Shlomo Rozen1, Inna Vints1, Ana Lerner1,2, Oded Hod3, Edward N Brothers4, Salvador Moncho4. 1. School of Chemistry, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv 6997801, Israel. 2. Chemistry Department, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Beer-Sheva 84105, Israel. 3. Department of Physical Chemistry, School of Chemistry, The Raymond and Beverly Sackler Faculty of Exact Sciences and The Sackler Center for Computational Molecular and Materials Science, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv 6997801, Israel. 4. Science Program, Texas A&M University at Qatar, Education City, Doha 23874, Qatar.
Abstract
The present study of the chemistry of short-lived α-fluorocarbocations reveals that even inactive methyl carbons can serve as nucleophiles, attacking a cationic center. This, in turn, facilitates the synthesis of a cyclopropane ring in certain triterpene backbones. We report the synthesis of compounds similar to 2, containing a bridgehead cyclopropane, and compounds of type 3 with an 11 membered bicyclic ring consisting of two bridgehead double bonds (anti-Bredt) within a triterpene skeleton. The synthesis involves three unconventional chemical processes: (a) a methyl group serving as a nucleophile; (b) the unexpected and unprecedented synthesis of a strained system in the absence of an external neighboring trigger; and (c) the formation of an 11-membered bicyclic diene ring within a triterpenoid skeleton. An α-fluorocarbocation mechanism is proposed and supported by density functional theory calculations.
The present study of the chemistry of short-lived α-fluorocarbocations reveals that even inactive methyl carbons can serve as nucleophiles, attacking a cationic center. This, in turn, facilitates the synthesis of a cyclopropane ring in certain triterpene backbones. We report the synthesis of compounds similar to 2, containing a bridgehead cyclopropane, and compounds of type 3 with an 11 membered bicyclic ring consisting of two bridgehead double bonds (anti-Bredt) within a triterpene skeleton. The synthesis involves three unconventional chemical processes: (a) a methyl group serving as a nucleophile; (b) the unexpected and unprecedented synthesis of a strained system in the absence of an external neighboring trigger; and (c) the formation of an 11-membered bicyclic diene ring within a triterpenoid skeleton. An α-fluorocarbocation mechanism is proposed and supported by density functional theory calculations.
Following carbon, oxygen,
hydrogen, and nitrogen, fluorine stands
out due to its vast impact on medicinal chemistry, agriculture, material
science, modern anesthetics, refrigerants, and more.[1] As such, it is desirable to identify distinctive fluorine-based
intermediate structures that may serve as platforms for the synthesis
of novel compounds and unveil their unique chemistry.α-Fluorocarbocations
constitute an important family of such
fluorine-bearing intermediates. Nevertheless, only a limited number
of reactions that involve this halo-carbocation are known.[2] Because fluorine is the most electronegative
atom, α-fluorocarbocation intermediates are expected to be considerably
more reactive than the corresponding bare carbocations of different
types[3] and hence exhibit significantly
shorter lifetimes. This, in turn, opens the door for novel α-fluorocarbocation-based
chemistry that requires broad understanding of their nature. In the
present study, we demonstrate and analyze examples of unusual reactions
that take place when this intriguing species serves as an intermediate.Previously, some of us have shown that under suitable conditions,
nitrogen diluted fluorine can be a suitable starting point for many
new and unprecedented reactions,[4] including syn addition across both isolated double bonds and enones.[5] Unlike the heavier halogens, elemental fluorine
as well as other reagents possessing a strong electrophilic fluorine
atom such as acetyl- and trifluoroacetyl hypofluorites add across
those π centers in a syn mode through a fast
reaction.[2,3] The underlying mechanism involved the initial
formation of a very short-lived ion pair cage constituting of the
α-fluorocarbocation and its counterion (Figure a) that instantly collapsed into the syn product. A four-center reaction mechanism was ruled
out because when stabilizing the α-fluorocarbocation (as in
4-methoxystylbene), a mixture of stereoisomers resulting from both syn- and anti-additions was obtained (Figure b).[2] Obviously the latter cannot be a product of a four-center
process. Because these reactions have been performed at low temperatures
and in the presence of polar solvents and/or radical inhibitors, a
radical mechanism was also ruled out, suggesting an ionic mode of
addition.[6]
Figure 1
Examples of chemical reactions where an
intermediate α-fluorocarbocation
is formed via the attack of a double bond by an electrophilic fluorine.
(a) A standard parallel attack of F2 on a double bond resulting
in a short-lived α-fluorocarbocation that forms a syn-addition product. (b) By stabilizing the α-fluorocarbocation,
both syn- and anti-addition products
were obtained.[2,5]
Examples of chemical reactions where an
intermediate α-fluorocarbocation
is formed via the attack of a double bond by an electrophilic fluorine.
(a) A standard parallel attack of F2 on a double bond resulting
in a short-lived α-fluorocarbocation that forms a syn-addition product. (b) By stabilizing the α-fluorocarbocation,
both syn- and anti-addition products
were obtained.[2,5]
Results
and Discussion
Unlike the above findings, there are cases
where the F2 cannot approach the targeted double bond in
a parallel configuration.
A distinctive example of such a situation can be found in several
important triterpene molecules, such as methyl 3-acetoxy-18β-glycyrrhetate
(1),[7] a member of the β-amirin
family (see Figure ). Interest in this specific compound arose mainly due to its biological
activities, especially against various ulcers.[8] This led to extensive explorative modifications of its skeleton[9] none, however, around the remarkably stable enone
in ring C. Notably, even when the highly reactive [BrF] types of reagents
are present, the enone in 1 remains unaffected[10] because the bulky bromine atom cannot readily
access the C12 position. This supports the argument that when a fluorine
molecule attacks this bond, its ability to approach it in the preferred
parallel orientation is inhibited by steric effects associated with
the nearby methyl groups (see further discussion of this issue in SI Section 2 and below).
Figure 2
Molecular structure of
methyl 3-acetoxy-18β-glycyrrhetate
Molecular structure of
methyl 3-acetoxy-18β-glycyrrhetateIn the present study, to avoid radical reactions (and thus mixtures
of different compounds) and to encourage an ionic mechanism that promotes
more distinctive products, we dissolved 1 in a polar
solvent mixture (CHCl3/CFCl3/EtOH 1/1/0.2) and
reacted it with F2 (10% in N2) at −75
°C. Under these conditions, we expected the positive pole of
the polarized small fluorine molecule to easily attack the enone of
the C ring in an electrophilic mode.[11] However,
as mentioned above, the fluorine cannot approach the enone in a parallel
orientation, so instead, it attacks carbon 12 in a nearly perpendicular
mode (see Figure ).
This hypothesis is further supported by density functional theory
(DFT) calculations (see below). Such an action by the fluorine results
in a cage of ions (structure A in Figure ) where the fluoride anion, which is stabilized
by the acidic hydrogens of the solvent, is relatively far from the
positively charged carbon of the α-fluorocarbocation. This,
in turn, implies that unlike the case of isolated double bonds or
common enones, the resulting very short-lived cage containing the
α-fluorocarbocation A cannot easily form syn-difluoro derivatives and must find an alternative route
to collapse.
Figure 3
Formation of the α-fluorocarbocation cage of 1. (A) Schematic representation of the vicinity of the reaction
center.
(B) The outcome of the calculated path to the transition state as
obtained by the DFT calculations.
Formation of the α-fluorocarbocation cage of 1. (A) Schematic representation of the vicinity of the reaction
center.
(B) The outcome of the calculated path to the transition state as
obtained by the DFT calculations.Intuitively, one may envision two plausible pathways for the collapse
mechanism of the short-lived fluorocarbocation in cage A involving the ejection of either the hydrogen at the C12 or at the
C18 position to form the corresponding enone. Surprisingly, neither
of these pathways is undertaken. Instead, an unprecedented nucleophilic
attack on the α-fluorocarbocation at C13 by the carbon of the
angular 27-methyl group takes place. This attack is accompanied by
the ejection of a proton from that methyl and the formation of a strained
cyclopropane derivative (2) with greater than 90% yield
(Figure ).
Figure 4
(a) Schematic
and (b) X-ray structure of the cyclopropane derivative 2.
(a) Schematic
and (b) X-ray structure of the cyclopropane derivative 2.To substantiate this unexpected
finding, we measured the 1H NMR spectrum of 2 (see SI Section 1), which demonstrates the disappearance of the 27-methyl group
signature, usually found at 1.22 ppm, and the appearance of a single
cyclopropane hydrogen at 0.47 ppm. The second cyclopropyl hydrogen
could not be identified as it is somewhat deshielded by the α-fluoro-carbonyl,
thus appearing in a region where many other methylene hydrogens resonate.
This is supported by our calculated NMR signals yielding a 1.31 ppm
peak for the 27-methyl group of 1 and 0.37 and 1.38 ppm
peaks for the cyclopropane hydrogens of 2 (see Figure S1 in SI Section 2 for the calculated
NMR spectrum). Further validation of our findings, is given by the
X-ray diffraction measurement of compound 2 (Figure b) which unequivocally
demonstrates the cyclopropane structure (for the cif file, see SI Section 3).This unique product strongly
indicates the stereoelectronic factors
facilitating the involvement of the 27-methyl group, which kinetically
favors the cyclopropane structure formation over the thermodynamically
preferred enone products. To the best of our knowledge, the only other
triterpenoid possessing a cyclopropane ring between rings C and D
is the recently isolated phainanoid F (see Figure a for a partial structure), which was found
to be a stout immunosuppressant.[12] Therefore,
exploiting this mechanism not only unveils unique chemistry but also
opens a new route to biologically relevant structural motifs.
Figure 5
The only naturally
occurring (to the best of our knowledge) structures
that resemble those synthesized in the present study. (a) A cyclopropane
ring within the naturally occurring phainanoid F. (b) An oxo-diene
bridged 11-membered bicyclic ring in the naturally occurring Tylopiol
A.
The only naturally
occurring (to the best of our knowledge) structures
that resemble those synthesized in the present study. (a) A cyclopropane
ring within the naturally occurring phainanoid F. (b) An oxo-diene
bridged 11-membered bicyclic ring in the naturally occurring Tylopiol
A.To elucidate the underlying mechanism
for the formation of the
cyclopropane species, we performed a set of DFT calculations characterizing
the reaction pathway at the ωB97XD[13]/6-31+g(d,p) level of theory using the Gaussian Development Version[14] (see SI Section 2 for further details regarding the calculations). In theory, the
approach of the F2 toward the triterpene’s enone
moiety could proceed from either side of the triterpene’s plane
with a slight preference of the α-side, and since the experimental
findings indicate that the attack is indeed from that direction, we
proceeded with the DFT calculations accordingly (the data regarding
the β-side reaction is available in Figure S3 of SI Section 2).To explore the entire reaction path
between the reactants and the
cyclopropanated species (2), we performed intrinsic reaction
coordinate (IRC) analysis.[15] We find that
after 16 steps of the IRC procedure, the perpendicular approach of
the fluorine results in C12–F bond formation with bond length
of 1.387 Å, which is the most stable isolated α-fluorocarbocation
geometry. The accompanied fluoride anion is practically free (2.180
Å from the other fluorine) (see SI Section 2, Figures S4 and S5).As was recently demonstrated by
Singleton,[16] however, calculations with
explicit solvent molecules are important
for concluding the exact effects on ion pair stability. To evaluate
the role of the chloroform/ethanol solvent on the reaction mechanism,
we performed calculations with a minimalistic explicit solvent model.
To this end, the α-fluorocarbocation/fluoride ion pair was placed
in an implicit chloroform solvent environment and optimized in the
presence of a methanol molecule (see Figure ). An intermediate structure prior to the
C27 methyl hydrogen abstraction is found. In this intermediate, the
distance between the fluoride anion and the C27 methyl’s hydrogen
is 1.680 Å, while the corresponding C–H bond is elongated
to 1.129 Å. The formation of such a structure points toward a
two-step pathway. The competition with the alcohol molecule results
in weakening of the methyl C27–H bond, which by itself is significantly
tilted toward the α-fluorocarbocation, but with no full cleavage.
The second inevitable step would be the final construction of the
cyclopropane. Therefore, even in the presence of an explicit solvent
that reduces the tendency of the leaving fluoride anion to accept
one of the C27 methyl hydrogens, the short live α-fluorocarbocation
tends to undergo a fast (though not completely barrierless) cyclopropanation
reaction.
Figure 6
Side (a) and top (b) views of the DFT optimized geometry of the
α-fluorocarbocation/fluoride ion pair optimized with an implicit
chloroform solvent model in the presence of an explicit methanol molecule.
For clarity, only the relevant region is depicted.
Side (a) and top (b) views of the DFT optimized geometry of the
α-fluorocarbocation/fluoride ion pair optimized with an implicit
chloroform solvent model in the presence of an explicit methanol molecule.
For clarity, only the relevant region is depicted.Having established the reliability of the DFT calculations
for
the studied system, we harnessed the same computational protocol to
perform a reference calculation, where the F2 is replaced
by HF forming a similar, but fluorine-free carbocation. This allows
us to evaluate the importance of the fluorine atom within the molecular
backbone for the intramolecular cyclopropanation reaction. Upon attack
on the double bond, the proton of the HF molecule is inserted in position
C12, forming a plain carbocation while the fluoride anion leaves.
The corresponding geometry and charge distribution are given in SI Section 2, Table S2, and Figure S6. As in the case of the
F2 attack, the carbocation/fluoride anion pair could potentially
result in the fluoride abstracting a hydrogen atom from either the
C27 methyl group or the C14 or C18 positions. In particular, the cyclopropanated
species of the HF attack is 7.3 kcal/mol less stable than the reactants
(to be compared with the corresponding F2 structures, which
is about ∼100 kcal/mol more stable than the reactants). This
indicates that the thermodynamically favorable option in the case
of HF attack is to decompose back to the reactants. Furthermore, the
barrier to cross during this endoergic reaction is extremely high
(41.2 kcal/mol compared to 2.7 kcal/mol for the F2 attack
case), marking it also as kinetically unfavorable. Therefore, we conclude
that during the reaction with F2, the fluorine insertion
to the double bond leading to the short-lived α-fluorocarbocation
is essential for the rapid cyclopropane moiety formation.Once
formed, the cyclopropanated structure 2 is obviously
a metastable structure. We found that the presence of solvents possessing
even weak acidic hydrogens, such as chloroform, is sufficient to promote
the opening of the strained cyclopropane ring cleaving the C13–C14
bond in a matter of a few hours. Notably, the resulting 11-membered
bicyclic ring dienone (3), whose structure was confirmed
by X-ray diffraction (Figure , for the cif file, see SI Section 3), was obtained in quantitative yield. To the best of our knowledge,
this is the first example of a dienone where each double bond resides
on a CH2 bridgehead (a double anti-Bredt’s rule),
although a related oxobicyclo [4.4.1] diene system (Tylopiol A, see Figure b) was recently described.[17] An interesting UV spectral absorption at 285
nm (ε = 2.2 × 103) was also measured for 3, representing a red shift of about 35 nm relative to reactant 1. This value reflects the partial through-space interaction
of the two double bonds characteristic to all compounds of this type
(see below).
Figure 7
(top) The reaction of 2 converted to 3 and (bottom) the X-ray structure of 3.
(top) The reaction of 2 converted to 3 and (bottom) the X-ray structure of 3.The two unique reactions described above that stem
from the short-lived
nature of the α-fluorocarbocation moiety are not limited to
18β-glycyrrhetic acid. To demonstrate the viability of these
reactions in other triterpenoids, we considered two additional molecules.
The first was methyl 3-trichloroacetoxy-α-glycyrrhetate (4) (rings D/E being in trans-configuration),
and the second was methyl 3-acetoxy-11-oxooleanoate (5) made through oxidation of methyl 3-acetoxy-oleanoate (6) by chrome-trioxide (see Figure ).[18]
Figure 8
Structures of compounds 4, 5, and 6. Note that 6 was oxidized to 5 with the aid of CrO3.
Structures of compounds 4, 5, and 6. Note that 6 was oxidized to 5 with the aid of CrO3.The purpose of the fluorination of 4 was to see if
the trans-configuration of the D/E rings affects
the approach of the F2 molecule to the C12–C13 double
bond compared to the methyl 3-acetoxy-β-glycyrrhetate (1). The results show that the relative arrangement of these
rings has a negligible effect on the reaction, and only the angular
methyl groups, which direct the attack from the α-side, govern
the approach of the fluorine toward the enone. The resulting fluoro-cyclopropane
derivative 7 is formed in 95% yield (Figure ). The properties of this compound
were found to be very similar to 2, including the 1H NMR spectral line of one of the hydrogens in the cyclopropane
ring that appeared at 0.47 ppm. Similar to the β-glycyrrhetate
series, compound 7 was found to readily decompose (within
a few hours), when solvents with somewhat acidic hydrogen (e.g., CHCl3) were present, to form the bridgehead 11-membered bicyclic
ring dienone (8) in quantitative yields. Similar to compound 3, this product revealed a typical UV absorption of 287 nm
(ε = 3.7 × 103), and the final proof was again
obtained by X-ray crystallography (for the appropriate cif file see SI Section 3). To check whether the location
of the carboxylic moiety has some effect on the α-fluorocarbocation,
we tested also the oleanolic acid derivative 5. The changed
location of the carboxylic acid did not affect the course of the reaction.
When a dilute 10% F2 in N2 was bubbled through
a solution of 5 in CHCl3/CFCl3/EtOH
- 1:1:0.2 at −75 °C, the fluoro-cyclopropane derivative 9 was formed in 90% yield. In turn, this compound was also
converted to the dienone 10 in higher than 95% yield
with a typical UV absorption of 290 nm (see Figure ).
Figure 9
Cyclopropanation reaction course of 4 and 5 with fluorine and the consecutive dehydrofluorination.
Cyclopropanation reaction course of 4 and 5 with fluorine and the consecutive dehydrofluorination.
Conclusions
Our findings demonstrate
that the α-fluorocarbocation resulting
from the addition of F–X (X = F, OAc, OTFA, and the like) to
double bonds is a unique moiety, quite distinct from common carbocations.
Its short life span is responsible for some unexpected reactions,
such as the syn-addition across double bonds. When,
however, the reaction’s transition state does not favor a parallel
approach to the double bond as in the cases described herein, the
very short living α-fluorocarbocation intermediate may be responsible
for unconventional results such as a nucleophilic attack on it by
a methyl group promoting unprecedented cyclopropanation. In addition,
the decomposition of the strained cyclopropane expands Bredt’s
rule by forming an 11-membered bicyclic ring that includes two bridgehead
double bonds within a triterpene skeleton. These important findings
may therefore shed light on new processes involving short-lived carbocations
within the realm of fluorine chemistry and beyond.
Experimental Section
IR spectra were recorded with
an FTIR ATR spectrometer (TENSOR
27 by Bruker), and MS were measured under ESI and APPI conditions. 1H NMR spectra were recorded using a 400.2 MHz spectrometer
with CDCl3 as a solvent and Me4Si as an internal
standard. The 19F NMR spectra were measured at 376.5 MHz
with CFCl3, serving as an internal standard. The proton
broadband decoupled 13C{1H} NMR spectra were
recorded at 100.6 MHz. NMR spectra of the various compounds studied
herein are provided in SI Section 1.
Fluorination
Fluorine is a strong oxidant and corrosive
material. In organic chemistry, it is used after dilution with nitrogen
or helium (generally from 1% to 20% depending on the reaction type).
Such dilution can be achieved by using either an appropriate copper
or Monel vacuum line constructed in a well-ventilated area or by purchasing
prediluted fluorine. A detailed description of a simple setup for
fluorine dilution was previously presented.[19] The reactions themselves are carried out in standard glassware.
If elementary precautions are taken, work with F2 (which
is less toxic and less dangerous than chlorine or bromine (!)[20]) proceeds smoothly, and we have had no bad experience
working with it. The reactions were usually carried out on scales
of 1–5 mmol of the α,β-unsaturated carbonyl compounds,
monitored by TLC or NMR. Fluorine, at concentrations of 7–10%
in N2, was slowly passed through a cold (−78 °C)
and vigorously stirred solution of the triterpene dissolved in 100
mL of CFCl3, 125 mL CHCl3, and 25 mL of EtOH.
An efficient mixing is achieved by using a vibromixer, which also
ensures a fine dispersion of the gas bubbles. The reactions were completed
within 3–4 h. They were terminated by pouring them into 200
mL of water, washing the organic layer with NaHCO3 solution
followed by water until neutral, drying the organic layer over MgSO4, and finally evaporating the solvent. The crude product was
usually purified by recrystallization from EtOAc:petroleum ether.
Dehydrofluorination (HF elimination) was achieved simply by stirring
the fluorinated product overnight in chloroform at room temperature.
Authors: S Shibata; K Takahashi; S Yano; M Harada; H Saito; Y Tamura; A Kumagai; K Hirabayashi; M Yamamoto; N Nagata Journal: Chem Pharm Bull (Tokyo) Date: 1987-05 Impact factor: 1.645
Authors: Eric P Gillis; Kyle J Eastman; Matthew D Hill; David J Donnelly; Nicholas A Meanwell Journal: J Med Chem Date: 2015-07-22 Impact factor: 7.446
Authors: Jiang Wang; María Sánchez-Roselló; José Luis Aceña; Carlos del Pozo; Alexander E Sorochinsky; Santos Fustero; Vadim A Soloshonok; Hong Liu Journal: Chem Rev Date: 2013-12-03 Impact factor: 60.622