B Cribier1, C Taieb2, M Saint Aroman3, J Shourick4. 1. Clinique Dermatologique, Hôpitaux Universitaires de Strasbourg, Strasbourg Cedex, France. 2. EMMA, Patients Priority, Fontenay sous-bois, France. 3. Pierre Fabre Dermo-Cosmétique, Corporate Patient Centricity, Lavaur, France. 4. Epidemiology, CHU Toulouse, Toulouse, France.
This study was funded by Pierre Fabre Dermo‐Cosmétique.
Conflicts of interest
MSA is employee of Pierre Fabre Dermo‐Cosmétique, and other authors do not have any conflict of interest to declare.EditorThe requirement to wear masks as part of barrier measures to prevent the transmission of SARS‐CoV‐2 has generated many dermatological issues, for healthcare professionals (HCP) and the general population.
These problems may be related to skin changes due to occlusion, i.e. increased temperature and humidity, water loss, friction etc.
While some studies focussed on skin changes in the general population, others suggested that facial skin diseases worsen with wearing permanently a mask.
To date, no study has evaluated these consequences in real‐life settings in a large population‐based multinational representative sample.We performed a survey in 4 countries (France, Italy, Spain, Germany), in a representative sample generated using the quota method.We first compared the population with no skin diseases, those with skin diseases not involving the face and those with a skin disease involving the face using the chi‐square test for categorical variables and Kruskal–Wallis for the responders’ age. Patients we asked about different skin sensation due to the mask and those reporting at least one were categorized as having ‘uncomfortable sensation due to the mask’ which we used as outcome in a multivariate logistic regression.Among the 8077 respondents, 7221 had to wear a mask during the day (89.4%). The median age was 32.00 IQR [46.00–60.00]; they were 3641 (50.4%) women (Table 1). Among them, 28% (n = 2021) declared to suffer from skin diseases [atopic dermatitis/eczema (7.73%; n = 558) – psoriasis (4.06%; n = 293) – acne (6.44%; n = 465) – rosacea (2.60%; n = 188) – chronic hand eczema (1.48%; n = 107) – vitiligo (1.25%; n = 90) – hidradenitis suppurativa (0.46%; n = 3)].
Table 1
Demographic data
No skin disease N = 5196
Skin disease not involving the face N = 1075
Skin disease involving the face N = 950
P value
Country
N
%
N
%
N
%
<0.001
France
1445
27.8
213
19.8
227
23.9
Germany
1044
20.1
177
16.5
179
18.8
Spain
1319
25.4
359
33.4
325
34.2
Italy
1388
26.7
326
30.3
219
23.1
Age
49 ± 28
45 ± 24
35 ± 25
<0.001
Sex
N
%
N
%
N
%
Women
2544
49
555
51.6
542
57.1
<0.001
Men
2652
51
520
48.4
408
42.9
Area
N
%
N
%
N
%
0.003
Urban area
2451
47.2
536
49.9
474
49.9
Semi‐urban area
1627
31.3
334
31.1
322
33.9
Rural area
1118
21.5
205
19.1
154
16.2
Wear Mask
N
%
N
%
N
%
<0.001
0–4 h
2861
55.1
514
47.8
370
38.9
4–8 h
1604
30.9
384
35.7
369
38.8
>8 h
731
14.1
177
16.5
211
22.2
Unpleasant sensation
1846
35.5
571
53.1
655
68.9
<0.001
Itch
722
13.9
233
21.7
292
30.7
<0.001
Tingling
714
13.7
246
22.9
321
33.8
<0.001
Sensation of tightness
612
11.8
168
15.6
210
22.1
<0.001
Burning sensation
299
5.8
111
10.3
128
13.5
<0.001
Protect from others look
2180
42
383
35.6
554
58.3
<0.001
Demographic dataUnpleasant sensation due to wearing a mask was reported by 3072 (42.5%) respondents (itch 17.3%, tingling 17.7%, burning sensation 7.5%, sensation of tightness 13.7%). Each type of unpleasant sensations was more prevalent in subjects with dermatoses and among them in those with dermatoses involving the face (Table 1). The multivariate analysis with uncomfortable sensations as outcome (Fig. 1) showed an OR of 2.02 IC 95% [1.76, 2.33], (P < 0.001) for skin diseases without face involvement and of 3.2 IC 95% [2.73, 3.75], (P < 0.001) for skin diseases with face involvement. The longer the responders wore their mask the more they reported unpleasant sensations: for 0–4 h vs 4–8 h OR 2.24 IC 95% [2, 2.52], (P < 0.001) and vs >8 h the OR 2.69 IC 95% [2.32, 3.13], (P < 0.001).
Figure 1
Multivariate analysis with uncomfortable sensations as outcome.
Multivariate analysis with uncomfortable sensations as outcome.Studies from Poland showed that pruritus is a major symptom caused by mask wearing, affecting up to 30% of HCP.
Similar symptoms were reported in the general population. Worsening of face skin conditions such as seborrheic dermatitis, acne and rosacea has been reported and was confirmed by our study.
,
Moreover, pruritus was reported having increased in HCP with facial dermatosis while acne seems worsened in almost half of the responders.
,
Increased sweating was also reported.These issues are not only inconvenient; they also cause the frequent manipulation of the mask, a factor that has been reported to be involved in viral transmission. This is particularly relevant in people with facial skin diseases, especially when they are HCP. Thus, it may be critical to consider in the future all symptoms when designing the inside part of masks. Obviously, side effects of prolonged mask wearing are not new, with similar findings already observed during the SARS epidemic.
,
However, today these inconveniences have been observed in a much larger population and thus may have important consequences in terms of wearing correctly the mask helping to protect oneself and the others.Therefore, dermatologists play an important role in public health by managing skin conditions related to wearing masks.
Authors: Shino Bay Aguilera; Irene De La Pena; Martha Viera; Bertha Baum; Brian W Morrison; Olivier Amar; Matthieu Beustes-Stefanelli; Mehreen Hall Journal: J Drugs Dermatol Date: 2020-09-01 Impact factor: 2.114
Authors: Piotr K Krajewski; Łukasz Matusiak; Marta Szepietowska; Rafał Białynicki-Birula; Jacek C Szepietowski Journal: Biology (Basel) Date: 2020-12-07