Yang Li1, Yan Li1, Jing Xia1, Qing Yang2, Yijie Chen3, Hui Sun1,4. 1. College of Life Sciences, Wuhan University, Wuhan, Hubei Province 430072, P. R. China. 2. College of Food Science and Engineering, Wuhan Polytechnic University, Wuhan, Hubei Province 430023, P. R. China. 3. College of Food Science and Technology, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan, Hubei Province 430070, P. R. China. 4. Hubei Province key Laboratory of Allergy and Immunology, Wuhan University, Wuhan, Hubei Province 430072, P. R. China.
Abstract
Many lectins have been reported to have antitumor activities; identifying the glycan ligands in tumor cells of lectins is crucial for lectin clinical application. An edible mushroom galectin, Agrocybe aegerita lectin (AAL/AAGL), that has a high antitumor activity has been reported. In this paper, based on the glycan array data, it is showed that the Thomsen-Friedenreich antigen (TF antigen)-related O-glycans were found to be highly correlated with the antitumor activity of AAL/AAGL. Further glycosyltransferase quantification suggested that the ratio between GAL3ST2 and ST3GAL1 (GAL3ST2/ST3GAL1), which determined the 3'-sulfo-TF expression level, was highly correlated with the antitumor activity of AAL/AAGL. Overexpressing the enzyme of GAL3ST2 in HL60 and HeLa cell lines could increase the growth inhibition ratio of AAL/AAGL from 22.7 to 43.9% and 27.8 to 39.1%, respectively. However, ST3GAL1 in Jurkat cells could decrease the growth inhibition ratio from 44.7 to 35.6%. All the data suggested that the 3'-sulfo-TF antigen is one of the main glycan ligands that AAL/AAGL recognizes in tumor cells. AAL/AAGL may potentially serve as a reagent for cancer diagnosis and a targeted therapy for the 3'-sulfo-TF antigen.
Many lectins have been reported to have antitumor activities; identifying the glycan ligands in tumor cells of lectins is crucial for lectin clinical application. An edible mushroom galectin, Agrocybe aegerita lectin (AAL/AAGL), that has a high antitumor activity has been reported. In this paper, based on the glycan array data, it is showed that the Thomsen-Friedenreich antigen (TF antigen)-related O-glycans were found to be highly correlated with the antitumor activity of AAL/AAGL. Further glycosyltransferase quantification suggested that the ratio between GAL3ST2 and ST3GAL1 (GAL3ST2/ST3GAL1), which determined the 3'-sulfo-TF expression level, was highly correlated with the antitumor activity of AAL/AAGL. Overexpressing the enzyme of GAL3ST2 in HL60 and HeLa cell lines could increase the growth inhibition ratio of AAL/AAGL from 22.7 to 43.9% and 27.8 to 39.1%, respectively. However, ST3GAL1 in Jurkat cells could decrease the growth inhibition ratio from 44.7 to 35.6%. All the data suggested that the 3'-sulfo-TF antigen is one of the main glycan ligands that AAL/AAGL recognizes in tumor cells. AAL/AAGL may potentially serve as a reagent for cancer diagnosis and a targeted therapy for the 3'-sulfo-TF antigen.
Lectins,
also known as glycan-binding proteins, are a group of
carbohydrate-binding proteins of nonimmune origin that are ubiquitously
distributed in plants, animals, and fungi and have multiple significant
biological functions, such as antifungal, antiviral, and, most notably,
antitumor activities.[1−3] These antitumor lectins are known to possess proinflammatory,
antiproliferative, antimicrobial, immunomodulatory, and antiviral
activities by being involved in growth regulation, cell adhesion,
cell migration, cell apoptosis, and immune responses.[4−6]Several lectins have been investigated for their anticancer
effects
in preclinical and clinical stage trials.[7] For example, intravenous treatment with Concanavalin A (ConA) has
been used to induce in vivo autophagic cell death in hepatoma cells
in a murine in situ hepatoma model.[8] A
diet containing Phaseolus vulgarisagglutinin
(PHA) was demonstrated to dramatically reduce the growth of an established
murine non-Hodgkin lymphoma tumor in mice.[9] Mistletoe lectin has been reported to exhibit potent inhibition
of tumor growth and metastasis through apoptosis in melanoma and ovarian
cancer.[10] The in vivo anticancer efficiency
of Abrus agglutinin (AGG) has been evaluated in several tumor models
through the induction of cell death and activation of Th1 immunomodulation.[11] AGG treatment significantly reduced the growth
of HCC in nude mice bearing HepG2 xenografts, efficiently suppressed
humanbreast tumor growth in nude mice, inhibited the growth of tumors
in a FaDu xenograft model, targeted cancer stem-like cells by eliminating
their self-renewal capacity and EMT, and had antitumor activities
in colorectal cancer.[12] Intraperitoneal
injection of Momordica charantia lectin
has been reported to result in a suppression of approximately 45%
in the growth of nasopharyngeal carcinoma xenograft tumors that had
been inoculated subcutaneously in nude mice, leading to the induction
of apoptosis in cancer cells.[13]Ricinus communisagglutinin I (RCA I), a galactose-binding
lectin, showed anticancer therapeutic activity by targeting tumor
blood vessels, which led to a reduction in the expression levels of
VEGFR-2 and tumor regression.[14]There
are two plant lectins in clinical stage trials. Viscum
album lectin extract intratumoral injections
in 123 colon adenoma cancerpatients produced results with complete
success, without adverse or life-threatening drug reactions[15] and a complete regression in a 78-year-old Caucasian
male.[16] The combinatorial treatment of Viscum album L. lectin with different standard anticancer
drugs resulted in improved one-year and three-year overall survival
rates in stage IV nonsmall cell lung cancerpatients.[17] Mistletoe lectin ps76a2 improved the quality of life of
breast cancerpatients during chemotherapy.[18]Most of these antitumor activities are directly related to
the
ability of these proteins to interact with carbohydrates via the carbohydrate
recognition domain (CRD).[19,20] Numerous lectins have
been studied in great detail to unravel their carbohydrate-binding
specificity by using glycan inhibition assays; frontal affinity chromatography
and glycan microarrays.[21,22] Glycan microarrays
are a high-throughput method to determine the specificity of glycan-binding
proteins. In addition, the glycan array technology also allows quantification
of the relative affinity of carbohydrate-binding proteins to glycans.[23] The specific binding of a lectin to a carbohydrate
structure can be exploited in lectin affinity chromatography for glycan
enrichment.[24] It is well known that ConA
is a mannose binding lectin, soybean agglutinin (SBA) is specific
to the galactosylated ligand,[25] and Phaseolus vulgaris lectin (PHA-E) has an unusual
specificity toward biantennary galactosylated N-glycan with bisecting N-acetylglucosamine (GlcNAc).[26] ConA is now the most widely used lectin for the characterization
and purification of high-mannoseN-glycan-containing glycoconjugates
and for the detection of these carbohydrate structures on biomolecules
and cells.[20] Even though several glycoprotein
ligands of SBA, ConA, and PHA have been identified, such as SBA interacting
with TLR4, ConA, TLR2/6 and PHA, TLR2/6, 4, and 5, the detailed carbohydrate
moiety in these glycoprotein ligands recognized by these antitumor
lectins on the tumor cell membrane surface has not been specifically
identified.[27]AAL/AAGL, a lectin
purified from the edible mushroom A.
aegerita, is an antitumor protein that exerts its tumor-suppressing
function via apoptosis-inducing activity in cancer cells. AAL/AAGL
belongs to the galectin family, which has conserved the CRD of the
galectin family and β-galactoside binding activity.[28] It was reported that AAL/AAGL can be internalized
by recognizing the carbohydrate moiety on the cell membrane surface
and localizes in the nucleus of HeLa cells similar to human galectins.[29,30] Moreover, the apoptosis-inducting activity is closely related to
the nuclear localization. Crystallization of AAL/AAGL and the tumor
Thomsen-Friedenreich antigen (TF antigen) also indicated that AAL/AAGL
could bind to the TF antigen just as observed for other mammalian
galectins.[31] However, the specific ligand
that determines the antitumor activity of AAL/AAGL has still not been
illuminated.In this study, we demonstrated that the antitumor
activity of AAL/AAGL
was triggered by the interactions with carbohydrate molecules on the
cell surface. By analyzing the glycan array data of AAL/AAGL and its
mutants, we found that the 3′-sulfo TF and 3′-sialyl-TF
antigen had the highest binding for AAL/AAGL among the TF-related
antigens. Further investigation indicated that the expression level
of the 3′-sulfo-TF antigen determined by the ratio of GAL3ST2/ST3GAL1
had a high correlation with the antitumor activity of AAL/AAGL. These
data suggested that AAL/AAGL could be proposed as a drug for targeting
tumor cells that strongly express 3′-sulfo-TF antigens.
Results
Antiproliferative Effect
of AAL/AAGL through
the Induction of Apoptosis In Vitro
In our previous papers,
a series of experiments indicated that AAL/AAGL possesses a potent
antitumor function in several tumor cell lines, including HeLa, SW480,
and SGC-7901 cells, and apoptosis-inducing activity in tumor cells.[32] In this paper, several leukemic cell lines (including
Jurkat, Molt4, HL60, and K562 cells) and two kinds of lymphoma cell
lines (Raji and U937 cells) were used for testing the antitumor activity
of AAL/AAGL. As shown in Figure A, AAL/AAGL displayed a growth-inhibitory effect in
a time-dependent and concentration-dependent manner (Table ). Jurkat, Molt4, and Raji cells
were more sensitive to AAL/AAGL compared with HL60, K562, and U937
cells. To further detect the sensitivity of different cells to AAL/AAGL,
we selected Jurkat cells, which were more sensitive to AAL/AAGL, and
investigated the activation of apoptosis signals after AAL/AAGL treatment.
In Figure B, Jurkat
and HL60 cells were selected as sensitive and nonsensitive cells,
respectively, for further analysis. AAL/AAGL activated caspase-3 in
Jurkat cells but not in HL60 cells after AAL/AAGL treatment for 48
h. As shown in Figure C, treatment of AAL/AAGL-sensitive Jurkat cells with AAL/AAGL showed
that the protein expression levels of caspase-8, −9, −3,
and PARP were upregulated, the JNK MAP kinases were activated, and
the expression of Bcl-2 was downregulated. The blockade of caspase
activation by the pretreatment with Z-VAD-FMK, a pan-caspase inhibitor,
prevented the cell death induction by AAL/AAGL in Jurkat cells (Figure D). Taken together,
these data suggest that Jurkat, Molt4, and Raji cells are more sensitive
to AAL/AAGL, compared with HL60, K562, and U937 cells and that AAL/AAGL
induces apoptosis in Jurkat cells in a caspase-dependent manner.
Figure 1
Different
antitumor effects of AAL/AAGL in several tumor cells.
(A) Different concentrations of AAL/AAGL incubated with six types
of tumor cells for 48 h, after which the growth inhibition rate was
assessed with a CCK-8 kit. (B) Jurkat and HL60 cells were treated
with AAL/AAGL (2.5 and 5 μM) and PBS, and the expression level
of caspase-3 was detected by the Western blot after 48 h. (C) Jurkat
cells were treated with 5 μM AAL/AAGL, and the cells were collected
after 6, 12, and 24 h, respectively. The expression levels of cleaved
caspase-8, 9, 3, cleaved PARP, Bcl-2, and p-JNK were detected by the
Western blot. (D) Jurkat cells were treated with 5 μM AAL/AAGL
and 50 μM zVAD-FMK, a caspase inhibitor. After 48 h, the inhibition
rate in Jurkat cells in each group was assessed with a CCK-8 kit.
Table 1
Effect of 5 μM AAL/AAGL on the
Viable Cell Ratio and Growth Inhibition Rate of Cells
cells
viable cell
ratio (% control)
growth inhibition (%)
Jurkat
56.37 ± 3.63
43.63 ± 3.63
Molt4
54.00 ± 8.86
46.00 ±
8.86
Raji
62.19 ± 5.35
37.81 ± 5.35
HL60
78.94 ± 1.74
21.06 ± 1.74
K562
72.54 ± 2.00
27.46 ±
2.00
U937
74.60 ± 4.30
25.40 ± 4.30
Different
antitumor effects of AAL/AAGL in several tumor cells.
(A) Different concentrations of AAL/AAGL incubated with six types
of tumor cells for 48 h, after which the growth inhibition rate was
assessed with a CCK-8 kit. (B) Jurkat and HL60 cells were treated
with AAL/AAGL (2.5 and 5 μM) and PBS, and the expression level
of caspase-3 was detected by the Western blot after 48 h. (C) Jurkat
cells were treated with 5 μM AAL/AAGL, and the cells were collected
after 6, 12, and 24 h, respectively. The expression levels of cleaved
caspase-8, 9, 3, cleaved PARP, Bcl-2, and p-JNK were detected by the
Western blot. (D) Jurkat cells were treated with 5 μM AAL/AAGL
and 50 μM zVAD-FMK, a caspase inhibitor. After 48 h, the inhibition
rate in Jurkat cells in each group was assessed with a CCK-8 kit.
Antitumor Activity of AAL/AAGL Is Directly
Proportional to Cell Surface Binding Activity
To explore
the reason for the sensitivity differences to AAL/AAGL between the
different tumor cells, we investigated the cell binding of AAL/AAGL
in these cells. As shown in Figure A, the cell lines with a stronger binding for AAL/AAGL
were more sensitive to AAL/AAGL, and HL60, which was resistant to
AAL/AAGL, had the lowest binding for AAL/AAGL (Figure A,B). By analysis and statistics of the linear
regression method, a correlation value of 0.9646 was calculated between
the binding of AAL/AAGL to different cells and the inhibition of AAL/AAGL-induced
apoptosis in tumor growth (Table ). The high correlation value indicated a very good
fit of the linear regression line to the data points in Figure C. These results indicated
that there is a high positive correlation between the cell surface
AAL/AAGL binding and the antitumor activity of AAL/AAGL.
Figure 2
Antitumor activity
of AAL/AAGL is directly proportional to cell
surface binding activity. (A) Six kinds of cells were incubated with
AAL/AAGL, and the binding of AAL/AAGL for the different cells was
analyzed by flow cytometry. (B) ANOVA analysis of the data in Figure
A. (C) Correlation analysis of the binding of AAL/AAGL for cells and
tumor growth inhibition activity. The R value was
shown to be 0.9646.
Antitumor activity
of AAL/AAGL is directly proportional to cell
surface binding activity. (A) Six kinds of cells were incubated with
AAL/AAGL, and the binding of AAL/AAGL for the different cells was
analyzed by flow cytometry. (B) ANOVA analysis of the data in Figure
A. (C) Correlation analysis of the binding of AAL/AAGL for cells and
tumor growth inhibition activity. The R value was
shown to be 0.9646.
The Antitumor
Activity of AAL/AAGL Is Dependent
on the O-Glycans of Tumor Cells
Next, we
tried to determine the glycans related to the binding of AAL/AAGL
for different cells and the apoptosis-inducing activity of AAL/AAGL.
Galectins, a family of at least 15 β-galactoside-binding proteins,
are involved in growth development, as well as in cancer progression
and metastasis, and lactose is commonly used as an inhibitor of galectins
in vitro. The addition of 100 μM lactose abrogated the antiproliferative
activity of AAL/AAGL (Figure A), showing that AAL/AAGL-induced cell death required AAL/AAGL
binding to saccharide ligands on the surface of the cells. As reported
previously, several galectins, in particular galectin-1 and galectin-3,
can recognize the TF antigen, and the crystal structure of AAL/AAGL,
complexed with the TF antigen, was also reported. We used benzyl-α-GalNAc,
an O-glycan synthesis inhibitor, to inhibit the O-glycosylation
of O-glycans. As shown in Figure B, treatment of Jurkat cells with benzyl-α-GalNAc
resulted in decreased AAL/AAGL binding to these cells. The mean fluorescence
intensity of cells treated with benzyl-α-GalNAc decreased approximately
35% compared with the control (Figure C). The viable cell ratio was increased dramatically
from 54.9 to 83% (Figure D). Treatment of Jurkat cells with benzyl-α-GalNAc resulted
in a dramatic decrease in sensitivity to AAL/AAGL-induced cell death.
The annexin V-positive PI-positive cell ratio was reduced dramatically
from 45.7 to 12.4% (Figure E,F). These results indicated that elongated O-glycans on cell-surface glycoproteins regulate the cells’
sensitivity to AAL/AAGL-induced cell death.
Figure 3
Antitumor activity of
AAL/AAGL depends on the O-glycans on the cell surface.
(A) Apoptosis was induced by the activity
of glycan binding of AAL/AAGL. Jurkat cells were treated with 5 μM
AAL/AAGL, and 100 μM lactose was added. After 48 h, the inhibition
rate of Jurkat cells in each group was assessed with a CCK-8 kit.
MFI: mean fluorescence intensity; (B) effects of benzyl-α-GalNAc
treatment of Jurkat cells on the binding of AAL/AAGL for cells. Benzyl-α-GalNAc
treatment of the Jurkat cells (solid line); untreated cells (dashed
lines). Benzyl-α-GalNAc inhibited the addition of O-glycans, after which the AAL/AAGL binding rate was assessed by flow
cytometry. (C) ANOVA analysis of the data in Figure B. (D) CCK-8 kit was used to assess the effect
of benzyl-α-GalNAc and AAL/AAGL treatment in Jurkat cells on
the viable cell ratio of the cells. (E) Influence of benzyl-α-GalNAc-treated
Jurkat cells by an annexin V-PI double staining assay on the apoptosis
induced by AAL/AAGL. (F) Statistical analysis of the data on the annexinV-PI+cell
ratio in Figure E.
**p < 0.01.
Antitumor activity of
AAL/AAGL depends on the O-glycans on the cell surface.
(A) Apoptosis was induced by the activity
of glycan binding of AAL/AAGL. Jurkat cells were treated with 5 μM
AAL/AAGL, and 100 μM lactose was added. After 48 h, the inhibition
rate of Jurkat cells in each group was assessed with a CCK-8 kit.
MFI: mean fluorescence intensity; (B) effects of benzyl-α-GalNAc
treatment of Jurkat cells on the binding of AAL/AAGL for cells. Benzyl-α-GalNAc
treatment of the Jurkat cells (solid line); untreated cells (dashed
lines). Benzyl-α-GalNAc inhibited the addition of O-glycans, after which the AAL/AAGL binding rate was assessed by flow
cytometry. (C) ANOVA analysis of the data in Figure B. (D) CCK-8 kit was used to assess the effect
of benzyl-α-GalNAc and AAL/AAGL treatment in Jurkat cells on
the viable cell ratio of the cells. (E) Influence of benzyl-α-GalNAc-treated
Jurkat cells by an annexin V-PI double staining assay on the apoptosis
induced by AAL/AAGL. (F) Statistical analysis of the data on the annexinV-PI+cell
ratio in Figure E.
**p < 0.01.
3′-Sulfo-TF, 3′-Sialyl-TF, and
TF Binding Activities Show a High Correlation with the Antitumor Activity
of AAL/AAGL
The TF antigen and related O-glycans have been reported as binding ligands of many galectins.
We get the glycan array data of AAL/AAGL and its mutants (Supporting data 1–6) from CFG (http://www.functionalglycomics.org/) by searching the lectin name “AAL,” for further TF
and related O-glycan binding activity analysis. In Figure S1, we analyzed the glycan array of AAL/AAGL
at different concentrations using a dot plot method according to the
terminal-glycans. Several main O- and N-glycotypes are also marked
in Figure S1. As shown in Figure A, the TF-related glycans were
further analyzed in detail. The glycan array results of three concentrations
of AAL/AAGL showed that at concentrations of 100 and 200 μg/mL,
AAL/AAGL had a high binding for the 3′-sulfo-TF and 3′-sialyl-TF
antigens, and at 20 μg/mL, AAL/AAGL only had a high binding
activity for 3′-sulfo-TF. As shown in Figure B, mutant I144G retained both 3′-sulfo-TF
and 3′-sialyl-TF binding activities, H59Q only retained the
3′-sulfo-TF activity, and R63H lost both TF-related glycan-binding
activities. Due to the high binding activity of sulfo- and sialyl-TF,
the correlation between binding activity and apoptosis-inducing activity
was analyzed by regression. As shown in Figure C,D, there was a high correlation between
these activities, and the R values were 0.6657 and 0.5628 for 3′-sulfo-TF
and 3′-sialyl-TF, respectively. However, there was a low correlation
between TF and the apoptotic-inducing activity, with an R value of
only 0.1779 (Figure E). The R value was 0.4034 between the lactose-binding
ability of AAL/AAGL and its mutants and the apoptotic-inducing activity
(Figure F). This has
further indicated that AAL/AAGL-induced death in the sensitive cells
is perhaps related to 3′-sulfo-TF and 3′-sialyl-TF.
Figure 4
3′-Sulfo-TF
and 3′-sialyl-TF on the cell surface
may determine the antitumor activity of AAL/AAGL. Glycan array analysis
data. (A) Binding activity of AAL/AAGL (200, 100, and 20 μg/mL)
to TF and related glycans. (B) Binding activity of AAL/AAGL and three
AAL/AAGL mutants (R59Q, R63H, and I144G, 200 μg/mL) to TF and
related glycans. RFU: relative fluorescence unit. (C) Linear regression
analysis of binding activity to 3′-sulfo-TF and apoptosis-inducing
activity of AAL/AAGL and three AAL/AAGL mutants, which showed an R
value of 0.6657. (D) Linear regression analysis of binding activity
to 3′-sialyl-TF and apoptosis-inducing activity of AAL/AAGL
and three AAL/AAGL mutants, which showed an R value of 0.5628. (E)
Linear regression analysis of binding activity to TF and apoptosis-inducing
activity of AAL/AAGL and three AAL/AAGL mutants, which showed an R
value of 0.1779. (F) Linear regression analysis of lactose-binding
activity and apoptosis-inducing activity of AAL/AAGL and three AAL/AAGL
mutants, which showed an R value of only 0.4034.
3′-Sulfo-TF
and 3′-sialyl-TF on the cell surface
may determine the antitumor activity of AAL/AAGL. Glycan array analysis
data. (A) Binding activity of AAL/AAGL (200, 100, and 20 μg/mL)
to TF and related glycans. (B) Binding activity of AAL/AAGL and three
AAL/AAGL mutants (R59Q, R63H, and I144G, 200 μg/mL) to TF and
related glycans. RFU: relative fluorescence unit. (C) Linear regression
analysis of binding activity to 3′-sulfo-TF and apoptosis-inducing
activity of AAL/AAGL and three AAL/AAGL mutants, which showed an R
value of 0.6657. (D) Linear regression analysis of binding activity
to 3′-sialyl-TF and apoptosis-inducing activity of AAL/AAGL
and three AAL/AAGL mutants, which showed an R value of 0.5628. (E)
Linear regression analysis of binding activity to TF and apoptosis-inducing
activity of AAL/AAGL and three AAL/AAGL mutants, which showed an R
value of 0.1779. (F) Linear regression analysis of lactose-binding
activity and apoptosis-inducing activity of AAL/AAGL and three AAL/AAGL
mutants, which showed an R value of only 0.4034.
Antitumor Activity of AAL/AAGL
Has a Positive
Relationship with GALST2/ST3GAL1 (Ratio between GAL3ST2 and ST3GAL1)
According to the synthesis pathway of TF and related glycans (Figure A), there are five
glycosyltransferases involved in the synthesis of these glycans. To
identify which glycosyltransferases were the main factors determining
the susceptibility to AAL/AAGL, all these five glycosyltransferases
were quantified by RT-PCR and were analyzed for the correlation between
their relative expression and antitumor activity.
Figure 5
Antitumor activity of
AAL/AAGL has a high-positive correlation
with GAL3ST2/ST3GAL1 (indicate Sulfo-TF/Sialyl-TF). (A) Synthesis
pathways of TF and its related antigens. The mRNA expression levels
of (B) 3′-sialyl-TF synthesis enzyme ST3GAL1; (C) 3′-sulfo-TF
synthesis enzyme GAL3ST2; (D) synthesis enzyme ratio of 3′-sialyl-TF/Core2;
(E) synthesis enzyme ratio of 3′-sulfo-TF/Core2; (F) synthesis
enzyme ratio of 3′-sulfo-TF/3′-sialyl-TF (GAL3ST2/ST3GAL1)
was used to analyze the correlation with the tumor growth inhibition
rate of AAL/AAGL.
Antitumor activity of
AAL/AAGL has a high-positive correlation
with GAL3ST2/ST3GAL1 (indicate Sulfo-TF/Sialyl-TF). (A) Synthesis
pathways of TF and its related antigens. The mRNA expression levels
of (B) 3′-sialyl-TF synthesis enzyme ST3GAL1; (C) 3′-sulfo-TF
synthesis enzyme GAL3ST2; (D) synthesis enzyme ratio of 3′-sialyl-TF/Core2;
(E) synthesis enzyme ratio of 3′-sulfo-TF/Core2; (F) synthesis
enzyme ratio of 3′-sulfo-TF/3′-sialyl-TF (GAL3ST2/ST3GAL1)
was used to analyze the correlation with the tumor growth inhibition
rate of AAL/AAGL.The expression levels
of the glycosyltransferase mRNA were normalized
to GAPDH mRNA levels, and the expression levels of the glycosyltransferases
in different cells were plotted against the inhibitory effect of AAL/AAGL.
Linear regression analysis was then performed. As shown in Figure S2 and Table , there were low correlations between C1GALT1,
C2GNT2, ST6GALNAC1, and inhibitory activity. We further investigated
the expression of ST3GAL1 (Figure B) and GAL3ST2 (Figure C), which could transfer sialic acid and sulfate to
the TF antigen, respectively. To our surprise, the correlation between
the mRNA levels of these glycosyltransferases and inhibitory activity
was also low (Figure B,C). These results indicated that a single glycosyltransferase may
not determine the structure of the TF-related antigen and the binding
of the cells for AAL/AAGL because sulfotransferases and sialyltransferases
can compete for the same site of acceptors. The expression of 3′-sulfo-TF
and 3′-sialyl-TF may depend on the ratio between sulfotransferases
and sialyltransferases.
Table 2
Relationships among
the Expressions
of Glycosyltransferases, Glycan Structures, and the AAL/AAGL Sensitivity
of Cells
glycosyltransferase
(normalized to GAPDH)
product
R value
C1GALT1
TF
0.2471
C2GNT1
core-2
0.6652
C2GNT2
core-2
0.3186
ST6GALNAC1
sialyl-Tn
0.465
ST3GAL1
3′-sialyl-TF
0.4949
GAL3ST2
3′-sulfo-TF
0.2783
GAL3ST2/C2GNT1
3′-sulfo-TF/core-2
0.277
ST3GAL1/C2GNT1
3′-sialyl-TF/core-2
0.4865
GAL3ST2/C1GALT1
3′-sulfo-TF/TF
0.2755
ST3GAL1/C1GALT1
3′-sialyl-TF/TF
0.4605
GAL3ST2/ST3GAL1
3′-sulfo-TF/3′-sialyl-TF
0.7807
To confirm this hypothesis, the ratios between
GAL3ST2 and ST3GAL1
were plotted against the inhibitory effects of AAL/AAGL, and the results
showed that there was a high correlation between them. The R value
calculated was 0.7807, which is the highest in the list in Table , compared with the
other ratios between the glycosyltransferases of ST3GAL1/C2GNT1, GAL3ST2/C2GNT1,
and inhibitory activity (Figure D–F). These results showed that the cells with
a high ratio between GAL3ST2 and ST3GAL1 express more 3′-sulfo-TF
antigens on the cell surface and that these cells are more sensitive
to AAL/AAGL.
The Ratio between GAL3ST2
and ST3GAL1 Regulates
the AAL/AAGL Sensitivity of Cells
To further confirm that
the antitumor activity of AAL/AAGL was dependent on the 3′-sulfo-TF
antigen, which was decided by the ratio between sulfotransferases
and sialyltransferases, we regulated the ratio between GAL3ST2 and
ST3GAL1 in three cell lines, including Jurkat cells, HeLa cells, and
HL60 cells. The ST3GAL1 had been overexpressed in Jurkat cells. Because
of the competition of GAL3ST2 and ST3GAL1 for the same site of the
TF antigen, overexpressing ST3GAL1 in Jurkat reduced the 3′-sulfo-TF
antigen expression. The ST3GAL1-transfected Jurkat cells reduced the
AAL/AAGL binding activity (Figure A,B), and the viable cell ratio was increased from
55.3 to 64.4% (Figure C). These results directly addressed the role of the O-glycan of the 3′-sulfo-TF antigen in regulating cell susceptibility
to AAL/AAGL.
Figure 6
Ratio between GAL3ST2 and ST3GAL1 regulates the AAL/AAGL
sensitivity
of cells. (A) Affinities of Jurkat cells (solid line) overexpressing
ST3GAL1, and the control Jurkat cells (dotted line) for AAL/AAGL were
determined by flow cytometry after the cells were incubated with AAL/AAGL.
(B) Statistics data of Figure A. (C) Analysis of the viable cell ratio of the Jurkat cells
overexpressing ST3GAL1 and the control Jurkat cells that were treated
with AAL/AAGL. (D, E) Binding of HL60 cells (solid line) overexpressing
GAL3ST2 and the control HL60 cells (dotted line) for AAL/AAGL. (F)
Analysis of the viable cell ratio of the GAL3ST2-overexpressing HL60
cells and control HL60 cells that were treated with AAL/AAGL. (G–I)
Treatment of the HeLa cells was the same as that for the HL60 cells
as mentioned above, and GAL3ST2 was overexpressed in the HeLa cells.
**p < 0.01. (J, K) Ratio of GAL3ST2 to ST3GAL1
before and after the overexpression of glycosyltransferases in three
cell lines (Jurkat, HL60, and HeLa cells) was correlated with the
(J) AAL/AAGL binding and (K) growth inhibition rate of the cells.
Ratio between GAL3ST2 and ST3GAL1 regulates the AAL/AAGL
sensitivity
of cells. (A) Affinities of Jurkat cells (solid line) overexpressing
ST3GAL1, and the control Jurkat cells (dotted line) for AAL/AAGL were
determined by flow cytometry after the cells were incubated with AAL/AAGL.
(B) Statistics data of Figure A. (C) Analysis of the viable cell ratio of the Jurkat cells
overexpressing ST3GAL1 and the control Jurkat cells that were treated
with AAL/AAGL. (D, E) Binding of HL60 cells (solid line) overexpressing
GAL3ST2 and the control HL60 cells (dotted line) for AAL/AAGL. (F)
Analysis of the viable cell ratio of the GAL3ST2-overexpressing HL60
cells and control HL60 cells that were treated with AAL/AAGL. (G–I)
Treatment of the HeLa cells was the same as that for the HL60 cells
as mentioned above, and GAL3ST2 was overexpressed in the HeLa cells.
**p < 0.01. (J, K) Ratio of GAL3ST2 to ST3GAL1
before and after the overexpression of glycosyltransferases in three
cell lines (Jurkat, HL60, and HeLa cells) was correlated with the
(J) AAL/AAGL binding and (K) growth inhibition rate of the cells.HL60 had a low ratio between GAL3ST2 and ST3GAL1.
To increase the
ratio between GAL3ST2 and ST3GAL1, GAL3ST2 was overexpressed in HL60
cells by stable transfection. Because of the competition of GAL3ST2
and ST3GAL1 for the same site of the TF antigen, overexpressing GAL3ST2
in HL60 cells increased the 3′-sulfo-TF antigen expression.
As shown in Figure D,E, the GAL3ST2-transfected HL60 cells showed an increased AAL/AAGL
binding activity, and their antitumor activity was increased from
22.7 to 43.9% (Figure F). Similar results were also observed in HeLa cells. The GAL3ST2-transfected
HeLa cells showed an increased AAL/AAGL binding and antiproliferative
activity (Figure G–I).
Next, we calculated the ratios between GAL3ST2 and ST3GAL1 in the
control cells and in the related enzyme overexpressing cells of the
three cell lines (Jurkat or -M, HL60 or -M, and HeLa or -M), after
which we analyzed the correlation between these ratios and the binding
of AAL/AAGL (Figure J) and inhibitory activity of AAL/AAGL (Figure K), respectively. The results showed that
there was a high correlation between the ratios and the binding and
the inhibitory activity. Our data suggested that the expression of
the 3′-sulfo-TF antigen determines the apoptosis-inducing activity
of AAL/AAGL and that the sensitive cell lines have high ratios between
GAL3ST2 and ST3GAL1. These results suggest that AAL/AAGL may potentially
serve as a 3′-sulfo-TF ligand for cancer diagnosis and for
targeted therapy.
Discussion
Lectins
are glycan-binding proteins whose activities depend on
the binding to specific carbohydrate structures.[20] To date, glycan ligands of many lectins have been identified
by glycan arrays and other methods. These data have helped to develop
many new methods for using lectins in glycan enrichment, drug delivery,
and even tumor therapy.[33] Glycan arrays
provide valuable candidate glycan ligands of lectins. However, those
candidate glycan ligands should be further verified because lectin
may recognize different ligands in different cells or species. Our
data indicated that AAL/AAGL recognizes 3′-sulfo-TF in human
cells. However, the sialic acid-sugars (Figure S1) may be AAL/AAGL’s ligands in Agrocybe aegertia, from which AAL/AAGL purified. Identifying the physiological ligands
of lectins in cells needs more investigation, which is important for
the more effective use of lectins. In this paper, based on the glycan
array data, we successfully identified that 3′-sulfo-TF is
one of the main ligands involved in the apoptosis-inducing activity
of AAL/AAGL by analyzing glycosyltransferases. Our work provides a
reference for the study of the physiological glycan ligands of other
lectins.AAL/AAGL is an edible mushroom lectin and belongs to
the galectin
family, which has a highly conserved CRD region that recognizes β-galactoside-containing
glycans. Mammalian galectin has been intensively investigated for
its ubiquitous location and for its ability to regulate multiple biologic
functions.[34,35] Although there are some studies
on glycan ligands of mammalian galectin that reported that LacNAc
was a common ligand of all galectins,[36] it is obvious that galectins function with distinct activities through
different glycans. The TF-related antigens (Gal1–3GalNAc1-Ser/Thr,
Thomsen-Friedenreich, TF antigen) which are overexpressed at the tumor
cell surface and have been proposed to facilitate tumor progression
by helping tumor cells to escape from immunity and by protecting tumor
cells from apoptosis.[37−39] It has been reported that Gal-2 could interact with
mucin in a β-galactoside-dependent manner, strengthening the
gastric mucosa barrier structure.[40] The
crystal structure analysis supports the identification of the distinct
TF-binding properties of Gal-1 and Gal-3.[41] It has been reported that core 2 O-glycans are
receptors for galectin-1. Conversely, Gal-1 binding is thwarted when
LacNAc is modified by a 2,3-linked sialic acid.[42] Core 2 O-glycans may be the primary ligands
for Gal-3 on diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL) cells as a novel
mechanism of apoptosis resistance in DLBCL.[43]The sulfation modification is an important event in cell adhesion,
bacterial binding, and the regulation of biosynthetic pathways.[44,45] Sulfated glycoconjugates were found in a wide range of biological
compounds, including glycoproteins, proteoglycans, glycolipids, and
polysaccharides, which contribute to many important physiological
processes, such as inflammatory reaction, blood coagulation, and cell
adhesion and cancermetastasis.[46,47] When the TF antigen
is catalyzed by GAL3ST2 at the C3 position of galactose, the 3′-sulfo-TF
antigen ([3OSO3]-Galβ1–3GalNAcα-Ser/Thr) is produced.[37] In breast epithelial mammary tumors, GAL3ST2
is more strongly expressed in more metastatic tumors,[48,49] indicating that 3′-sulfo-TF expressed from tumor cells may
be a promising prognostic marker. The 3′-sulfo-TF antigen is
also identified as the ligand of Galectin-4,[50,51] a member of human galectin, which is expressed in the epithelium
of the alimentary tract. Hiroko Ideo et al. showed that MUC1 possessing
a 3′-sulfo-TF antigen was highly expressed in the blood streams
of patients with recurrent and/or metastatic breast cancer. The Gal4/MUC1(3′-sulfo-TF)
assay was more sensitive than the cancer antigen15–3 assay,
especially in the relapsed or metastatic breast cancer.[52] Galectin-4 suppresses T cell activation depended
on the 3′-sulfo-glycolipid group.[53] Galectin-4 could be used as for the quantification of the 3′-sulfo-TF
antigen on account of high binding affinity to it. In this report,
we identified 3′-sulfo-TF as the glycan ligand of AAL/AAGL
and showed the expression of the 3′-sulfo-TF antigen, which
is determined by the ratio of GAL3ST2/ST3GAL1. This work also suggests
that AAL/AAGL potentially could be used for cancer diagnosis, therapy,
and quantification of the 3′-sulfo-TF antigen.Recently,
some lectins have the ability to discriminate between
normal cells and tumor cells as a result of their different glycosylation
patterns. The use of lectins in the modification of nanoparticles
for anticancer drug delivery has been reported.[54] The plant lectin ConA covalently coupled with nanoparticles
has been developed for bone cancer treatment.[55] G. Obaid, I et al. showed that jacalin, a lectin specific for the
T antigen, can deliver nanoparticles to HT-29humancolon adenocarcinoma
cells.[56] These new pharmaceutical preparations
increase antitumor effectiveness and decrease toxicity toward healthy
cells. AAL/AAGL with high binding affinity to the 3′-sulfo-TF
antigen could be covalently coupled with nanoparticles and emerged
as important tools to target cancer therapy.Of note, even though
galectins recognize similar glycosidic structures,
different galectins can induce distinct or even opposite activities.[35] It should be considered that galectins could
exert diverse activities through slightly different glycans on different
types of cells or under stimulation. In addition to antitumor activity,
AAL/AAGL has also been reported to play important roles in fungus
development from mycelia to the fruiting body.[57] In this report, we found that the glycan ligand of O-glycan (3′-sulfo-TF) was the glycan ligand for
AAL/AAGL antitumor activity, but there may be other glycan ligands
for AAL/AAGL’s multiple functions that remain unknown and deserve
further investigation.
Materials and Methods
Glycan Array Analysis
A complete
list of the glycans and the RFU values obtained for the binding of
AAL/AAGL (200, 100, and 20 μg/mL) and several mutants (200 μg/mL)
(Supporting data1–6), along with
the statistical analysis, is available at http://www.functionalglycomics.org/ by searching the lectin name “AAL.”
Cell Lines and Reagents
Humanleukemia
cell lines derived from acute myelogenous leukemia (HL-60), erythroblastic
cell leukemia (K562), pro-monocytic leukemia (U937), Burkitt’s
lymphoma (Raji), and T-cell leukemia (Molt-4, Jurkat) were obtained
from the CCTCC (China Center for Type Culture Collection, Wuhan, Huibei,
People’s Republic of China). All cells were grown in the RPMI
medium supplemented with fetal bovine serum, 100 mg/mL streptomycin,
and 100 units/mL penicillin. Recombinant AAL/AAGL was purified as
previously described.[58]
Assays for Growth Inhibition and Apoptosis
Cells were
treated with 5 μM AAL/AAGL, 100 μM lactose,
and 50 μM Z-VAD-FMK or with appropriate buffer controls for
48 h at 37 °C. The growth-inhibitory effect of AAL/AAGL was then
analyzed with a modified MTT assay using the Cell Counting Kit-8 (Dojindo,
Japan). The data represent the results of the means±standard
errors of three independent experiments. To assess apoptosis, the
cells were counterstained with propidium iodide and annexin V-FITC.
Western Blotting
Western blotting
was performed as described previously. The primary antibodies (Abs)
used were those against caspase-3, poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP),
phosphorylated JNK (all from Cell Signaling Technology, Beverly, MA,
USA), the TF antigen (A78-G/A7), actin, β-tubulin (all from
Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Santa Cruz, CA, USA), caspase-9, caspase-8,
bcl-2, GAPDH (all from Beyotime Institute of Biotechnology, Jiangsu,
Haimen, China), and FAS (Proteintech Group, Chicago, IL, USA).
Cell Surface Binding Affinity of AAL/AAGL
Cells were
treated with 2 mM benzyl-a-GalNAc in ethanol or with
appropriate buffer controls for 72 h at 37 °C. Cells (1 ×
106) were incubated with AAL/AAGL (5 μM) in PBS buffer
containing 5.0% BSA. After being washed in PBS, the cells were incubated
with a polyclonal rabbit anti-AAL/AAGL antibody (1:100) for 1 h, after
which a FITC-conjugated goat antirabbit IgG (Pierce Chemical Co.,
Rockford, IL, USA) was added to the sample and incubated for 30 min
followed by washing with PBS. For the negative control, the cells
were incubated only with the polyclonal rabbit anti-AAL/AAGL antibody
and the FITC-conjugated goat antirabbit antibody. After binding of
AAL/AAGL, the stably transfected cells were finally stained with Texas
red-conjugated goat antirabbit antibody. The cells were washed twice
and subjected to flow cytometric analysis. Statistical software GraphPad
Prism was used for ANOVA analysis of flow cytometry data. All treatments
were performed three times.
Analysis of Glycosyltransferase
Gene Expression
RNA was isolated as described previously.[59] RT-PCR was performed according to the protocol
provided in the SuperScript
One-Step RT-PCR with Platinum Taq (Invitrogen). The real-time PCR
of core 1 synthase (C1GALT1), glucosaminyl (N-acetyl)
transferase 1 (C2GNT1), C2GNT2, ST3 beta-galactoside alpha-2,3-sialyltransferase
1 (ST3GAL1), alpha-N-acetylgalactosaminide alpha-2,6-sialyltransferase
1 (ST6GALNAC1), and galactose-3-O-sulfotransferase 2 (GAL3ST2) was
performed. Quantitation of human glycosyltransferase transcript expression
by real-time PCR was performed on a real-time PCR detection system
with SYBR Green Real-time PCR Master Mix (TOYOBO, Japan) using 1 μL
of cDNA. The PCR conditions included 1 cycle at 95 °C for 2 min
followed by 45 cycles at 95 °C for 15 s, 60 °C for 15 s,
and 72 °C for 45 s. The amount of glycosyltransferase transcript
was normalized to the amount of GAPDH transcript in the same cDNA
sample. Relative fold differences in transcript expression were approximated
using the comparative CT method. Real-time PCR was performed using
the following PCR primers: C1GALT1, 5-TCATCCCTTTGTGCCAGAACACC-3 (5′-primer)
and 5-TCAGAGCAGCAACCAGGACCCTC-3 (3′-primer); C2GNT1, 5-GACGTTGCTGCGAAGG-3
(5′-primer) and 5- CCAAGTGTCTGACACTTACA-3 (3′-primer);
C2GNT2 5-GGCAGTGCTTCAGGCTATTC-3 (5′-primer) and 5-GGCATACACAGCTCGCAGTA-3
(3′-primer); ST3GAL1, 5-ATGCATGTCTGCGATGAGGTGGACTTGT-3 (5′-primer)
and 5-GCCAAGGTGGCCGTCACGTTAGACT-3 (3′-primer); ST6GALNAC1;
GAL3ST2, 5-TGTTCCTGAAGACGCACAAG-3 (5′-primer) and 5-AACCTCAGGTGGTTGCACAT-3
(3′-primer). To validate differences in the expression levels
of ST3GAL1 and the C2GNT2, reverse transcription-PCR (RT-PCR) analysis
was performed. Semi-quantitative PCR was performed using the following
PCR primers: ST3GAL1, 5-CTCACCTCCTTCTTCCTGAACTACT-3 (5′-primer)
and ST3GAL1, 5-GACAAAGTCGTGACTGTCTATCTCA-3 (3′-primer); GAL3ST2,
5-AGAGATACTTCCGGGTCATCCTC-3 (5′-primer) and GAL3ST2, 5-GCGTAGGTTTTGTAGTAGATGAAGG-3
(3′-primer); GAPDH, 5-AGGTCGGAGTCAACGGATTTG-3 (5′-primer)
and GAPDH, 5-GTGATGGCATGGACTGTGGT-3 (3′-primer).
Expression of β-Galactoside α2,3-Sialyltransferase
1 in Jurkat Cells
β-Galactoside α2,3-sialyltransferase
1 (ST3GAL1) cDNA (gift of Dr. Linda G. Baum, Department of Pathology
and Laboratory Medicine, School of Medicine, University of California
at Los Angeles) was subcloned into pEGFP (Clontech; pST3). Jurkat
cells (2 × 107) were transfected with 100 μg
of pST3 or vector alone (control) by electroporation. Stable transfectants
were isolated using 0.8 mg/mL G418 (Sigma). Clones appeared after
3 weeks and were selected according to their phenotype as determined
by FACS analysis.
Expression of Galactose-3-O-Sulfotransferase
2 in HL60 Cells
Galactose-3-O-sulfoTransferase 2 (GAL3ST2)
cDNA (gift of Dr. Koichi Honke, Department of Biochemistry, Kochi
University Medical School, Kohasu, Japan) was subcloned into pEGFP
(Clontech; pST3). HL60 cells (2 × 107) were transfected
with 100 μg of pST3 or vector alone (control) by electroporation.
Stable transfectants were isolated using 0.8 mg/mL G418 (Sigma). Clones
appeared after 3 weeks and were selected according to their phenotype
as determined by FACS analysis.
Chemicals
Z-VAD-FMK was purchased
from the Beyotime Institute of Biotechnology (Jiangsu, Haimen, China);
benzyl-a-N-acetylgalactosamine (benzyl-a-GalNAc),
G418, and lactose were purchased from Sigma (St Louis, MO, USA).
Authors: Mathias Ingemann Nielsen; John Stegmayr; Oliver C Grant; Zhang Yang; Ulf J Nilsson; Irene Boos; Michael C Carlsson; Robert J Woods; Carlo Unverzagt; Hakon Leffler; Hans H Wandall Journal: J Biol Chem Date: 2018-11-01 Impact factor: 5.157
Authors: Qi Xiao; Anna-Kristin Ludwig; Cecilia Romanò; Irene Buzzacchera; Samuel E Sherman; Maria Vetro; Sabine Vértesy; Herbert Kaltner; Ellen H Reed; Martin Möller; Christopher J Wilson; Daniel A Hammer; Stefan Oscarson; Michael L Klein; Hans-Joachim Gabius; Virgil Percec Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2018-01-30 Impact factor: 11.205