Long COVID and neuropsychiatric manifestations (Review).

There is accumulating evidence in the literature indicating that a number of patients with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) may experience a range of neuropsychiatric symptoms, persisting or even presenting following the resolution of acute COVID-19. Among the neuropsychiatric manifestations more frequently associated with 'long COVID' are depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder, sleep disturbances, fatigue and cognitive deficits, that can potentially be debilitating and negatively affect patients' wellbeing, albeit in the majority of cases symptoms tend to improve over time. Despite variations in results obtained from studies using different methodological approaches to define 'long COVID' syndrome, the most widely accepted factors associated with a higher risk of developing neuropsychiatric manifestations include the severity of foregoing COVID-19, the female sex, the presence of comorbidities, a history of mental health disease and an elevation in the levels of inflammatory markers, albeit further research is required to establish causal associations. To date, the pathophysiological mechanisms implicated in neuropsychiatric manifestations of 'long COVID' remain only partially elucidated, while the role of the indirect effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, such as social isolation and uncertainty concerning social, financial and health recovery post-COVID, have also been highlighted. Given the alarming effects of 'long-COVID', interdisciplinary cooperation for the early identification of patients who are at a high risk of persistent neuropsychiatric presentations, beyond COVID-19 recovery, is crucial to ensure that appropriate integrated physical and mental health support is provided, with the aim of mitigating the risks of long-term disability at a societal and individual level. Copyright: © Efstathiou et al.

1. Introduction

Over 2 years have passed since the World Health Organization (WHO) declared coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) as a global public health emergency (1). During this period, significant efforts have been made to describe, study, and understand the clinical manifestations of the disease and its repercussions on physical and mental health (2-7).

During the acute phase of COVID-19, apart from the typical systemic and pulmonary manifestations, such as fever, cough, sore throat and dyspnea, neuropsychiatric symptoms related to severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) infection may occur (8-10). Neuropsychiatric manifestations of acute COVID-19 include hyposmia/anosmia, consciousness disorders, delirium, agitation, encephalopathy, encephalitis, acute ischemic stroke, hypoxic/ischemic brain injury, seizures, vertigo, numbness/paresthesia, anxiety, depression and insomnia, while new-onset psychosis has also been reported in the setting of acute COVID-19 infection (11-20).

Crucially, while the acute phase of COVID-19 has been well-characterized, the data concerning the long-term outcomes of the disease are comparatively rather limited (21). There is increasing evidence to indicate that a number of patients may experience new, recurring or ongoing symptoms, as well as clinical signs, that persist beyond the acute illness; a condition that is colloquially referred to as ‘long COVID’ (22-25). Over the course of the pandemic, several definitions have been proposed and various terms have been used to describe the long-term symptoms and consequences following SARS-CoV-2 infection, including ‘post-COVID conditions’, ‘chronic COVID’, ‘long-haul COVID’, ‘long-term COVID-19’, ‘post-acute COVID-19’, ‘post-acute COVID syndrome’, ‘post COVID syndrome’ and ‘post-acute sequelae of SARS-COV-2 infection (PASC)’ (21,22,26,27). However, it is important to note that i) the lack of a standardized definition for ‘long COVID’; ii) the use of different temporal criteria for ‘long COVID’ diagnosis (i.e., 3 weeks up to several months after SARS-CoV-2 infection); and iii) the inclusion and attribution of diverse symptoms, conditions or signs to ‘long COVID’, may hinder the accurate classification of patients and may thus limit the elucidation of ‘long COVID’ syndrome (22,23,26-28).

‘Long COVID’ can become debilitating for some patients, while it has also been associated with a higher risk of mortality (23,29). In particular, individuals with ‘long COVID’ may present a wide spectrum of clinical manifestations, both pulmonary and extrapulmonary ones (including nervous system and neurocognitive disorders, musculoskeletal pain, mental health disorders, metabolic disorders, cardiovascular disorders, gastrointestinal disorders, and anemia), as well as signs and symptoms related to poor physical wellbeing (including malaise and fatigue) (30).

Patients affected by ‘long COVID’ include also those who initially had mild or asymptomatic disease, pointing to residual effects that involve multiple organ systems, including the peripheral and central nervous system (CNS) (23,31,32). Research evidence suggests that the neuroinvasive and neurotrophic properties of SARS-CoV-2, as well as the rapid overproduction of cytokines and immune cell hyperactivation (i.e., cytokine storm) may influence the manifestation of neuropsychiatric symptoms during and after COVID-19 (33-35). Furthermore, the indirect effects of COVID-19, such as social isolation and feelings of loneliness, uncertainty of the prognosis or incomplete physical health recovery, changes in sleep and lifestyle behaviors and the economic burden may also affect the manifestation of neuropsychiatric symptoms (36,37).

The systematic research of neuropsychiatric manifestations in patients beyond the resolution of acute COVID-19 is thus crucial in order to broaden the current understanding regarding the sequelae experienced by COVID-19 survivors and may facilitate the development of targeted evidence-based approaches towards an integrated patient care.

2. Neuropsychiatric manifestations in COVID-19 survivors with ‘long COVID’

There is increasing scientific evidence to indicate that a significant proportion of COVID-19 survivors experience a range of neuropsychiatric symptoms persisting or even presenting months after the initial infection (29,32,38).

Of note, Mazza et al (39), in 2020, assessed 402 COVID-19 survivors at 1 month following treatment at the hospital emergency department, using self-rated psychometric instruments, and found that overall, 56% scored in the pathological range in at least one clinical dimension [i.e., including depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and obsessive-compulsive symptomatology] (39). Moreover, females, patients with a pre-existing psychiatric diagnosis and patients who were managed at home exhibited increased levels in the majority of psychopathological measurements (39). In a later cohort study, reassessing a subsample of 226 COVID-19 survivors of the aforementioned study at 3 months, Mazza et al (40), reported that 35.8% of the patients still scored in the pathological range in at least one psychopathological dimension (40).

Furthermore, Huang et al (41) evaluated a sample of 1,733 patients who were hospitalized due to COVID-19, 6 months following symptom onset and demonstrated that a significant proportion (76%) still reported at least one neuropsychiatric symptom, with the most common being fatigue/muscle weakness (63%) and sleep disturbances (26%). In a later study, 1-year follow-up data were available from a subsample of 1,276 COVID-19 survivors (36). Of note, within 1 year after acute infection, the majority of individuals exhibited a good physical and functional recovery over time, and had returned to their original work and life, albeit their health status remained lower compared to non-COVID-19 participants (controls) matched for age, sex and comorbidities (36).

Notably, Taquet et al (42) reported that among 236,379 patients diagnosed with COVID-19, the estimated incidence of a neurological or psychiatric diagnosis in the succeeding 6 months was 33.62%, with a proportion of 12.84% receiving such a diagnosis for the first time, whereas the estimated incidence was even higher for patients who had been admitted to an intensive care unit (ICU).

Depression, anxiety, PTSD, sleep disturbances, fatigue and cognitive deficits are among the most commonly reported neuropsychiatric symptoms in published studies investigating ‘long COVID’ (20,43), and thus should be explicitly assessed when treating patients with symptoms beyond the phase of acute SARS-COV-2 infection.

Anxiety, depression and ‘long COVID’

According to previous systematic reviews, the most frequently reported psychiatric symptoms in the context of ‘long COVID’ are depression and anxiety (20,38). Considering that, particularly persisting, depression and anxiety symptoms are associated with substantial individual morbidity with severe repercussions on the quality of life of patients, the psychiatric manifestations of ‘long COVID’ may also pose a significant healthcare challenge with major societal implications (44,45).

Of note, a previous retrospective cohort study found that among 236,379 patients, 17.39% were diagnosed with anxiety disorder (7.11% received first such diagnosis) and 13.66% with mood disorder (4.22% received first such diagnosis) in the 6 months following COVID-19 diagnosis. Notably, as regards patients who were admitted in the ICU, estimated incidences were 22.43% for anxiety disorder (9.24% for first diagnosis) and 22.52% for mood disorder (8.07% for first diagnosis) (42).

Furthermore, another prospective cohort study, including 251 patients with COVID-19 reported that 29.6% of the survivors presented state anxiety one month after hospital discharge, that was persistent at the 3-month follow-up assessment (i.e., in 25.5% of patients), while no changes in anxiety/depression symptoms were noted at 3-month follow-up (evaluated with EuroQoL-5 Dimensions, EQ-5D) (46).

Notably, a previous cohort study including 134 patients with COVID-19 assessed at a median of ~3.8 months (46-167 days) post-discharge, reported that at follow-up, 47.8% of the survivors experienced anxiety and 39.6% a low mood, with female patients being at a higher risk in comparison to males (47).

Accordingly, another prospective uncontrolled cohort study that evaluated, via telephone interview, 478 patients who were hospitalized due to COVID-19, 4 months after discharge, indicated that 31.4% of these patients reported anxiety and 20.6% depression (48), while another 4-month follow-up study found that among 94 COVID-19 patients who presented COVID-19 related pneumonia with respiratory failure, 21% presented anxiety post-hospital discharge (49).

Of note, a retrospective, case series of 200 hospitalized patients with severe-to-critical COVID-19 infection reported that at 4-7 months from disease-onset, 20% of patients presented anxiety or a low mood, sometimes associated with intrusive thoughts or flashbacks, while patients with pre-existing mental health issues presented a deterioration of their symptoms both during hospitalization and after discharge (50).

Furthermore, another cohort study, including 402 COVID-19 survivors who were hospitalized, demonstrated that at a 1-month assessment, 31% presented with depression and 42% with anxiety. Crucially, a significant decrease was recorded from the 1- to the 3-month follow-up assessment with regards to anxiety, whereas depression rates were not altered. It is important to note that the severity of baseline systemic inflammation predicted the severity of depressive psychopathology at the 3-month follow-up (40). Accordingly, a recent multimodal magnetic resonance imaging study assessing 42 COVID-19 survivors without brain lesions, at ~3 months (90.59±54.66 days) after COVID-19 infection, revealed that the systemic immune-inflammation index measured in the emergency department predicted increased depression several weeks after the clearance of the virus, while the severity of depression symptoms was also associated with decreasing grey matter (GM) volumes in the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) (51).

Of note, a multicenter observational study including 1,142 COVID-19 survivors reported that at ~7 months after hospital discharge 16.2% of the patients presented self-rated anxiety symptoms, while 19.7% depressive symptoms. The female sex, the number of days spent at the hospital, the number of pre-existing medical comorbidities, and the number of lingering symptoms at hospital admission were significantly associated with depressive symptoms, whereas only the number of symptoms at hospital admission was associated with anxiety (52).

Moreover, a longitudinal study that assessed 165 consecutive non-neurological patients 6 months after hospitalization due to COVID-19, reported that 26.7% of the patients presented depressive symptoms or anxiety (53). Similarly, a larger cohort study that assessed 1,733 hospitalized patients 6 months following symptom onset demonstrated that 23% of these patents experienced anxiety or depression (41). It is important to note that the 1-year follow-up findings suggested an exacerbation of psychiatric symptoms, as the proportion of individuals with anxiety or depression increased significantly from 23% at the 6-month assessment to 26% at the 12-month assessment (36). Another 1-year follow-up study including 171 discharged patients with COVID-19 without a mental health history revealed that 35.1% of these patients reported anxiety and 32.2% depression (54). Accordingly, a cohort study including 2,433 COVID-19 survivors, also identified anxiety symptoms (10.4%) 1 year after hospital discharge, albeit to a lesser extent (55).

Findings concerning the trajectory of depression and anxiety symptoms are contradictory, as there are reports of an increase over time [e.g., higher anxiety and depression from the 6- to the 12-month assessment (36)], or results, suggesting symptom amelioration [e.g., decrease in anxiety at 1 month after admission (56), and also from the 1- to the 3-month assessment (40), as well as a decrease in depression at 1-month after admission (56)]. However, there are also reports of non-significant changes noted at the follow-up assessment [e.g., persistent anxiety 1 month after hospital discharge (46), as well as depression 1 month after admission (57) that remained unaltered between the 1- and 3-month assessment (40)].

As regards factors that may be associated with depression and anxiety in patients with ‘long COVID’, a number of studies have identified an elevated risk among COVID-19 survivors with an increased disease severity, with differences arising among patients who were treated at home or in outpatient settings, those who were hospitalized or patients requiring treatment in the ICU (30,41,42,58), although this connection has been suggested to be rather weak for psychiatric compared to neurological outcomes (42). Nevertheless, de Graaf et al (59) indicated that depression and anxiety symptoms did not differentiate between hospitalized patients treated in the ICU and those in a general ward. Similar findings were obtained in another study on a sample of COVID-19 survivors, with no pre-existing neurological, psychiatric, or severe medical condition, referred to an outpatient rehabilitation program due to persistent symptoms and/or sequelae of COVID-19 >3 months following acute COVID-19 infection (60). Accordingly, other studies did not find either differences in anxiety or depression between COVID-19 survivors with varying degrees of severity (e.g., mild, moderate, severe) (61,62), while Yuan et al (63) reported that depression was not associated with the severity of initial infection or a history of hospital admittance. As regards the impact of comorbidities, while associations with either depression (28) or both anxiety and depression symptoms (64), have been suggested, other studies have not found any association between comorbidities and ‘long COVID’ symptoms (63,65,66).

There is evidence to indicate that patients with a history of mental health issues may be at a higher risk of presenting persisting depression symptoms (39,40); however, there are also findings revealing that among COVID-19 survivors with self-rated anxiety and depression, a high proportion does not have pre-existing mental health conditions (58). Furthermore, it should be noted that often, studies investigating mental health sequalae among COVID-19 survivors, either define psychiatric history as an exclusion criterion or do not report findings using standardized assessment with respect to this (43). Crucially, a number of studies suggest that females are, in general, more likely to display anxiety or depression at follow-up (40,41,47,67); however, the absence of such an association has also been reported (63).

Post-traumatic stress disorder and ‘long COVID’

Taking into consideration the findings of previous studies regarding previous coronavirus outbreaks, such as SARS and Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS), that reported significantly elevated PTSD rates in survivors even after several months, it is evident that the investigation of PTSD with respect to ‘long COVID’ is of utmost importance (68,69).

Of note, in a previous study, among 402 patients assessed at 1 month after hospital treatment, 28% presented PTSD (39), while when a subsample of 226 survivors was reassessed at 3 months, a significant decrease from the 1- to the 3-month follow-up was identified with respect to PTSD symptoms (40). Nevertheless, another prospective cohort study, assessing 251 hospitalized patients both at 1 and 3 months post-discharge, reported that at 1 month, 24.5% of patients experienced PTSD, a proportion that did not change significantly at the 3-month post-discharge evaluation (46).

Furthermore, in a large cohort study including 760 hospitalized patients, assessed at a median of 65 days (i.e., ~9 weeks) post-discharge, 10.5% screened positive for PTSD, with patients having more physical symptoms at admission and at follow-up being more likely to present PTSD symptoms. Patients with PTSD were more likely to experience persistent symptoms of breathlessness, myalgia, anorexia and confusion, whereas they were less likely to have returned to work (70). Notably, in another large cohort study, among 767 COVID-19 survivors assessed at a median time of 81 days after discharge, 30.5% reported PTSD (71).

Crucially, in a cohort study, at 4 months after discharge, PTSD was identified in 14.2% of 478 patients hospitalized due to COVID-19(48). Similarly, in a prospective, longitudinal cohort study, among 1,077 patients assessed at a median of 5.9 months after hospital discharge, 12.2% reported symptoms compatible with PTSD (72). Nevertheless, another 4-month follow-up study including 238 hospitalized patients due to severe COVID-19 found that at 4 months after discharge, 42.9% of the patients presented PTSD symptoms, while 17.2% of the patients reported moderate-to-severe symptom severity (73).

Notably, a 12-month longitudinal study revealed that 24.6% of the 171 discharged patients with COVID-19, without a mental health history, reported PTSD at the follow-up assessment (54). Of note, another study using a multimodal brain imaging approach demonstrated that systemic immune-inflammation during the acute phase predicted increased the risk of PTSD symptoms at ~3 months (90.59±54.66 days) post-COVID, while such symptoms were also associated with decreasing GM volumes both, in the ACC and in the bilateral insular cortex (51).

As regards the risk factors, there is evidence to indicate that psychological distress at the onset of illness may be predictive of PTSD development (74), while higher levels of anxiety and depression symptoms during the first week of hospitalization have also been suggested to independently predict a higher risk of developing PTSD symptoms at 1 month after hospitalization (56).

The setting of care (e.g., ICU, general hospital ward, outpatient setting) has emerged as a risk factor for PTSD in some studies (58,74); however, this is not the case in others (40,59,73,75). Of note, in previous studies, no differences were found among COVID-19 survivors with different levels of disease severity (e.g., mild, moderate, severe, or critical disease) (61,62). In another study, hospitalization was identified as a protective factor against developing PTSD, when comparing to patients discharged from the emergency department (76).

With respect to physical comorbidities, the findings suggest that there is no association with PTSD development, particularly following adjustment for other confounding factors (73,76). Crucially, patients with pre-existing mental health problems are likely to be at a greater risk of presenting PTSD (39,40), even when controlling for other demographic or clinically relevant factors (75); nevertheless, non-significant associations have also been reported (77).

Furthermore, studies using either univariate or multivariate analyses, have demonstrated that PTSD symptoms more commonly present in females following COVID-19 (39,40,75,77), particularly when treated in an ICU (58). However, it is important to note that there is also evidence to indicate that when adjusting for other variables, the sex effect may lose statistical significance (46,76). On the other hand, Bellan et al (73) indicated that the male sex was independently associated with the presence of moderate-to-severe PTSD symptoms.

The findings are not consistent regarding the role of body mass index (BMI) with regards to PTSD. There is evidence to suggest that a higher BMI (i.e., obesity) is associated with PTSD, independently of other factors (75), while it has also been indicated that this association is more pronounced in patients treated in the ICU (58); nevertheless, other studies have not found any such associations (73,76). Further factors suggested to predict PTSD severity include previous traumatic events, prolonged COVID-19 symptoms, stigmatization and a negative view of the COVID-19 pandemic (77).

Sleep disturbances, fatigue, other neuropsychiatric symptoms and ‘long COVID’

Sleep difficulties of varying degrees, as well as fatigue, that can potentially be debilitating and negatively affect the quality of life of patients, are among the long-term effects that COVID-19 survivors may continue to experience or even present for the first time weeks to months following the initial infection (20,38). Furthermore, post-acute neuropsychiatric manifestations of ‘long COVID’ include memory impairment, concentration difficulties, headaches, disorientation or confusion and obsessive-compulsive symptoms, among others (31,78).

In a previous prospective cohort study that assessed 251 survivors, at 1 month after discharge, 41.8% of the patients experienced insomnia, 35.3% pain/discomfort, 26.8% problems in usual daily activities and 10.3% problems in self-care. Among the aforementioned symptoms, none was significantly altered at the 3-month post-discharge evaluation, apart from insomnia, which improved significantly (i.e., affecting 25.5% of patients) albeit a number of patients still experienced sleep disturbances (46).

Accordingly, in another study, 402 patients with COVID-19 who were assessed at 1 month after hospital treatment, 40% reported insomnia and 20% obsessive-compulsive symptoms (39). Crucially, a significant decrease from the 1- to the 3-month follow-up assessment (in a subsample of 226 survivors) was recorded for insomnia, whereas notably, obsessive-compulsive symptomatology worsened (40). Furthermore, a significant proportion of patients (78%) displayed poor performances in at least one cognitive domain, with executive functions (50%) and psychomotor coordination (57%) emerging as the most impaired, followed by attention and information processing (33%), verbal fluency (32%), working memory (24%) and verbal memory (10%). Notably, baseline systemic inflammation predicted neurocognitive performance at the 3-month follow-up (40).

Another study demonstrated that among 134 patients with COVID-19 assessed after a median of ~3.8 months post-discharge, 51.5% reported myalgia, 39.6% extreme fatigue, 37.3% memory impairment, 35.1% sleep disturbances, 25.4% attention deficits and 9.7% cognitive impairment. Females were more likely to suffer from sleep disturbances, fatigue, myalgia and memory impairment compared to males, while higher a BMI was significantly associated with myalgia and fatigue (47). Crucially, in a larger retrospective cohort study, including 932 hospitalized patients with COVID-19, a relatively low proportion with respect to fatigue was noted at 3 months after discharge (i.e., 1.8%) (79).

Of note, in another study with a 4-month follow-up, including 94 survivors who had COVID-19-related pneumonia with respiratory failure, at 4 months after their discharge, 52% of patients reported experiencing fatigue, 10% anorexia and 31% insomnia (49). Similarly, in a 4-month post-discharge assessment of 478 patients who were hospitalized due to COVID-19, the neuropsychiatric symptoms reported included insomnia (53.6%), fatigue (31.1%), memory difficulties (17.5%), persistent paresthesia (12.1%), mental slowness (10.1%), memory difficulties (10.0%) and headaches (5.5%), while cognitive impairment was found in 38.4% of patients. Notably, 51% of the COVID-19 survivors reported at least one symptom that did not exist prior to the disease (48). Accordingly, in another study among 200 hospitalized patients with severe-to-critical COVID-19 infection, it was found that at 4-7 months from disease-onset a significant proportion of patients experienced significant fatigue (53.5%), decreased mobility (37.5%) and pain (36.8%). Further neuropsychiatric symptoms included cognitive difficulties, mainly in concentration and short-term recall (12.5%), sleeping disturbances (14.6%), while 12.2% of patients became frail (50).

A prospective, longitudinal cohort study that assessed 1,077 patients at a median of 5.9 months following hospital discharge found that the most commonly reported persistent symptoms at follow-up were aching muscles/pain (57.2%), fatigue (worsening of symptoms reported by 56.2%), physical slowing down (49.9%), slowing down in thinking (42.4%), impaired sleep quality (worsening of symptoms reported by 41.8%), joint pain or swelling (47.8%), limb weakness (46.3%), difficulty with concentration (40.2%), short-term memory loss (42.0%) and headaches (33.4%). Moreover, less frequently reported symptoms included, among others, confusion/fuzzy head, dizziness or lightheadedness, altered personality/behavior and difficulty with communication. Of note, 29% of the patients reported that they felt fully recovered at follow-up, while non-recovery was associated with female sex, middle age (40-59 years), two or more comorbidities and more severe acute illness (72).

Of note, a previous cohort study, following a total of 952 patients with absent-to-mild COVID-19 symptoms for a median time period of 6.8 months (i.e., 442 and 353 patients observed over a period of 4 and 7 months after symptom onset, respectively), demonstrated that while the most common symptoms at disease onset included cough (64.4%), ageusia (59.1%), anosmia (54.3%), body aches (53.2%), headaches (53.1%) and fever (44.6%), the most frequently reported symptoms at 4-month follow-up were anosmia (12.4%), ageusia (11.1%), fatigue (9.7%) and shortness of breath (8.6%). Intriguingly, symptoms such as anosmia (14.7%), shortness of breath (13.6%), fatigue (14.7%) and ageusia (11.0%) were also present at the 7-month assessment, while headaches (3.7%) were also recorded (80).

Furthermore, a retrospective observational follow-up study including 797 COVID-19 survivors who were hospitalized, demonstrated that at 6 months post-discharge, 22.1% presented fatigue, 3.8% muscle weakness, 15.3% musculoskeletal pain, 5.3% headache, 3.4% paresthesia, 2.6% disorientation or confusion, and 4.9% sleep disturbances (67). Another 6-month follow-up cohort study that evaluated 796 patients with severe COVID-19 rehabilitation, found that the most common neuropsychiatric symptoms at follow-up comprised fatigue (25.3%) and sleep disorder (23.2%), while hypomnesia (8.7%), dizziness and headache (1.9%) were also recorded (81). Crucially, among 165 patients, 6 months after hospitalization due to COVID-19, fatigue (33.9%), memory/concentration complaints (31.5%), sleep disorders (31.5%), myalgias (30.3%) and the loss of dependency in instrumental activities of daily living (20.7%) emerged as the most common neuropsychiatric symptoms (53). In another cohort study, poor sleep quality was recorded 7 months after discharge in 34.5% of 1,142 patients who were hospitalized due to COVID-19, while females, patients with a higher number of days of hospital stay, a higher number of comorbidities and a higher number of symptoms at hospital admission were more likely to report poor sleep quality (52).

Notably, a retrospective cohort study reported that among 236,379 patients diagnosed with COVID-19, the estimated incidences at 6 months post-COVID were 1.40% for psychotic disorders (0.42% for first such diagnosis), 6.58% for substance use disorder (1.92% for first diagnosis), 5.42% for insomnia (2.53% for first diagnosis), 2.10, and 0.67% for dementia (42).

Furthermore, in another study, among 1,733 patients hospitalized due to COVID-19, within 6 months from symptom onset, 63% experienced symptoms of fatigue or muscle weakness, 27% pain or discomfort, 26% sleep difficulties, 6% dizziness, 2% myalgia and 2% headache (41). In a subsample of 1,276 COVID-19 survivors who were assessed both at 6 and 12 months following symptom onset, the majority of the aforementioned neuropsychiatric symptoms appeared to have improved. In particular, symptoms of fatigue or muscle weakness decreased from 52 to 20%, while sleep difficulties from 27 to 17%. However, a statistically significant increase was observed with respect to myalgia (from 3 to 4%) and headache (from 2 to 5%), whereas no statistically significant changes were noted for pain or discomfort (from 27 to 29%) and dizziness (from 6 to 5%) (36).

Notably, the neuropsychiatric symptoms reported in a retrospective cohort study that assessed 2,433 COVID-19 survivors at 1 year after their hospital discharge included fatigue (27.7%) and myalgia (7.9%), while patients with severe disease during hospitalization presented more frequently with post-COVID symptoms (55). Importantly, in the aforementioned study, an older age, female sex and severe disease during hospital stay were associated with a higher risk of fatigue, while an advanced age and severe disease were also associated with an increased risk of having more post-infection symptoms. Furthermore, another 1-year follow-up study on 171 discharged patients, reported neuropsychiatric symptoms including fatigue (48.5%), memory complaints (32.2%), headaches (15.8%) and paresthesia (7%). Notably, the most affected cognitive domain was semantic verbal fluency (32.7%) followed by immediate verbal memory/learning (20.5%), working memory/executive function (12.3%) and delayed verbal memory (7.6%) (54).

Sleep disturbances persisting in patients even months after acute COVID-19 infection have been highlighted in several studies, with some of these indicating that almost half of the survivors experience difficulties related to sleep (39,48), although there is evidence for improvement over time (40,46). The pivotal essential role of sleep in physical and mental health is well-established (82). Vice versa, there is evidence to indicate that insomnia and other mental health conditions not only share common pathophysiological causes, but also exhibit a bidirectional association, with disrupted sleep most likely being a contributory causal factor for the occurrence of major types of mental health disorders (83). Among patients with ‘long COVID’, the female sex (39,40,47,52,81), a history of mental health issues (39,40) and the number of comorbidities (52) are likely associated with an increased risk of experiencing sleep disturbances. Of note, there are studies that indicate no difference between patients admitted to hospital as compared to those discharged from the emergency department (76), or an association of sleep disorders with disease severity (41,62,81); however there are also studies that associate insomnia with the care setting/disease severity (e.g., patients without hospitalization, patients with hospitalization, patients with ICU admission or patients with encephalopathy) (30,42), or highlight the number of symptoms at hospital admission and the number of days spent at hospital, as risk factors for a poor sleep quality (52). Nevertheless, a previous study also found that patients that were not treated in the ICU presented a lower sleep quality and higher daytime dysfunction compared to those treated in the ICU, while no other differences were noted in any of the other sleep-related dimensions (i.e., latency, duration, efficacy, disturbance or medication use) (60).

Fatigue is among the most commonly reported symptoms that patients experience following the resolution of acute COVID-19, while according to a recent meta-analysis, ~32% of individuals experienced fatigue at ≥12 weeks following COVID-19 diagnosis (84). Females are, in general, at a greater risk of experiencing persisting fatigue post-COVID (41,47,67,81,85,86), either when treated in a hospital ward or in the ICU (58), with differences being observed even at 1 year of follow-up (36,55). Nevertheless, other studies have reported no such associations (87,88). An older age has been independently associated with fatigue or muscle weakness (41) and higher rates of fatigue (87) at 6 months post-discharge, as well as at the 1-year follow-up (55), whereas other findings suggesting an absence of significant association have also been reported at the 10-week (85) and 1-year follow-up following discharge (36). Furthermore, patients with a higher BMI are likely to experience increased fatigue (47,89), although findings not supporting this association have also been reported (58,85,87). Crucially, as regards the impact of COVID-19 severity on post-viral fatigue, the findings are not consistent. There are reports of severe disease linked to a higher risk of fatigue at 3 months (62) and 6 months after COVID-19 (30,53,90), as well as of fatigue or muscle weakness (41) at 6 months post-discharge and fatigue up to 1 year post-discharge (55); however, in the study sample of Huang et al this association has emerged only for the 6-month assessment (41), but not the 12 month assessment (36). Of note, another study assessing patients, with no neurological or psychiatric history, at >3 months after acute COVID-19 infection, indicated that there was no significant association between previous admission to ICU and fatigue (60), while another study assessing fatigue at a median of 10 weeks after the initial COVID-19 symptoms demonstrated that there was no association between COVID-19 severity (need for inpatient admission, supplemental oxygen or critical care) and fatigue following COVID-19(85). Accordingly, Shang et al (81) did not find any differences between severe and critical illness at 6-month follow-up assessment among patients with severe COVID-19. Other risk factors for fatigue may include high symptom load during COVID-19(89), the length of hospital stay (87), dyspnea during COVID-19(89), confusion during COVID-19(89), previous depression (89), a pre-existing diagnosis of depression/anxiety (85), sleep disturbances (62), as well as new neurological diagnoses (62). Of note, in the study by Huang et al (36), therapy using corticosteroids during the acute phase was associated with an increased risk of fatigue or muscle weakness at 1 year post-discharge, whereas intravenous immunoglobulin therapy in the acute phase decreased the risk of persistent fatigue or muscle weakness. Townsend et al (85) reported no association between routine laboratory markers of inflammation and cell turnover (leukocyte, neutrophil or lymphocyte counts, neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio, lactate dehydrogenase, C-reactive protein) or pro-inflammatory molecules [interleukin (IL)-6 or sCD25] and fatigue post COVID-19, while Liang et al (91) found that serum troponin-I levels during acute illness correlated positively with fatigue after hospital discharge.

Cognitive impairment persisting in patients with COVID-19, is particularly concerning, as apart from the individual physical/mental health and social repercussions, this may also translate into a major global healthcare and economic burden (84). Cognitive impairment/deficits reported following the resolution of acute COVID-19 symptoms, may include difficulties in concentration, memory, attention, language, executive function, encoding and verbal fluency, and visuospatial function, among others (20,78,92). A previous systematic review and meta-analysis regarding the psychiatric and neuropsychiatric presentations associated with severe coronavirus infections, such as SARS or MERS, demonstrated that during the acute illness, common cognitive problems among hospitalized patients included confusion [prevalence, 27.9%; 95% confidence interval (CI), 20.5-36.0], an impaired concentration or attention (prevalence, 38.2%; 95% CI, 29.0-47.9) and impaired memory (prevalence, 34.1%; 95% CI, 26.2-42.5), while an impaired concentration or attention (prevalence, 19.9%; 95% CI, 14.2-26.2) and memory impairment (prevalence, 18.9%; 95% CI, 14.1-24.2) were frequently reported during the post-illness stage as well (93). Notably, a recent meta-analysis revealed that ~22% of individuals experienced fatigue ≥12 weeks following the diagnosis of COVID-19(84). Disease severity has been associated with cognitive deficits, such as deficits related to memory [i.e., memory complaints (53), memory deficits (30), hypomnesia (81)], confusion (53) and visual disturbances (53). Nevertheless, there are studies that fail to support such a connection. In particular, de Graaf et al (2021) did not find any significant differences with regards to cognitive function between patients treated in a general hospital ward and those admitted to the ICU (59). Accordingly, in the study by De Lorenzo et al (76), patients admitted to hospital as compared to those discharged from the emergency department did not differ as regards self-reported cognitive impairment measures. Furthermore, a study assessing patients in an outpatient rehabilitation program due to persistent symptoms and/or sequelae of COVID-19, with no prior neurological or psychiatric history, indicated that there was no significant association between previous admission to the ICU and orientation, attention, verbal learning, long-term verbal memory, verbal recognition, working memory or executive control (60). Importantly, Méndez et al (94) did not find an association between sex and neurocognitive impairment at the 2-month post-discharge assessment, while Shang et al (81) did not find any differences in hypomnesia between male and female patients at the 6-month follow-up among patients with severe COVID-19. Nevertheless, according to other studies, females were more likely than males to report memory impairment (47), a poor performance in working memory (40), disorientation or confusion (67). Of note, delirium during hospitalization and stress-related symptoms have been found to be associated with an increased likelihood of neurocognitive impairment at 2-month assessment (94), while according to Mazza et al (40) neurocognitive impairments were associated with severity of depressive psychopathology, while processing speed, verbal memory and fluency, and psychomotor coordination were predicted by baseline systemic inflammation.

3. Pathophysiological mechanisms underlying neuropsychiatric symptoms of ‘long COVID’

Significant strides have been made recently in the understanding of the underlying pathophysiology of neuropsychiatric complications following acute COVID-19 infection (Fig. 1). The neuroinvasive potential of coronaviruses has long been recognized; however, the precise route of entry of SARS-COV-2 in the nervous system remains only partially elucidated (95). The retrograde transport of viral antigens along the axons of both the olfactory neurons (96-99) and vagus nerve (100) has been suggested by research using animal models, while the Spike (S) viral protein has been shown to have the capacity of crossing the blood-brain barrier in mice (101). Additionally, SARS-COV-2 has the ability to enter host cells directly by binding its Spike protein to the angiotensin-I converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) (102), which is abundantly expressed in neural tissue-namely endothelial cells, neurons, glial cells, brain nuclei, etc. (103). The strong binding affinity of the Spike protein to ACE2(104) and the potential use of CD147 as a route of entry into cells (105), leads to a robust immune response, with infected macrophages releasing significant amounts of Th-1 (IL-1β, IL-6, interferon-γ, tumor necrosis factor-α, CXCL10 and CCL2) and Th-2 cytokines (IL-4, IL-10 and IL-1 receptor antagonist) (106,107). Notably, IL-6 is the main contributor to the dysregulated inflammatory response induced by the virus (108).

Figure 1

Pathophysiological mechanisms implicated in acute and ‘long-COVID’ neuropsychiatric sequelae. (A) In acute COVID-19 infection, SARS-CoV-2 enters the CNS via hematogenous transmission or retrograde transport along the axons of the olfactory (94-97) and vagus nerve (100). Vagus nerve affection may lead to autonomic dysregulation, impaired cerebral autoregulation and subsequent brain hypoxia (100). Moreover, the SARS-CoV-2-induced cytokine storm results in impaired blood-brain barrier function and increased blood-brain barrier permeability. The latter induces the transmigration of virus-infected leukocytes into the CNS, the activation of microglial cells and astrocytes, which in turn trigger apoptotic cascades and demyelination, respectively. At the neuronal level (illustrated in the magnified inset), SARS-CoV-2 cell entry is mainly facilitated by the ACE2 receptor, located on the surface of neuronal cells. Intracellular inflammatory responses in the setting of acute SARS-CoV-2 infection induce lysosomal, mitochondrial and endoplasmic reticulum dysfunction, while protein misfolding and intracellular accumulation of protein aggregates may induce long-lasting neurodegenerative cascades (132). (B) In ‘long-COVID’ syndrome, neuropsychiatric deficits have been mainly associated with ongoing inflammatory, metabolic and degenerative processes, which have been linked to ‘ACE2-rich’ brain areas, extending from the somatosensory cortex to the rectal/orbital gyrus, the temporal lobe, the thalamus and hypothalamus, and further, to brainstem and cerebellar regions (133). Serotoninergic pathways are depicted in purple. Apart from serotoninergic pathways, further neurotransmitter imbalances (not illustrated), including acetylcholine, dopamine and histamine have been found to be linked to lingering neuropsychiatric symptoms noted in patients with ‘long-COVID’ (134). The image was created using BioRender (https://biorender.com). CNS, central nervous system; SARS-CoV-2, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2; ACE2, angiotensin-converting enzyme 2.

Those direct effects of acute COVID-19 infection may subsequently contribute to the symptomatology noted in ‘long COVID’. It should, nevertheless, be noted that the exact mechanisms of ‘long COVID’ remain poorly delineated to date, while new evidence continues to emerge. Anxiety syndromes, depression and cognitive impairment are considered to have a multifactorial origin, with somatic, functional and psychosocial factors all contributing to the clinical picture. The psychological stressors of social isolation and infection with a novel potentially fatal virus, as well as the fear of infecting others or being stigmatized, all play a key role (109-111). The activation of the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal glands axis observed in patients with COVID-19 mediates glucocorticoid secretion (i.e., the main hormonal response to physical and mental stress stimuli) and is also one of the main neurobiological mechanisms in depression as it inhibits neurogenesis and decreases the proliferation and survival of nerve cells in the dentate gyrus of the hippocampus (112-114).

The cytokine storm as part of the systemic hyperinflammatory state observed in acute COVID-19 infection, also plays a key role in persistent maladies, precipitated by changes in cerebral perfusion, an increased permeability of the blood-brain barrier, changes in astrocytes involved in synaptogenesis and the imbalance of neurotransmitters (115). These molecules dysregulate neurogenesis, causing neurons, oligodendrocytes and glial cells to lose their physiological function (116). This occurring disruption of neuronal plasticity, synaptic function, myelination and blood-brain barrier maintenance can subsequently impair cognitive function and may lead to a number of the long-term neuropsychiatric symptoms of COVID-19(117). Of note, previous studies have demonstrated that the systemic immune-inflammation index (SII) was elevated at the 3-month follow-up in patients reporting depressive and cognitive impairment symptomatology (39,118). The SII is an objective marker of host systemic inflammation and immune response, implicating neutrophils, platelets and lymphocytes, cells involved in various inflammatory pathways. Individuals who presented with a marked decrease in the SII exhibited a decrease in the severity of depression, while by contrast, increased levels of SII had a negative effect on neurocognitive performance (memory, verbal fluency, speed of information processing, psychomotor coordination), since this elevation reflects prolonged systemic inflammation (40).

Another factor that also may account for the delayed sequelae of COVID-19 is the failure of reactive neuroglia to return to the physiological state. Neuroglia undergo complex remodeling in response to systemic pathology, a process known as gliosis, in order to remove pathogens, strengthen brain-organism barriers and contribute to the regenerative potential of the CNS (116). This reactive response results in the formation of a glial scar isolating the damaged area, protecting the adjacent healthy nervous tissue (119). The resolution of systemic pathology is what enables the restoration of homeostatic status of neuroglial cells. Post-mortem examinations of the brains of patients with COVID-19 have highlighted a perturbed glial homeostasis, with significant changes in both astrocytes and microglia (120). These alterations are consistent with morphological and functional astrocyte remodeling in chronic stress and major psychiatric diseases (121,122).

Autonomic dysfunction, either due to dysfunction related to the initial infection (123-126) or mediated by autoantibodies (127) (possibly to adrenoceptors and muscarinic receptors), has been hypothesized to cause orthostatic intolerance syndrome in patients with ‘long COVID’. The concomitant involvement of other organs, such as the heart or lungs, is prominent and associated with neurological sequelae, while perturbed viral infection-induced colon inflammation, gut microbial imbalance and α-synuclein upregulation play a role in the disruption of interplay between the gastrointestinal tract and the CNS (128).

The formation of thrombi due to endothelial dysfunction, hypercoagulability and the lingering cytokine storm in patients with ‘long COVID’ may be associated with a high incidence of thrombotic cerebral complications (129). Additionally, direct damage to the blood-brain barrier by the virus and hypertension due to elevation in ACE2 may cause hemorrhagic complications with persistent sequelae following the resolution of acute SARS-CoV-2 infection (130). The high susceptibility of white matter to ischemia renders it particularly vulnerable to ischemic changes. Furthermore, long-term alterations have recently been confirmed by the neuroradiological evidence of structural damage and impaired functional integrity of the brain, at a 3-month follow-up of COVID-19 survivors (131).

4. Conclusion

The present review article has provided insight into the long-term neuropsychiatric effects of COVID-19, while presenting a comprehensive overview of published epidemiological data to date, as well as research evidence on the pathophysiological mechanisms underlying the neuropsychiatric manifestations of ‘long COVID’. Considering the disconcerting effects of COVID-19 and the global dimensions of the pandemic, interdisciplinary cooperation is warranted for the early identification of patients who are at a high risk of developing persistent neuropsychiatric deficits following recovery from acute disease. To this end, it is of paramount importance to ensure that appropriate integrated physical and mental health support is provided, with the aim of mitigating the risks of long-term disability at an individual and societal level.