| Literature DB >> 34290890 |
Shally Sharma1, Ritika Khandelwal2, Kapil Yadav2, Gomathi Ramaswamy3, Kashish Vohra2.
Abstract
In developing countries there is a need for simple and cost-effective strategies to reduce the prevalence of iron deficiency anemia. The objective of the current systematic review is to summarize how cooking food in iron pots or iron ingots can increase the blood hemoglobin level and iron content of the food. Literature search was conducted using databases namely PubMed, Google Scholar, Medline-Ovid, IndMed, Cochrane library, World Health Organization bulletin and by cross-referencing articles. Thirteen researches were found to be suitable for inclusion in this systematic review. Four studies reported significant increase in blood hemoglobin levels while others reported only a minor increase. Significant improvement in amount of iron in food and iron bioavailability was also observed when food was cooked using iron pot or ingots. This can be used as a strategy for reduction of iron deficiency anemia. However, more research is required to understand the efficacy of this approach.Entities:
Keywords: Anemia; Iron deficiency anemia; Iron pots; hemoglobin; iron ingots
Year: 2021 PMID: 34290890 PMCID: PMC8266402 DOI: 10.3126/nje.v11i2.36682
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nepal J Epidemiol
Summary of literature on the effect of cooking in iron containing cookware and using iron ingot on anemia status of the study participants
| Author | Year | Country | Study design and duration | Participant Characteristics | Intervention | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1998 | Brazil | RCT[ | n= 45 | Infants consumed food prepared in Fe pot or Al pot | Mean hemoglobin (+0.52g/l) in Fe pot significantly increased as compared to Al pot (-0.74g/dl) | |
| 1999 | Ethiopia | RCT | n= 407 | Three meals cooked in Al, clay & Fe pot. | More increase in crude Fe content in meat and vegetables than legumes | |
| 2003 | Malawi | RCT | n= 322 | Fe or Al cooking pot assigned for cooking | < 12 years: No increase in Hb, | |
| 2004 | Malawi | Experimental laboratory trial | Three Malawian meals prepared in two Fe pots and a glass pot | Fe content improved from 3.15 μg to 147.32 μg/g in food, when cooked in Fe pot | ||
| 2007 | Benin, Africa | Cluster RCT | n=71 children, age= 6-24 months; | Two groups used cast Fe or blue steel pots and controls had Fe supplements | Insignificant differences in mean Hb or IDA among groups, SF[ | |
| 2010 | Cambodia | RCT | n=189 women | 3 groups: control, received Fe fish with no follow up and received Fe fish with follow up | No significant change in Hb | |
| 2011 | Cambodia | Experimental study | - | 4 groups: Controls: glass pot and Al pot; glass pot with Fe fish; and Al pot with Fe ingot | Use of iron ingot while making water and soup samples met more daily iron needs | |
| 2015 | Cambodia | RCT | n=310 | 3 groups: Fe ingot, Fe ingot plus nutrition education, and untreated control group | Mean Hb concentration varied by 1.18 g/dL across control and treatment group (p<0.001) | |
| 2013 | India | Randomised trial | n= 27 pre-schoolers, mean age 2.9±0.9y | Supplementation with a snack cooked in Fe pot, for 5 days/week | Hb improved from 10.1±1.6 to 10.9±1.7 g/dL (p<0.001) | |
| 2017 | Cambodia | RCT | n=327 women, mean age 32 years | 3 groups: iron-ingot, iron-supplement (18 mg/d), and control group | Insignificant differences in mean Hb concentration among iron-supplement or ingot group compared with control | |
| 2017 | Brazil | Cluster RCT | n=175 preschoolers | Consumption of food cooked in Fe pot or Al pot | No significant increase in Hb for non-IDA children, Hb (Fe vs. Al): +1.69g/dl vs. +1.10g/dl for anemic children | |
| 2017 | China | Experimental study | Panel of 12 trained | Five pea samples soaked in deionized water, boiled in Fe pot & clay pot with variable iron content (0, 0.05, 0.50, 5.00 mg/L FeSO4) and freeze dried. | Pea pastes in Fe pot had 3.3 times higher Fe content (21.4±1.0 mg) than clay pot (p<0.05), more FeSO4 (wt/vol), more Fe content in pea | |
| 1991 | USA | Experimental study | - | Fe content compared in raw sauce samples, sauce prepared in Fe pot and non Fe pot | Apple sauce (Fe pot vs. non Fe pot vs. raw): 6.26mg vs. 0.18mg vs. 0.26mg/100g (p>0.05), |
*Fe: Iron,
+Hb: Hemoglobin,
++RCT: Randomised control trial,
#Al: Aluminium,
**IDA: Iron deficiency anemia,
+++SF: Serum ferritin,
##M:F : Male: female ratio in study
Figure 1.– Figure 1- PRISMA flow diagram which included database search using keywords, title, abstract screening and full text
Figure 2.Risk of bias as percentage for included randomized trials
Figure 3.Risk of bias summary