Xiaoran Hu1, Tian Zeng1, Corey C Husic1, Maxwell J Robb1. 1. Division of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California 91125, United States.
Abstract
Polymers that release functional small molecules in response to mechanical force are appealing targets for drug delivery, sensing, catalysis, and many other applications. Mechanically sensitive molecules called mechanophores are uniquely suited to enable molecular release with excellent selectivity and control, but mechanophore designs capable of releasing cargo with diverse chemical functionality are limited. Here, we describe a general and highly modular mechanophore platform based on masked 2-furylcarbinol derivatives that spontaneously decompose under mild conditions upon liberation via a mechanically triggered reaction, resulting in the release of a covalently installed molecular payload. We identify key structure-property relationships for the reactivity of 2-furylcarbinol derivatives that enable the mechanically triggered release of functionally diverse molecular cargo with release kinetics being tunable over several orders of magnitude. In particular, the incorporation of an electron-donating phenoxy group on the furan ring in combination with an α-methyl substituent dramatically lowers the activation barrier for fragmentation, providing a highly active substrate for molecular release. Moreover, we find that phenoxy substitution enhances the thermal stability of the mechanophore without adversely affecting its mechanochemical reactivity. The generality and efficacy of this molecular design platform are demonstrated using ultrasound-induced mechanical force to trigger the efficient release of a broad scope of cargo molecules, including those bearing alcohol, phenol, alkylamine, arylamine, carboxylic acid, and sulfonic acid functional groups.
Polymers that release functional small molecules in response to mechanical force are appealing targets for drug delivery, sensing, catalysis, and many other applications. Mechanically sensitive molecules called mechanophores are uniquely suited to enable molecular release with excellent selectivity and control, but mechanophore designs capable of releasing cargo with diverse chemical functionality are limited. Here, we describe a general and highly modular mechanophore platform based on masked 2-furylcarbinol derivatives that spontaneously decompose under mild conditions upon liberation via a mechanically triggered reaction, resulting in the release of a covalently installed molecular payload. We identify key structure-property relationships for the reactivity of 2-furylcarbinol derivatives that enable the mechanically triggered release of functionally diverse molecular cargo with release kinetics being tunable over several orders of magnitude. In particular, the incorporation of an electron-donating phenoxy group on the furan ring in combination with an α-methyl substituent dramatically lowers the activation barrier for fragmentation, providing a highly active substrate for molecular release. Moreover, we find that phenoxy substitution enhances the thermal stability of the mechanophore without adversely affecting its mechanochemical reactivity. The generality and efficacy of this molecular design platform are demonstrated using ultrasound-induced mechanical force to trigger the efficient release of a broad scope of cargo molecules, including those bearing alcohol, phenol, alkylamine, arylamine, carboxylic acid, and sulfonic acid functional groups.
Polymers
that release functional molecules in response to a specific
stimulus are desirable for a variety of applications including sensing,
catalysis, self-healing, and targeted drug delivery.[1−3] Mechanically triggered release is a particularly appealing target.
To this end, several different approaches have been demonstrated,
including physically entrapped payloads within a polymeric matrix,[4] dissociation of supramolecular assemblies,[5,6] and the use of fluid-filled microcapsules[7] or vascular networks[8] embedded within
a material that release their payload after being ruptured. Recently,
the use of mechanical force as an external stimulus to drive covalent
chemical transformations has emerged as an attractive strategy.[9] Force is typically transduced via polymer chains
to mechanically sensitive molecules known as mechanophores that respond
in a chemoselective fashion, resulting in a productive chemical reaction.[10,11] In the context of targeted drug delivery, for example, ultrasound
is capable of penetrating deep within biological tissues to stimulate
mechanochemical transformations noninvasively with spatial and temporal
precision.[12] In light of these advantages,
the field of polymer mechanochemistry has attracted significant interest
for the design of autonomous materials that respond innately to mechanically
dynamic environments,[3] as well as abundant
opportunities to advance the fundamental understanding of mechanochemical
reactivity, which is underdeveloped in comparison to other areas of
organic chemistry.[13]Several mechanophores
have been designed to achieve the mechanically
triggered release of functional organic molecules, although the scope
of molecules that can be released is still relatively limited. Moore
and Craig have designed mechanophores based on gem-dichlorocyclopropane motifs that undergo mechanochemical rearrangement
reactions with subsequent release of HCl.[14,15] Boydston has developed mechanophores based on a flex-activation
manifold demonstrating release of a benzyl furfuryl ether molecule
via a mechanically induced cycloelimination reaction[16,17] and the release of N-heterocyclic carbenes.[18] Notably, each approach uses a judiciously designed mechanophore
to release a specific compound upon mechanical activation, which consequently
limits the scope of molecules that can be released. Small-molecule
release has also been achieved through the mechanically triggered
heterolytic scission and subsequent depolymerization of poly(o-phthalaldehyde) to regenerate its constituent monomers.[19,20] Finally, Herrmann and Göstl have introduced an elegant mechanophore
design that relies on the mechanically activated reduction[21,22] of a chain-centered disulfide unit and ensuing 5-exo-trig cyclization to release an alcohol attached
via a β-carbonate linker.[5,23] While the release of
several different alcohols has been successfully demonstrated using
this disulfide mechanophore platform, it is susceptible to nonspecific
activation via chemical reduction or thiol exchange and the cargo
scope appears to be somewhat limited, as indicated by the low release
efficiency observed for amine payloads.[24]In 2019, our group reported a strategy for molecular release
via
a mechanically triggered cascade reaction in which a mechanochemical
retro-Diels–Alder reaction unveils an unstable furfuryl carbonate
motif that subsequently decomposes under mild conditions to release
its molecular payload. The mechanically triggered release of the fluorescent
probe 7-hydroxy-4-methylcoumarin was demonstrated to occur efficiently
at room temperature with a half-life (t1/2) on the order of 1 h following mechanical activation (Scheme a).[25] The α-methyl group on the furfuryl carbonate was a key structural
feature that enabled relatively fast release of hydroxycoumarin, presumably
due to stabilization of the developing positive charge in the transition
state leading to the secondary furfuryl cation intermediate.[26,27] This general strategy relies on the concept of mechanically gated
reactivity,[28] in which the mechanochemical
reaction is decoupled from the ultimate functional response, and follows
our earlier conceptualization of mechanically gated photoswitching.[29] This paradigm offers a powerful approach for
the design of highly modular systems, as the mechanochemical behavior
of the mechanophore and the functional properties of the masked intermediate
can be controlled independently. While the molecular design strategy
is promising, our first-generation mechanophore is nevertheless limited
to the release of phenols and a more general platform capable of releasing
functionally diverse molecular cargo on reasonable time scales is
desired.
Scheme 1
Mechanically Triggered Molecular Release via a Retro-Diels–Alder/Fragmentation
Cascade
Here we investigate the effect
of substitution on the reactivity
of 2-furylcarbinol derivatives, identifying structure–activity
relationships (SAR) that enable the mechanically triggered release
of functionally diverse molecular payloads from a second-generation
mechanophore platform (Scheme b). Using density functional theory (DFT) calculations to
guide molecular design, we demonstrate that the rate of molecular
release is significantly modulated by varying the substitution of
the 2-furylcarbinol scaffold. In particular, substitution at the 3-position
of the furan ring with an electron-donating phenoxy group, combined
with an α-methyl substituent, renders a highly reactive substrate
for molecular release. Masked 2-furylcarbinol derivatives are incorporated
into polymers and activated using ultrasound to achieve the mechanically
triggered release of alkyl/aryl alcohols and amines and further extended
to cargo molecules containing carboxylic acid and sulfonic acid functional
groups conjugated to the mechanophore via carboxylate and sulfonate
linkages.
Results and Discussion
Furfuryl carbonates decompose
in polar protic media by the mechanism
depicted in Scheme a via a putative furfuryl cation intermediate.[30] Primary furfuryl carbonates possessing only an alkyl group
at the 5-position of the furan ring are relatively unreactive and
decompose slowly at room temperature; however, installation of an
additional α-methyl group significantly reduces the activation
barrier for carbonate fragmentation.[25] While
this substitution pattern is sufficient to enable the release of a
phenolic cargo molecule with a half-life of approximately 1 h, the
rate of fragmentation is still prohibitively slow for alcohol- and
amine-derived furfuryl carbonates and carbamates, respectively. For
example, preliminary kinetic studies performed on a small-molecule
model compound reveal that the release of a primary alcohol from our
earlier furfuryl carbonate substrate occurs with a half-life of approximately
4 days, or nearly 100× slower than the release of hydroxycoumarin
(Figure S1). We reasoned that the addition
of an electron-donating substituent[31] at
the 3-position of the furan would further suppress the activation
barrier for fragmentation since this substituent is in resonance with
the furfuryl carbocation, potentially enabling the efficient release
of even more challenging payloads such as amines[32] under mild conditions.To test this hypothesis, we
first computed the activation energies
for fragmentation of a series of model primary and secondary furfurylcarbonate (FC1(O)–FC4(O)) and furfurylcarbamate (FC1(NH)–FC4(NH)) substrates
with varying substitution at the 3-position of the furan ring (Figure ). Activation energies
were calculated using DFT at the M06-2X/6-311+G** level of theory
using a polarizable continuum model to simulate a polar solvent environment
(see the Supporting Information for details).
For the furfuryl carbonate series, α-methyl substitution reduces
the activation energy for fragmentation by 3.2–3.8 kcal/mol
relative to the primary furfuryl carbonate substrates. Similarly,
the addition of an electron-donating phenoxy substituent at the 3-position
of the furan ring lowers the computed activation energies by 3.7–4.3
kcal/mol. Significantly, the combination of α-methyl and 3-phenoxy
substitution on FC1(O) results in a computed activation
energy of 18.3 kcal/mol, suggesting a nearly instantaneous reaction
at room temperature. These values indicate that the half-life for
reaction of FC1(O) is nearly 5 orders of magnitude shorter
than that of the unsubstituted primary furfuryl carbonate represented
by FC4(O) and approximately 500× shorter than that
of our originally reported secondary furfuryl carbonate substrate
depicted by FC3(O). A similar trend in reactivity is
observed for the furfuryl carbamate model series; however, calculated
activation energies are 5.5–7.6 kcal/mol higher for the furfurylcarbamates in comparison to the analogous furfuryl carbonate substrates
in all cases. The higher activation energies calculated for the furfurylcarbamate series are consistent with experimentally determined reaction
kinetics for different self-immolative spacers,[33] which suggest that the more electron withdrawing carbonate
leaving group is able to better stabilize the partial negative charge
on the oxygen atom of the fragmenting C–O bond in the transition
state relative to a carbamate leaving group. The activation energies
calculated for furfuryl carbamates FC2(NH)–FC4(NH) suggest that decomposition of similarly substituted
substrates occurs on time scales that are impractical for triggered
release. For furfuryl carbamate model FC1(NH), however,
the combination of α-methyl and 3-phenoxy substitution significantly
reduces the activation barrier to 23.8 kcal/mol, which approaches
the activation energy calculated for our first-generation furfurylcarbonate and suggests that the release of challenging amine-based
molecular payloads may be accessible on reasonable time scales.
Figure 1
Substituent
effects on the reactivity of 2-furylcarbinol derivatives.
(a) Structures of model furfuryl carbonates (X = O) and furfuryl carbamates
(X = NH) with varying substitution patterns, and (b) corresponding
activation energies for fragmentation of the α-C–O bond
calculated at the M06-2X/6-311+G** level of density functional theory.
Substituent
effects on the reactivity of 2-furylcarbinol derivatives.
(a) Structures of model furfuryl carbonates (X = O) and furfuryl carbamates
(X = NH) with varying substitution patterns, and (b) corresponding
activation energies for fragmentation of the α-C–O bond
calculated at the M06-2X/6-311+G** level of density functional theory.To validate the computational predictions, we synthesized
fluorogenic
furfuryl carbamate model compound 1 containing α-methyl
and 3-phenoxy substituents and investigated its reactivity experimentally
(Figure a). The coumarin
payload exhibits a fluorescence turn-on after release, allowing the
reaction to be conveniently monitored using photoluminescence (PL),
in addition to NMR spectroscopy. The addition of methanol to a room-temperature
solution of 1 in acetonitrile-d3 (19 μM, 3:1 MeCN/MeOH) triggers decomposition and results
in clean conversion to aminocoumarin 3 and furfuryl methyl
ether 4, as evidenced by NMR spectroscopy (Figure b). The formation of furfuryl
methyl ether 4 is consistent with the transient formation
of a furfuryl cation intermediate that is intercepted by methanol.
Interestingly, when the reaction is performed at significantly higher
concentrations, another set of peaks was observed in the 1H NMR spectra corresponding to the formation of a side product that
was identified to be the furfuryl amine derived from nucleophilic
attack of the furfuryl cation intermediate by liberated aminocoumarin 3 (Figures S2 and S3). A similar
reaction was not observed for the furfuryl carbonate studied previously,
highlighting the increased nucleophilicity of the amine cargo. Importantly,
however, this furfuryl amine side product is formed in <2% yield
in reactions with a substrate concentration of 19 μM, which
is similar to the concentration of mechanophores in typical ultrasonication
experiments (vide infra). These results confirm that
at these relatively low substrate concentrations, the reaction depicted
in Figure a is sufficiently
descriptive. The kinetics of furfuryl carbamate decomposition were
further studied by monitoring the conversion of starting material
and the generation of aminocoumarin 3 as a function of
time using NMR and PL spectroscopy, respectively (Figure c). Furfuryl carbamate 1 is fully converted to products in approximately 5 h, with
a concomitant increase in fluorescence corresponding to the generation
of aminocoumarin 3 (Figure S4). The data from both time course experiments were fitted to first-order
rate expressions, providing half-lives of t1/2 = 34 and 45 min from NMR and PL measurements, respectively. In direct
contrast, secondary furfuryl carbamate model compound 2, which does not contain a 3-phenoxy substituent but is otherwise
identical to our previously reported furfuryl carbonate that is active
toward phenol release,[25] is completely
unreactive under the same conditions (Figure c and Figure S5). The striking difference in decomposition behavior between model
compounds 1 and 2 highlights the effect
of an electron-donating phenoxy substituent on the furan ring and
supports the molecular design for a second-generation mechanophore
platform enabling the molecular release of previously inaccessible
payloads.
Figure 2
Characterization of the decomposition reactions of model furfuryl
carbamates 1 and 2. (a) Decomposition of 1 in MeCN/MeOH (3:1) at room temperature generates fluorescent
aminocoumarin 3 and furfuryl methyl ether 4 via a putative furfuryl cation intermediate; (b) partial 1H NMR spectra (400 MHz, CDCl3) demonstrating the clean
conversion of 1 to products ([1]0 = 19 μM); (c) time course experiments following the conversion
of furfuryl carbamates 1 and 2 by NMR spectroscopy
(in 3:1 MeCN-d3/MeOH; [1]0 = 14 mM; [2]0 = 14 mM) and the generation
of aminocoumarin 3 by photoluminescence spectroscopy
(3:1 MeCN/MeOH; λex = 365 nm; λem = 424 nm; [1]0, [2]0 = 7.6 μM).
Characterization of the decomposition reactions of model furfurylcarbamates 1 and 2. (a) Decomposition of 1 in MeCN/MeOH (3:1) at room temperature generates fluorescent
aminocoumarin 3 and furfuryl methyl ether 4 via a putative furfuryl cation intermediate; (b) partial 1H NMR spectra (400 MHz, CDCl3) demonstrating the clean
conversion of 1 to products ([1]0 = 19 μM); (c) time course experiments following the conversion
of furfuryl carbamates 1 and 2 by NMR spectroscopy
(in 3:1 MeCN-d3/MeOH; [1]0 = 14 mM; [2]0 = 14 mM) and the generation
of aminocoumarin 3 by photoluminescence spectroscopy
(3:1 MeCN/MeOH; λex = 365 nm; λem = 424 nm; [1]0, [2]0 = 7.6 μM).We next synthesized a
series of furan–maleimide Diels–Alder
adducts serving as masked furfuryl carbonates/carbamates with varying
substitution and incorporated them into polymers to study their mechanochemical
behavior. Polymers containing a chain-centered mechanophore are mechanically
activated in solution using ultrasonication, which produces elongational
forces that are maximized near the chain midpoint.[34] The synthesis of polymers containing a masked phenoxy-substituted
secondary furfuryl carbonate/carbamate is illustrated in Scheme , while details for
the synthesis of polymers containing a masked phenoxy-substituted
primary furfuryl carbonate/carbamate (1°, 3-OPh) as well as a
secondary furfuryl carbonate/carbamate without a phenoxy substituent
(2°, 3H) matching our first-generation molecular
design are provided in the Supporting Information. Starting from 3-bromofurfural, a phenoxy group was installed via
a nucleophilic substitution reaction with phenol, followed by Grignard
addition and protection to yield furfuryl silyl ether 6. Next, a formylation reaction and subsequent desilylation with TBAF
yielded 2,3,5-trisubstituted furfuryl alcohol 7. Reduction
of the aldehyde with sodium borohydride and a [4 + 2] cycloaddition
reaction with a prefunctionalized maleimide dienophile in a two-step
sequence furnished an isomeric mixture of Diels–Alder adducts,
from which endo diastereomer (±)-7 was isolated by silica gel chromatography. Esterification of the
primary alcohol proceeded with reasonable selectivity using α-bromoisobutyryl
bromide to give the modular bis-initiator (±)-9 containing
a secondary alcohol for cargo attachment. The precursor bis-initiator
(±)-9 was then conveniently elaborated to carbonate
(±)-10(O) and carbamate (±)-10(NH) containing fluorogenic coumarin payloads via a reaction with the
corresponding chloroformate or isocyanate, respectively. After cargo
installation, the bis-initiators were employed in the controlled radical
polymerization of methyl acrylate with Cu wire/Me6TREN
in DMSO[35] to afford poly(methyl acrylate)
(PMA) polymersPMA-1(O) and PMA-1(NH) containing
a chain-centered mechanophore. An analogous synthetic approach enabled
the preparation of chain-centered polymersPMA-2(X) (1°,
3-OPh) and PMA-3(X) (2°, 3-H) with differing mechanophore
substitution. The structure of each polymer is illustrated in Scheme along with the number-average
molecular weight (Mn), which was determined
to be in the range 94.7–102 kDa with Đ ≤ 1.06 by gel permeation chromatography (GPC) monitored with
refractive index and multiangle light scattering detectors. In addition,
chain-end functional control polymers were synthesized similarly by
starting from the masked furfuryl carbonates/carbamates containing
a single α-bromo ester initiating group (see the Supporting Information for details).
Scheme 2
Synthesis
of Poly(methyl acrylate) (PMA) Polymers Containing a Chain-Centered
Mechanophore with α-Methyl/Phenoxy Substitution and a Fluorogenic
Coumarin Payload
Scheme 3
Ultrasound-Induced
Mechanical Activation of Substituted Mechanophores
and Release of Fluorescent Hydroxycoumarin or Aminocoumarin Cargo
Đ = 1.03–1.06
for all polymers.
Ultrasound-Induced
Mechanical Activation of Substituted Mechanophores
and Release of Fluorescent Hydroxycoumarin or Aminocoumarin Cargo
Đ = 1.03–1.06
for all polymers.Prior to evaluating their
molecular release behavior, we sought
to investigate how substitution of the 2-furylcarbinol derivatives
affects the mechanochemical and thermal properties of the Diels–Alder
adducts. First, DFT calculations were performed on truncated models
of each carbamate-functionalized mechanophore using the constrained
geometries simulate external force (CoGEF) method,[36] which is a simple and reliable computational technique
for predicting mechanochemical reactivity.[37] The mechanical elongation of each furan–maleimide adduct
results in a predicted retro-[4 + 2] cycloaddition reaction to produce
the expected furfuryl carbamate and maleimide fragments with nearly
identical energy–displacement profiles (Figure S6). The calculated rupture force (Fmax) is essentially the same regardless of substitution,
which occurs at 4.0–4.1 nN and suggests similar mechanochemical
activity of each mechanophore that is primarily dictated by pulling
geometry.[38−40] In contrast to the predicted mechanochemical invariability,
however, the addition of a phenoxy group leads to a pronounced increase
in the thermal stability of the Diels–Alder adduct, which has
been observed previously for cycloadducts derived from 3-alkoxyfurans
and ascribed to a reduction in the energetic penalty for loss of furan
aromaticity.[41,42] Heating a solution of (±)-9 in toluene-d8 at 70 °C
results in <2% cycloelimination after 5 h, while the same conditions
lead to approximately 46% reversion of the analogous Diels–Alder
adduct without the phenoxy substituent (Figure S7). At room temperature, phenoxy-substituted mechanophore
(±)-9 is stable indefinitely in toluene-d8 in comparison to the slow, but detectable
reversion of the compound with no phenoxy group, as monitored over
several months using 1H NMR spectroscopy (Figure S8). The improved thermal stability of the phenoxy-substituted
mechanophores in combination with the predicted mechanochemical activity
being similar to that of our originally reported masked furfuryl carbonate
mechanophore renders this second-generation molecular design an attractive
platform for mechanically triggered release.The mechanically
triggered release of hydroxycoumarin or aminocoumarin
from PMA-1(X)–PMA-3(X) in 3:1 MeCN/MeOH
was evaluated using pulsed ultrasonication (1 s on/1 s off, 8–10
°C, 20 kHz, 8.2 W/cm2), and the effect of substitution
on the rate of coumarin release from the mechanically liberated 2-furylcarbinol
derivatives was measured using photoluminescence spectroscopy (Scheme ). Each polymer solution
was subjected to 60 min of ultrasonication (“on” time),
warmed to room temperature, and then fluorescence was monitored over
time. Kinetic data for the release of hydroxycoumarin from PMA-1(O)–PMA-3(O) are illustrated in Figure a, while the data for release
of aminocoumarin from PMA-1(NH)–PMA-3(NH) are illustrated in Figure b. For clarity and to account for slight differences in average
polymer molecular weight and dispersity that influence the extent
of mechanophore conversion during ultrasonication,[43−45] the initial
fluorescence intensity (t = 0) is subtracted from
each measurement and the data are normalized to emphasize the relative
rates of molecular release (see the Supporting Information for additional details). The fluorescence emission
from solutions of PMA-1(O) and PMA-2(O) reached
a maximum prior to the first measurement and remained essentially
constant over time, indicating that the release of hydroxycoumarin
from both primary and secondary furfuryl carbonates containing a 3-phenoxy
substituent completed nearly instantaneously upon formation (t1/2 < 5 min). These results are contrasted
by the release of hydroxycoumarin from mechanically activated PMA-3(O) containing our first-generation mechanophore, which
occurs steadily and predictably over several hours postactivation.
Fitting the time-dependent photoluminescence data for release of hydroxycoumarin
from PMA-3(O) to a first-order rate expression gives
an estimated half-life for decomposition of the 3H secondary furfuryl carbonate of 46 min (average of two trials).
Figure 3
Mechanically
triggered release of (a) hydroxycoumarin and (b) aminocoumarin
from polymers as a function of mechanophore substitution. Polymer
solutions (2 mg/mL in 3:1 MeCN/MeOH) were sonicated for 60 min (“on”
time), warmed to room temperature, and the release of coumarin cargo
from the mechanically liberated 2-furylcarbinol derivatives was monitored
by photoluminescence spectroscopy. PL parameters: λex = 330 nm, λem = 378 nm (hydroxycoumarin); λex = 365 nm, λem = 424 nm (aminocoumarin).
The initial PL intensity was subtracted from each measurement and
the data were normalized to the plateau value. For PMA-3(NH), the data were normalized assuming 36% mechanophore activation;
the black dashed line represents a first-order reaction with a half-life
of 240 days.
Mechanically
triggered release of (a) hydroxycoumarin and (b) aminocoumarin
from polymers as a function of mechanophore substitution. Polymer
solutions (2 mg/mL in 3:1 MeCN/MeOH) were sonicated for 60 min (“on”
time), warmed to room temperature, and the release of coumarin cargo
from the mechanically liberated 2-furylcarbinol derivatives was monitored
by photoluminescence spectroscopy. PL parameters: λex = 330 nm, λem = 378 nm (hydroxycoumarin); λex = 365 nm, λem = 424 nm (aminocoumarin).
The initial PL intensity was subtracted from each measurement and
the data were normalized to the plateau value. For PMA-3(NH), the data were normalized assuming 36% mechanophore activation;
the black dashed line represents a first-order reaction with a half-life
of 240 days.The release of aminocoumarin from
mechanically activated PMA-1(NH)–PMA-3(NH) provides an even clearer
demonstration of the effect of substitution on the kinetics of furfurylcarbamate decomposition, with reaction half-lives spanning 4 orders
of magnitude (Figure b). The time-dependent photoluminescence of the sonicated solution
of PMA-1(NH) is described by a first-order rate expression
and reaches a maximum intensity after approximately 4 h postactivation,
corresponding to the release of aminocoumarin with an average half-life
of 41 min from two replicate experiments. This remarkably fast release
from the furfuryl carbamate containing both α-methyl and 3-phenoxy
substituents is consistent with the substantially diminished activation
energy calculated by DFT for corresponding model substrate FC1(NH). In comparison, the release of aminocoumarin from mechanically activated PMA-2(NH) containing a masked primary furfuryl carbamate with
a 3-phenoxy substituent is over 200× slower with an average half-life
of 6.5 days, again highlighting the stabilizing effect of the α-methyl
substituent identified previously. For PMA-3(NH) containing
a chain-centered mechanophore analogous to our first-generation molecular
design with an α-methyl substituent and no phenoxy group, only
8% release of aminocoumarin was observed after 30 days postactivation.
This calculation assumes a mechanophore conversion of 36% as determined
previously for our original masked furfuryl carbonate under nearly
identical conditions.[25] The time-dependent
photoluminescence data for release of aminocoumarin from PMA-3(NH) fall on the line for a first-order reaction with a half-life of
approximately 240 days. It is worth noting that the yield of hydroxycoumarin
or aminocoumarin released from each polymer studied, with the exception
of PMA-3(NH), was 34–39% relative to the mechanophore
concentration in each experiment, which is consistent with the anticipated
mechanophore conversion after a relatively short exposure to ultrasound
(Table S1).The results above illustrate
the ability to control the rate of
mechanically triggered release by fine-tuning the molecular structure
of the furan–maleimide mechanophore, and in particular, highlight
the potential for releasing diverse chemical payloads from masked
secondary 2-furylcarbinol derivatives containing a 3-phenoxy group.
Therefore, we sought to further investigate the scope of molecular
cargo that can be effectively released upon mechanical activation
of the second-generation mechanophore (Scheme ). Starting again from modular bis-initiator
precursor (±)-9 containing a secondary alcohol,
a variety of molecular cargo were installed via different functional
group connectivity and the mechanophores were incorporated into polymers
following the same protocol as before (Table S2; see the Supporting Information for additional
details). In addition to the hydroxycoumarin (phenol) and aminocoumarin
(arylamine) payloads attached via carbonate and carbamate groups,
respectively, four other cargo molecules were installed, including
those bearing alcohol, alkylamine, carboxylic acid, and sulfonic acid
functional groups. Conjugation of the alcohol and alkylamine functional
cargo molecules was achieved using carbonate and carbamate spacers,
respectively, where a decarboxylation step is required for molecular
release similar to the coumarin-based phenol and arylamine payloads.
On the other hand, cargo molecules bearing carboxylic acid and sulfonic
acid functional groups were conjugated directly to the mechanophore
substrate through carboxylate and sulfonate linkages. Each payload
molecule was chosen to be strongly absorbing in the UV region to facilitate
the characterization of their release using high-performance liquid
chromatography (HPLC) equipped with a UV detector. For each derivative,
a corresponding chain-end functional control polymer was also synthesized
and evaluated under the same conditions to confirm the mechanical
origin of molecular release (Table S3).[9]
Scheme 4
Scope of Mechanically Triggered Cargo Release
from the Second-Generation
Mechanophore with α-Methyl/Phenoxy Substitution
Values
of percent release and
half-lives are averages from two replicate experiments. Percent release
is reported relative to the initial mechanophore concentration and
does not account for incomplete mechanophore conversion after 60 min
of ultrasonication. The values of percent release were determined
by HPLC.
Half-life for cargo
release was measured by photoluminescence spectroscopy.
Half-life for cargo release was measured
by HPLC.
Scope of Mechanically Triggered Cargo Release
from the Second-Generation
Mechanophore with α-Methyl/Phenoxy Substitution
Values
of percent release and
half-lives are averages from two replicate experiments. Percent release
is reported relative to the initial mechanophore concentration and
does not account for incomplete mechanophore conversion after 60 min
of ultrasonication. The values of percent release were determined
by HPLC.Half-life for cargo
release was measured by photoluminescence spectroscopy.Half-life for cargo release was measured
by HPLC.Similar to the kinetic studies performed
above and following the
same ultrasonication procedures, solutions of each polymer (2.0 mg/mL
in 3:1 MeCN/MeOH) were subjected to pulsed ultrasonication (60 min
“on” time) and then payload release from the mechanically
liberated 2-furylcarbinol derivative was monitored at room temperature
by HPLC and quantified using an internal standard (see the Supporting Information for details). The identity
of each cargo molecule, the average half-life and yield of payload
release measured from two replicate experiments, and the values of Mn and Đ of the parent
chain-centered polymers are summarized in Scheme . Similar to hydroxycoumarin, the mechanically
triggered release of 1-pyrenebutanol was sufficiently rapid such that
it was complete prior to the first HPLC measurement (t1/2 < 30 min). Release of 1-pyrenemethylamine from
the corresponding furfuryl carbamate occurred with a moderate half-life
of 4.2 h, albeit approximately 6× slower than the release of
aminocoumarin. The difference in release kinetics between the alkyl-
and arylamines is ascribed to the difference in pKa values of the conjugate acids,[33] with the aniline derivative being a better leaving group. The second-generation
mechanophore design not only enables the successful release of alcohols
and amines via carbonate and carbamate linkages but is also capable
of effecting the release of payloads incorporating carboxylic acid
and sulfonic acid functional groups conjugated to the mechanophore
via carboxylate and sulfonate linkages. The mechanically triggered
release of 1-pyrenebutanoic acid proceeded with a half-life of approximately
28 h, while the release of 2-naphthalenesulfonic acid was complete
before the first HPLC measurement (t1/2 < 30 min). Again, this trend is consistent with the significantly
lower pKa value of the sulfonic acid in
comparison to the carboxylic acid, reflecting the relative stabilities
of sulfonate and carbonate leaving groups. The mechanically triggered
release of organic acids enabled by this second-generation platform
significantly expands upon the limited repertoire of mechanophores
that generate HCl[14,15] and is also highly modular in
nature owing to the generality of the mechanophore design.The
percent release for each cargo molecule determined by HPLC
is reported in Scheme relative to the initial concentration of the mechanophore. It is
important to note, however, that only a fraction of mechanophores
is converted after 60 min of ultrasonication, which again is expected
to be ∼36% based on the experimental conditions and the average
molecular weight of the polymers (Mn ≈
100 kDa).[25] As demonstrated previously,
increasing the sonication time to 150 min results in 64% release of
hydroxycoumarin from PMA-3(O).[25] Among other factors,[46] the rate of mechanophore
activation is particularly sensitive to the length of the attached
polymer chains, with longer chains producing faster mechanochemical
reactions.[44,45] Here the duration of ultrasonication
was selected on the basis of experimental expediency. With the exception
of the alkylamine cargo, the yields for payload release after 60 min
of ultrasonication are within the range of 33–41%. These results
suggest that payload release from the mechanochemically generated
2-furylcarbinol derivative in each case is highly efficient. Release
of the alkylamine plateaus at approximately 8%, and we tentatively
attribute the reduced yield to a reaction between the amine and polymer-bound
furfuryl cation intermediate, similar to the side reaction observed
in the decomposition of model compound 1 at relatively
high concentrations. In this case, the enhanced nucleophilicity of
the alkylamine is anticipated to promote this reaction pathway to
a greater extent in comparison to aminocoumarin. On the other hand,
the higher yield of 41% measured for the release of both organic acid
payloads is consistent with the slightly higher average molecular
weight of those polymers, which results in increased mechanophore
conversion during the same period of ultrasonication. Finally, we
note that payload release was not observed from any of the chain-end
functional control polymers under identical experimental conditions
(see the Supporting Information for details),
confirming that molecular release from polymers bearing a chain-centered
mechanophore was indeed triggered by mechanical force.[9]
Conclusions
We have demonstrated the mechanically triggered
release of functionally
diverse small molecules with tunable release kinetics from a second-generation
mechanophore platform. The mechanophore design leverages a mechanically
triggered cascade reaction in which mechanochemical activation of
a furan–maleimide Diels–Alder adduct reveals an unstable
2-furylcarbinol derivative that spontaneously decomposes under mild
conditions to release a covalently bound payload molecule. Using DFT
calculations to guide the molecular design, we have identified key
structure–property relationships for the reactivity of 2-furylcarbinol
derivatives that enable significant advancements over an earlier mechanophore
design, which was limited to the release of phenolic cargo molecules
with relatively slow release kinetics. The incorporation of an electron-donating
3-phenoxy substituent on the furan heterocycle reduces the activation
barrier for fragmentation of the furfuryl C–O bond, through
the putative resonance stabilization of the developing positive charge
in the transition state leading to the furfuryl cation intermediate.
Moreover, phenoxy substitution was found to enhance the thermal stability
of the Diels–Alder mechanophore without adversely affecting
its mechanochemical reactivity. Changing the substitution on the masked
2-furylcarbinol derivatives allows the rates of molecular release
to be varied by several orders of magnitude, while the combination
of α-methyl and 3-phenoxy substitution results in a highly active
substrate for the triggered release of functionally diverse molecular
payloads. Starting from a modular mechanophore initiator, a variety
of molecular cargoes were conveniently installed and then incorporated
into polymers by controlled radical polymerization. The mechanically
triggered release of functionally diverse cargo molecules bearing
alkyl/aryl alcohols and amines as well as carboxylic acid and sulfonic
acid functional groups was demonstrated using ultrasonication, exhibiting
fast rates of release and high reaction efficiencies. The generality
and efficacy of the mechanophore design make it a promising platform
for the mechanically triggered release of a wide variety of functional
molecules to address applications in catalysis, sensing, drug delivery,
and other areas.
Authors: Charles E Diesendruck; Brian D Steinberg; Naoto Sugai; Meredith N Silberstein; Nancy R Sottos; Scott R White; Paul V Braun; Jeffrey S Moore Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2012-07-17 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: Sai Sriharsha M Konda; Johnathan N Brantley; Bibin T Varghese; Kelly M Wiggins; Christopher W Bielawski; Dmitrii E Makarov Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2013-08-19 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: S R White; N R Sottos; P H Geubelle; J S Moore; M R Kessler; S R Sriram; E N Brown; S Viswanathan Journal: Nature Date: 2001-02-15 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Maxwell J Robb; Tae Ann Kim; Abigail J Halmes; Scott R White; Nancy R Sottos; Jeffrey S Moore Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2016-09-12 Impact factor: 15.419