Background: Pediatric buckle fractures of the wrist can be safely managed in 'minimalist' fashion with splinting and limited follow-up; however, traditional means of treatment remain prevalent. The purpose of this study was to 1) evaluate preferences for buckle fracture management among providers at a single institution and 2) identify factors influencing clinical decision-making and barriers to implementation of minimalist practices. Methods: A 13 question survey was developed split into three sections: 1) Demographics, 2) Preferred management, and 3) Influential factors. The survey was distributed to 32 providers within our hospital system involved in buckle fracture management via email over a 1 year period. Descriptive statistics of responses were performed to address study aims. Results: The survey participation rate was 72%. Respondents had 12.2+/-12.5 (Range: 1-41) years of experience. Casting of buckle fractures was preferred by 56.5% of providers. Most (77%) were aware of literature supporting minimalist strategies. Family preferences (59.1%) and compliance concerns (54.5%) were cited as the biggest barriers to implementing these practices. Colleague recommendations and patient and caregiver preferences had the strongest influence on providers' practice. Following completion, 88.2% of providers stated they would change or consider changing their practices. Discussion: Despite awareness of the evidence base, a casting preference still exists. While other aspects of the minimalist approach were popular, prior work suggests this does not necessarily translate into practice. Commonly cited barriers include family preferences and compliance concerns; however, awareness of these issues may enable change. Level of Evidence: III.
Background: Pediatric buckle fractures of the wrist can be safely managed in 'minimalist' fashion with splinting and limited follow-up; however, traditional means of treatment remain prevalent. The purpose of this study was to 1) evaluate preferences for buckle fracture management among providers at a single institution and 2) identify factors influencing clinical decision-making and barriers to implementation of minimalist practices. Methods: A 13 question survey was developed split into three sections: 1) Demographics, 2) Preferred management, and 3) Influential factors. The survey was distributed to 32 providers within our hospital system involved in buckle fracture management via email over a 1 year period. Descriptive statistics of responses were performed to address study aims. Results: The survey participation rate was 72%. Respondents had 12.2+/-12.5 (Range: 1-41) years of experience. Casting of buckle fractures was preferred by 56.5% of providers. Most (77%) were aware of literature supporting minimalist strategies. Family preferences (59.1%) and compliance concerns (54.5%) were cited as the biggest barriers to implementing these practices. Colleague recommendations and patient and caregiver preferences had the strongest influence on providers' practice. Following completion, 88.2% of providers stated they would change or consider changing their practices. Discussion: Despite awareness of the evidence base, a casting preference still exists. While other aspects of the minimalist approach were popular, prior work suggests this does not necessarily translate into practice. Commonly cited barriers include family preferences and compliance concerns; however, awareness of these issues may enable change. Level of Evidence: III.
Authors: Paul A Harris; Robert Taylor; Robert Thielke; Jonathon Payne; Nathaniel Gonzalez; Jose G Conde Journal: J Biomed Inform Date: 2008-09-30 Impact factor: 6.317
Authors: Kristine G Williams; Gillian Smith; Scott J Luhmann; Jingnan Mao; Joseph D Gunn; Janet D Luhmann Journal: Pediatr Emerg Care Date: 2013-05 Impact factor: 1.454