| Literature DB >> 33427378 |
Amy K LeBlanc1, Matthew Atherton2, R Timothy Bentley3,4, C Elizabeth Boudreau5, Jenna H Burton6, Kaitlin M Curran7, Steven Dow6, Michelle A Giuffrida8, Heidi B Kellihan9, Nicola J Mason10,11,12, Michelle Oblak13, Laura E Selmic14, Kimberly A Selting15, Ameet Singh13, Sonja Tjostheim9, David M Vail9, Kristen M Weishaar6, Erika P Berger16, John H Rossmeisl17, Christina Mazcko1.
Abstract
The updated VCOG-CTCAE v2 guidelines contain several important updates and additions since the last update (v1.1) was released in 2011 and published within Veterinary and Comparative Oncology in 2016. As the Veterinary Cooperative Oncology Group (VCOG) is no longer an active entity, the original authors and contributors to the VCOG-CTCAE v1.0 and v1.1 were consulted for input, and additional co-authors sought for expansion and refinement of the adverse event (AE) categories. VCOG-CTCAE v2 includes expanded neurology, cardiac and immunologic AE sections, and the addition of procedural-specific AEs. It is our intent that, through inclusion of additional authors from ACVIM subspecialties and the American College of Veterinary Surgery, that we can more comprehensively capture AEs that are observed during clinical studies conducted across a variety of disease states, clinical scenarios, and body systems. It is also our intent that these updated veterinary CTCAE guidelines will offer improved application and ease of use within veterinary practice in general, as well as within clinical trials that assess new therapeutic strategies for animals with a variety of diseases. Throughout the revision process, we strived to ensure the grading structure for each AE category was reflective of the decision-making process applied to determination of dose-limiting events. As phase I trial decisions are based on these criteria and ultimately determine the maximally tolerated dose, there is impact on standard dosing recommendations for any new drug registration or application. This document should be updated regularly to reflect ongoing application to clinical studies carried out in veterinary patients.Entities:
Keywords: adverse events; clinical trials; comparative oncology; investigational therapy; small animal
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 33427378 PMCID: PMC8248125 DOI: 10.1111/vco.12677
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Vet Comp Oncol ISSN: 1476-5810 Impact factor: 2.613
| Grade 1 | Mild; asymptomatic or mild symptoms; clinical signs or diagnostic observations only; intervention not indicated. |
| Grade 2 | Moderate; outpatient or non‐invasive intervention indicated; moderate limitation of Activities of Daily Living (ADL). |
| Grade 3 | Severe or medically significant but not immediately life threatening; hospitalization or prolongation of hospitalization indicated; disabling; significantly limiting Activities of Daily Living (ADL). |
| Grade 4 | Life‐threatening consequences; urgent interventions indicated |
| Grade 5 | Death related to AE Death can be defined as either euthanasia or natural death, according to the investigators' discretion. |
| ADMINISTRATION SITE CONDITIONS | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grade | |||||
| Adverse Event | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| Infusion site extravasation/reaction | Swelling including oedema but without erythema or pain | Erythema with associated signs (eg, oedema, pain, swelling induration, phlebitis) | Ulceration or necrosis; severe tissue damage; surgical intervention indicated (such as soft tissue debridement and repair) | Life‐threatening consequences (euthanasia will be performed without intervention), primarily wound that shows no evidence of healing or improvement over 2 weeks; urgent and extreme intervention indicated (such as limb amputation) | Death |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by leakage of a pharmacologic or a biologic substance from the infusion site into the surrounding tissue. Signs include induration, erythema, swelling and marked discomfort at the infusion site. | |||||
| Other (specify, _________) | Asymptomatic or mild symptoms; clinical or diagnostic observations only; intervention not indicated |
Moderate; minimal, local or non‐invasive intervention indicated; limiting age appropriate ADL |
Severe or medically significant but not immediately life‐threatening; hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization indicated; limiting self care ADL | Life‐threatening consequences; urgent intervention indicated | Death |
| BODY CAVITY | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grade | |||||
| Adverse Event | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| Abdominal pain | Mild pain | Moderate pain; limiting ADL | Severe pain; limiting ADL | — | — |
| Definition: A sensation of marked discomfort in the abdominal region. | |||||
| Ascites | Clinical or diagnostic observations only; intervention not indicated | Symptomatic; medical intervention indicated | Severe symptoms; invasive intervention indicated |
Life‐threatening consequences; urgent operative intervention indicated | Death |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by accumulation of serous or haemorrhagic fluid in the peritoneal cavity. | |||||
| Hernia, non‐diaphragmatic | Clinical or diagnostic observation only; intervention not indicated | Reducible, non‐strangulating; elective intervention indicated | Incarcerated, symptomatic; operative intervention indicated | Life‐threatening consequences; strangulating or necrotic; urgent intervention indicated | Death |
| Definition: Organ or tissue displacement through an opening in muscle or fascia of the body wall, scrotum, or inguinal, femoral or pelvic canals | |||||
| Hernia, hiatal | Clinical or diagnostic observation only; intervention not indicated | Symptomatic; medical management indicated | Symptomatic; operative intervention indicated | Severe symptoms; urgent intervention indicated | Death |
| Definition: Displacement of abdominal contents into the thorax through the oesophageal hiatus | |||||
| Hernia, diaphragmatic | — | Clinical or diagnostic observation with minimal or absent symptoms; incidental finding without recent history of trauma; elective intervention indicated | Symptomatic; operative intervention indicated | Life‐threatening consequences; urgent operative intervention indicated | Death |
| Definition: Displacement of abdominal contents into the thorax through an abnormal opening in the diaphragm muscle, fascia, or attachments to the body wall. | |||||
| Peritonitis (septic) | — | Symptomatic; medical management indicated | Hospitalization, IV antimicrobials indicated; invasive intervention indicated (eg, tube feeding, abdominal drainage, surgery) | Life‐threatening consequences including organ system dysfunction; urgent operative intervention indicated | Death |
| Definition: Focal or generalized inflammation of the peritoneum attributed to microbial contamination. | |||||
| Peritonitis (non‐septic) | Asymptomatic diagnostic finding; intervention not indicated | Symptomatic; medical management indicated | Hospitalization, invasive intervention indicated (eg, tube feeding, abdominal drainage, surgery) | Life‐threatening consequences including organ system dysfunction; urgent intervention indicated | Death |
| Definition: Focal of generalized inflammation of the peritoneum attributed to non‐microbial (sterile) aetiologies. | |||||
| Pleural effusion (non‐malignant) | Asymptomatic | Symptomatic, intervention with diuretics or single thoracocentesis indicated | Symptomatic and supplemental oxygen, >1 thoracocenteses, continuous tube drainage or pleurodesis indicated | Life‐threatening (eg, haemodynamic instability or ventilatory support) | Death |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by an increase in amounts of fluid within the pleural cavity. Symptoms include shortness of breath, cough and marked chest discomfort. | |||||
| Pleuritis (septic) | — | Symptomatic; medical management indicated | Hospitalization, IV antimicrobials indicated; invasive intervention indicated (eg, thoracic drainage or lavage, surgery) | Life‐threatening consequences including organ system dysfunction; urgent operative intervention indicated | Death |
| Definition: Focal or generalized inflammation of the pleural cavity attributed to microbial contamination. | |||||
| Pneumothorax | Asymptomatic, radiographic findings only | Symptomatic; non‐operative intervention indicated | Sclerosis and/or operative intervention indicated | Life‐threatening, haemodynamic instability; ventilatory support | Death |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by abnormal presence of air in the pleural cavity resulting in the collapse of the lung. | |||||
| Other (specify, _________) | Asymptomatic or mild symptoms; clinical or diagnostic observations only; intervention not indicated |
Moderate; minimal, local or non‐invasive intervention indicated; limiting age appropriate ADL | Severe or medically significant but not immediately life‐threatening; hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization indicated; limiting self care ADL | Life‐threatening consequences; urgent intervention indicated | Death |
| CONSTITUTIONAL CLINICAL SIGNS | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grade | |||||
| Adverse Event | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| Lethargy/fatigue | Mild lethargy over baseline; diminished activity from pre‐disease level, but able to function as an acceptable pet | Moderate lethargy causing some difficulty with performing ADL; ambulatory only to the point of eating, sleeping, and consistently defecating and urinating in acceptable area; Decreased grooming habits | Compromised, severely restricted in ADL; will ambulate if assisted; unable to confine urinations and defecation to acceptable areas unless assisted; absent grooming habits | Disabled, fully recumbent posture; reliant on urinary catheter and/or bladder expression; has no control over bowel movements | Death |
| Definition: Disorders characterized by a state of generalized weakness with a pronounced inability to summon sufficient energy to accomplish daily activities. | |||||
| Fever |
39.5‐40.0°C (103.5‐104°F) |
>40.0‐40.8°C (>104‐105.5°F) |
>40.9‐41.7°C (>105.6‐107.6°F) |
>41.8°C (>107.6°F) | Death |
| Hypothermia | — |
36.1‐>34.4°C (97.0‐>94.0°F) |
34.4‐>32.2°C (93.9‐>90.0°F) |
<32.1°C (<89.9°F) or life‐threatening consequences (eg, coma, hypotension, pulmonary oedema) | Death |
| Weight loss | >5% but <10% from baseline | 10%‐15% from baseline | >15% but <20% of baseline | >20% of baseline | Death |
| Other (specify, _________) | Asymptomatic or mild symptoms; clinical or diagnostic observations only; intervention not indicated |
Moderate; minimal, local or non‐invasive intervention indicated; limiting age appropriate ADL |
Severe or medically significant but not immediately life‐threatening; hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization indicated; limiting self care ADL | Life‐threatening consequences; urgent intervention indicated | Death |
| DERMATOLOGIC/SKIN | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grade | |||||
| Adverse Event | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| Alopecia | Transient sparse thinning or denuding of hair at localized site, patchy alopecia (regrows but takes longer than 4 weeks) | Transient generalized thinning of hair coat, generalized alopecia (regrows but takes longer than 4 weeks) | Permanent sparse or generalized thinning of hair at localized site, or permanent patchy or generalized alopecia | — | — |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by a decrease in density of hair compared to normal for a given individual at a given age and body location. | |||||
| Bruising (in absence of Grade 3 or 4 thrombocytopenia) | Localized or in a dependent area | Generalized/multi‐focal | — | — | — |
| Definition: A finding of injury of the soft tissues or bone characterized by leakage of blood into surrounding tissues. | |||||
| Oedema, limbs | 5%‐10% inter‐limb discrepancy in volume or circumference at point of greatest difference; swelling or obscuration of anatomic architecture on close inspection | >10%‐30% inter‐limb discrepancy in volume or circumference at point of greatest difference; readily apparent obscuration of anatomic architecture, deviation from normal anatomic contour | >30% inter‐limb discrepancy in volume; gross deviation from normal anatomic contour; limiting ADL | — | — |
| Definition: Swelling due to excessive fluid accumulation in the upper or lower extremities. | |||||
| Oedema, localized | Localized to dependent areas; no disability or functional impairment | Moderate localized oedema; intervention indicated | Severe localized oedema limiting ADL; intervention indicated | — | — |
| Definition: Swelling due to excessive fluid accumulation at a specific anatomic site. | |||||
| Erythema | Limited to localized site | Generalized | — | — | — |
| Definition: Superficial reddening of the skin, usually in patches, as a result of injury or irritation causing dilatation of the blood capillaries. | |||||
| Erythema multiforme | Target lesions covering <10% BSA and not associated with skin tenderness | Target lesions covering 10%‐30% BSA and associated with skin tenderness | Target lesions covering >30% BSA, or any number of lesions associated with oral or genital erosions |
Target lesions covering >30% BSA; associated with fluid or electrolyte abnormalities; ICU care indicated | Death |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by target lesions (a pink‐red ring around a pale centre). | |||||
| Hyperpigmentation | Slight or moderate and confined to fewer than 3 sites (localized), or slight generalized changes | Marked localized (<3 sites), or moderate generalized changes (more than 3 sites) | Marked generalized changes | — | — |
| Hypopigmentation | Slight or moderate and confined to fewer than 3 sites (localized), or slight generalized changes | Marked localized (<3 sites), or moderate generalized changes (more than 3 sites) | Marked generalized changes | — | — |
| Nail/nailbed/claw changes | Discoloration, pitting, any number of nail(s)/claw(s) | Weakening (friable, breaks easily), no pain or changes in gait, any number of nail(s)/claw(s) | Partial or complete loss of nail(s)/claw(s) on any number of paws/feet; pain; lameness | Partial or complete loss of nail(s)/claw(s) on at least two paws/feet and significantly interfering with ADL—unwilling to ambulate | Nail/nailbed/claw changes that result in a decision for euthanasia |
| Palmar‐plantar erythrodysesthesia syndrome | Minimal changes or pododermatitis (eg, erythema) without pain | Skin or paw pad changes (eg, peeling/flaking, blisters, bleeding, oedema) or pain, not interfering with function, easily managed medically, resolves significantly within 1 week of drug withdrawal | Skin or paw pad changes that are painful and interfere with function (lameness, excessive licking) and include moist, ulcerative dermatitis, and return to function within 1 week of drug withdrawal | Skin or paw pad changes that are painful, interfere with function and change in function persists longer than 1 week | Skin or paw pad changes that result in a decision for euthanasia |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by redness, marked discomfort, swelling and possible ulceration of the palmar/plantar surfaces of the paws. | |||||
| Photosensitivity | Painless erythema | Painful erythema | Erythema with dry desquamation | Erythema with moist desquamation or ulceration, life‐threatening (would result in euthanasia if not treated); disabling | Complications of photosensitivity that result in death or euthanasia |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by an increase in sensitivity of the skin to light. | |||||
| Pruritus | Mild or localized, does not result in lesions because of self‐trauma | Moderate or widespread and occurs regularly; may occur at night but not when eating or playing; would result in lesions due to self‐trauma if restraint (e‐collar or covering of affected area) is not used when unsupervised. | Licking or scratching continuously, requires restraint (e‐collar or covering of affected area) at all times to prevent self‐trauma, oral corticosteroid or immunosuppressive therapy usually prescribed unless contraindicated | Severe and prolonged; continues when eating, playing, exercising, limits sleeping and eating; oral corticosteroid or immunosuppressive therapy indicated | — |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by intense itching. | |||||
| Purpura | Combined area of lesions covering <10% BSA | Combined area of lesions covering 10%‐30% BSA; bleeding with trauma | Combined area of lesions covering >30% BSA; spontaneous bleeding | — | — |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by haemorrhagic areas of the skin and mucous membrane. Newer lesions appear reddish in colour. Older lesions are usually a darker purple colour and eventually become a brownish‐yellow colour. | |||||
| Rash: acne/acneiform | Macules, papules apules and/or pustules covering <10% BSA, which may or may not be associated with symptoms of pruritus or tenderness | Macules, papules apules and/or pustules covering 10%‐30% BSA, which may or may not be associated with symptoms of pruritus or tenderness | Macules, papules apules and/or pustules covering >30% BSA, which may or may not be associated with symptoms of pruritus or tenderness; limiting ADL; associated with local superinfection with oral antibiotics indicated | Macules, papules apules and/or pustules covering any % BSA, which may or may not be associated with symptoms of pruritus or tenderness and are associated with extensive superinfection with IV antibiotics indicated; life‐threatening consequences | Death |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by an eruption of papules and pustules or a disorder characterized by the presence of macules (flat) and papules (elevated). Also known as morbilliform rash. | |||||
| Scaling | Fine scaling, noticeable only upon close examination | Scaling easily visible but not exfoliation in clumps; minimal crusting | Easily visible generalized scaling and crusting with generalized exfoliation upon examination | — | — |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by flaky and dull skin. | |||||
| Skin atrophy |
Covering <10% BSA; associated with telangiectasia or changes in skin colour | Covering 10%‐30% BSA; associated with striae or adnexal structure loss | Covering >30% BSA; associated with ulceration | — | — |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by the degeneration and thinning of the epidermis and dermis. | |||||
| Skin ulceration | Non‐blanchable erythema of only superficially eroded intact skin with associated warmth or oedema | Combined area of ulcers ≤2 cm and partial thickness skin loss involving skin or subcutaneous fat | Combined area of ulcers >2 cm with partial thickness skin loss or full‐thickness skin loss (any size) involving damage to or necrosis of subcutaneous tissue that may extend down to fascia | Any size ulcer (full thickness) with extensive destruction, tissue necrosis, or damage to muscle, bone, or supporting structures with or without full thickness skin loss | Death |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by circumscribed, inflammatory and necrotic erosive lesion on the skin. If depth and size are discrepant, grade is assigned based on depth of ulceration and not size. | |||||
| Toxic epidermal necrolysis | — | — | — | Skin sloughing covering ≥30% body surface area with associated symptoms (eg, erythema, purpura or epidermal detachment) | Death |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by greater than 30% total body skin area separation of dermis. The syndrome is thought to be a hypersensitivity complex affecting the skin and the mucous membranes. | |||||
| Urticaria (hives, welts, wheals) | Transient, resolves without treatment | Some discomfort, Intervention indicated for <48 h | Moderate to marked discomfort, Intervention indicated for >48 h | — | — |
| Definition: A disorder characterized by a pruritic skin eruption characterized by wheals with pale interiors and well‐defined red margins. | |||||
| Other (specify, _________) | Asymptomatic or mild symptoms; clinical or diagnostic observations only; intervention not indicated |
Moderate; minimal, local or non‐invasive intervention indicated; limiting age appropriate ADL | Severe or medically significant but not immediately life‐threatening; hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization indicated; limiting self care ADL | Life‐threatening consequences; urgent intervention indicated | Death |