Theo Meuwissen1, Irene van den Berg2, Mike Goddard2,3. 1. Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Box 5003, 1432, Ås, Norway. theo.meuwissen@nmbu.no. 2. Agriculture Victoria, Bundoora, Australia. 3. Faculty of Veterinary and Agricultural Sciences, University of Melbourne, Parkville, Australia.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Whole-genome sequence (WGS) data are increasingly available on large numbers of individuals in animal and plant breeding and in human genetics through second-generation resequencing technologies, 1000 genomes projects, and large-scale genotype imputation from lower marker densities. Here, we present a computationally fast implementation of a variable selection genomic prediction method, that could handle WGS data on more than 35,000 individuals, test its accuracy for across-breed predictions and assess its quantitative trait locus (QTL) mapping precision. METHODS: The Monte Carlo Markov chain (MCMC) variable selection model (Bayes GC) fits simultaneously a genomic best linear unbiased prediction (GBLUP) term, i.e. a polygenic effect whose correlations are described by a genomic relationship matrix (G), and a Bayes C term, i.e. a set of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) with large effects selected by the model. Computational speed is improved by a Metropolis-Hastings sampling that directs computations to the SNPs, which are, a priori, most likely to be included into the model. Speed is also improved by running many relatively short MCMC chains. Memory requirements are reduced by storing the genotype matrix in binary form. The model was tested on a WGS dataset containing Holstein, Jersey and Australian Red cattle. The data contained 4,809,520 genotypes on 35,549 individuals together with their milk, fat and protein yields, and fat and protein percentage traits. RESULTS: The prediction accuracies of the Jersey individuals improved by 1.5% when using across-breed GBLUP compared to within-breed predictions. Using WGS instead of 600 k SNP-chip data yielded on average a 3% accuracy improvement for Australian Red cows. QTL were fine-mapped by locating the SNP with the highest posterior probability of being included in the model. Various QTL known from the literature were rediscovered, and a new SNP affecting milk production was discovered on chromosome 20 at 34.501126 Mb. Due to the high mapping precision, it was clear that many of the discovered QTL were the same across the five dairy traits. CONCLUSIONS: Across-breed Bayes GC genomic prediction improved prediction accuracies compared to GBLUP. The combination of across-breed WGS data and Bayesian genomic prediction proved remarkably effective for the fine-mapping of QTL.
BACKGROUND: Whole-genome sequence (WGS) data are increasingly available on large numbers of individuals in animal and plant breeding and in human genetics through second-generation resequencing technologies, 1000 genomes projects, and large-scale genotype imputation from lower marker densities. Here, we present a computationally fast implementation of a variable selection genomic prediction method, that could handle WGS data on more than 35,000 individuals, test its accuracy for across-breed predictions and assess its quantitative trait locus (QTL) mapping precision. METHODS: The Monte Carlo Markov chain (MCMC) variable selection model (Bayes GC) fits simultaneously a genomic best linear unbiased prediction (GBLUP) term, i.e. a polygenic effect whose correlations are described by a genomic relationship matrix (G), and a Bayes C term, i.e. a set of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) with large effects selected by the model. Computational speed is improved by a Metropolis-Hastings sampling that directs computations to the SNPs, which are, a priori, most likely to be included into the model. Speed is also improved by running many relatively short MCMC chains. Memory requirements are reduced by storing the genotype matrix in binary form. The model was tested on a WGS dataset containing Holstein, Jersey and Australian Redcattle. The data contained 4,809,520 genotypes on 35,549 individuals together with their milk, fat and protein yields, and fat and protein percentage traits. RESULTS: The prediction accuracies of the Jersey individuals improved by 1.5% when using across-breed GBLUP compared to within-breed predictions. Using WGS instead of 600 k SNP-chip data yielded on average a 3% accuracy improvement for Australian Redcows. QTL were fine-mapped by locating the SNP with the highest posterior probability of being included in the model. Various QTL known from the literature were rediscovered, and a new SNP affecting milk production was discovered on chromosome 20 at 34.501126 Mb. Due to the high mapping precision, it was clear that many of the discovered QTL were the same across the five dairy traits. CONCLUSIONS: Across-breed Bayes GC genomic prediction improved prediction accuracies compared to GBLUP. The combination of across-breed WGS data and Bayesian genomic prediction proved remarkably effective for the fine-mapping of QTL.
Authors: Shaun Purcell; Benjamin Neale; Kathe Todd-Brown; Lori Thomas; Manuel A R Ferreira; David Bender; Julian Maller; Pamela Sklar; Paul I W de Bakker; Mark J Daly; Pak C Sham Journal: Am J Hum Genet Date: 2007-07-25 Impact factor: 11.025
Authors: Gonçalo R Abecasis; David Altshuler; Adam Auton; Lisa D Brooks; Richard M Durbin; Richard A Gibbs; Matt E Hurles; Gil A McVean Journal: Nature Date: 2010-10-28 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Hans D Daetwyler; Aurélien Capitan; Hubert Pausch; Paul Stothard; Rianne van Binsbergen; Rasmus F Brøndum; Xiaoping Liao; Anis Djari; Sabrina C Rodriguez; Cécile Grohs; Diane Esquerré; Olivier Bouchez; Marie-Noëlle Rossignol; Christophe Klopp; Dominique Rocha; Sébastien Fritz; André Eggen; Phil J Bowman; David Coote; Amanda J Chamberlain; Charlotte Anderson; Curt P VanTassell; Ina Hulsegge; Mike E Goddard; Bernt Guldbrandtsen; Mogens S Lund; Roel F Veerkamp; Didier A Boichard; Ruedi Fries; Ben J Hayes Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2014-07-13 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Tingting Wang; Yi-Ping Phoebe Chen; Michael E Goddard; Theo H E Meuwissen; Kathryn E Kemper; Ben J Hayes Journal: Genet Sel Evol Date: 2015-04-30 Impact factor: 4.297
Authors: Irene van den Berg; Ruidong Xiang; Janez Jenko; Hubert Pausch; Mekki Boussaha; Chris Schrooten; Thierry Tribout; Arne B Gjuvsland; Didier Boichard; Øyvind Nordbø; Marie-Pierre Sanchez; Mike E Goddard Journal: Genet Sel Evol Date: 2020-07-07 Impact factor: 4.297
Authors: Lakshmi K Matukumalli; Cynthia T Lawley; Robert D Schnabel; Jeremy F Taylor; Mark F Allan; Michael P Heaton; Jeff O'Connell; Stephen S Moore; Timothy P L Smith; Tad S Sonstegard; Curtis P Van Tassell Journal: PLoS One Date: 2009-04-24 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Andrew R Wood; Tonu Esko; Jian Yang; Sailaja Vedantam; Tune H Pers; Stefan Gustafsson; Audrey Y Chu; Karol Estrada; Jian'an Luan; Zoltán Kutalik; Najaf Amin; Martin L Buchkovich; Damien C Croteau-Chonka; Felix R Day; Yanan Duan; Tove Fall; Rudolf Fehrmann; Teresa Ferreira; Anne U Jackson; Juha Karjalainen; Ken Sin Lo; Adam E Locke; Reedik Mägi; Evelin Mihailov; Eleonora Porcu; Joshua C Randall; André Scherag; Anna A E Vinkhuyzen; Harm-Jan Westra; Thomas W Winkler; Tsegaselassie Workalemahu; Jing Hua Zhao; Devin Absher; Eva Albrecht; Denise Anderson; Jeffrey Baron; Marian Beekman; Ayse Demirkan; Georg B Ehret; Bjarke Feenstra; Mary F Feitosa; Krista Fischer; Ross M Fraser; Anuj Goel; Jian Gong; Anne E Justice; Stavroula Kanoni; Marcus E Kleber; Kati Kristiansson; Unhee Lim; Vaneet Lotay; Julian C Lui; Massimo Mangino; Irene Mateo Leach; Carolina Medina-Gomez; Michael A Nalls; Dale R Nyholt; Cameron D Palmer; Dorota Pasko; Sonali Pechlivanis; Inga Prokopenko; Janina S Ried; Stephan Ripke; Dmitry Shungin; Alena Stancáková; Rona J Strawbridge; Yun Ju Sung; Toshiko Tanaka; Alexander Teumer; Stella Trompet; Sander W van der Laan; Jessica van Setten; Jana V Van Vliet-Ostaptchouk; Zhaoming Wang; Loïc Yengo; Weihua Zhang; Uzma Afzal; Johan Arnlöv; Gillian M Arscott; Stefania Bandinelli; Amy Barrett; Claire Bellis; Amanda J Bennett; Christian Berne; Matthias Blüher; Jennifer L Bolton; Yvonne Böttcher; Heather A Boyd; Marcel Bruinenberg; Brendan M Buckley; Steven Buyske; Ida H Caspersen; Peter S Chines; Robert Clarke; Simone Claudi-Boehm; Matthew Cooper; E Warwick Daw; Pim A De Jong; Joris Deelen; Graciela Delgado; Josh C Denny; Rosalie Dhonukshe-Rutten; Maria Dimitriou; Alex S F Doney; Marcus Dörr; Niina Eklund; Elodie Eury; Lasse Folkersen; Melissa E Garcia; Frank Geller; Vilmantas Giedraitis; Alan S Go; Harald Grallert; Tanja B Grammer; Jürgen Gräßler; Henrik Grönberg; Lisette C P G M de Groot; Christopher J Groves; Jeffrey Haessler; Per Hall; Toomas Haller; Goran Hallmans; Anke Hannemann; Catharina A Hartman; Maija Hassinen; Caroline Hayward; Nancy L Heard-Costa; Quinta Helmer; Gibran Hemani; Anjali K Henders; Hans L Hillege; Mark A Hlatky; Wolfgang Hoffmann; Per Hoffmann; Oddgeir Holmen; Jeanine J Houwing-Duistermaat; Thomas Illig; Aaron Isaacs; Alan L James; Janina Jeff; Berit Johansen; Åsa Johansson; Jennifer Jolley; Thorhildur Juliusdottir; Juhani Junttila; Abel N Kho; Leena Kinnunen; Norman Klopp; Thomas Kocher; Wolfgang Kratzer; Peter Lichtner; Lars Lind; Jaana Lindström; Stéphane Lobbens; Mattias Lorentzon; Yingchang Lu; Valeriya Lyssenko; Patrik K E Magnusson; Anubha Mahajan; Marc Maillard; Wendy L McArdle; Colin A McKenzie; Stela McLachlan; Paul J McLaren; Cristina Menni; Sigrun Merger; Lili Milani; Alireza Moayyeri; Keri L Monda; Mario A Morken; Gabriele Müller; Martina Müller-Nurasyid; Arthur W Musk; Narisu Narisu; Matthias Nauck; Ilja M Nolte; Markus M Nöthen; Laticia Oozageer; Stefan Pilz; Nigel W Rayner; Frida Renstrom; Neil R Robertson; Lynda M Rose; Ronan Roussel; Serena Sanna; Hubert Scharnagl; Salome Scholtens; Fredrick R Schumacher; Heribert Schunkert; Robert A Scott; Joban Sehmi; Thomas Seufferlein; Jianxin Shi; Karri Silventoinen; Johannes H Smit; Albert Vernon Smith; Joanna Smolonska; Alice V Stanton; Kathleen Stirrups; David J Stott; Heather M Stringham; Johan Sundström; Morris A Swertz; Ann-Christine Syvänen; Bamidele O Tayo; Gudmar Thorleifsson; Jonathan P Tyrer; Suzanne van Dijk; Natasja M van Schoor; Nathalie van der Velde; Diana van Heemst; Floor V A van Oort; Sita H Vermeulen; Niek Verweij; Judith M Vonk; Lindsay L Waite; Melanie Waldenberger; Roman Wennauer; Lynne R Wilkens; Christina Willenborg; Tom Wilsgaard; Mary K Wojczynski; Andrew Wong; Alan F Wright; Qunyuan Zhang; Dominique Arveiler; Stephan J L Bakker; John Beilby; Richard N Bergman; Sven Bergmann; Reiner Biffar; John Blangero; Dorret I Boomsma; Stefan R Bornstein; Pascal Bovet; Paolo Brambilla; Morris J Brown; Harry Campbell; Mark J Caulfield; Aravinda Chakravarti; Rory Collins; Francis S Collins; Dana C Crawford; L Adrienne Cupples; John Danesh; Ulf de Faire; Hester M den Ruijter; Raimund Erbel; Jeanette Erdmann; Johan G Eriksson; Martin Farrall; Ele Ferrannini; Jean Ferrières; Ian Ford; Nita G Forouhi; Terrence Forrester; Ron T Gansevoort; Pablo V Gejman; Christian Gieger; Alain Golay; Omri Gottesman; Vilmundur Gudnason; Ulf Gyllensten; David W Haas; Alistair S Hall; Tamara B Harris; Andrew T Hattersley; Andrew C Heath; Christian Hengstenberg; Andrew A Hicks; Lucia A Hindorff; Aroon D Hingorani; Albert Hofman; G Kees Hovingh; Steve E Humphries; Steven C Hunt; Elina Hypponen; Kevin B Jacobs; Marjo-Riitta Jarvelin; Pekka Jousilahti; Antti M Jula; Jaakko Kaprio; John J P Kastelein; Manfred Kayser; Frank Kee; Sirkka M Keinanen-Kiukaanniemi; Lambertus A Kiemeney; Jaspal S Kooner; Charles Kooperberg; Seppo Koskinen; Peter Kovacs; Aldi T Kraja; Meena Kumari; Johanna Kuusisto; Timo A Lakka; Claudia Langenberg; Loic Le Marchand; Terho Lehtimäki; Sara Lupoli; Pamela A F Madden; Satu Männistö; Paolo Manunta; André Marette; Tara C Matise; Barbara McKnight; Thomas Meitinger; Frans L Moll; Grant W Montgomery; Andrew D Morris; Andrew P Morris; Jeffrey C Murray; Mari Nelis; Claes Ohlsson; Albertine J Oldehinkel; Ken K Ong; Willem H Ouwehand; Gerard Pasterkamp; Annette Peters; Peter P Pramstaller; Jackie F Price; Lu Qi; Olli T Raitakari; Tuomo Rankinen; D C Rao; Treva K Rice; Marylyn Ritchie; Igor Rudan; Veikko Salomaa; Nilesh J Samani; Jouko Saramies; Mark A Sarzynski; Peter E H Schwarz; Sylvain Sebert; Peter Sever; Alan R Shuldiner; Juha Sinisalo; Valgerdur Steinthorsdottir; Ronald P Stolk; Jean-Claude Tardif; Anke Tönjes; Angelo Tremblay; Elena Tremoli; Jarmo Virtamo; Marie-Claude Vohl; Philippe Amouyel; Folkert W Asselbergs; Themistocles L Assimes; Murielle Bochud; Bernhard O Boehm; Eric Boerwinkle; Erwin P Bottinger; Claude Bouchard; Stéphane Cauchi; John C Chambers; Stephen J Chanock; Richard S Cooper; Paul I W de Bakker; George Dedoussis; Luigi Ferrucci; Paul W Franks; Philippe Froguel; Leif C Groop; Christopher A Haiman; Anders Hamsten; M Geoffrey Hayes; Jennie Hui; David J Hunter; Kristian Hveem; J Wouter Jukema; Robert C Kaplan; Mika Kivimaki; Diana Kuh; Markku Laakso; Yongmei Liu; Nicholas G Martin; Winfried März; Mads Melbye; Susanne Moebus; Patricia B Munroe; Inger Njølstad; Ben A Oostra; Colin N A Palmer; Nancy L Pedersen; Markus Perola; Louis Pérusse; Ulrike Peters; Joseph E Powell; Chris Power; Thomas Quertermous; Rainer Rauramaa; Eva Reinmaa; Paul M Ridker; Fernando Rivadeneira; Jerome I Rotter; Timo E Saaristo; Danish Saleheen; David Schlessinger; P Eline Slagboom; Harold Snieder; Tim D Spector; Konstantin Strauch; Michael Stumvoll; Jaakko Tuomilehto; Matti Uusitupa; Pim van der Harst; Henry Völzke; Mark Walker; Nicholas J Wareham; Hugh Watkins; H-Erich Wichmann; James F Wilson; Pieter Zanen; Panos Deloukas; Iris M Heid; Cecilia M Lindgren; Karen L Mohlke; Elizabeth K Speliotes; Unnur Thorsteinsdottir; Inês Barroso; Caroline S Fox; Kari E North; David P Strachan; Jacques S Beckmann; Sonja I Berndt; Michael Boehnke; Ingrid B Borecki; Mark I McCarthy; Andres Metspalu; Kari Stefansson; André G Uitterlinden; Cornelia M van Duijn; Lude Franke; Cristen J Willer; Alkes L Price; Guillaume Lettre; Ruth J F Loos; Michael N Weedon; Erik Ingelsson; Jeffrey R O'Connell; Goncalo R Abecasis; Daniel I Chasman; Michael E Goddard; Peter M Visscher; Joel N Hirschhorn; Timothy M Frayling Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2014-10-05 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Roger Ros-Freixedes; Martin Johnsson; Andrew Whalen; Ching-Yi Chen; Bruno D Valente; William O Herring; Gregor Gorjanc; John M Hickey Journal: Genet Sel Evol Date: 2022-09-24 Impact factor: 5.100