| Literature DB >> 33341233 |
David A Jans1, Kylie M Wagstaff2.
Abstract
FDA approved for parasitic indications, the small molecule ivermectin has been the focus of growing attention in the last 8 years due to its potential as an antiviral. We first identified ivermectin in a high throughput compound library screen as an agent potently able to inhibit recognition of the nuclear localizing Human Immunodeficiency Virus-1 (HIV-1) integrase protein by the host importin (IMP) α/β1 heterodimer, and recently demonstrated its ability to bind directly to IMPα to cause conformational changes that prevent its function in nuclear import of key viral as well as host proteins. Cell culture experiments have shown robust antiviral action towards a whole range of viruses, including HIV-1, dengue, Zika and West Nile Virus, Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus, Chikungunya, pseudorabies virus, adenovirus, and SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19). Close to 70 clinical trials are currently in progress worldwide for SARS-CoV-2. Although few of these studies have been completed, the results that are available, as well as those from observational/retrospective studies, indicate clinical benefit. Here we discuss the case for ivermectin as a host-directed broad-spectrum antiviral agent, including for SARS-CoV-2.Entities:
Keywords: Antiviral; COVID-19; Dengue virus; Ivermectin; SARS-CoV-2; Zika virus
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2020 PMID: 33341233 PMCID: PMC7577703 DOI: 10.1016/j.bbrc.2020.10.042
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Biochem Biophys Res Commun ISSN: 0006-291X Impact factor: 3.575
Fig. 1Model of IMPα′s role in nuclear transport of host and viral proteins, and mechanism of inhibition by ivermectin. A. Host proteins such as members of the NF-κB transcription factor family localize in the nucleus through IMPα/β1, where the “IBB” (IMPβ-binding) region of IMPα (purple curved line) is bound by IMPβ1 to enable cargo recognition by IMPα within the heterodimer. Subsequently, IMPβ1 mediates transport of the trimeric complex into the nucleus through the nuclear envelope (NE)-embedded nuclear pore (NPC, nuclear pore complex). Release within the nucleus enables the transcription factor to carry out normal function in transcriptional regulation, including in the antiviral response. IMPα cannot mediate nuclear import, unless heterodimerised with IMPβ1. B. In viral infection, specific viral proteins (eg. NS5 in the case of DENV, ZIKV) able to interact with IMPα utilize the IMPα/β1 heterodimer to access the nucleus and antagonize the antiviral response [14,27,28]. This is critical for optimal virus production as shown by mutagenic and inhibitor studies. The SARS-CoV-2 proteins that may access the nucleus via IMPα/β1 in infected cells has not been examined, but in ORF6 (Open Reading Frame 6) protein from SARS-CoV1 has been shown to bind IMPα [29], and ORF4b from MERS-CoV (Middle Eastern Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus) are both known to access the nucleus in NLS-dependent fashion [30]. C. The small molecule ivermectin (structure shown) binds to IMPα (binding site shown as red lozenge) both within the IMPα/β heterodimer to dissociate it, and to free IMPα to prevent it binding to IMPβ1, thereby preventing NS5 nuclear import [11], contributing to reduced virus production. (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the Web version of this article.)
In vitro effects of ivermectin on IMPα.a
| Effect on IMPα | Cargo Protein | |
|---|---|---|
| Virus | Host | |
| Inhibits direct binding of IMPα (ALPHASCREEN/AUC) | HIV IN (IC50 5 μM) {34] | IMPβ1 (IC50 7 μM) [11] |
| DENV1 NS5 (IC50 2 μM)) [8] | ||
| DENV2 NS5 (IC50 1 μM) [7,8,11] | ||
| Hendra V (IC50 15 μM) [13] | ||
| SV40 T-ag [34] | ||
| Cellular Context | ||
Inhibits binding of IMPα in transfected cell context (BiFC/CoIP) | SV40 T-ag [11,20] | |
| DENV2 NS5 ([7,11] | ||
| Adenovirus EIA [20] | ||
Inhibits nuclear accumulation in a transfected cell context of IMPα/β1- (but not β1-) recognised proteins (CLSM) [7] | HIV-IN [7] | TRF1 [7,34] |
| SV40 T-ag [7,16,34] | ||
| DENV2 NS5 [7] | ||
| VEEV Capsid [16] | ||
| adenovirus E1A [20] | ||
| PSV UL42 [18] | ||
| hCMV ppUL44, pUL5 [7] | ||
Reduces nuclear localisation in infected cells | VEEV Capsid [9] | |
| adenovirus E1A [20] | ||
aAbbreviations: HIV-1, human immunodeficiency virus; DENV, dengue virus; VEEV, Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus; PSV, Pseudorabies virus; hCMV, human cytomegalovirus; T-ag, SV40 large T-antigen; DENV, dengue virus; TRF1, telomere repeat factor 1; LPS, lipopolysaccharide.
bInhibits helicase activity (FRET based assay) of DENV2, YFV and WNV NS3 (IC50 0.2–0.5 μM) [12].
Documented antiviral action of ivermectin.a
| Virus | Inhibitory Concentration/Fold reduction (Assay) |
|---|---|
| Coronavirus | |
| SARS-CoV-2 | EC50 = 2.2/2.8 μM/5000-fold reduction (qPCR/released/cell-associated virus) [17] |
| Lentivirus | |
| HIV-1 (VSV-G-pseudotyped NL4-3.Luc.R-E-HIV) | 50 μM > 2-fold reduction (luciferase) [7] |
| Orthomyxovirus | |
| Influenza VLPs (avian influenza A/MxA escape mutants) | 10 μM total inhibition (luciferase) [10] |
| Flavivirus: | |
| YFV (17D) | EC50 = 5/0.5 nM (CPE/qPCR) [12]/3 μM > 50,000-fold reduction (pfu) [15] |
| DENV1 (EDEN-1) | EC50 = 2.3/3 μM (CFI, 2 hosts) [8]/EC50 = 0.7 μM (qPCR) [12] |
| DENV2 (NGC) | EC50 = 0.4/0.6 μM (pfu/qPCR) [11]/50 μM total inhibition (pfu) [7] |
| DENV2 (EDEN-2) | EC50 = 2.1/1.7 μM (CFI, 2 hosts) [8] |
| DENV3 (EDEN-3) | EC50 = 1.7 μM (CFI) [8] |
| DENV4 (EDEN-4) | EC50 = 1.9 μM (CFI) [8] |
| WNV (NY99) | EC50 = 4 μM (qPCR) [12] |
| WNV (MRM61C) | EC50 = 1/0.5 μM (pfu/qPCR) [11] |
| ZIKV (Asian/Cook Islands/2014) | EC50 = 1.3/1.6 μM (pfu/qPCR) [11] |
| Alphavirus: | |
| Chikungunya virus (CHIKV-Rluc) | EC50 = 1.9/0.6 μM (luciferase, 2 hosts)/3 μM > 5000-fold reduction (pfu) [15] |
| Sindbis (HR) | 3 μM > 1000-fold (pfu) [15] |
| Semlicki Forest Virus | 3 μM > 200-fold (pfu) [15] |
| VEEV (TC83) | 1 μM c. 20-fold (pfu) [9] |
| Henipavirus: | |
| Hendra (Hendra virus/Australia/Horse/1994) | est. EC50 = 2 μM (TCID/luciferase) [13] |
| DNA viruses | |
| Adenovirus (HAdV-C5) | EC50 = c. 2.5 μM; 10 μM 20-fold reduction (qPCR) [20] |
| Adenovirus (HAdV-B3) | 10 μM c. 8-fold reduction (qPCR) [20] |
| BK polyomavirus (BKPyV) | Est. EC50 1.5 μM (pfu/CPE/qPCR) [19] |
| Pseudorabies | Est. EC50 c. 0.8 μM 1000-fold [18] |
aIn vitro
bInhibits helicase activity (FRET based assay) of DENV2, YFV and WNV NS3 (IC50 0.2–0.5 μM) [12].
Abbreviations: HIV-1, human immunodeficiency virus; VLP, virus like particle; PSV, Pseudorabies virus; YFV (yellow fever virus); DENV, dengue virus; ZIKV, zika virus; WNV, West Nile virus; TCID; pfu, plaque forming unit (infectious virus assay); CPE, cytopathic effects; qPCR, quantitative polymerase chain reaction; CFI, cell fluorescence-based immunofluorescence assay.
Summary of Current Clinical Trials using Ivermectin for SARS-CoV-2.
| Title, URL | Status | N | Interventions | Start | Locations | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ivermectin Effect on SARS-CoV-2 Replication in Patients With COVID-19; | R | 45 | 18.5.20 | CEMIC, Buenos Aires, Ciudad De Buenos Aires, Argentina | |
| 2 | Ivermectin and Nitazoxanide Combination Therapy for COVID-19; | NY | 100 | 20.5.20 | Tanta University, Egypt | |
| 3 | Ivermectin vs. Placebo for the Treatment of Patients With Mild to Moderate COVID-19; | R | 100 | 12.5.20 | Sheba Medical Center, Ramat-Gan, Israel | |
| 4 | Hydroxychloroquine and Ivermectin for the Treatment of COVID-19 Infection; | A | 200 | 4.5.20 | Jose Manuel Arreola Guerra, Aguascalientes, Mexico | |
| 5 | Efficacy of Ivermectin in Adult Patients With Early Stages of COVID-19; | R | 400 | 20.6.20 | Colombia | |
| 6 | Ivermectin In Treatment of COVID 19 Patients; | R | 100 | 9.6.20 | Isolation and referral hospitals for COVID 19 patients, Cairo, Egypt | |
| 7 | Efficacy and Safety of Ivermectin and Doxycycline in Combination or IVE Alone in Patients With COVID-19 Infection; | E | 72 | 16.6.20 | ICDDR, Dhaka, Bangladesh | |
| 8 | Efficacy of Ivermectin as Add on Therapy in COVID19 Patients; | C | 100 | 18.4.20 | General Directorate of Medical City, Bagdad, Baghdad, Iraq | |
| 9 | COVidIVERmectin: Ivermectin for Treatment of Covid-19 (COVER); | R | 102 | 20.6.20 | Negrar, Verona, Italy; Bologna, Italy; Milan, Italy; Rovereto, Italy; Turin, Italy; Barcelona, Spain; Madrid, Spain | |
| 10 | Efficacy, Safety and Tolerability of Ivermectin in Subjects Infected With SARS-CoV-2 With or Without Symptoms (SILVERBULLET); | NY | 66 | 20.6.20 | Investigacion Biomedica para el Desarrollo de Farmacos S.A. de C.V., Mexico | |
| 11 | Sars-CoV-2/COVID-19 Ivermectin Navarra-ISGlobal Trial (SAINT); | A | 24 | 14.5.20 | Clinica Universidad de Navarra, Pamplona, Navarra, Spain | |
| 12 | A Comparative Study on Ivermectin and Hydroxychloroquine on the COVID19 Patients in Bangladesh; | C | 116 | 2.5.20 | Chakoria Upazilla Health Complex, Cox's Bazar, Bangladesh | |
| 13 | Ivermectin vs Combined Hydroxychloroquine and Antiretroviral Drugs (ART) Among Asymptomatic COVID-19 Infection (IDRA-COVID19); | NY | 80 | 20.7.20 | Siriraj Hospital, Bangkok Noi, Bangkok, Thailand | |
| 14 | IVERMECTIN Aspirin Dexametasone and Enoxaparin as Treatment of Covid 19; | A | 100 | 1.5.20 | Hospital Eurnekian, Buenos Aires, Argentina | |
| 15 | A Preventive Treatment for Migrant Workers at High-risk of Covid-19; | C | 5000 | 13.5.20 | Tuas South Dormitory, Singapore, Singapore | |
| 16 | New Antiviral Drugs for Treatment of COVID-19; | NY | 100 | 20.5.20 | Mansoura University, Mansoura, Select A State Or Province, Egypt | |
| 17 | Early Treatment With Ivermectin and LosarTAN for Cancer Patients With COVID-19 Infection (TITAN); | R | 176 | 20.7.20 | Instituto do Cancer do Estado de São Paulo, Brazil | |
| 18 | Ivermectin in Treatment of COVID-19; | R | 100 | 31.5.20 | Waheed Shouman, Zagazig, Sharkia, Egypt | |
| 19 | Efficacy of Ivermectin in COVID-19; | R | 100 | 15.4.20 | Combined Military Hospital Lahore, Lahore, Punjab, Pakistan | |
| 20 | Ivermectin and Doxycycine in COVID-19 Treatment; | R | 40 | 1.6.20 | Sherief Abd-Elsalam, Tanta, Egypt | |
| 21 | The Efficacy of Ivermectin and Nitazoxanide in COVID-19 Treatment; | R | 300 | 16.6.20 | Tanta University, Tanta, Egypt | |
| 22 | Prophylactic Ivermectin in COVID-19 Contacts; | C | 304 | 31.5.20 | Zagazig University, Zagazig, Sharkia, Egypt | |
| 23 | Max Ivermectin- COVID 19 Study Versus Standard of Care Treatment for COVID 19 Cases. A Pilot Study; | R | 50 | 25.4.20 | Max Super Speciality Hospital, Saket (A unit of Devki Devi Foundation), New Delhi, Delhi, India | |
| 24 | A Study to Compare the Efficacy and Safety of Different Doses of Ivermectin for COVID-19 (IFORS); | R | 64 | 1.7.20 | Hospital Univeristário da Universidade Federal de São Carlos (HU-UFSCar), São Carlos, São Paulo, Brazil | |
| 25 | Novel Agents for Treatment of High-risk COVID-19 Positive Patients; | R | 240 | 1.5.20 | University of Kentucky Markey Cancer Center, Lexington, Kentucky, United States | |
| 26 | Ivermectin-Azithromycin-Cholecalciferol (IvAzCol) Combination Therapy for COVID-19; | C | 30 | 15.3.20 | Outpatient treatment, Mexico City, Mexico | |
| 27 | USEFULNESS of Topic Ivermectin and Carrageenan to Prevent Contagion of Covid 19 (IVERCAR); | A | 1195 | 1.6.20 | Hospital Eurnekian, Buenos Aires, Argentina | |
| 28 | Novel Regimens in COVID-19 Treatment; | NY | 80 | 8.5.20 | Tanta University, Egypt | |
| 29 | Anti-Androgen Treatment for COVID-19; | R | 254 | 26.6.20 | Corpometria Institute, Brasilia, Brazil | |
| 30 | A Real-life Experience on Treatment of Patients With COVID 19; | R | 120 | 16.6.20 | Tanta University Hospital, Tanta, Egypt | |
| 31 | Worldwide Trends on COVID-19 Research After the Declaration of COVID-19 Pandemic (observational); | NY | 200 | Completed interventional vs. completed observational studies on | 25.7.20 | Qassim University, Saudi Arabia |
| 32 | Trial of Combination Therapy to Treat COVID-19 Infection; | NY | 300 | 22.7.20 | ProgenaBiome, California, USA | |
| 33 | Randomised clinical trial of ivermectin for treatment and prophylaxis of COVID-19; | O | 266 | 8.5.20 | Fundació Assistencial Mútua Terrassa, Spain | |
| 34 | Multicenter, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study investigating efficacy, safety and tolerability of ivermectin HUVE-19 in patients with proven SARS-CoV-2 infection (COVID-19) and manifested clinical symptoms; | O | 120 | 5.5.20 | Bulgaria (9 sites) | |
| 35 | Efficacy of hydroxychloroquine, ciclesonide and ivermectin in treatment of moderate covid-19 illness: an open-label randomised controlled study (EHYCIVER-COVID); | NY | 120 | 15.5.20 | New Delhi, India | |
| 36 | A Phase IIB open label randomized controlled trial to evaluate the efficacy and safety of Ivermectin in reducing viral loads in patients with hematological disorders who are admitted with COVID 19 infection; | NY | 50 | 27.5.20 | Christian Medical College Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India | |
| 37 | Interventional study to assess the efficacy of Ivermectin with standard of care treatment versus standard of care in patients of COVID-19 at R D Gardi Medical College, Ujjain, India; | NY | 50 | 24.5.20 | R D Gardi Medical College, Ujjain, Madhya Pradesh, India | |
| 38 | Study to assess the efficacy of Ivermectin as prophylaxis of COVID 19 among health care workers and COVID 19 contacts in Ujjain, India; | NY | 2000 | 27.5.20 | R D Gardi Medical College, Ujjain, Madhya Pradesh, India | |
| 39 | Randomised Controlled Trial of Ivermectin in hospitalised patients with COVID19 (RIVET-COV); | NY | 60 | 25.6.20 | New Delhi, India | |
| 40 | A Prospective, randomized, single centred, open labelled, two arm, placebo-controlled trial to evaluate efficacy and safety of Ivermectin drug in patients infected with SARS-CoV-2 virus; | NY | 100 | 18.6.20 | Symbiosis University Hospital and Research Centre, Maharashtra, India | |
| 41 | A Clinical Trial to Study the Efficacy of “Ivermectin” in the prevention of Covid-19. A Single Arm Study; | NY | 50 | 10.7.20 | DVFM, Andhra Pradesh, India | |
| 42 | Ivermectin Nasal Spray for COVID19 Patients; | NY | 60 | 10.8.20 | Tanta University, Tanta, Egypt | |
| 43 | Outpatient use of ivermectin in COVID-19; | NY | 200 | 26.8.20 | Temple University Hospital, Philadelphia, USA | |
| 44 | Ivermectin to prevent hospitilizations in COVID-19; | R | 500 | 21.8.20 | Ministry of Public Health, Province of Corrientes, Argentina | |
| 45 | Clinical trial of ivermectin plus doxycycline for the treatment of confirmed Covid-19 infection; | C | 400 | 19.8.20 | Dhaka Medical College, Dhaka Bangladesh | |
| 46 | Pilot study to evaluate the potential of ivermectin to reduce COVID-19 transmission; | O | 24 | 8.5.20 | Clinica Universidad de Navarra, Pamplona, Spain | |
| 47 | Dose-Finding study of Ivermectin treatment on patients infected with Covid-19:A clinical trial; | A | 125 | 4.5.20 | Qazvin University of Medical Sciences, Qazvin, Iran | |
| 48 | In vivo use of ivermectin (IVR) for treatment for corona virus infected patients: a randomized controlled trial; | NY | 60 | 10.6.20 | Rayak Hospital, Riyaq, Lebanon | |
| 49 | A randomized clinical trial study, comparison of the therapeutic effects of Ivermectin, Kaletra and Chloroquine with Kaletra and Chloroquine in the treatment of patients with coronavirus 2019 (COVID-19); | A | 60 | 30.5.20 | Ahvaz Razi Hospital, Ahvaz, Iran | |
| 50 | A double-blind clinical trial to repurpose and assess the efficacy and safety of ivermectin in COVID-19; | R | 45 | 23.4.20 | Lagos University Teaching Hospital, Lagos, Nigeria | |
| 51 | Effectiveness of Ivermectin in the Treatment of Coronavirus Infection in Patients admitted to Educational Hospitals of Mazandaran in 2020; | R | 60 | 21.5.20 | Bouali Hospital, Sari, Iran | |
| 52 | Sub-cutaneous Ivermectin in Combination With and Without Oral Zinc and Nigella Sativa: a Placebo Randomized Control Trial on Mild to Moderate COVID-19 Patients; | R | 40 | 14.7.20 | Shaikh Zayed Hospital, Lahore, Pakistan | |
| 53 | Pragmatic study "CORIVER": Ivermectin as antiviral treatment for patients infected by SARS-COV2 (COVID-19); | O | 45 | 22.7.20 | Hospital Universitario Virgen de las Nieves, Granada, Spain | |
| 54 | Effectiveness and Safety of Ivermectin for the Prevention of Covid-19 Infection in Colombian Health Personnel at All Levels of Care, During the 2020 Pandemic: A Randomized Clinical Controlled Trial; | NY | 550 | 7.9.20 | Pontificia Universidad Javeriana, Valle Del Cauca, Colombia | |
| 55 | Ivermectin Inhalation Forms in the Management of COVID-19 Egyptian Patients; | NY | 60 | 10.8.20 | Tanta University, Tanta, Egypt | |
| 56 | Safety and Efficacy of Ivermectin and Doxycycline in Treatment of Covid-19. | NY | 188 | 16.9.20 | Bangladesh Medical College Hospital, Dhaka, Bangladesh | |
| 57 | Comparative Study of Hydroxychloroquine and Ivermectin in Covid-19 Prophylaxis; | R | 400 | 12.5.20 | Drug Research and Development Centre, Federal University of Ceará, Ceará, Brazil | |
| 58 | Assessment of response of ivermectin on virological clearance in COVID 19 patients; | NY | 56 | 26.08.20 | Maulana Azad Medical College, New Delhi, India | |
| 59 | Evaluation of the effect of ivermectin on patients with COVID-19; | C | 130 | 23.08.20 | Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran | |
| 60 | Prophylactic Ivermectin in COVID 19 Contacts http://ctri.nic.in/Clinicaltrials; CTRI/2020/08/027282 | NY | 180 | 20.08.20 | Government Institute of Medical Sciences Greater Noida, Uttar Pradesh, India | |
| 61 | Ivermectin as a possible treatment for COVID-19; | NY | 90 | 18.08.20 | AAIMS, Patna, India | |
| 62 | Evaluating the effect of Ivermectin on covid 19 patients; | R | 60 | 06.08.20 | Ahvaz University of Medical Sciences, Ahvaz, Iran | |
| 63 | Evaluate the Efficacy of Siddha Treatment in Patients with Novel Coronavirus Infectious Disease; | R | 100 | 05.08.20 | Indian Medicine and Homeopathy Department, Tamil Nadu, India | |
| 64 | Ivermectin effect in the treatment of patients with covid-19; | R | 40 | 20.07.20 | Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran | |
| 65 | Randomized phase IIA clinical trial to compare the efficacy of ivermectin versus placebo to obtain negative PCR results in patients with early phase Covid-19; PER-034-20 | R | 68 | 17.07.20 | Universidad Peruana Cayetano Heredia, Lima, Peru | |
| 66 | Evaluation of ivermectin effects on Covid-19; | R | 50 | 22.08.20 | Kermanshah University of Medial Sciences, Kermanshah, Iran | |
| 67 | A placebo-controlled, randomized, double-blind study in COvid-19 patients with iveRmectin; An inVEstigator iniTiaTEd trial (CORVETTE-01); jRCT2031200120 | R | 240 | 16.09.20 | Kitasato University Hospital, Kanagawa, Japan | |
| 68 | A single-centre, open-label, randomized controlled study of ivermectin treated mild to moderate COVID-19 cases; Debidwar Upazila Health Complex | C | 62 | 01.05.20 | Debidwar Upazila Health Complex, Comilla, Bangladesh |
R, Recruiting, NY, Not yet recruiting, A, Active not recruiting, C, Completed, E, Enrolling by invitation, O, ongoing.
Number of patients.
SC, standard care, QD, once per day, BID, twice daily, QID, 4 times daily, TID, 3 times daily, PPE, personal protective equipment, vs. versus, HCQ, hydroxychloroquine; DOC, doxycycline; CQ, chloroquine, ATM, Azithromycin, NZX, Nanozoxide
Raw data for asymptomatic family close contacts of confirmed COVID patients show that 2 doses of ivermectin 72 h apart resulted in only 7.4% of 203 subjects reporting symptoms of SARS-CoV-2 infection, in contrast to 101 control untreated subjects, of whom 58.4% reported symptoms; evidence of prophylaxis by ivermectin.
Recovery rate of the 28 patients that received ivermectin/AZM/cholecalciferol was 100%, with mean symptomatic recovery 3.6 days (negative PCR confirmed day 10). Imaging on day 10 showed improvement in all patients with pneumonia. Authors conclude the combination therapy might mitigate disease progression without significant adverse effects but further studies required (preferably controlled) [46].
Preliminary results for 1195 subjects consistent with prophylaxis effected by ivermectin/carrageenan topical combination [47].
Raw data shows a significant reduction in the number of 183 patients with late clinical recovery (requiring >12 days to show clinical improvement) in the ivermectin/DOC group compared to placebo (23 versus 37.2%), as well as a significant reduction (8.7 versus 17.8%) in patients showing clinical deterioration (from mild/moderate to moderate or severe), and a significant reduction (7.7 versus 20%) in persistent Covid-19 positive patients at 14 days compared to 180 control patients; evidence of efficacy for ivermectin/DOC.
No statistically significant clinical benefit in 32 treated subjects compared to 30 subjects given placebo, but authors concluded study requires confirmation with larger numbers of subjects [48].