| Literature DB >> 34190034 |
Marni Sommer1, Belen Torondel2, Julie Hennegan3,4, Penelope A Phillips-Howard5, Thérèse Mahon6, Albert Motivans7, Garazi Zulaika5, Caitlin Gruer8, Jacquelyn Haver9, Bethany A Caruso10.
Abstract
There is increasing global attention to the importance of menstrual health and hygiene (MHH) for the lives of those who menstruate and gender equality. Yet, the global development community, which focuses on issues ranging from gender to climate change to health, is overdue to draw attention to how addressing MHH may enable progress in attaining the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). To address this gap, we undertook a collective exercise to hypothesize the linkages between MHH and the 17 SDGs, and to identify how MHH contributes to priority outcome measures within key sectoral areas of relevance to menstruating girls in low- and middle-income countries. These areas included Education, Gender, Health (Sexual and Reproductive Health; Psychosocial Wellbeing), and Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (WASH). These efforts were undertaken from February - March 2019 by global monitoring experts, together with select representatives from research institutions, non-governmental organizations, and governments (n = 26 measures task force members). Through this paper we highlight the findings of our activities. First, we outline the existing or potential linkages between MHH and all of the SDGs. Second, we report the identified priority outcomes related to MHH for key sectors to monitor. By identifying the potential contribution of MHH towards achieving the SDGs and highlighting the ways in which MHH can be monitored within these goals, we aim to advance recognition of the fundamental role of MHH in the development efforts of countries around the world.Entities:
Keywords: Menstrual health; education; gender; psychosocial; sanitation
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34190034 PMCID: PMC8253211 DOI: 10.1080/16549716.2021.1920315
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Glob Health Action ISSN: 1654-9880 Impact factor: 2.640
Figure 1.Relationship between menstrual health and hygiene (MHH) and Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
Figure 2.Methodological approach for identifying priority outcomes
Relevance of Menstrual Health and Hygiene (MHH) to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and type of linkage (see Figure 1)
| SDG | Hypothesized linkage to MHH | Type of link |
|---|---|---|
| 1. MHH directly contributes to SDG | ||
Lack of WASH, menstrual supplies/products, and pain management solutions may contribute to perpetuating the cycle of poverty as it limits the ability for those who menstruate to take part in economic opportunities. | 2 and 3 | |
| | Poverty may contribute to lack of adequate WASH and menstrual supplies and products. | 2 and 3 |
Those who menstruate in poverty may need to make trade-offs (with food purchasing and other survival necessities) in daily life for menstrual materials. | 3 | |
Restrictions on girls’ and women’s movements during menstruation may hinder the ability to engage in food procurement or food preparation-related activities. | 3 | |
Knowledge of the menstrual cycle and confidence navigating menstruation may have strong links with SRH and wellbeing, including family planning. | 1 | |
Understanding menstrual pain and norms of menstrual bleeding may be essential for wellbeing, and for identifying whether or not there is a need to seek out advice or medical attention. | 1 | |
Being able to hygienically manage menses may have consequences for reproductive health, reproductive tract infections (impacting maternal and HIV-related outcomes), and wellbeing. | 1 | |
Access to health care and menstrual pain relief may influence MHH (e.g. universal access to SRH health-care services; integration of RH into national strategies) | 1 and 3 | |
Positive associations may exist between MHH, SRH and mental health and psychosocial well-being; linkages, for example, with improved education/#4 and economics #8). | 1 | |
School physical (e,g. toilets by sex with privacy, see SDG#6) and social environments that are not discriminatory towards menstruating students may improve MHH; includes disposal systems, such as SDG#6 and #9). | 1 and 3 | |
Quality of teaching about MHH may strengthen knowledge and confidence in school for students who menstruate; Providing MHH training to teachers may increase support for menstruating students and improve their MHH. | 1 and 3 | |
Presence of female teachers may increase social and more broadly education system support around MHH in school. | 1 and 3 | |
Schools may serve as a location of MHH interventions, especially related to information, knowledge, life skills | 1 and 3 | |
MHH experience may shape learning experiences; a lack of MHH knowledge, access to facilities and supplies, and health support may impede learning. | 1 and 3 | |
Comprehensive Sexuality Education (CSE) supports knowledge and awareness mentioned in SDG3. | 1 and 3 | |
Assuring that all schools, workplaces, households, etc., may enable managing menstruation with dignity and comfort, challenge discriminatory gender norms and reduce experiences of stigma and gender inequitable social and physical environments. | 1 and 3 | |
Poor MHH may be a source of gender inequality and discrimination, hindering the health and well-being of those who menstruate, and their engagement in activities of daily living, free of fear, shame and stigma. | 1 | |
Engaging men and boys on menstruation in order to increase their knowledge and understanding, may reduce stigma and increase their support of those who menstruate in their lives. | 1 and 3 | |
May enable the ability to manage menstruation in safety and comfort with facilities, clean water, disposal, etc. at home, schools, institutions, in public places, reducing gender discrimination of inadequate facilities. | 1 and 3 | |
Access/right to water, sanitation and hygiene during menstruation may be essential for daily life. | 3 | |
Menstrual waste may impact the sustainability and functionality of WASH services. | 1 and 3 | |
Privacy and safety of WASH may be essential to protect against gender and sexual violence. | 3 | |
Energy may be needed to produce single-use pads. | 3 and 4 | |
Energy may be needed in maintaining (washing, boiling) menstrual products; ranging from menstrual pads to cloths to cups. | 3 and 4 | |
Energy may be needed to adequately dispose of used menstrual products (e.g. burning); the latter also contributes to pollution. | 3 and 4 | |
Workplace physical and social environments may need to support MHH in order to not be gender discriminatory. | 1 and 4 | |
Inadequate awareness of and resources for menstrual disorders may hinder engagement in work | 1 and 4 | |
Reduced economic productivity may occur when MHH needs are not fully met. | 1 and 4 | |
Ensuring access to safe and ggender-sensitivesanitation facilities and disposal solutions in work environments, the absence of which may hinder those who are menstruating from high economic productivity. | 1 and 4 | |
Encouraging innovation in toilet design, disposal systems, laundering and menstrual product types may improve MHH. | 2 | |
Small companies and social entrepreneurs making menstrual products and creating small sanitation-related businesses (female friendly toilets, waste disposal) may be generating employment | 2 | |
May support environmentally responsible production of MHH products. | 2 | |
May address inequalities in who can manage menstruation without significant barriers (e.g. people with disabilities, transgender individuals, those with unstable housing). | 1 | |
Economic inequalities contribute to unmet MHH needs, and unmet MHH needs may exacerbate inequalities based on access to resources including products and changing/bathing (WASH) facilities, exposing girls and women to SRH risks and violence. | 1 | |
Providing female friendly toilets may enable good MHH. | 1 and 2 | |
Constructing or adapting sanitation systems may adequately address product disposal and waste management. | 1 and 2 | |
May ensure water availability and access for cleaning and laundering menstrual products as needed. | 1 and 2 | |
May address pollution generated by single-use disposables and used reusables; dumping and burning of waste (plastics, fluoxins, dioxins). | 1 and 2 | |
May support innovation on menstrual product waste management to reduce pollution. | 2 and 3 | |
May provide menstrual product choice, including bio-degradable and safe reusable options. | 2 and 3 | |
Water shortages secondary to climate change may impact MHH. | 2 and 3 | |
Climate change-related planning and management may be insufficient if does not include MHH considerations for women, youth, and marginalized communities in relation to product innovations. | 2 and 3 | |
May address pollution related to menstrual product disposal practices. | 2 and 3 | |
Education of girls is a high-impact climate solution, which may be hindered if inadequate attention given to MHH in schools (see #4). | 2 and 3 | |
Single-use menstrual materials may contribute to environmental pollution. | 2 | |
Lack of appropriate menstrual product disposal options may lead to disposal practices contaminating rivers, lakes and other waterways. | 2 | |
Improper menstrual product disposal (and increased use of ssingle-usedisposables) may contribute to contaminating the environment. | 2 and 3 | |
Pads are often promoted without disposal implications, and may end up in rivers, forests; more attention may be needed for menstrual product disposal and waste management. | 2 and 3 | |
Marginalized groups may not receive attention/resources/support for MHH (e.g. homeless, transgender and non-binary, refugees). | 4 | |
Gender-based violence (GBV) may inhibit access to MHH needs; may experience vulnerability to GBV near toilets. | 4 | |
Persistence and impact of gender unequal taxation (e.g. menstrual products as luxury goods) may negatively impact those who menstruate. | 3 | |
Could address the intersection women’s empowerment and health. | 3 | |
MHH may be essential to meet education for all, and a reduction of the ongoing gender gap in schooling. | 3 | |
Public-private partnerships may be essential for WASH delivery, menstrual product provision, etc. | 3 | |
Could encourage cooperation on access to menstrual related technologies and innovations including those related to menstrual disposal solutions that could be adapted to local contexts. | 3 | |
| [ | ||
Figure 3.Spider diagram analyses of Sexual and Reproductive Health (SRH) and MHH aligned outcome measures
Examples of sector priority outcomes’ alignment with Menstrual Health and Hygiene (MHH)
| Sector priority outcomes Linked to SDGs | Alignment with MHH |
|---|---|
| Proportion of schools, and teachers in school who have received high quality gender-sensitive teacher training | Teacher training enables effective and sensitive delivery of MHH guidance and support for menstruating girls. |
| Proportion of schools that provide life-skills-based HIV and sexuality education | Curricula that include comprehensive sexuality education (CSE). MHH content and teaching methods that raise awareness for girls, boys and teachers, help challenge discriminatory gender norms and destigmatize menstruation. |
| Attendance, completion rates (primary, lower and upper secondary education) (SDG 4.1.2, 4.1.4 and 4.1.5), transition rates (from primary to lower secondary education), disaggregated by sex | May restrict ability to participate and engage in school during menstruation, and related absenteeism. Potential implications of menarche for child marriage and/or early pregnancy. |
| Learning achievement (proportion of children and young people in grade 2/3, end of primary and end of lower secondary achieving at least a minimal level of proficiency in reading and mathematics disaggregated by sex (SDG 4.1.1) | Inadequate, educational, social and physical support for menstruating girls may impact confidence, concentration and engagement in classroom; performance on academic activities. |
| Proportion of girls suffering psychological distress and anxiety associated with MHH (SDG 3.8.1) | Shame, stigma/teasing, and other menstruation-related stressors (e.g. pain, lack of materials) may lead to psychological distress. |
| Proportion of girls diagnosed with mental health issues related to MHH (SDG 3.8.1) | Inability to participate fully in valued/important social activities; the negative impact that not participating in educational/economic activities can have on mental health. |
| Proportion of girls reporting stigma associated with their MHH | Internationalized menstrual stigma around menarche and menstruation. |
| Adolescent birth rate (10–14 year olds and 15–19 year olds) (SDG 3.7) | Limited menstruation-related knowledge (and related social norms) may constrain ability to make decisions about sex and pregnancy prevention; sexual risk-taking behaviors; need for transactional sex due to economic vulnerability and need for menstrual supplies; lack of sexual decision-making authority within relationships due to gender power disparities. |
| Proportion of girls in a given setting with anemia (moderate or severe) | Lack of reproductive health care services, ongoing anemia may contribute to poor health outcomes. |
| Contraception (modern contraceptive prevalence, disaggregated by age) | Knowledge, bodily autonomy/empowerment, management of CIMBCs*. |
| Proportion of girls <19 years forced into child marriage | Menarche may indicate readiness for marriage in societies where women are first seen as spouses, mothers and caregivers |
| Proportion of schools with female-friendly WASH facilities | Enables MHH while in classroom and at school for female students, teachers and administration |
| Proportion of women and girls able to manage MHH specific needs at home (SDG 6.2) | Enables MHH while at home |
| Proportion of health care facilities with acceptable female-friendly WASH facilities | Enables MHH while in health care facilities and supports targets for universal health coverage and quality of care, etc. |
| Proportion of women and girls in refugee camps able to manage MHH specific needs (SDG6.2) | Enables MHH in refugee camps and other vulnerable situations |
| Gender norms and discriminatory practices | Shape norms around menstruation – impacts menstrual health, while menstrual specific norms reinforce some gender norms/expectations; such as policies and tax regulations that support those who menstruate; or practices that limit those who menstruate from engaging in religious life. |
| Proportion of girls forced into child labor, including domestic work (SDG 5.1.1) | Gender enabling environments – including for MHH – needed beyond schools. |
| Proportion of girls <19 forced into child marriage | Menarche may indicate readiness for marriage, negatively impacting efforts to empower girls as they transition into adulthood. |
| Gender budgeting or resource allocation for gender equity (SDG 5.c.1) | Enables the financing of MHH related interventions. |
| Proportion of girls experiencing gender-based violence (SDG 5.2.2) | Menarche may increase vulnerability of girls to sexual violence, sexual coercion, adolescent births and early marriage. |
| [ | |
*CIMBC = Contraceptive-Induced Menstrual Bleeding Changes, may include bleeding patterns which are predictable but deviate from a typical menstrual pattern, such as amenorrhea induced by some long-acting contraceptives [34].