| Literature DB >> 33418284 |
Karine Kahil1, Mohamad Ali Cheaito2, Rawad El Hayek3, Marwa Nofal4, Sarah El Halabi5, Kundadak Ganesh Kudva6, Victor Pereira-Sanchez7, Samer El Hayek8.
Abstract
Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) was recently declared a pandemic by the WHO. This outbreak threatens not only physical health but also has significant repercussions on mental health. In recent world history, major infectious outbreaks were associated with severe mental health sequelae, including suicide. In this study, we systematically review the literature on suicidal outcomes during major international respiratory outbreaks, including COVID-19. We reviewed descriptive and analytic articles addressing suicide during major international respiratory outbreaks. We searched PubMed, Medline, Embase, Scopus, and PsycInfo databases and then utilized an independent method for study selection by a pair of reviewers. Two reviewers completed data abstraction and conducted a narrative summary of the findings. Our search generated 2,153 articles. Nine studies (three descriptive, five analytical, and one with mixed methodology) were eligible. The included studies were heterogeneous, divergent in methods, and with a low degree of evidence. Deducing an association between pandemics, suicide, and suicide-related outcomes remains thus poorly supported. Future research with better methodological characteristics, the use of longitudinal studies, and a focus on suicide as the primary outcome would allow for an in-depth understanding and formulation of the scope of this problem.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; Epidemic; Mental health.; Outbreak; Pandemic; Suicide
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 33418284 PMCID: PMC7764387 DOI: 10.1016/j.ajp.2020.102509
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Asian J Psychiatr ISSN: 1876-2018
Fig. 1Systematic review flowchart. Nine studies were included in the qualitative synthesis.
Summary of descriptive studies tackling suicide-related outcomes during major international outbreaks of respiratory viruses.
| Study | Type | Country | Outbreak | Number | Gender | Age (years) | Suicide method | Reason for suicide | Psychiatric history |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Case report | Bangladesh | COVID-19 | 1 | Male | 36 | Hanging from a tree | Moral duty of not passing the suspected COVID-19 infection to the inhabitants of the village | Not mentioned | |
| Case report | India | COVID-19 | 1 | Male | 50 | Hanging from a tree | Fear and panic of having acquired COVID-19 infection | Not mentioned | |
| Case series | India | COVID-19 | 2 | Male | 52 | Shooting self in the abdomen | Worries of being infected by COVID-19 from a friend carrying the virus, followed by the development of depressive symptoms after two weeks of isolation to prevent the spread of any infection to family members, and excessive fear of having a painful death from COVID-19 | No previous psychiatric history | |
| Male | 40 | Hanging with a rope | Worries of being infected by COVID-19 from foreigners, followed by the development of depressive symptoms over two weeks period, self-isolation, and excessive fear of having a painful death from COVID-19 | Not mentioned | |||||
| Case series | China | SARS | 22 | 11 males | 74.9 ± 5.72 | Jumping from a height (n = 2) | Fear of contracting SARS (n = 12): negative news about SARS (especially the death toll among elderly) causing worries about getting infected, avoiding hospital admission due to fear of a higher risk of infection, and feelings of a burden and risk to family | Depression and anxiety (n = 2) | |
| Fear of social isolation (n = 7): reduced contact with others and disruption of normal life | Schizophrenia (n = 1) | ||||||||
| Disease burden among those with long-term illnesses (n = 6): associated unpleasant emotions and feelings of burden from the chronic illness |
Summary of analytical studies tackling suicide-related outcomes during major international outbreaks of respiratory viruses.
| a. General characteristics and methodology of the included analytical studies. | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Study | Type | Country | Outbreak | Methodology | Conflict of interest | ||
| Recruitment strategy | Recruitment site | Eligibility criteria | |||||
| Cross-sectional | United States | COVID-19 | Online survey data collected from March 11 to March 13, 2020 | Participants recruited through Amazon MTurk in exchange forpayment ($0.50) | Participants were eligible if they provided consent and complete information, followed the directions to a validity item, had spent at least one hour during the past two weeks thinking about and/or watching media about COVID-19, and had experienced significant anxiety, fear, or worry about the disease outbreak. | None | |
| Cross-sectional | United States | Influenza A, B, and coronavirus | Participants recruited from two studies of environmental influences on mood disorders and suicidal behavior (studies not mentioned within the manuscript) | Participants recruited from the University of Maryland, Johns Hopkins University, and the Sheppard Pratt Health System | Patients were eligible if they met criteria for major depressive or bipolar disorder according to the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Disorders. Suicide attempts were recorded using the Columbia Suicide History Form. | None | |
| Patients meeting criteria for substance dependence, cognitive disorders, or primary psychotic disorders were excluded. | |||||||
| Cross-sectional | China | SARS | Chart review of death case records in the year 2003 | Death records obtained from the Coroner’s Court in Hong Kong | Case records were eligible if they contained suicide notes and witnesses’ descriptions of the suicide deaths (ICD10: X60-X84). Wherever SARS was mentioned as being crucial to the suicide act and was included in the police death investigation, the suicide death was defined as a SARS-related case. Non-SARS-related cases were then randomly selected for comparison. | Not mentioned | |
| Cross-sectional | China | SARS | Chart review of suicide case records for the period 1993–2004 | Suicide records obtained from the Coroner’s Court in Hong Kong | No reported inclusion or exclusion criteria. | None | |
| Case records contained sociodemographic, medical, and psychosocial data gathered from police investigations and medical institutions. Information about suicide was obtained from suicide notes, interviews, and witness reports. | |||||||
| Cross-sectional | China | SARS | Chart review of suicide case records for the period 1986–2003 | Suicide records obtained from the Census and Statistics Department of the Government of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region | Deaths labeled as “of undetermined cause” were excluded from the analysis. | Not mentioned | |
| Cross-sectional | Taiwan | SARS | Retrospective chart review from March 14 to August 31, 2003 | Charts obtained from the emergency department of Taipei Veterans General Hospital, a tertiary referral and teaching medical center in northern Taiwan | Patients younger than 14 years were excluded. | Not mentioned | |
| Patient information was reviewed and compared for different stages of the SARS epidemic (pre-epidemic, early epidemic, peak epidemic, late epidemic, and post-epidemic stages). | |||||||