With the ongoing COVID-19 (Coronavirus Disease 2019) pandemic, caused by the novel coronavirus SARS-CoV-2 (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2), there is a need for sensitive, specific, and affordable diagnostic tests to identify infected individuals, not all of whom are symptomatic. The most sensitive test involves the detection of viral RNA using RT-qPCR (quantitative reverse transcription PCR), with many commercial kits now available for this purpose. However, these are expensive, and supply of such kits in sufficient numbers cannot always be guaranteed. We therefore developed a multiplex assay using well-established SARS-CoV-2 targets alongside a human cellular control (RPP30) and a viral spike-in control (Phocine Herpes Virus 1 [PhHV-1]), which monitor sample quality and nucleic acid extraction efficiency, respectively. Here, we establish that this test performs as well as widely used commercial assays, but at substantially reduced cost. Furthermore, we demonstrate >1,000-fold variability in material routinely collected by combined nose and throat swabbing and establish a statistically significant correlation between the detected level of human and SARS-CoV-2 nucleic acids. The inclusion of the human control probe in our assay therefore provides a quantitative measure of sample quality that could help reduce false-negative rates. We demonstrate the feasibility of establishing a robust RT-qPCR assay at approximately 10% of the cost of equivalent commercial assays, which could benefit low-resource environments and make high-volume testing affordable.
With the ongoing COVID-19 (n class="Disease">Coronavirus Disease 2019) pandemic, caused by the novel coronavirusSARS-CoV-2 (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2), there is a need for sensitive, specific, and affordable diagnostic tests to identify infected individuals, not all of whom are symptomatic. The most sensitive test involves the detection of viral RNA using RT-qPCR (quantitative reverse transcription PCR), with many commercial kits now available for this purpose. However, these are expensive, and supply of such kits in sufficient numbers cannot always be guaranteed. We therefore developed a multiplex assay using well-established SARS-CoV-2 targets alongside a human cellular control (RPP30) and a viral spike-in control (Phocine Herpes Virus 1 [PhHV-1]), which monitor sample quality and nucleic acid extraction efficiency, respectively. Here, we establish that this test performs as well as widely used commercial assays, but at substantially reduced cost. Furthermore, we demonstrate >1,000-fold variability in material routinely collected by combined nose and throat swabbing and establish a statistically significant correlation between the detected level of human and SARS-CoV-2 nucleic acids. The inclusion of the human control probe in our assay therefore provides a quantitative measure of sample quality that could help reduce false-negative rates. We demonstrate the feasibility of establishing a robust RT-qPCR assay at approximately 10% of the cost of equivalent commercial assays, which could benefit low-resource environments and make high-volume testing affordable.
Authors: Stephen A Bustin; Vladimir Benes; Jeremy A Garson; Jan Hellemans; Jim Huggett; Mikael Kubista; Reinhold Mueller; Tania Nolan; Michael W Pfaffl; Gregory L Shipley; Jo Vandesompele; Carl T Wittwer Journal: Clin Chem Date: 2009-02-26 Impact factor: 8.327
Authors: Peter J A Cock; Tiago Antao; Jeffrey T Chang; Brad A Chapman; Cymon J Cox; Andrew Dalke; Iddo Friedberg; Thomas Hamelryck; Frank Kauff; Bartek Wilczynski; Michiel J L de Hoon Journal: Bioinformatics Date: 2009-03-20 Impact factor: 6.937
Authors: Chantal B F Vogels; Anderson F Brito; Anne L Wyllie; Joseph R Fauver; Isabel M Ott; Chaney C Kalinich; Mary E Petrone; Arnau Casanovas-Massana; M Catherine Muenker; Adam J Moore; Jonathan Klein; Peiwen Lu; Alice Lu-Culligan; Xiaodong Jiang; Daniel J Kim; Eriko Kudo; Tianyang Mao; Miyu Moriyama; Ji Eun Oh; Annsea Park; Julio Silva; Eric Song; Takehiro Takahashi; Manabu Taura; Maria Tokuyama; Arvind Venkataraman; Orr-El Weizman; Patrick Wong; Yexin Yang; Nagarjuna R Cheemarla; Elizabeth B White; Sarah Lapidus; Rebecca Earnest; Bertie Geng; Pavithra Vijayakumar; Camila Odio; John Fournier; Santos Bermejo; Shelli Farhadian; Charles S Dela Cruz; Akiko Iwasaki; Albert I Ko; Marie L Landry; Ellen F Foxman; Nathan D Grubaugh Journal: Nat Microbiol Date: 2020-07-10 Impact factor: 30.964
Authors: Jie Yang; Yang Song; Xiangyu Deng; Jeffrey A Vanegas; Zheng You; Yuxuan Zhang; Zhengyan Weng; Lori Avery; Kevin D Dieckhaus; Advaith Peddi; Yang Gao; Yi Zhang; Xue Gao Journal: Nat Chem Biol Date: 2022-09-22 Impact factor: 16.174
Authors: Kimberly S Butler; Bryan D Carson; Joshua D Podlevsky; Cathryn M Mayes; Jessica M Rowland; DeAnna Campbell; J Bryce Ricken; George Wudiri; Jerilyn A Timlin Journal: Sci Rep Date: 2022-10-22 Impact factor: 4.996
Authors: Maria Jose Lista; Pedro M Matos; Thomas J A Maguire; Kate Poulton; Elena Ortiz-Zapater; Robert Page; Helin Sertkaya; Ana M Ortega-Prieto; Aoife M O'Byrne; Clement Bouton; Ruth E Dickenson; Mattia Ficarelli; Jose M Jimenez-Guardeño; Mark Howard; Gilberto Betancor; Rui Pedro Galao; Suzanne Pickering; Adrian W Signell; Harry Wilson; Penelope Cliff; Mark Tan Kia Ik; Amita Patel; Eithne MacMahon; Emma Cunningham; Katie Doores; Monica Agromayor; Juan Martin-Serrano; Esperanza Perucha; Hannah E Mischo; Manu Shankar-Hari; Rahul Batra; Jonathan Edgeworth; Mark Zuckerman; Michael H Malim; Stuart Neil; Rocio Teresa Martinez-Nunez Journal: medRxiv Date: 2021-04-10
Authors: Maria Jose Lista; Pedro M Matos; Thomas J A Maguire; Kate Poulton; Elena Ortiz-Zapater; Robert Page; Helin Sertkaya; Ana M Ortega-Prieto; Edward Scourfield; Aoife M O'Byrne; Clement Bouton; Ruth E Dickenson; Mattia Ficarelli; Jose M Jimenez-Guardeño; Mark Howard; Gilberto Betancor; Rui Pedro Galao; Suzanne Pickering; Adrian W Signell; Harry Wilson; Penelope Cliff; Mark Tan Kia Ik; Amita Patel; Eithne MacMahon; Emma Cunningham; Katie Doores; Monica Agromayor; Juan Martin-Serrano; Esperanza Perucha; Hannah E Mischo; Manu Shankar-Hari; Rahul Batra; Jonathan Edgeworth; Mark Zuckerman; Michael H Malim; Stuart Neil; Rocio Teresa Martinez-Nunez Journal: PLoS One Date: 2021-09-15 Impact factor: 3.752
Authors: Zuzana Dankova; Elena Novakova; Maria Skerenova; Veronika Holubekova; Vincent Lucansky; Dana Dvorska; Dusan Brany; Zuzana Kolkova; Jan Strnadel; Sandra Mersakova; Katarina Janikova; Marek Samec; Michal Pokusa; Martin Petras; Miroslava Sarlinova; Ivana Kasubova; Dusan Loderer; Vladimira Sadlonova; Jana Kompanikova; Nina Kotlebova; Adriana Kompanikova; Martina Hrnciarova; Andrea Stanclova; Martina Antosova; Anton Dzian; Vladimir Nosal; Ivan Kocan; Dalibor Murgas; Dusan Krkoska; Andrea Calkovska; Erika Halasova Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2021-07-01 Impact factor: 3.390
Authors: Antoine Vallatos; James M Maguire; Nikolas Pilavakis; Gabrielis Cerniauskas; Alexander Sturtivant; Alexander J Speakman; Steve Gourlay; Scott Inglis; Graham McCall; Andrew Davie; Mike Boyd; Adriana A S Tavares; Connor Doherty; Sharen Roberts; Paul Aitken; Mark Mason; Scott Cummings; Andrew Mullen; Gordon Paterson; Matthew Proudfoot; Sean Brady; Steven Kesterton; Fraser Queen; Steve Fletcher; Andrew Sherlock; Katherine E Dunn Journal: Front Med Technol Date: 2021-08-02