| Literature DB >> 33791308 |
Aria Salehpour1, Mohammad Rezaei2, Arezoo Khoradmehr1, Yaser Tahamtani2,3,4, Amin Tamadon1,5.
Abstract
Despite extensive studies on type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM), there is no definitive cure, drug, or prevention. Therefore, for developing new therapeutics, proper study models of T2DM is necessary to conduct further preclinical researches. Diabetes has been induced in animals using chemical, genetic, hormonal, antibody, viral, and surgical methods or a combination of them. Beside different approaches of diabetes induction, different animal species have been suggested. Although more than 85% of articles have proposed rat (genus Rattus) as the proper model for diabetes induction, zebrafish (Danio rerio) models of diabetes are being used more frequently in diabetes related studies. In this systematic review, we compare different aspects of available methods of inducing hyperglycemia referred as T2DM in zebrafish by utilizing a scoring system. Evaluating 26 approved models of T2DM in zebrafish, this scoring system may help researchers to compare different T2DM zebrafish models and select the best one regarding their own research theme. Eventually, glyoxalase1 (glo1-/-) knockout model of hyperglycemia achieved the highest score. In addition to assessment of hyperglycemic induction methods in zebrafish, eight most commonly proposed diabetic induction approval methods are suggested to help researchers confirm their subsequent proposed models.Entities:
Keywords: Danio rerio (zebrafish); T2DM; animal modeling; diabetes mellitus; hyperglycemia; zebrafish
Year: 2021 PMID: 33791308 PMCID: PMC8005598 DOI: 10.3389/fcell.2021.652061
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Cell Dev Biol ISSN: 2296-634X
Comparison of non-genetic induced hyperglycemia models referred as T2DM in zebrafish.
| Immersion alternatively in 2 and 0% glucose solution model of hyperglycemia | Adult (1–3 years old) | 1 month | • Simple | • Needs continues alteration of solution | Gleeson et al., |
| Immersion in stepwise elevating glucose concentration model of hyperglycemia | Adult (1–3 years/5–11 months) | 2 month/10 days | • Simple | • No significant drawback | Connaughton et al., |
| Chronic immersion in 110 mM glucose solution model of hyperglycemia | Adult stage (3–5 cm) | 14 days | • Simple | • 20% mortality | Capiotti et al., |
| Chronic immersion in 4% glucose solution model of hyperglycemia | Adult | 28 days | • Simple | • Not suitable for female zebrafish | Carnovali et al., |
| Immersion in alternating 4 and 5% glucose solution model of hyperglycemia | Larva | 5 days | • Simple | • High mortality | Singh et al., |
| Immersion in 130 mM glucose solution model of elevated hyperglycemia | Larva | 3 days | • Simple | • No investigation for insulin resistance property | Jung et al., |
| Obesity model of hyperglycemia | Adult (4–6 months) | 6 weeks | • Simple | • Long time of induction | Zang et al., |
| High fat diet (HFD) containing 1% egg yolk model of hyperglycemia | Adult | 10 weeks | • Simple | • Long time of induction | Meng et al., |
| Bisphenol F induced model of hyperglycemia | Larva | 2 days | • Simple | • No significant changes to glucagon mRNA expressions | Zhao et al., |
| Bisphenol S induced model of hyperglycemia | Adult (9 months) | 28 days | • Simple | • Not elevated insulin levels | Zhao et al., |
| Combined high cholesterol diet (HCD) and high glucose (HG) environment model of hyperglycemia for larval zebrafish | Larva | 10 days | • Simple | • No significant drawback | Wang et al., |
| Combined high cholesterol diet (HCD) and high glucose (HG) environment model of hyperglycemia for adult zebrafish | Adult | 19 days | • Simple | • Not revealing insulin resistance symptoms | Wang et al., |
We considered an induction time of up to two weeks as fast induction.
Comparison of genetic induced hyperglycemia models referred as T2DM in zebrafish.
| Tg (acta1: dnIGF1R-EGFP) transgenic line or zebrafish muscle insulin resistance (zMIR) model of hyperglycemia | Adult | No time | • Insulin resistance | • Long period for exhibiting symptoms | Maddison et al., |
| FOXN3 [Tg(fapb10a:foxn3,EGFP)z106 and Tg(fapb10a:FOXN3,EGFP)z107] models of hyperglycemia | Larva/adult | No time | • Stable hyperglycemia in both larval stage and adulthood | • No significant drawback | Karanth et al., |
| KATP gain of function (KATP-GOF) model of hyperglycemia | Larva/adult | No time | • Severely hyperglycemic | • No significant drawback | Emfinger et al., |
| Type 2 deiodinase (DIO2) knockout model of hyperglycemia | Adult | No time | • Insulin resistance | • Normoglycemia in older group | Houbrechts et al., |
| Multiplex conditional mutagenesis model of hyperglycemia | Larva/adult | No time | • Insulin resistance | • No significant drawback | Maddison et al., |
| Leptin receptor mutation model of hyperglycemia | Larva/adult | No time | • Increased insulin | • Not persistent hyperglycemia | Michel et al., |
| • Pdx1 gene knockout model of hyperglycemia | Larva/adult | No time | • Retinopathic symptoms | • Not revealing insulin resistance, decreased β-cells | Kimmel et al., |
| MODY gene mutation model of hyperglycemia | Larva | No time | • Tolbutamide responsiveness | • No investigation for insulin resistance property | Mathews and Gustafsson, |
| Aldh3a1 gene knockout model of hyperglycemia | Larva | No time | • 4-HNE elevation as HbA1c elevation | • No investigation for insulin resistance property | Lou et al., |
| G protein-coupled receptor 27 (Gpr27) knockout model of hyperglycemia | Larva | No time | • Post-prandial hyperglycemia | • No significant drawback | Nath et al., |
| Glyoxalase1 (glo1−/−) knockout model of hyperglycemia | Larva/adult | No time | • Increased post-prandial glucose | • Not persistent hyperglycemia | Lodd et al., |
| Glucose transporter 12 (GLUT12) deficient model of hyperglycemia | Larva | No time | • Insulin resistance | • No significant drawback | Jiménez-Amilburu et al., |
| Single insra or insrb knockout model of hyperglycemia | Larva | No time | • Post-prandial hyperglycemia | • No significant drawback | Yang et al., |
Scoring of non-genetic induced hyperglycemia models referred as T2DM in zebrafish.
| Model/method | NA | Immersion alternatively in 2 and 0% glucose solution model of hyperglycemia | Immersion in stepwise elevating glucose concentration model of hyperglycemia | Chronic immersion in 110 mM glucose solution model of hyperglycemia | Chronic immersion in 4% glucose solution model of hyperglycemia | Immersion in alternating 4 and 5% glucose solution model of hyperglycemia | Immersion in 130 mM glucose solution model of elevated hyperglycemi | Obesity model of hyperglycemia | High fat diet (HFD) containing 1% egg yolk model of hyperglycemia | Bisphenol F induced model of hyperglycemia | Bisphenol S induced model of hyperglycemia | Combined high cholesterol diet (HCD) and high glucose (HG) environment model of hyperglycemia for larval zebrafish | Combined high cholesterol diet (HCD) and high glucose (HG) environment model of hyperglycemia for adult zebrafish |
| References | Cox and Edelman, | Gleeson et al., | Connaughton et al., | Capiotti et al., | Carnovali et al., | Singh et al., | Jung et al., | Zang et al., | Meng et al., | Zhao et al., | Zhao et al., | Wang et al., | Wang et al., |
| Hyperglycemic outcome | |||||||||||||
| Impaired GT | |||||||||||||
| HbA1c alternatives assay | |||||||||||||
| Retinopathy | |||||||||||||
| Insulin resistance | |||||||||||||
| Anti-diabetic drug responsiveness | |||||||||||||
| Stable hyperglycemia | |||||||||||||
| Total score | 7 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 5 | 2 | 3 | 0 | 3 | 0 |
| Larval or embryonic stage | |||||||||||||
| Adult stage | |||||||||||||
| Induction time | |||||||||||||
| Total score | 3 | 1 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 |
| Model score | 10 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 7 | 2 | 5 | 2 | 5 | 2 |
GT, Glucose tolerance; D, Day; M, Month.
: Positive score = +1.
: Negative score = −1.
: No information available = 0.
Scoring of induction time: 0–30 days = +1; more than 30 days = −1.
Scoring of genetic induced hyperglycemia models referred as T2DM in zebrafish.
| Model/method | NA | Tg (acta1: dnIGF1R-EGFP) transgenic line or zebrafish muscle insulin resistance (zMIR) model of hyperglycemia | FOXN3 [Tg(fapb10a: foxn3,EGFP) z106 and Tg(fapb10a: FOXN3,EGFP) z107] models of hyperglycemia | KATP gain of function (KATP-GOF) model of hyperglycemia | Type 2 deiodinase (DIO2) knockout model of hyperglycemia | Multiplex conditional mutagenesis model of hyperglycemia | Leptin receptor mutation model of hyperglycemia | Pdx1 gene knockout model of hyperglycemia PDX1 gene knockdown model of hyperglycemia | MODY gene mutation model of hyperglycemia | Aldh3a1 gene knockout model of hyperglycemia | G protein-coupled receptor 27 (Gpr27) knockout model of hyperglycemia | Glucose transporter 12 (GLUT12) deficient model of hyperglycemia | Single insra or insrb knockout model of hyperglycemia | |
| References | Cox and Edelman, | Maddison et al., | Karanth et al., | Emfinger et al., | Houbrechts et al., | Yin et al., | Michel et al., | Kimmel et al., | Mathews and Gustafsson, | Lou et al., | Nath et al., | Lodd et al., | Jiménez-Amilburu et al., | Yang et al., |
| Hyperglycemic outcome | ||||||||||||||
| Impaired GT | ||||||||||||||
| HbA1c alternatives assay | ||||||||||||||
| Retinopathy | ||||||||||||||
| Insulin resistance | ||||||||||||||
| Anti-diabetic drug responsiveness | ||||||||||||||
| Stable hyperglycemia | ||||||||||||||
| Total score | 7 | 4 | 2 | 2 | 3 | 5 | 1 | 5 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 6 | 3 | 3 |
| Larval or embryonic stage | ||||||||||||||
| Adult stage | ||||||||||||||
| Induction time | ||||||||||||||
| Total score | 3 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | |
| Model score | 10 | 6 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 7 | 4 | 8 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 9 | 5 | 5 |
GT, Glucose tolerance; D, Day; M, Month.
: Positive score = +1.
: Negative score = −1.
: No information available = 0.
Scoring of induction time: 0–30 days = +1; more than 30 days = −1.
Figure 1(A) Number of research article publications by year to demonstrate the growing interest of researchers by hyperglycemic model of zebrafish (Danio rerio) based on the PubMed/Medline database. (B) Development of new genetic or non-genetic hyperglycemic model of zebrafish (Danio rerio) by year.