Zhen Song1, Yihui Ma1, Min Chen1, Adriano Ambrosi1, Caifeng Ding1, Xiliang Luo1. 1. Key Laboratory of Optic-Electric Sensing and Analytical Chemistry for Life Science, MOE, Shandong Key Laboratory of Biochemical Analysis, Key Laboratory of Analytical Chemistry for Life Science in Universities of Shandong, College of Chemistry and Molecular Engineering, Qingdao University of Science and Technology, Qingdao 266042, PR China.
Abstract
Biofouling caused by the accumulation of biomolecules on sensing surfaces is one of the major problems and challenges to realize the practical application of electrochemical biosensors, and an effective way to counter this problem is the construction of antifouling biosensors. Herein, an antifouling electrochemical biosensor was constructed based on electropolymerized polyaniline (PANI) nanowires and newly designed peptides for the detection of the COVID-19 N-gene. The inverted Y-shaped peptides were designed with excellent antifouling properties and two anchoring branches, and their antifouling performances against proteins and complex biological media were investigated using different approaches. Based on the biotin-streptavidin affinity system, biotin-labeled probes specific to the N-gene (nucleocapsid phosphoprotein) of COVID-19 were immobilized onto the peptide-coated PANI nanowires, forming a highly sensitive and antifouling electrochemical sensing interface for the detection of COVID-19 nucleic acid. The antifouling genosensor demonstrated a wide linear range (10-14 to 10-9 M) and an exceptional low detection limit (3.5 fM). The remarkable performance of the genosensor derives from the high peak current of PANI, which is chosen as the sensing signal, and the extraordinary antifouling properties of designed peptides, which guarantee accurate detection in complex systems. These crucial features represent essential elements for future rapid and decentralized clinical testing.
Biofouling caused by the accumulation of biomolecules on sensing surfaces is one of the major problems and challenges to realize the practical application of electrochemical biosensors, and an effective way to counter this problem is the construction of antifouling biosensors. Herein, an antifouling electrochemical biosensor was constructed based on electropolymerized polyaniline (PANI) nanowires and newly designed peptides for the detection of the COVID-19 N-gene. The inverted Y-shaped peptides were designed with excellent antifouling properties and two anchoring branches, and their antifouling performances against proteins and complex biological media were investigated using different approaches. Based on the biotin-streptavidin affinity system, biotin-labeled probes specific to the N-gene (nucleocapsid phosphoprotein) of COVID-19 were immobilized onto the peptide-coated PANI nanowires, forming a highly sensitive and antifouling electrochemical sensing interface for the detection of COVID-19 nucleic acid. The antifouling genosensor demonstrated a wide linear range (10-14 to 10-9 M) and an exceptional low detection limit (3.5 fM). The remarkable performance of the genosensor derives from the high peak current of PANI, which is chosen as the sensing signal, and the extraordinary antifouling properties of designed peptides, which guarantee accurate detection in complex systems. These crucial features represent essential elements for future rapid and decentralized clinical testing.
Coronavirus
disease 2019 (COVID-19),
caused by the 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCov), is a new severe
respiratory disease accompanied by fever, breathlessness, and cough.
Following the first discovery in December 2019, it rapidly swept around
the world and was classified as a pandemic by the World Health Organization
(WHO) on March 12, 2020.[1] According to
the report from the WHO, over 105.3 million cases and 2.3 million
deaths have been confirmed globally as of Feb 8, 2021.[2] Unfortunately, no medical treatment is yet available to
specifically cure COVID-19 disease or prevent the viral infection,
and with exponential diffusion still experienced by several countries
in the world, social distancing, personal hygiene habits, and more
importantly an accurate and massive screening of the population, for
early diagnosis of the disease, represent the currently available
weapons to best fight the pandemic.At present, reverse-transcription
polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR),
which is widely available for clinical samples, such as nasal and
pharyngeal swabs, blood, excrement, and so on, is referred to as the
“gold standard” techniques.[3−5] However, high
demand for kits, tedious sample collection, and transportation become
the major limitations. Next, a lateral flow immunoassay can realize
rapid and real-time detection with a sample device, but it cannot
diagnose the positive cases in its early stage due to the fact that
detectable antibodies are produced by the body only after several
weeks from the infection.[6] In addition,
chest computed tomography (CT) is considered as the most effective
means of disease diagnosis, but it is only available in hospitals
and clinics and due to its high costs and limited availability cannot
be employed for rapid and massive testing.[7,8] Hence,
development of a time-saving, highly sensitive and accurate, cost-effective
method for COVID-19 detection is urgently needed and would have a
significant impact for dealing with this pandemic.Compared
with the currently existing diagnostic approaches, electrochemical
biosensors possess important characteristics that perfectly fit the
current requirements, such as ease of operation, cost effectiveness,
portable equipment, rapidity and high sensitivity.[9,10] However,
interface biofouling arising from the biomolecule adsorption represents
one of the major problems for electrochemical sensing platforms and
restricts their practical application.[11,12] One possible
solution to this problem is the creation of a sensing interface modified
with an effective antifouling film, which limits non-specific adsorption
of biomolecules without interfering with the specific analyte recognition
and detection. In addition, such an antifouling material introduced
should be biocompatible and non-toxic, so that it can be used even
in wearable or implantable devices.[13] Peptides
represent excellent candidates as antifouling agents due to their
good biocompatibility and biodegradability. Several peptides with
different structure designs and sequences have been applied as antifouling
films.[9,11,14,15] For example, Nowinski and co-workers designed a zwitterionic
peptide (CPPPPEKEKEKE) with an alternating arrangement of glutamic
acid (E, negatively charged) and lysine (K, positively charged), which
is similar to zwitterionic polymers,[16] that
can form a hydrated layer, effectively resisting biofouling (<0.3
ng·cm-2).[17] Two short sequences
PFB-VVD and PFB-LLE (PFB: pentafluorobenzaldehyde) with chemical modification
have also shown good ability to resist protein adsorption.[18] In another work, a branched zwitterionic peptide
(CPPPPEK2(EK)4(EK)) designed by Liu and co-workers demonstrated superior
resistance to human serum and cell adhesion over linear sequences.[19]Due to its fast and reversible doping/de-doping
kinetics, multiple
redox states, high conductivity, and cost-effective synthesis, polyaniline
(PANI) has been widely used in fabrication of sensing interfaces.[20−22] More importantly, the structure of PANI can be easily tuned by simply
changing the parameters during the electrochemical deposition, achieving
excellent control over its resulting structure. Besides, the availability
of abundant amino groups provides an ideal platform for further grafting
biomolecules.In this work, we fabricate electrically polymerized
PANI nanowires
as the electrode coating for the immobilization of a newly designed
inverted Y-shaped peptide as an antifouling agent and the specific
N-gene capture probe (an antisense oligonucleotide) as a recognition
element for the detection of the COVID-19 N-gene (nucleocapsid phosphoprotein
gene) (Scheme ). The
newly designed inverted Y-shaped peptide ((CKEKEKEKE)2KEPPPPKEKEKEKEK-biotin)
consists of one antifouling main chain (KEPPPPKEKEKEKEK-biotin) in
the upper part, which has four proline residues (PPPP) assisting in
the formation of the α-helical secondary structure, and two
anchor-antifouling side chains (CKEKEKEKE) in the lower part. Two
cysteine (C) residues at the ends of the two side chains were used
as the surface anchor to immobilize the peptides onto the PANI nanowires
through the sulfo-SMCC cross-linking. The presence of two anchor chains
guarantees a robust and stable immobilization onto the electrode while
providing enhanced flexibility of the main chain where the probe is
attached. Such an innovative design contributes to high interface
coverage and a better antifouling performance compared with the standard
single anchor design.[19,23] Thereafter, streptavidin (SA,
a tetramer protein) was employed as a linker to immobilize the N-gene
capture probe on biotin–peptide-covered interfaces based on
the biotin–streptavidin affinity system. The sensing platforms
based on the biotin–streptavidin interaction, proved to be
an effective way of constructing biosensors, have been widely reported.[24−27] The biotin-labeled branched peptides were first conjugated with
SA, which provides four specific binding sites for the immobilization
of the biotin-labeled N-gene probe. A SA–biotin immobilization
scheme was employed since the zwitterionic property of the peptide
can be significantly affected by the covalent immobilization of the
probe through amide bonds.[11,28] The resulting electrochemical
genosensor for COVID-19 N-gene detection was tested with complex serum
samples, demonstrating excellent detection limit and specificity thanks
to the improved antifouling properties.
Scheme 1
Schematic Diagram
of the Antifouling COVID-19 Genosensor Fabrication
Process
Experimental Section
Reagents
A newly designed inverted Y-shaped peptide
labeled with biotin ((CKEKEKEKE)2KEPPPPKEKEKEKEK-biotin)
and a linear peptide labeled with biotin (CKEKEKEKEKEPPPPKEKEKEKEK-biotin)
as the control group used in this work were designed by us and synthesized
by Bank-peptide Biological Technology Co. Ltd. (Hefei, China). The
N-gene probe labeled with biotin (antisense oligonucleotide: 5′-biotin-CCAATGTGATCTTTTGGTGT-3′),
target sequence (N-Gene of Covid-19: 5′-ACACCAAAAGAUCACAUUGG-3′),
noncomplementary sequence (5′-UUCUUCGAACGU GUCACGU-3′),
Cy5-DNA (TCAACATCAGTCTGATAAGCTA), miRNA-141, miRNA-21, FITC-BSA, and
SA were provided by Sangon Biotech Co., Ltd. (Shanghai, China) and
stored at −20 °C. 4-(N-Maleimidomethyl)-cyclohexane-1-carboxylic
acid 3-sulfo-N-hydroxysuccinimide ester sodium salt
(sulfo-SMCC) was ordered from Sigma-Aldrich (USA). Perchloric acid
(HClO4) and aniline were provided by Aladdin Reagents (Shanghai,
China). Myoglobin (Mb), albumin (BSA), lysozyme (Lys), and fetal bovine
serum (FBS) were ordered from Beijing Bo Yang Hongda Technology Co.,
Ltd. (Beijing, China). The Eighth People’s Hospital of Qingdao
provided the human serum samples from volunteers for us, and advanced
informed agreement was obtained for the use of the human serum. All
samples were prepared under the authority of the committee of the
Eighth People’s Hospital of Qingdao and conducted in accordance
with the relevant guidelines and laws. All chemicals were of analytical
grade. During the entire process of the experiment, the ultrapure
water (18 MΩ·cm–1) was purified using
a Milli-Q water system (USA) and applied for preparing aqueous solutions.
The working buffer was 10 mM and 0.2 M phosphate-buffered solution
(PBS, pH 7.4).
Apparatus and Measurements
All electrochemistry
measurements
were carried out using a CHI 660E electrochemical workstation (Shanghai
Chenhua Instrument Co., China). Electrochemical testing was performed
using a three-electrode system: reference electrode (a saturated calomel
electrode, SCE), counter electrode (a platinum wire), and working
electrode (a bare or modified glassy carbon electrode, GCE, 3.0 mm
in diameter). A galvanostatic technique was used for modification
of the GCE with PANI nanowires. Electrochemical performance of the
biosensor was recorded by differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) and
cyclic voltammetry (CV). DPV and CV were measured within a detection
voltage from −0.6 to 0.6 V at a scan rate of 100 mV·s–1 and an amplitude of 50 mV in phosphate-buffered saline
(PBS, 0.2 M, pH 7.4).The surface characterizations of the modified
electrodes were carried out by means of a JEOL JSM-7500F scanning
electron microscope (SEM, Hitachi Co., Japan). The fluorescence images
of the antifouling performance were conducted with a TCS SP5 confocal
laser microscope (Leica, Germany). Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy
(FTIR) was used to characterize the elemental changes of the modified
electrodes using the Bruker Tensor 70 spectrometer. X-ray photoelectron
spectroscopy (XPS) spectra were recorded with an ESCALAB 250Xi spectrometry
(Thermo Fisher Scientific, U.K.) instrument with a monochromatic Al
Kα X-ray source (hν = 15 kV); all spectra were calibrated
to the standard value of the C(1s) peak (284.6 eV). A Zetasizer Nano-ZS
(Malvern Instruments, Malvern, U.K.) and software calculation were
used to measure the net charge of the peptides. The secondary structure
of the peptides was verified using a JASCO J-810 spectropolarimeter
(Jasco Inc., Japan) and the corresponding circular dichroism (CD)
spectra. A JC2000D1 system (Shanghai Zhongchen, China) was employed
to evaluate the hydrophilic properties of the modified or bare GCE.
Synthesis of PANI Nanowires and Preparation of the Antifouling
Interface
Prior to assembly, the bare GCE was polished[29] and then treated in an ultrasonic bath with
water, ethanol, and water. The pretreated bare GCE was immersed in
0.1 M PANI diluted with 1.0 M HClO4, and PANI nanowires
were electrodeposited on it using a galvanostatic technique. PANI
electrodeposition was conducted with three constant current densities
of 0.6, 0.3, and 0.15 mA·cm–2 for 0.5, 0.5,
and 0.5 h in sequence, respectively. Abundant amino groups in PANI
provided the conditions for immobilization of peptides. The obtained
PANI nanowire-modified GCE (PANI/GCE) was washed with deionized water,
and then, PANI/GCE was pretreated with 2 mM sulfo-SMCC solution for
1 h before attaching the peptides. The modified electrodes were then
incubated in a solution containing 2.0 mg·mL–1 biotin peptides in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS, 0.2 M, pH7.4)
for 3 h. As a result, the antifouling interface (biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE)
was obtained.
Immobilization of the Covid-19 N-Gene Probe
Here, binding
of the biotin probe to the biotin peptides depended mainly on the
specific interaction between biotin and SA. According to previous
studies,[30,31] the designed peptide-modified electrodes
(biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE) were exposed to 2 μM SA solution for
1 h at 37 °C. After washing, the abovementioned electrodes were
incubated in 1 μM biotin probe solution at 37 °C for 90
min. After further washing, the prepared biosensor was stored at 4
°C before use.
Characterization of the Newly Designed Inverted
Y-Shaped Peptide
CD spectrum was employed to obtain the secondary
structure information
of the newly designed inverted Y-shaped peptide in the wavelength
range from 190 to 300 nm and a step resolution of 0.5 nm, using a
0.5 mg·mL–1 peptide suspension. Zeta potential
measurements were used to evaluate the charges of the peptides. The
hydrophilicity property of the peptide-modified surfaces was measured
using the water contact angle.
Antifouling Performance
and Fluorescence Imaging
The
antifouling performance testing of the modified electrodes with or
without designed inverted Y-shaped peptides was performed in a series
of single-protein solutions (BSA, Lys, and Mb) and practical media
(FBS and human serum solutions). Current changes were recorded by
DPV measurements before and after incubation in interfering solutions.
PBS buffer (10 mM, pH 7.4) was used to dilute the proteins and complex
biological samples.The fluorescence images of the modified
electrodes were acquired after incubation in fluorescein isothiocyanate-labeled
bovine serum albumin (FITC-BSA) and Cy5-labeled DNA (Cy5-DNA) solutions
for 2 h. The bare GCE was selected as the control group. After thorough
washing, the treated electrodes were placed into the imaging instrument.
Then, the imaging system was used to image the biotin-peptide/PANI-modified
electrodes, PANI film electrodes, and bare GCE individually (ex: 488
nm ± 10 nm, 10 s exposure).
Detection of the N Gene
of Covid-19 (Target RNA)
The
biosensor was incubated in target N-gene solution with different concentrations
at 37 °C for 1 h. Afterward, non-captured target RNA was washed
with PBS buffer and the abovementioned electrodes were prepared for
electrochemistry detection. The changes in the current signal were
recorded before and after specific binding with target RNA using an
electrochemical station. To further evaluate the application potential
in complex samples, the biosensor was used to analyze targets in 20%
(V/V) human serum with all the other conditions unchanged.
Results
and Discussion
Characterization Studies of the Newly Designed
Inverted Y-Shaped
Peptide
The structure, chromatogram, and mass spectra of
the newly designed inverted Y-shaped peptide are shown in Figures S1 and S2. The antifouling performance
of the interfaces directly depends on the properties of used peptides.
Biofouling processes are usually caused by charge and hydrophobic
interactions between interferents and interfaces as demonstrated in
the past.[32,33] Hence, electrical and hydrophilic properties
of the designed peptide were investigated. A peptide property calculator
was used to quantify the net charge of the peptide at pH = 7. As depicted
in Figure S3A,B, the non-labeled and biotin-labeled
peptide sequence has positive 0.9 and negative 0.1 net charge, respectively.
This illustrates that the charges of the designed peptide were effectively
neutralized when the end lysine residue is combined with biotin. Next,
the zeta potential of biotin-labeled peptide was close to 0.0 mV;
see Figure S3C. These results suggested
that the designed peptide was electrically neutral. Furthermore, it
is worth noting that hydrophobicity and hydrophilicity are perhaps
the most important gauge of the anti-contamination ability and play
a crucial role in the design and selection of effective antifouling
materials.[13,18]Hence, it is important
to understand the interaction between water and the modified surface.
As displayed in Figure C,D and Table S1, the water contact angle
of the bare GCE and PANI/GCE was about 55.85° and 41.87°,
respectively. After peptide immobilization, the water contact angle
decreased from 41.87° (PANI/GCE) to 16.09° (biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE),
indicating that the surfaces were more hydrophobic. This change can
mainly stem from the good hydrophilicity of the newly designed inverted
Y-shaped peptide (Figure E).
Figure 1
SEM images of the PANI nanowire film at low (A, ×20k) and
high (B, ×50k) magnifications. Water contact angles of the bare
GCE (C), PANI/GCE (D), and biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE (E). CD spectra
(F) of the newly designed inverted Y-shaped peptide in PBS at a concentration
of 0.5 mg·mL–1. DPV response (G) of the bare
GCE (a), PANI/GCE (b), biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE (c), SA/biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE
(d), biotin-probe/SA/biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE (e), and target RNA/biotin-probe/SA/biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE
(f) in PBS (0.2 M, pH 7.4).
SEM images of the PANI nanowire film at low (A, ×20k) and
high (B, ×50k) magnifications. Water contact angles of the bare
GCE (C), PANI/GCE (D), and biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE (E). CD spectra
(F) of the newly designed inverted Y-shaped peptide in PBS at a concentration
of 0.5 mg·mL–1. DPV response (G) of the bare
GCE (a), PANI/GCE (b), biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE (c), SA/biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE
(d), biotin-probe/SA/biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE (e), and target RNA/biotin-probe/SA/biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE
(f) in PBS (0.2 M, pH 7.4).The secondary structure of the inverted Y shaped peptide was elucidated
using CD spectra (Figure F). It is clear that a weak positive band and a strong negative
band appeared at 225 and 200 nm, respectively, portending the generation
of the polyproline helix conformation of the Y- shaped peptide.[17,34]
Characterization of the Surface Modification and Biosensor Assembly
Process
The morphology of the PANI-coated GCE was characterized
by SEM, as shown in Figure A,B. Interestingly, the PANI grown on the GCE formed a uniform
nanowire network structure with the diameter of 150–200 nm,
exhibiting a very high specific surface area.The biosensor
assembly process was monitored using electrochemical measurements.
As shown in Figure G, current changes were recorded upon different modification steps
in 0.2 M PBS solution (pH 7.4). Clearly, the DPV curve of the bare
GCE presents no peak. Upon PANI nanowire deposition onto the GCE,
an obvious current peak (curve b) was observed at the potential of
−0.01 V, which is associated with the transition between leucoemeraldine
and emeraldine conformations of the PANI polymer. After incubation
with the biotin peptide (curve c), SA (curve d), and biotin probe
(curve e), the current signal of the modified electrode further decreased.
These results may be explained by the poor conductivity and space
effect of the biomolecules, which could block the charge transfer
between the interface and the solution. Finally, further current decrease
resulted when specific binding occurred between the biotin probe and
the target RNA (curve f).The interfacial modification of the
electrode before and after
peptide attachment has been confirmed using FTIR based on the appearance
of new characteristic peaks (Figure A). In our results, the peaks at 1565 and 1496 cm–1 in the PANI nanowire-coated substrate (curve a) can
be assigned to the C=C stretching vibrations of the quinoid
ring and benzenoid ring, separately. A narrow peak appeared at a frequency
of 1243 cm–1 owing to the stretching and bending
of the C–C bond. The bands at 1302 and 1146 cm–1 corresponded to various stretching connected with the C–N
bond of secondary aromatic amine, and a C–H out-of-plane bending
band appeared at 803 cm–1. These characteristic
peaks were consistent with previous reports about PANI.[35,36] The spectrum of the peptide-modified electrode (curve b) also showed
five distinctive peaks at 1572, 1476, 1296, 1245, and 811 cm–1. An additional peak in the region of 1690–1630 cm–1 appeared at 1645 cm–1, which is a characteristic
of the formed amides.[37−39] This indicates that the designed peptides were successfully
fixed onto the PANI film.
Figure 2
FTIR spectra (A) of PANI (a, red line) and biotin-peptide/PANI
(b, black line). XPS survey scans of PANI (B), biotin-peptide/PANI
(C), and biotin-probe/SA/biotin-peptide/PANI (D).
FTIR spectra (A) of PANI (a, red line) and biotin-peptide/PANI
(b, black line). XPS survey scans of PANI (B), biotin-peptide/PANI
(C), and biotin-probe/SA/biotin-peptide/PANI (D).To further confirm the surface changes, XPS spectra were recorded
after PANI modification, biotin peptide immobilization, and biotin
probe attachment (Figure B–D). All XPS survey spectra displayed Cl, C, N, and
O peaks for PANI nanowire-coated electrodes. C1s and N1s peaks could be assigned to the PANI film, and a Cl2p peak was seen due to HClO4 doping during electrodeposition.After incubation in biotin peptides, the Cl2p peak decreased
together with the appearance of two obvious S peaks (S2s and S2p) at 164 and 228 eV, which can be assigned to
the cysteine and biotin of the peptide, indicating its successful
immobilization. Following the SA and biotin probe assembly, a new
P2s peak emerged due to the phosphate skeleton from the
probe. All characterization results are consistent with the previously
discussed electrochemical measurements and provide confirmation of
the successful assembly of the biosensor.
Optimization of Experimental
Conditions
Only under
optimal experimental conditions, the constructed biosensor would give
the best sensing performance. Hence, we investigated the influence
of the incubation time of the SA, concentration and immobilization
time of the biotin probe, and hybridization time of the target N-gene,
as depicted in Figure S4. Based on this
study, the following optimized conditions were selected and employed
for the analytical sensing operations: (A) SA incubation time, 60
min; (B) biotin probe immobilization time, 90 min; (C) biotin probe
concentration, 2 μΜ; and (D) target N-gene hybridization
time, 60 min.
Antifouling Performance
To study
the antifouling performance
of the newly designed inverted Y-shaped peptide, bare and PANI- and
biotin-peptide/PANI-coated GCEs were immersed in different single
proteins and complex biological suspension liquids, and then, current
changes [signal suppression = (ΔI/I0) × 100%, ΔI = I0 – I, I0 and I represent the peak current of DPV
before and after immersion in interference solutions for 30 min, respectively]
caused by non-specific adsorption of interferences were recorded.
As displayed in Figure A–C, the current-changing trends for different interfaces
were similar after the incubation in the solution of negatively charged
BSA, neutral Mb, and positively charged Lys with increasing signal
suppression at higher protein concentrations. However, the current
variation of the biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE (red bar) was significantly
smaller than that of the bare GCE (orange bar) and PANI (blue bar)-modified
electrode, revealing the excellent resistance to single-protein adsorption
by the electrode modified with the peptide. Knowing that proteins
generally tend to adsorb onto hydrophobic interfaces rather than on
hydrophilic ones,[7] these results also demonstrated
the good hydrophilicity of the peptides, consistent with the water
contact angle results. Following, human serum was chosen to be the
complex biological sample to test the antifouling performance, and
the influence of the biotin probe and SA on antifouling performance
was also investigated, as shown in Figure D–F. The lower parts were the original
DPV data and the upper parts represent statistical analyses after
being incubated in various concentrations of human serum of the bare
GCE, PANI/GCE, and biotin-probe/SA/biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE. Again,
the superior antifouling performance of the biotin-probe/SA/biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE
over the other two interfaces can be noticed, although the non-antifouling
biotin probe and SA were introduced into the interfaces. This result
may be ascribed to the adequate coverage by peptide coating and the
excellent antifouling ability of the newly designed inverted Y-shaped
peptide. Remarkably, even after soaking in 20% human serum, the signal
suppression by the peptide-modified electrode was 4.92%, indicating
promising potential for real application.
Figure 3
Histogram of antifouling
performance of different modified surfaces
against several single proteins (A: BSA, B: Mb, and C: Lys). Antifouling
characteristics of the bare GCE (D), PANI/GCE (E), and biotin-probe/SA/biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE
(F) in different concentrations of human serum samples (V/V). Lower
parts are original DPV curves and data are reported in the upper bar
diagram. Each DPV curve in the lower part corresponds to an upper
bar.
Histogram of antifouling
performance of different modified surfaces
against several single proteins (A: BSA, B: Mb, and C: Lys). Antifouling
characteristics of the bare GCE (D), PANI/GCE (E), and biotin-probe/SA/biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE
(F) in different concentrations of human serum samples (V/V). Lower
parts are original DPV curves and data are reported in the upper bar
diagram. Each DPV curve in the lower part corresponds to an upper
bar.In order to describe the antifouling
characteristics more intuitively,
the bare and PANI- and biotin-peptide/PANI-modified electrodes were
incubated in PBS buffer (10 mM, pH 7.4) containing 0.2 mg·mL–1 FITC-BSA for 2 h to allow protein adsorption, and
then, the protein adsorption behaviors at different interfaces were
analyzed using fluorescence microscopy, as summarized in Figures A and S5. The amount of protein adsorption is reflected
by fluorescence intensity. The bare GCE showed the strongest fluorescent
(first column), followed by the PANI/GCE surface (second column),
while the biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE (third column) showed the weakest
fluorescent intensity. Similarly, confocal fluorescent images were
shown in Figures A
and S6 after incubation in Cy5-DNA solution
for 2 h. The biotin-peptide/PANI-modified GCE exhibited good resistance
to DNA adsorption. Based on all the results mentioned above, it can
be concluded that the newly designed inverted Y-shaped peptide possesses
excellent and stable antifouling properties toward single proteins
and even concentrated complex biological media. Long-term antifouling
performance was also investigated, as displayed in Figure S7. Additionally, a comparison antifouling experiment
was carried out between the newly designed branched peptide and a
linear peptide (control peptide) in different concentrations of FBS.
As shown in Figure B, the newly designed inverted Y-shaped peptide displayed better
antifouling performance compared to the control peptide at every used
concentration. These results could be due to both the good water permeability
of the film, which helps in improving the hydrophilicity[40,41] and also the improved interface coverage by the antifouling anchor
side chains.
Figure 4
(A) Antifouling performances of the bare (first column),
PANI nanowire-modified
(second column), biotin-peptide/PANI nanowire (third column)-modified
GCE against FITC-BSA and Cy5-DNA (2 h incubation) monitored by fluorescence
microscopy. (B) Comparative antifouling performance of the bare and
PANI-, control-peptide/PANI-, and biotin-peptide/PANI-modified GCE
in FBS samples (V/V). Control-peptide (linear), CKEKEKEKEKEPPPPKEKEKEKEK-biotin;
biotin-peptide, (CKEKEKEKE)2KEPPPPKEKEKEKEK-biotin.
(A) Antifouling performances of the bare (first column),
PANI nanowire-modified
(second column), biotin-peptide/PANI nanowire (third column)-modified
GCE against FITC-BSA and Cy5-DNA (2 h incubation) monitored by fluorescence
microscopy. (B) Comparative antifouling performance of the bare and
PANI-, control-peptide/PANI-, and biotin-peptide/PANI-modified GCE
in FBS samples (V/V). Control-peptide (linear), CKEKEKEKEKEPPPPKEKEKEKEK-biotin;
biotin-peptide, (CKEKEKEKE)2KEPPPPKEKEKEKEK-biotin.
Electrochemical Detection of the COVID-19
N-Gene
After
incubation in a series of concentrations of the target N-gene, the
DPV measurements were performed to record the current change caused
by the hybridization between the biotin probe and the target RNA,
for the quantitative detection of the target N-gene (Figure A). As depicted in Figure B, the result showed
a good linear relation between the logarithm of the target concentration
(10–14 to 10–9 mol·L–1) and the current signal under the optimal conditions.
The linear fitting equation is ΔI (μA)
= 4.89 log C + 71.88, and the limit of detection
(LOD) was calculated as 3.5 fM (S/N = 3). In addition, when the same
experiment was performed in target solution containing 10% FBS, the
linear regression equation is ΔI (μA)
= 5.28 log C + 77.23, which was similar to that in
pure target solution (Figure C). This means that the electrode interface was almost not
affected by the presence of interferences in the FBS. Furthermore,
the preliminary application in human serum was also investigated by
a standard addition method with acceptable recoveries from 98.03%
to 101.63% (Table S2), indicating that
the developed biosensor has great potential for practical application.
Such remarkable performance can be attributed to the excellent electrochemical
properties of the PANI conducting polymer being used as an interface
substrate, which provided a sensitive current signal, and to the good
antifouling properties of the newly designed peptide that effectively
resists interferences even in complex matrix systems. Given that there
are few reports on the detection of COVID-19 by electrochemical methods, Table S3 lists the performance of several different
approaches for the detecting COVID-19.
Figure 5
(A) DPV responses of
the genosensor after incubation in different
concentrations of target N-gene solutions, curves from a to h: 10–14 to 10–8 M. Inset: partial enlargement
of the current peaks. Current response of the genosensor for the COVID-19
N-gene in PBS (0.2 M, pH 7.4) (B) and complex biological media (10%
FBS) (C). The inset shows the corresponding calibration curves. Error
bars represent the standard deviations of the three measurements.
(A) DPV responses of
the genosensor after incubation in different
concentrations of target N-gene solutions, curves from a to h: 10–14 to 10–8 M. Inset: partial enlargement
of the current peaks. Current response of the genosensor for the COVID-19
N-gene in PBS (0.2 M, pH 7.4) (B) and complex biological media (10%
FBS) (C). The inset shows the corresponding calibration curves. Error
bars represent the standard deviations of the three measurements.
Stability, Selectivity, and Reproducibility
of the Genosensor
Stability, selectivity, and reproducibility
represent three important
parameters to be verified for biosensor systems. The stability of
the genosensor here fabricated (biotin-probe/SA/biotin-peptide/PANI/GCE)
was first studied by consecutive CV tests in 0.2 M PBS (pH 7.4) for
50 cycles. As displayed in Figure S8A,
the genosensor exhibited outstanding stability with almost unchanged
peak current and potential after 50 cycles scan. Furthermore, the
stability of the prepared genosensor was also monitored by interval
tests within 10 days, with the signal retention of 92.8% and relative
standard deviations (RSD) of 1.51% (Figure S8B). The selectivity of the genosensor was tested with 10–9 M miRNA-21 and miRNA-141, noncomplementary, as interferences. Even
when the concentration of interfering agents was about 100 times larger
than that of the target, no obvious responses were observed from current
signals and the current variation value of the genosensor toward the
mixture showed almost equal to that of the target, demonstrating the
good selectivity of the genosensor (Figure S9). To further explore the reproducibility, we used the same biosensor
to detect two concentrations (low and high), 10 fM and 1 nM target
COVID-19 N-gene. The RSDs were 3.06% and 1.62% (Figure S10), respectively, showing good accuracy and reproducibility.
Conclusions
Overall, a sensitive and robust electrochemical
genosensor was
fabricated employing a newly designed peptide as an antifouling agent
integrated into a PANI nanowire platform for the COVID-19 N-gene.
This electrochemical system exhibited extraordinary antifouling properties
thanks to the designed inverted Y-shaped peptide with two anchoring
branches, which bind tightly to the surface of PANI nanowires and
effectively resist the nonspecific adsorption. PANI nanowires not
only provided a large surface area for the immobilization of biomolecules
but also enabled sensitive current signal generation. The fabricated
genosensor demonstrated exceptional antifouling properties in parallel
with remarkable analytical ability for the COVID-19 N-gene, reaching
LOD as low as 3.5 fM even in complex human serum samples and exhibiting
promising potential for early detection of COVID-19viral infection
in decentralized settings.
Authors: Linda J Carter; Linda V Garner; Jeffrey W Smoot; Yingzhu Li; Qiongqiong Zhou; Catherine J Saveson; Janet M Sasso; Anne C Gregg; Divya J Soares; Tiffany R Beskid; Susan R Jervey; Cynthia Liu Journal: ACS Cent Sci Date: 2020-04-30 Impact factor: 14.553
Authors: Buddhisha Udugama; Pranav Kadhiresan; Hannah N Kozlowski; Ayden Malekjahani; Matthew Osborne; Vanessa Y C Li; Hongmin Chen; Samira Mubareka; Jonathan B Gubbay; Warren C W Chan Journal: ACS Nano Date: 2020-03-30 Impact factor: 15.881
Authors: Mohammed Jawad Ahmed Alathari; Yousif Al Mashhadany; Mohd Hadri Hafiz Mokhtar; Norhafizah Burham; Mohd Saiful Dzulkefly Bin Zan; Ahmad Ashrif A Bakar; Norhana Arsad Journal: Sensors (Basel) Date: 2021-12-15 Impact factor: 3.576