; Patrick R Varley; Paula K Shireman; Myrick C Shinall; Nader N Massarweh; Jason Johanning; Shipra Arya Journal: JAMA Surg Date: 2021-01-13 Impact factor: 14.766
Authors: Myrick C Shinall; Ada Youk; Nader N Massarweh; Paula K Shireman; Shipra Arya; Elizabeth L George; Daniel E Hall Journal: JAMA Netw Open Date: 2020-07-01
Authors: Patrick R Varley; Jeffrey D Borrebach; Shipra Arya; Nader N Massarweh; Andrew L Bilderback; Mary Kay Wisniewski; Joel B Nelson; Jonas T Johnson; Jason M Johanning; Daniel E Hall Journal: Ann Surg Date: 2021-12-01 Impact factor: 13.787