Gradual decay and sudden death of short-term memory for pitch.

The ability to discriminate frequency differences between pure tones declines as the duration of the interstimulus interval (ISI) increases. The conventional explanation for this finding is that pitch representations gradually decay from auditory short-term memory. Gradual decay means that internal noise increases with increasing ISI duration. Another possibility is that pitch representations experience "sudden death," disappearing without a trace from memory. Sudden death means that listeners guess (respond at random) more often when the ISIs are longer. Since internal noise and guessing probabilities influence the shape of psychometric functions in different ways, they can be estimated simultaneously. Eleven amateur musicians performed a two-interval, two-alternative forced-choice frequency-discrimination task. The frequencies of the first tones were roved, and frequency differences and ISI durations were manipulated across trials. Data were analyzed using Bayesian models that simultaneously estimated internal noise and guessing probabilities. On average across listeners, internal noise increased monotonically as a function of increasing ISI duration, suggesting that gradual decay occurred. The guessing rate decreased with an increasing ISI duration between 0.5 and 2 s but then increased with further increases in ISI duration, suggesting that sudden death occurred but perhaps only at longer ISIs. Results are problematic for decay-only models of discrimination and contrast with those from a study on visual short-term memory, which found that over similar durations, visual representations experienced little gradual decay yet substantial sudden death.