Mark Sedrak1, Armando L Alaminos-Bouza2, Andres Bruna3, Russell A Brown4. 1. Neurosurgery, Kaiser Permanente, Redwood City, USA. 2. Medical Physics, Mevis Informática Médica Ltda, São Paulo, BRA. 3. Director, Fi.Me. Fïsica Médica Srl, Córdoba, ARG. 4. Principal Engineer, Retired, Palo Alto, USA.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Frame-based stereotaxis has been widely utilized for precise neurosurgical procedures throughout the world for nearly 40 years. The N-localizer is an integral component of most of the extant systems. Analysis of targeting errors related to the N-localizer has not been carried out in sufficient detail. We highlight these potential errors and develop methods to reduce them. Methods: N-localizer systems comprising three and four N-localizers of various geometries were analyzed using Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. The simulations included native and altered geometric dimensions (Width [W] x Height [H]). Errors were computed using the MC simulations that included the x- and y-axes of vertically oriented rods, that altered the W/H ratio, and that added a fourth N-localizer to a three N-localizer system. Results: The inclusion of an overdetermined system of equations and the geometries of the N-localizer systems had significant effects on target errors. Root Mean Square Errors (RMS-e) computed via millions of MC iterations for each study demonstrated that errors were reduced by (1) inclusion of the x- and y-coordinates of the vertically oriented rods, (2) a greater triangular area enclosed by the diagonal fiducials of the N-localizer system (stereotactic triangle), (3) a larger W/H ratio, and (4) an N-localizer system that comprised four N-localizers. CONCLUSION: Monte Carlo simulations of Root Mean Square error (RMS-e) is a useful technique to understand targeting while using N-localizer systems in stereotactic neurosurgery. The application of vertical rod positions enhances computational accuracy and can be performed on any N-localizer system. Keeping the target point within the stereotactic triangle enclosed by the diagonal rods can also reduce errors. Additional optimizations of N-localizer geometry may also reduce potential targeting errors. Further analysis is needed to confirm these findings which may have clinical importance.
INTRODUCTION: Frame-based stereotaxis has been widely utilized for precise neurosurgical procedures throughout the world for nearly 40 years. The N-localizer is an integral component of most of the extant systems. Analysis of targeting errors related to the N-localizer has not been carried out in sufficient detail. We highlight these potential errors and develop methods to reduce them. Methods: N-localizer systems comprising three and four N-localizers of various geometries were analyzed using Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. The simulations included native and altered geometric dimensions (Width [W] x Height [H]). Errors were computed using the MC simulations that included the x- and y-axes of vertically oriented rods, that altered the W/H ratio, and that added a fourth N-localizer to a three N-localizer system. Results: The inclusion of an overdetermined system of equations and the geometries of the N-localizer systems had significant effects on target errors. Root Mean Square Errors (RMS-e) computed via millions of MC iterations for each study demonstrated that errors were reduced by (1) inclusion of the x- and y-coordinates of the vertically oriented rods, (2) a greater triangular area enclosed by the diagonal fiducials of the N-localizer system (stereotactic triangle), (3) a larger W/H ratio, and (4) an N-localizer system that comprised four N-localizers. CONCLUSION: Monte Carlo simulations of Root Mean Square error (RMS-e) is a useful technique to understand targeting while using N-localizer systems in stereotactic neurosurgery. The application of vertical rod positions enhances computational accuracy and can be performed on any N-localizer system. Keeping the target point within the stereotactic triangle enclosed by the diagonal rods can also reduce errors. Additional optimizations of N-localizer geometry may also reduce potential targeting errors. Further analysis is needed to confirm these findings which may have clinical importance.
Authors: Mark Sedrak; Patrick Pezeshkian; David Purger; Siddharth Srivastava; Ross Anderson; Derek W Yecies; Elena Call; Suketu Khandhar; Keegan Balster; Ivan Bernstein; Diana M Bruce; Armando L Alaminos-Bouza Journal: Cureus Date: 2022-08-25
Authors: Tugce Kutuk; Rupesh Kotecha; Ranjini Tolakanahalli; D Jay J Wieczorek; Yongsook C Lee; Manmeet S Ahluwalia; Matthew D Hall; Michael W McDermott; Haley Appel; Alonso N Gutierrez; Minesh P Mehta; Martin C Tom Journal: Cancers (Basel) Date: 2022-07-13 Impact factor: 6.575