Andrew Bosworth1,2,3, Natasha Y Rickett3,4, Xiaofeng Dong4, Lisa F P Ng3,4,5, Isabel García-Dorival4, David A Matthews6, Tom Fletcher3,7, Michael Jacobs8, Emma C Thomson9, Miles W Carroll10,11,12, Julian A Hiscox13,14,15. 1. Public Health England, Manor Farm Road, Porton Down, Salisbury, UK. 2. Clinical Virology, University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust, Birmingham, UK. 3. Health Protection Research Unit in Emerging and Zoonotic Infections, National Institute for Health Research, Liverpool, UK. 4. Institute of Infection, Veterinary and Ecological Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK. 5. Infectious Disease Horizontal Technology Centre (ID HTC), A*STAR, Singapore, Singapore. 6. School of Cellular and Molecular Medicine, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK. 7. Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine, Liverpool, UK. 8. Department of Infection, Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK. 9. MRC-University of Glasgow Centre for Virus Research, Glasgow, UK. emma.thomson@glasgow.ac.uk. 10. Public Health England, Manor Farm Road, Porton Down, Salisbury, UK. miles.carroll@phe.gov.uk. 11. Health Protection Research Unit in Emerging and Zoonotic Infections, National Institute for Health Research, Liverpool, UK. miles.carroll@phe.gov.uk. 12. Nufield Department of Medicine, Wellcome Trust Centre for Human Genetics, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. miles.carroll@phe.gov.uk. 13. Health Protection Research Unit in Emerging and Zoonotic Infections, National Institute for Health Research, Liverpool, UK. julian.hiscox@liverpool.ac.uk. 14. Institute of Infection, Veterinary and Ecological Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK. julian.hiscox@liverpool.ac.uk. 15. Infectious Disease Horizontal Technology Centre (ID HTC), A*STAR, Singapore, Singapore. julian.hiscox@liverpool.ac.uk.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Ebola virus disease (EVD) is an often-fatal infection where the effectiveness of medical countermeasures is uncertain. During the West African outbreak (2013-2016), several patients were treated with different types of anti-viral therapies including monoclonal antibody-based cocktails that had the potential to neutralise Ebola virus (EBOV). However, at the time, the efficacy of these therapies was uncertain. Given the scale of the outbreak, several clinical phenotypes came to the forefront including the ability of the same virus to cause recrudescence in the same patient-perhaps through persisting in immune privileged sites. Several key questions remained including establishing if monoclonal antibody therapy was effective in humans with severe EVD, whether virus escape mutants were selected during treatment, and what is the potential mechanism(s) of persistence. This was made possible through longitudinal samples taken from a UK patient with EVD. METHODS: Several different sample types, plasma and cerebrospinal fluid, were collected and sequenced using Illumina-based RNAseq. Sequence reads were mapped both to EBOV and the human genome and differential gene expression analysis used to identify changes in the abundance of gene transcripts as infection progressed. Digital Cell Quantitation analysis was used to predict the immune phenotype in samples derived from blood. RESULTS: The findings were compared to equivalent data from West African patients. The study found that both virus and host markers were predictive of a fatal outcome. This suggested that the extensive supportive care, and most likely the application of the medical countermeasure ZMab (a monoclonal antibody cocktail), contributed to survival of the UK patient. The switch from progression to a 'fatal' outcome to a 'survival' outcome could be seen in both the viral and host markers. The UK patient also suffered a recrudescence infection 10 months after the initial infection. Analysis of the sequencing data indicated that the virus entered a period of reduced or minimal replication, rather than other potential mechanisms of persistence-such as defective interfering genomes. CONCLUSIONS: The data showed that comprehensive supportive care and the application of medical countermeasures are worth pursuing despite an initial unfavourable prognosis.
BACKGROUND: Ebola virus disease (EVD) is an often-fatal infection where the effectiveness of medical countermeasures is uncertain. During the West African outbreak (2013-2016), several patients were treated with different types of anti-viral therapies including monoclonal antibody-based cocktails that had the potential to neutralise Ebola virus (EBOV). However, at the time, the efficacy of these therapies was uncertain. Given the scale of the outbreak, several clinical phenotypes came to the forefront including the ability of the same virus to cause recrudescence in the same patient-perhaps through persisting in immune privileged sites. Several key questions remained including establishing if monoclonal antibody therapy was effective in humans with severe EVD, whether virus escape mutants were selected during treatment, and what is the potential mechanism(s) of persistence. This was made possible through longitudinal samples taken from a UK patient with EVD. METHODS: Several different sample types, plasma and cerebrospinal fluid, were collected and sequenced using Illumina-based RNAseq. Sequence reads were mapped both to EBOV and the human genome and differential gene expression analysis used to identify changes in the abundance of gene transcripts as infection progressed. Digital Cell Quantitation analysis was used to predict the immune phenotype in samples derived from blood. RESULTS: The findings were compared to equivalent data from West African patients. The study found that both virus and host markers were predictive of a fatal outcome. This suggested that the extensive supportive care, and most likely the application of the medical countermeasure ZMab (a monoclonal antibody cocktail), contributed to survival of the UK patient. The switch from progression to a 'fatal' outcome to a 'survival' outcome could be seen in both the viral and host markers. The UK patient also suffered a recrudescence infection 10 months after the initial infection. Analysis of the sequencing data indicated that the virus entered a period of reduced or minimal replication, rather than other potential mechanisms of persistence-such as defective interfering genomes. CONCLUSIONS: The data showed that comprehensive supportive care and the application of medical countermeasures are worth pursuing despite an initial unfavourable prognosis.
Authors: Xiankun Zeng; Candace D Blancett; Keith A Koistinen; Christopher W Schellhase; Jeremy J Bearss; Sheli R Radoshitzky; Shelley P Honnold; Taylor B Chance; Travis K Warren; Jeffrey W Froude; Kathleen A Cashman; John M Dye; Sina Bavari; Gustavo Palacios; Jens H Kuhn; Mei G Sun Journal: Nat Microbiol Date: 2017-07-17 Impact factor: 17.745
Authors: Adrienne R Trombley; Leslie Wachter; Jeffrey Garrison; Valerie A Buckley-Beason; Jordan Jahrling; Lisa E Hensley; Randal J Schoepp; David A Norwood; Augustine Goba; Joseph N Fair; David A Kulesh Journal: Am J Trop Med Hyg Date: 2010-05 Impact factor: 2.345
Authors: Emily Speranza; Paula Ruibal; Julia R Port; Feng Feng; Lia Burkhardt; Adam Grundhoff; Stephan Günther; Lisa Oestereich; Julian A Hiscox; John H Connor; César Muñoz-Fontela Journal: J Infect Dis Date: 2018-11-22 Impact factor: 5.226
Authors: Gytis Dudas; Luiz Max Carvalho; Trevor Bedford; Andrew J Tatem; Guy Baele; Nuno R Faria; Daniel J Park; Jason T Ladner; Armando Arias; Danny Asogun; Filip Bielejec; Sarah L Caddy; Matthew Cotten; Jonathan D'Ambrozio; Simon Dellicour; Antonino Di Caro; Joseph W Diclaro; Sophie Duraffour; Michael J Elmore; Lawrence S Fakoli; Ousmane Faye; Merle L Gilbert; Sahr M Gevao; Stephen Gire; Adrianne Gladden-Young; Andreas Gnirke; Augustine Goba; Donald S Grant; Bart L Haagmans; Julian A Hiscox; Umaru Jah; Jeffrey R Kugelman; Di Liu; Jia Lu; Christine M Malboeuf; Suzanne Mate; David A Matthews; Christian B Matranga; Luke W Meredith; James Qu; Joshua Quick; Suzan D Pas; My V T Phan; Georgios Pollakis; Chantal B Reusken; Mariano Sanchez-Lockhart; Stephen F Schaffner; John S Schieffelin; Rachel S Sealfon; Etienne Simon-Loriere; Saskia L Smits; Kilian Stoecker; Lucy Thorne; Ekaete Alice Tobin; Mohamed A Vandi; Simon J Watson; Kendra West; Shannon Whitmer; Michael R Wiley; Sarah M Winnicki; Shirlee Wohl; Roman Wölfel; Nathan L Yozwiak; Kristian G Andersen; Sylvia O Blyden; Fatorma Bolay; Miles W Carroll; Bernice Dahn; Boubacar Diallo; Pierre Formenty; Christophe Fraser; George F Gao; Robert F Garry; Ian Goodfellow; Stephan Günther; Christian T Happi; Edward C Holmes; Brima Kargbo; Sakoba Keïta; Paul Kellam; Marion P G Koopmans; Jens H Kuhn; Nicholas J Loman; N'Faly Magassouba; Dhamari Naidoo; Stuart T Nichol; Tolbert Nyenswah; Gustavo Palacios; Oliver G Pybus; Pardis C Sabeti; Amadou Sall; Ute Ströher; Isatta Wurie; Marc A Suchard; Philippe Lemey; Andrew Rambaut Journal: Nature Date: 2017-04-12 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Cole Trapnell; Brian A Williams; Geo Pertea; Ali Mortazavi; Gordon Kwan; Marijke J van Baren; Steven L Salzberg; Barbara J Wold; Lior Pachter Journal: Nat Biotechnol Date: 2010-05-02 Impact factor: 54.908
Authors: Eleonora Cimini; Domenico Viola; Mar Cabeza-Cabrerizo; Antonella Romanelli; Nicola Tumino; Alessandra Sacchi; Veronica Bordoni; Rita Casetti; Federica Turchi; Federico Martini; Joseph A Bore; Fara Raymond Koundouno; Sophie Duraffour; Janine Michel; Tobias Holm; Elsa Gayle Zekeng; Lauren Cowley; Isabel Garcia Dorival; Juliane Doerrbecker; Nicole Hetzelt; Jonathan H J Baum; Jasmine Portmann; Roman Wölfel; Martin Gabriel; Osvaldo Miranda; Graciliano Díaz; José E Díaz; Yoel A Fleites; Carlos A Piñeiro; Carlos M Castro; Lamine Koivogui; N'Faly Magassouba; Boubacar Diallo; Paula Ruibal; Lisa Oestereich; David M Wozniak; Anja Lüdtke; Beate Becker-Ziaja; Maria R Capobianchi; Giuseppe Ippolito; Miles W Carroll; Stephan Günther; Antonino Di Caro; César Muñoz-Fontela; Chiara Agrati Journal: PLoS Negl Trop Dis Date: 2017-05-30
Authors: Maria J Olmo-Uceda; Juan C Muñoz-Sánchez; Wilberth Lasso-Giraldo; Vicente Arnau; Wladimiro Díaz-Villanueva; Santiago F Elena Journal: Viruses Date: 2022-05-23 Impact factor: 5.818
Authors: Dawn L Weir; Si'Ana A Coggins; Bang K Vu; Jessica Coertse; Lianying Yan; Ina L Smith; Eric D Laing; Wanda Markotter; Christopher C Broder; Brian C Schaefer Journal: Viruses Date: 2021-03-01 Impact factor: 5.048
Authors: Robert J Watson; Julia Tree; Susan A Fotheringham; Yper Hall; Xiaofeng Dong; Kimberley Steeds; Jade Gouriet; Francisco J Salguero; Christopher Burton; James Pitman; Linda Easterbrook; Kevin S Richards; Jane Burton; Kevin Bewley; Christine Bruce; Julian A Hiscox; Miles W Carroll; Simon G P Funnell Journal: J Virol Date: 2021-09-29 Impact factor: 5.103