| Literature DB >> 33710321 |
Hema Chaplin1, Lewis Carpenter1, Anni Raz1, Elena Nikiphorou2, Heidi Lempp2, Sam Norton1,2.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To identify how refractory disease (or relevant terminology variations) in RA and polyarticular JIA (polyJIA) is defined and establish the key components of such definitions.Entities:
Keywords: definitions; juvenile idiopathic arthritis; non-response; refractory disease; rheumatoid arthritis; treatment-resistant
Year: 2021 PMID: 33710321 PMCID: PMC8328502 DOI: 10.1093/rheumatology/keab237
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Rheumatology (Oxford) ISSN: 1462-0324 Impact factor: 7.580
Eligibility criteria for considering studies for this review
| Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria | |
|---|---|---|
| Population |
RA PolyJIA Biologic drugs (e.g. etanercept/Enbrel, infliximab, Humira, anakinra, rituximab, tocilizumab etc.) or targeted synthetic therapies (e.g. Janus kinase inhibitors such as baricitinib or tofacitinib) explicitly stated as treatment |
Other health conditions besides RA or polyJIA Acute health conditions or symptoms Non-inflammatory rheumatic disease (e.g. OA) Other inflammatory rheumatic disease (e.g. PsA, AS and uveitis) Treated with conventional synthetic drugs only (e.g. MTX alone) |
| Intervention/exposure (construct) | Refractory disease and any variations for this (e.g. treatment/therapy resistant, difficult/hard to control, non-responsive/response) |
Disease that is being adequately controlled by treatment Acute symptoms that are adequately controlled by treatment |
| Comparison | Not applicable—studies with or without comparison groups included | Not applicable—studies with or without comparison groups included |
| Outcomes | Operationalized definition with clear components (either in the introduction, outcome variables, results or discussion) | No definition stated |
| Study design | Any study design (e.g. observational, interventional, qualitative studies, commentaries or reviews, policy documents) | Laboratory studies using animal models or cells |
PRISMA flowchart of study selection
Subthemes and themes across definitions of non-response and refractory disease
| Key themes | ||
|---|---|---|
| Persistency of symptoms and disease activity | Resistance to multiple drugs with different mechanisms of action | Other contributing factors |
| Subthemes | ||
| Disease activity criteriaa | Drug duration specified | Other contributing factors |
| Remission criteriaa | Drugs/regimes failed, intolerant, discontinued or switched | Biomechanical or degenerative drivers |
| Patient-reported outcomes/symptoms | Adverse event | |
| Presence or absence of inflammation | Steroid use or dependency | Comorbidities or extra-articular manifestations |
| Disease severity | Resistance to multiple drugs (regimes) with different structures or mechanisms of action | Serology or antibodies |
| New joint activity, damage or replacement | Incorrect diagnosis or not relevant treatment | |
| Persistency of symptoms and disease activity | ||
Both non-response criteria and refractory definitions/descriptions.
Refractory definitions/descriptions only.
Chart representing the different terms/labels used (frequencies) across definitions
Most frequently occurring components across studies (17/41), with key for full component descriptions
Network plot to demonstrate the frequency and occurrence of most frequently used components
The size of each node is relative to the number of studies including the component, while the width of the connecting lines is relative to the number of co-occurrences. Components with less than three occurrences are excluded from the graph and lines omitted where co-occurrences were one. Key for components is in Fig. 3.