| Literature DB >> 34067818 |
Liliana Hawrysz1, Grażyna Gierszewska1, Agnieszka Bitkowska1.
Abstract
The issue of research on patient satisfaction with healthcare services took on a completely new dimension due to the COVID-19 pandemic and the developing telehealth services. This results from the fact that during the pandemic, remote healthcare was often the only possible form of care provision to the patient. The COVID-19 pandemic has substantially accelerated the implementation of remote healthcare in healthcare institutions and made it an essential tool for providing healthcare services. The objective of the literature review was to study the research on patient satisfaction with remote healthcare services prior to and during the pandemic. The study featured a literature review of electronic databases, such as: Medline, ProQuest, PubMED, Ebsco, Google Scholar, WoS. The identified empirical papers were classified in two groups concerning the research on patient satisfaction prior to and during the COVID-19 pandemic, and were divided and descriptively synthesised. Certain limitations to the methodical quality of the research were demonstrated as result of the conducted analyses. It was also ascertained that researchers lack clarity on the method of defining and measuring satisfaction prior to and during the COVID-19 pandemic.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; patient satisfaction; remote healthcare; telehealth services
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34067818 PMCID: PMC8156025 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph18105338
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Selected characteristics of the research on patient satisfaction prior to the Covid-19 pandemic.
| Author | Categories of Care | Type of Measures | Telemedicine Tool | Country |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mendez et al. [ | Primary Care | own measures | videoconferencing | Canada |
| Yang Y. Zhang X. Lee P. [ | Neurology: chronic neurological disorders | own measures | unspecified | Chinese medical platform |
| Davis et al. [ | Neurology: chronic neurological disorders | own measures | videoconferencing | USA |
| Baranowski, M. L., Balakrishnan, V., & Chen, S. C. [ | Dermatology | own measures | unspecified | USA |
| Burns et al. [ | Rehabilitation | own measures | videoconferencing | Australia |
| Polinski et al. [ | Primary Care | own measures | videoconferencing | USA |
| Hilty et al. [ | Psychiatry | own measures | videoconferencing | USA |
| Saqui et al. [ | Gastroenterology: | own measures | videoconferencing | Canada |
| Simpson et al. [ | Psychotherapy: | own measures | videoconferencing | Scotland |
| Zilliacus et al. [ | Oncology (cancer) | own measures | videoconferencing | Australia |
| Tokuda et al. [ | Diabetes | own measures | videoconferencing | USA |
Figure 1Search strategy and selection of papers.
Selected characteristics of the research on patient satisfaction during the Covid-19 pandemic.
| Author | Categories of Care | Type of Measures | Telemedicine Tool | Country |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mohanty et al. [ | ambulatory neurosurgery | own measures | unspecified | USA |
| Gerbutavicius et al. [ | ophthalmology | own measures | video | Germany |
| Byrne & Watkinson [ | orthodontic | own measures | video | UK |
| Bhuva, Lankford, Patel, & Haddas [ | rehabilitation | own measures | mixed (audio/video) | USA |
| Zhu et al. [ | surgery | own measures | video | USA |
| Horgan, Alsabbagh, McGoldrick, Bhatia, & Messahel [ | surgery | own measures | audio | UK |
| Haxhihamza et al. [ | psychiatry | PSQ- 18 | video | Macedonia |
| Smrke et al. [ | oncology | own measures | audio | UK |
| Pinar et al. [ | urology | TSQ | video (virtual room) | France |
| Campennì et al. [ | proctology | own measures | mixed (audio/video | Italy |
| Semprino et al. [ | pediatric | own measures | video (Whatsapp) | Argentina |
| Kaur, Galloway, & Oyibo [ | endocrinology | own measures | audio | UK |
| Park et al. [ | unspecified | TUQ | audio | Korea |
| Itamura, Tang, et al. [ | otolaryngology | own measures | video | USA |
| Kodama et al. [ | cardiology | own measures | not specified/monitoring | USA |
| Liu et al. [ | outpatient visit | own measures | video | China |
| Timmers, Janssen, Stohr, Murk, & Berrevoets [ | unspecified | own measures | audio/monitoring | Netherlands |
| Kato-Lin & Thelen [ | unspecified/acute conditions | own measures | video | USA |
| Fieux et al. [ | otolaryngology | own measures | video | France |
| Layfield et al. [ | otolaryngology | TUQ | video | USA |
| Yoon et al. [ | neurosurgery | Hicks et al. [ | mixed (audio/video | USA |
| Dhahri, Iqbal, & Pardoe [ | outpatient visit | own measures | video | USA |
| Garcia-Huidobro, Rivera, Chang, Bravo, & Capurro [ | outpatient visit | own measures | video | Chile |
| Leibar Tamayo et al. [ | urology | own measures | audio | Spain |
| Barca et al., [ | surgery | own measures | mixed (audio/video | Italy |
| Rizzi, Polachek, Dulas, Strelzow, & Hynes [ | unspecified | own measures | video | USA |
| Casares, Wombles, Skinner, Westerveld, & Gireesh [ | neurology | own measures | video | USA |
| Tenforde et al. [ | rehabilitation | SQUIRE 2.0 | video | USA |
| Ramaswamy et al. [ | unspecified | WCM Press Ganey Medical Practice Survey | video | USA |
| Morisada et al. [ | rhinology | PSQ-18 | video | USA |
| Annis et al. [ | unspecified | own measures | audio/monitoring | USA |
| Kirby et al. [ | sports medicine | own measures | video | USA |
| Satin et al. [ | surgery | [ | video | USA |
| Chang, Jay, Kalpakjian, Andrews, & Smith [ | rehabilitation | own measures | mixed (audio/video | USA |
| Banks et al. [ | neurology | own measures | audio | Ireland |
| Barkai et al. [ | outpatient visit | own measures | video | Israel |
| Gutkin et al. [ | oncology | own measures | video | USA |
| Guinart, Marcy, Hauser, Dwyer, & Kane [ | psychiatry | own measures | mixed (audio/video | USA |
| Singh et al. [ | outpatient visit | own measures | audio | India |
| Motolese et al. [ | neurology | own measures | audio | Italy |
| Kumar et al. [ | orthopedics | [ | audio | India |
| Li, Chan, Huang, & Cheng [ | surgery | own measures | video | China |
| Ashmawy et al. [ | surgery | own measures | video | UK |
| Darr et al. [ | otolaryngology | The Pediatric Otolaryngology Telemedicine Satisfaction survey (POTSS): GMC, TESS, TUQ, TSUQ | mixed (audio/video | UK |
| Futterman et al. [ | gynecology | The Short Assessment of Patient Satisfaction (SAPS) | audio | USA |
| Isautier et al. [ | unspecified | own measures | mixed (audio/video | Australia |
| Kerr et al. [ | cardiology | own measures | audio | Ireland |
| Shafi et al. [ | orthopedics | own measures | video | USA |
| Sendagorta et al. [ | dermatology | own measures | asynchronous: store-and-forward | Spain |
| Itamura, Rimell, et al. [ | otolaryngology | own measures | video | USA |
| Singh et al. [ | cardiology | Patient Assessment of Communication during Telemedicine (PACT) | video | USA |
| Taxonera et al. [ | gastroenterology | own measures | audio | Spain |
| Schuster-Bruce, Middleton, Macpherson, Pearce, & Evans [ | oncology | own measures | audio | UK |
| Shiff, Frankel, Oake, Blachman-Braun, & Patel [ | urology | own measures | audio | Canada |
| Khan et al. [ | orthopedic, ophthalmology, and general medicine | own measures | audio | Pakistan |