Qingye Meng1, Ying Sun1, Hailin Cong1, Hao Hu2, Fu-Jian Xu3. 1. Institute of Biomedical Materials and Engineering, College of Materials Science and Engineering, Qingdao University, Qingdao, 266071, China. 2. Institute of Biomedical Materials and Engineering, College of Materials Science and Engineering, Qingdao University, Qingdao, 266071, China. huhao@qdu.edu.cn. 3. Key Lab of Biomedical Materials of Natural Macromolecules, Ministry of Education, Beijing Laboratory of Biomedical Materials, Beijing University of Chemical Technology, 100029, Beijing, China. xufj@mail.buct.edu.cn.
Abstract
Infectious diseases, such as the coronavirus disease-19, SARS virus, Ebola virus, and AIDS, threaten the health of human beings globally. New viruses, drug-resistant bacteria, and fungi continue to challenge the human efficacious drug bank. Researchers have developed a variety of new antiviral and antibacterial drugs in response to the infectious disease crisis. Meanwhile, the development of functional materials has also improved therapeutic outcomes. As a natural material, chitosan possesses good biocompatibility, bioactivity, and biosafety. It has been proven that the cooperation between chitosan and traditional medicine greatly improves the ability of anti-infection. This review summarized the application and design considerations of chitosan-composed systems for the treatment of infectious diseases, looking forward to providing the idea of infectious disease therapy.
Infectious diseases, such as the coronavirus disease-19, SARS virus, Ebola virus, and AIDS, threaten the health of human beings globally. New viruses, drug-resistant bacteria, and fungi continue to challenge the human efficacious drug bank. Researchers have developed a variety of new antiviral and antibacterial drugs in response to the infectious disease crisis. Meanwhile, the development of functional materials has also improved therapeutic outcomes. As a natural material, chitosan possesses good biocompatibility, bioactivity, and biosafety. It has been proven that the cooperation between chitosan and traditional medicine greatly improves the ability of anti-infection. This review summarized the application and design considerations of chitosan-composed systems for the treatment of infectious diseases, looking forward to providing the idea of infectious disease therapy.
Infectious diseases are currently one of the main causes of humandeath. The prevention and treatment of these diseases have been received great attention. There was a period in history when the incidence and mortality of infectious diseases have been declining, which can be attributed to the development of penicillin [1]. However, the pace of drug development has fallen behind the microbial mutations rates, especially the emergence of super bacteria and new viruses [2]. The emergence of coronavirus disease-19 (COVID-19) has brought a huge health crisis to all countries in the world. Seven coronaviruses infect humans currently, which including acute respiratory syndromecoronavirus (SARS-CoV) in 2002, Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) in 2012, and the COVID-19 or named SARS-CoV-2 last year [3, 4]. The development of new drugs and vaccines cannot be delayed [5]. Meanwhile, effective treatment strategies are constantly being tried in the clinic. In recent years, the dynamics of infectious diseases and the emergence of drug-resistant bacteria and viruses have also made the biomedical field pay more attention to new drug delivery platforms.Most infectious diseases are caused by bacteria, fungi, parasite, and viruses [6]. The current therapy methods for infectious diseases include vaccine injection and drug treatment for the infected site, which ultimate goal is to eliminate pathogens. Most vaccines are injected parenterally to stimulate the immune system to produce antibodies in the serum, but cannot produce mucosal antibody responses [7]. In recent years, needle-free administration via oral, nasal, pulmonary, and dermal routes has become an alternative to parenteral administration [8]. Some drug delivery systems based on micro- or nano-particles have been developed for targeted delivery of vaccines to generate effective adaptive immunity. Because of the high specific surface area of nanoparticles, drug molecules can obtain ideal drug loading efficiency in particles [9]. Vectors with low cost, good biocompatibility, and low side effects have attracted the interest of researchers.Chitosan is a natural and biocompatible polysaccharide, mainly derived from the exoskeleton of crustaceans. Due to the presence of quaternary ammonium salt groups, chitosan exhibits positive charges in physiological environments. [10]. A large number of active functional groups on the molecular chain make chitosan easy to be structurally and chemically modified to produce immune stimulation [11], the promotion of wound healing [12], and antibacterial and antifungal properties [13]. The versatility and adaptability of chitosan provide a unique opportunity for the development of new antibacterial therapies and prevention of infectious diseases. Chitosan-composed systems utilize the characteristics of chitosan to achieve great therapeutic effects. For example, the adhesiveness of chitosan can be used for noninvasive mucosal vaccine vectors [14]. When chitosan combined with other wound dressings such as hydrogels, it has certain antibacterial properties while promoting wound healing [15]. Chitosan-modified vectors exhibit good biocompatibility in vivo. Therefore, chitosan-composed systems have great potential in the therapy of infectious diseases.This review summarized the application of chitosan in the treatment of infectious diseases. By analyzing its design considerations and application, new ideas for the therapy of infectious diseases are expected to be proposed.
The application of chitosan in the infectious diseases therapy
The antibacterial action mechanism of chitosan is to bind to the negatively charged bacterial cell wall, which leads to a change in the permeability of the cell envelope and then attaches to the DNA to inhibit its replication [16]. The physical and biological properties of chitosan depend on the degree of deacetylation and molecular weight [17]. The number and distribution of acetyl groups in chitosan affect its biodegradability and cytotoxicity, and the degree of deacetylation of chitosan directly affects the efficiency of antigen delivery and the activity of chitosan as an adjuvant [18, 19]. The amine and hydroxyl functional groups present in chitosan can be chemically modified to introduce other groups, such as hydroxyalkyl [20, 21], carboxyalkyl [22], succinyl [23], thiol [24, 25], and sulfate [26], to prepare various chitosan derivatives. The adhesion and permeability enhancement of chitosan derivatives depend on the degree of substitution or quaternization of chitosan.The construction of chitosan-composed nanoscale vectors can take advantage of the size to achieve great therapeutic effects. There are various kinds of delivery systems, not limited to nanocarriers, and corresponding requirements for delivery systems are also varied. For instance, nanoparticles as drug delivery systems need to responsive release characteristics and require good biocompatibility; meanwhile, wound dressings emphasize the mechanical properties of the material to achieve sustained drug release. Hydrogels need to have good biocompatibility and the promotion of wound healing ability. Hydrogels loaded with therapeutic drugs have been proven to promote wound repair or enhance antibacterial and anti-infective properties. Therefore, in response to different infectious diseases, the treatment strategies tend to be diversified.
Chitosan-composed nanoparticles
Chitosan and its derivatives have antibacterial effects on Gram-negative bacteria and Gram-positive bacteria [27]. The effectiveness of the antibacterial agent on bacteria can be improved by being loaded into the chitosan-composed nanoparticles [28]. Chitosan can also work in collaboration with other nanoparticles. Nanoparticles have a high specific surface area. The high surface area leads to a higher charge density, thereby increasing the interaction with microbial elements [13]. For instance, chitosan films were incorporated onto gold nanoparticles to achieve improved antibacterial effects [29] (Fig. 1). The intrinsic effects of chitosan-composed nanoparticles on microorganisms have been enhanced on the nanoscale, while the adverse effects have hardly increased [30-32]. Chitosan-composed nanoparticles showed obvious antibacterial effects on E. coli and several Staphylococcus [13]. These chitosan-composed nanoparticles are superior to pure chitosanpolymers and doxycycline in inhibiting the growth of these species. Friedman et al. studied the antibacterial and immunological properties of chitosan-sodium alginate nanoparticles, which showed effective inhibition of the growth of P. acnes [33]. Studies have shown that chitosan nanoparticles, especially those formed with low molecular chitosan, can inhibit the formation of Streptococcus mutans biofilm in vitro [34]. Chitosan-composed nanoparticles can be uniformly dispersed throughout the sample and cause significant cell membrane damage [31]. Similarly, the anti-fungal mechanism of chitosan-composed nanoparticles is also through the close interaction of chitosan and fungal cell membranes, which caused fungal cell membrane rupture [35]. But it should be noted that A. niger is resistant to chitosan nanoparticles [36]. The cell wall of A. niger contains 10% chitin, which is related to its resistance to chitosan. Therefore, chitosan-composed nanoparticles need specific choices in antifungal aspects to achieve the ideal therapeutic effect.
Schematic diagram of self-aggregation formed by the PLA-g-CS copolymer in aqueous medium [39]
Schematic diagram of self-aggregation formed by the PLA-g-CScopolymer in aqueous medium [39]
Chitosan-based vaccine vectors
For the prevention and treatment of infectious diseases, drug treatment often brings some undesirable side effects and increases the drug resistance of bacteria and viruses. Vaccination is one of the effective treatment methods for the prevention and treatment of infectious diseases. By activating the immune system, the recurrence of infectious diseases can be effectively prevented [44]. The mucosal surface (nose, respiratory tract, oropharynx, gastrointestinal tract, and genitourinary system) is the most common entry route for pathogens (viruses and bacteria) [45]. Mucosal immunity not only provides humoral and cellular immune protection in the mucosal area but also provides systemic immunity [46]. Polymer-based vectors have flourished in mucosal vaccine delivery because they provide the advantage of delivering antigens to specific targets [47]. Moreover, the polymer-based vector can protect the antigen from harsh environments such as pH, bile, and gastrointestinal tract digestive enzymes, as well as can control or slow the release of the antigen. It has been reported that polymer-based particles can enhance the immune response to mucosal delivery of antigens [48] (Fig. 3). After encountering with an antigen, B cells convert themselves to antibody secreting plasma cells that produce antibodies for excreting the pathogens to mucosal surfaces (mucosal response), whereas dendritic cells (DCs) present the antigen via major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I and class II molecules to CD8+ and CD4+ T cells. The activation pathway of CD8+ T cells and CD4+ Th1 cells produces cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) and activated macrophages that kill intracellular pathogens or infected cells (cellular response), while the activation pathway of CD4+ Th2 cells produces activated B lymphocytes that secrete antibodies for neutralization of extracellular pathogens (humoral response).
Local infections are widespread in wounds, burns, diseases, surgical wounds, and all other tissues involved in surgery. A local infection may lead to prolonged wound healing, wound dehiscence, abscess formation, and sepsis, and in severe cases, it can also lead to life-threatening complications [55]. Therefore, the development of new biological materials that can prevent infection has become an urgent and important goal. Due to antibacterial properties, chitosan has inherent advantages as wound dressings. In the environment of multivalent electronegative molecules or anions, chitosan can form ion network through coordination and secondary interactions, which form gel network easily [56]. In recent years, materials with three-dimensional network composition have received more and more research as a new type of vector platform, such as three-dimensional scaffolds, drug banks, bandages, and wound dressings [57-59]. It is worth noting that biomedical hydrogels based on natural polymers, especially chitosan, have received special attention due to their good biocompatibility and biomimetic properties [60]. Chitosan-based gels can encapsulate biologically active molecules in the network through physical interaction or chemical coupling. For example, a hydrogel composed of carboxymethyl chitosan (CMC)/oxidized dextran was developed for loading anti-infective drugs (ceftriaxone sodium) [61]. The prepared hydrogel has been proven to have good biocompatibility and exhibit good anti-infective effects in vivo (subcutaneous infection model and cecal ligation and perforation model). Hu et al. used CMC, alginate (ALG), and calcium chloride to prepare a series of double-crosslinked amorphous hydrogels (CMC-ALG) through electrostatic interaction and divalent chelation, which loaded epidermal growth factor (EGF) (Fig. 5) [62]. The double cross-linked amorphous hydrogel promotes wound healing while being antibacterial.
Design considerations for chitosan-based drug delivery systems
Chitosan component can improve the biocompatibility, biosafety, and stability of drug delivery systems via chemical modification or physical mixing. According to different treatment strategies, the expected performance of the vector is diverse. For example, drug vectors need controlled release function, mucosal vaccine carriers need adhesive properties, and wound dressings require certain physical properties.
Adhesion
In mucosal vaccine carriers, chitosan has been used to increase the adhesive ability of vaccine carriers to achieve long-term retention on the mucosa [49]. In the antibacterial therapy of dental diseases, insufficient absorption and penetration of biofilms by traditional antibacterial agents are two major considerations for the use of these therapies [66]. Biofilms are complex bacterial communities that are highly resistant to antibiotics and human defense systems [67]. Researchers have done plenty of work on the anti-biofilm/antibacterial potential of metals and metal oxide nanoparticles, such as titanium oxide, copper, silver, gold, zinc, and silicon [68]. However, the side effects of metal nanoparticles limited their clinical applications. Therefore, natural biopolymers with adhesive properties can be used as potential antibacterial and anti-inflammatory nano-drug delivery systems [69, 70]. Chitosan has adhesive properties and is used to treat periodontitis. A faster healing rate of alveolar bone and periodontal epithelium in mice with periodontitis was observed [71]. The vector system can be attached to the tooth surface, tongue surface, and buccal cavity mucosa. As the environment of the oral cavity changes, the antibacterial agent can be released in response, so the antibacterial agent can penetrate the bacterial biofilm that caused the dental infection to achieve a therapeutic effect.
The balance between efficiency and toxicity
Polysaccharides have received extensive attention in the field of pharmacy due to their high-efficiency therapeutic applications in drug storage and reducing toxicity [72]. Almeida et al. prepared chitosan-based amphiphilic micelles for hydrophobic drug delivery [73]. This delivery strategy has demonstrated that chitosan micelles can stabilize the loaded drug, protect up to 75% of the drug from hydrolysis and retain its activity. The antibiotic polymyxin B (PMB) is considered to be an effective weapon against gram-negative “super bacteria” [74]. However, the severe nephrotoxicity and neurotoxicity of PMB limits its application [75, 76]. There have been many methods to reduce the toxicity of polymyxin by shielding the cationic part or reducing the number of cationic residues by negatively charged derivatives. For example, PMB prodrugs prepared from cationic amino acids modified by methanesulfonic acid and PEG [77, 78]. Although PMB prodrugs can significantly reduce its toxicity, it inevitably reduces its antibacterial properties. Some traditional drug delivery nano-platforms such as liposomes [79], silica nanoparticles [80], and polymer particles [81, 82] can improve the safety of PMB. However, due to the restriction of entering the bacterial membrane, the bactericidal activity of these nanocarriers is reduced. Chai et al. developed a pH-sensitive multi-ion nanocomplexes to deliver PMB for the treatment of acute lung infections, which showed fewer adverse reactions without affecting the inherent antibacterial effect (Fig. 7) [83]. This multi-ionic nanocomplexes are mixture of PMB and 2,3-dimethylmaleic anhydride (DA) grafted chitoligosaccharide. As a derivative of chitosan, chitoligosaccharide can be excreted or biodegraded in the body. By electrostatically complexing with negatively charged DA, the positive charge density of PMB was reduced, which leads to the decline of the toxicity. This delivery system showed the same antibacterial properties as free PMB in vivo, but significantly reduced the nephrotoxicity and neurotoxicity caused by PMB. Moreover, this method of electrostatically combining antibiotics and biocompatible materials can be extended to other antibiotics as a general strategy to reduce the side effects of highly toxic antibiotics.
Chitosan have great potential in combination therapy. Whether through chemical modification or physical mixing, the biocompatibility, biosafety, and stability of the drug delivery system could be improved. In some cases, the combination of chitosan and other therapeutic drugs can produce synergistic therapeutic effects.Chitosan is an attractive preparation widely used as a pharmaceutical excipient. El-Sharif et al. explored the antibacterial activity of the chitosan-EDTA combination against gram-negative bacteria, gram-positive bacteria, and Candida albicans [84]. This research showed that the use of chitosan as an enhancing agent with antibacterial and antifungal properties in combination with EDTA in pharmaceutical preparations. Camacho-Alonso et al. explored the antibacterial effect of chitosan accompanied by photodynamic therapy (PDT) on Enterococcus faecalis and evaluated the enhancement effect of chitosan on the photosensitizer methylene blue in the root canals of extracted humanteeth infected in vitro [85].Some matrixes can be chemically or physically modified by chitosan, which achieve good biocompatibility and antibacterial properties. The permanent presence of metal vascular stents in the blood vessel wall can cause foreign body reactions and thrombosis [86]. Researchers have developed bioabsorbable vascular stents (BVS) to overcome the above-mentioned limitations of metal stents. BVS can be absorbed over time without any permanent prosthetic constraints in the blood vessel [87]. Poly(L-lacticacid) (PLLA) is currently the most commonly used BVS polymer [88]. But compared with permanent metal stents, BVS made of PLLA faces a higher incidence of early thrombosis [89]. To solve this problem, chitosan is used to form heparin-like polysaccharide multilayer film with sulfated yam polysaccharide (SCYP) to assemble and modify the surface of PLLA membrane layer by layer [90]. The multilayer modified PLLA prepared by this strategy is non-cytotoxic, has good antibacterial activity against E. coli and S. aureus, and has drug loading/sustained release behavior. This strategy has potential applications in biomedical materials that contact blood. The combination of chitosan and antibacterial drugs provides an idea for constructing versatile treatment systems. These therapy strategies were summarized in Table 1, which not limited to the treatment of infectious diseases, which had a certain inspiration for the treatment of other diseases.
Table 1
Summary of chitosan-based vectors in drug delivery
Vector type
Application
Design considerations
Ref
Nanoparticles
Antibacterial
Antibacterial
[33]
Nanoparticles
Anti-fungal
Anti-fungal mechanism
[35]
Nanoparticles
Drug delivery
Continuous administration
[38]
Nanoparticles
Ocular administration
Corneal penetration
[39]
Nanoparticles
Vaccine vectors
Stability and adhesion
[50]
Hydrogel
Wound dressings
biocompatibility
[62]
Hydrogel
Wound dressings
Mechanical property
[63]
Hydrogel
Wound dressings
Biodegradable and mechanical properties
[64]
Hydrogel
Periodontitis
Adhesive property
[71]
Micelles
Drug delivery
Stability
[73]
Nanocomplexes
Drug delivery
Biocompatibility
[83]
Complexes
Antibacterial
Combination therapy
[84]
Complexes
Antibacterial
Combination therapy
[85]
Multilayer film
Antibacterial and Drug delivery
Combination therapy
[90]
Summary of chitosan-based vectors in drug delivery
Conclusion
Infectious diseases have always been one of the threats to human health. The effectiveness of traditional therapeutic agent and therapy strategies has been challenged. Chitosan and chitosan-composed systems show great potential in anti-infection field. Compared with the cumbersome and costly artificial polymers, low cost, wide sources, and good biocompatibility are the characteristics of the chitosan. However, chitosan is not a panacea for bacteria, fungi, and viruses that cause infectious diseases. But the biocompatibility of chitosan can be applied to the human body. Due to the low-cost and highly biocompatible, chitosan-based vectors have great potential in the future.As summarized in Fig. 8, in terms of infectious diseases, chitosan-composed systems in different forms or with diverse properties have been proposed. Chitosan-composed vectors have great application potential in vaccine vectors and drug vectors. These kinds of vectors can efficiently load therapeutic drugs, reduce the toxic and side effects of the drugs, and enhance the treatment efficacy. These concepts have certain potential in the development of clinical applications. In addition, due to its good antibacterial ability and biocompatibility, chitosan-based wound dressings have good prospects in clinical applications. As the wound dressing, it is not only required to promote wound healing, but also should be dedicated to rapid analgesia, anti-itching, and alleviating the discomfort of patients during the healing process. Moreover, simplifying the preparation steps of chitosan-based dressings can also promote its development in clinical applications. For the current epidemic of COVID-19 and possible viruses in the future, chitosan as a vaccine vector has high application value in terms of non-invasive vector. The chitosan-based vector can deliver antibodies to the nasal mucosa, and can load gene drugs that interfere with or disrupt viral DNA/RNA replication and deliver them to infected cells. These provide some inspiration for the fight against COVID-19 in the future.
Fig. 8
Applications and performances of chitosan-composed systems in infectious disease
Applications and performances of chitosan-composed systems in infectious diseaseThe development of new vectors increases the diversity of combination with chitosan-composed systems. It is believed that in the near future, more chitosan-composed systems would be developed in the treatment of infectious diseases and be widely used in clinical practice.
Authors: Ali M Zaki; Sander van Boheemen; Theo M Bestebroer; Albert D M E Osterhaus; Ron A M Fouchier Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2012-10-17 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: V I Gorbach; I N Krasikova; P A Luk'yanov; Y N Loenko; T F Solov'eva; Y S Ovodov; V V Deev; A A Pimenov Journal: Carbohydr Res Date: 1994-07-04 Impact factor: 2.104