| Literature DB >> 33917327 |
Maayan Shacham1, Lee Greenblatt-Kimron1, Yaira Hamama-Raz1, Leslie R Martin2, Oren Peleg3, Menachem Ben-Ezra1, Eitan Mijiritsky3,4.
Abstract
In January 2021, Israel started vaccinating healthcare workers (HCWs) and individuals older than 65 years with COVID-19 vaccines. Scientific literature points to vaccine hesitancy as being a major health concern. During time of pandemics, increased consciousness of health behaviors may be encountered. The current study aimed to assess attitudes to general vaccines and to COVID-19 vaccines in particular among adult (>18) Israeli general public, and among Israeli dentists and dental hygienists. Cross-sectional surveys were filled out by a total of 501 participants (361 Israeli adults >18 years, 73 dental hygienists, and 67 dentists). Along with basic demographics, participants responded to the Hebrew VAX, COVID-VAX and HCS scales. Group comparisons were analyzed using t tests and ANOVAs with Scheffe's test used for post hoc comparisons. Dental hygienists demonstrated significantly higher anti-vaccinations approaches than both dentists (p < 0.01) and the general public (p < 0.05). In all groups, attitudes towards the COVID-19 vaccines were more negative compared to attitudes towards general vaccines, with hygienists demonstrating significant negative attitudes compared to dentists (p < 0.05). The general public (p = 0.56) and hygienists demonstrated increased health awareness compared to dentists (p < 0.05). As health awareness has increased during the COVID-19 pandemic primary strategies to combat vaccine hesitancy should be implemented in the general public, and in particular, an dental teams.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; SARS-CoV-2; dental hygienists; dentists; vaccination; vaccination attitudes; vaccine hesitancy
Year: 2021 PMID: 33917327 PMCID: PMC8038659 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph18073804
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Basic demographics of the study sample (Israeli dentists, dental hygienists and adults >18 years (n = 501)).
| Study Group | Number of Participants | Age (Mean (±SD)) | Gender | Relationship Status | Degree of Religiosity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dentists | 67 | 42.13 (±10.66) | 65.7% male, | C = 88.1%, | S = 77.6%, |
| Dental hygienists | 73 | 44.60 (±16.32) | 100% female | C = 86.3% | S = 72.6%, |
| General population | 361 | 39.04 (±15.59) | 69.52% female, 30.47% male | C = 76.5% | S = 73.1% secular, |
Notes: C = In a committed relationship, NC = not in a committed relationship, S = Secular, T = Traditional, O = Orthodox.
ANOVA results indicating differences among the study participants based on the study variables, using post hoc Scheffé tests.
| Factors | Dentists ( | Dental Hygienists ( | Adult Population |
| Post hoc Scheffé |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| VAX score M (±SD) | 25.19 (±9.59), | 31.47 (±9.76), | 27.48 (±12.86), | 5.07 ** | 1 < 2 **, |
| COVID-VAX score M (±SD) | 26.53 (±9.42), | 32.84 (±10.95), 30.29–35.40 | 29.91 (±13.30), | 4.43 * | 1 < 2 * |
| HCS score M (±SD) | 32.38 (±5.27), | 35.15 (±6.01), | 34.17 (±5.51), | 4.50 * | 1 < 2 * |
| VAX items #1–3 (mistrust of vaccine benefit) | 5.00 (±2.29), | 7.05 (±3.71), | 6.16 (±3.75), | 5.74 ** | 1 < 2 ** |
| VAX items #4–6 (worries over unforeseen future effects) | 9.16 (±4.00), | 11.39 (±3.51), | 9.20 (±3.99), | 9.76 *** | 1 < 2 **, |
| VAX items #7–9 (concerns about commercial profits) | 4.47 (±2.60), | 5.49 (±2.73), | 5.22 (±3.46), | 1.90 | |
| VAX items #10–12 (preference to natural immunity) | 6.55 (±3.29), | 7.53 (±3.47), | 6.90 (±3.85), | 1.30 | |
| COVID-VAX items #1–3 | 6.82 (±3.57), | 8.53 (±3.85), | 7.85 (±4.30), | 3.03 * | |
| COVID-VAX items #4–6 | 9.62 (±3.70), | 10.58 (±3.39), | 9.88 (±3.93), | 1.31 | |
| COVID-VAX items #7–9 | 4.62 (±2.90), | 6.34 (±3.74), | 5.62 (±3.89), | 3.68 * | 1 < 2 * |
| COVID-VAX items #10–12 | 5.46 (±3.23), | 7.38 (±3.33), | 6.55 (±3.83), | 4.75 ** | 1 < 2 ** |
Notes: 1 = Dentists, 2 = Dental hygienists, 3 = Adult population, CI = Confidence interval, VAX score = vaccination attitudes, COVID-VAX score = COVID-19 vaccination attitudes, HCS score = awareness of health behaviors. * p ≤ 0.05; ** p ≤ 0.01; *** p ≤ 0.001.
ANOVA results indicating differences among the female study participants (n = 347) based on the study variables, using post hoc Scheffé tests.
| Factors | Dentists ( | Dental Hygienists ( | Adult Population ( |
| Post hoc Scheffé |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| VAX score M (±SD) | 24.65 (±6.91), 21.66–27.64 | 31.47 (±9.76), | 27.17 (±13.43), 25.50–28.84 | 4.25 * | 2 > 3 |
| COVID-VAX score M (±SD) | 27.13 (±5.78), 24.62–29.63 | 32.84 (±10.95), | 29.94 (±13.93), 28.20–31.67 | 2.18 | |
| HCS score M (±SD) | 32.43 (±3.76), 30.80–34.06 | 35.15 (±6.01), | 34.46 (±5.62), | 2.05 | |
| VAX items #1–3 (mistrust of vaccine belief) | 4.73 (±2.17), | 7.05 (±3.71), | 6.19 (±3.94), | 3.44 * | 1 < 2 |
| VAX items #4–6 (worries over unforeseen future effects) | 9.04 (±3.86), | 11.39 (±3.51), | 9.09 (±4.16), | 9.49 ** | 2 > 3 |
| VAX items #7–9 (concerns about commercial profits) | 4.39 (±2.18), | 5.49 (±2.73), | 5.31 (±3.59), | 0.96 | |
| VAX items #10–12 (preference to natural immunity) | 6.47 (±2.44), | 7.53 (±3.47), | 6.55 (±3.79), | 2.08 | |
| COVID-VAX items #1–3 | 6.91 (±3.30), | 8.53 (±3.85), | 8.01 (±4.44), | 1.29 | |
| COVID-VAX items #4–6 | 10.13 (±2.68), | 10.58 (±3.39), | 10.01 (±4.10), | 0.62 | |
| COVID-VAX items #7–9 | 4.43 (±1.75), | 6.34 (±3.74), | 5.67 (±4.10), | 2.17 | |
| COVID-VAX items #10–12 | 5.65 (±2.70). | 7.38 (±3.33), | 6.23 (±3.73), | 3.45 * |
Notes: 1 = Dentists, 2 = Dental hygienists, 3 = Adult population, CI = Confidence interval, VAX score = vaccination attitudes, COVID-VAX score = COVID-19 vaccination attitudes, HCS score = awareness of health behaviors. * p ≤ 0.05; ** p ≤ 0.001.
Differences between VAX and COVID-VAX scores among the different participants groups in the current study.
| VAX Score M (±SD) | COVID-VAX Score M (±SD) | Sig. | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dentists ( | 25.19 (±9.59) | 26.53 (±9.42) | −2.113 | 0.038 |
| Dental hygienists ( | 31.47 (±9.76) | 32.84 (±10.95) | −2.290 | 0.025 |
| Adult population ( | 27.48 (±12.86) | 29.91 (±13.30) | −7.655 | 0.001 |
Notes: VAX score = vaccination attitudes, COVID-VAX score = COVID-19 vaccination attitudes.