Gabriela K Khazanov1, Colin Xu2, Steven D Hollon3, Robert J DeRubeis2, Michael E Thase4. 1. Mental Illness Research, Education, and Clinical Center of the Veterans Integrated Service Network 4, Crescenz Veterans Affairs Medical Center. Electronic address: gabriela.khazanov@va.gov. 2. Department of Psychology, University of Pennsylvania. 3. Department of Psychology, Vanderbilt University. 4. Mental Illness Research, Education, and Clinical Center of the Veterans Integrated Service Network 4, Crescenz Veterans Affairs Medical Center.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Psychotherapy for depression and antidepressant medications have both been associated with decreases in suicidal ideation. Studies have not examined whether adding psychotherapy to antidepressant medications further reduces suicidal ideation relative to medications alone in adults. METHODS: Participants (N = 452) were randomized to 7 months of treatment with antidepressant medications or combined treatment with both medications and cognitive therapy for depression. We examined change in the suicide items from the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) and Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS) across treatment using Bayesian generalized linear mixed models for non-continuous outcomes. RESULTS: Suicidal ideation decreased across treatment. When measured with the BDI, participants receiving both cognitive therapy and antidepressant medications showed 17% greater reductions in suicidal ideation relative to those receiving medications alone; this effect remained significant when controlling for depression severity. While the same pattern was observed when suicidal ideation was measured with the HDRS, the effect was smaller (7%) and not statistically significant. When BDI and HDRS scores were combined, participants receiving both therapy and medications showed 9% greater reductions in suicidal ideation relative to those receiving medications alone; this effect was marginally significant when controlling for depression severity. LIMITATIONS: This is a secondary analysis of a randomized clinical trial designed to treat depression, in which suicidal ideation was assessed using single-item measures. CONCLUSIONS: Adding cognitive therapy to antidepressant medications may reduce suicidal ideation to a greater extent than medications alone. Pending replication, combination treatment may be preferred for individuals with suicidal ideation. TRIAL REGISTRATION: clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT00057577. Published by Elsevier B.V.
BACKGROUND: Psychotherapy for depression and antidepressant medications have both been associated with decreases in suicidal ideation. Studies have not examined whether adding psychotherapy to antidepressant medications further reduces suicidal ideation relative to medications alone in adults. METHODS: Participants (N = 452) were randomized to 7 months of treatment with antidepressant medications or combined treatment with both medications and cognitive therapy for depression. We examined change in the suicide items from the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) and Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS) across treatment using Bayesian generalized linear mixed models for non-continuous outcomes. RESULTS: Suicidal ideation decreased across treatment. When measured with the BDI, participants receiving both cognitive therapy and antidepressant medications showed 17% greater reductions in suicidal ideation relative to those receiving medications alone; this effect remained significant when controlling for depression severity. While the same pattern was observed when suicidal ideation was measured with the HDRS, the effect was smaller (7%) and not statistically significant. When BDI and HDRS scores were combined, participants receiving both therapy and medications showed 9% greater reductions in suicidal ideation relative to those receiving medications alone; this effect was marginally significant when controlling for depression severity. LIMITATIONS: This is a secondary analysis of a randomized clinical trial designed to treat depression, in which suicidal ideation was assessed using single-item measures. CONCLUSIONS: Adding cognitive therapy to antidepressant medications may reduce suicidal ideation to a greater extent than medications alone. Pending replication, combination treatment may be preferred for individuals with suicidal ideation. TRIAL REGISTRATION: clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT00057577. Published by Elsevier B.V.
Authors: Kelly L Green; Gregory K Brown; Shari Jager-Hyman; Jason Cha; Robert A Steer; Aaron T Beck Journal: J Clin Psychiatry Date: 2015-12 Impact factor: 4.384
Authors: Charles H Kellner; Max Fink; Rebecca Knapp; Georgios Petrides; Mustafa Husain; Teresa Rummans; Martina Mueller; Hilary Bernstein; Keith Rasmussen; Kevin O'connor; Glenn Smith; A John Rush; Melanie Biggs; Shawn McClintock; Samuel Bailine; Chitra Malur Journal: Am J Psychiatry Date: 2005-05 Impact factor: 18.112
Authors: M E Thase; J B Greenhouse; E Frank; C F Reynolds; P A Pilkonis; K Hurley; V Grochocinski; D J Kupfer Journal: Arch Gen Psychiatry Date: 1997-11
Authors: John S March; Susan Silva; Stephen Petrycki; John Curry; Karen Wells; John Fairbank; Barbara Burns; Marisa Domino; Steven McNulty; Benedetto Vitiello; Joanne Severe Journal: Arch Gen Psychiatry Date: 2007-10
Authors: Anoop D Shah; Jonathan W Bartlett; James Carpenter; Owen Nicholas; Harry Hemingway Journal: Am J Epidemiol Date: 2014-01-12 Impact factor: 4.897