| Literature DB >> 33257490 |
Irene Gil-González1, Agustín Martín-Rodríguez2, Rupert Conrad3, María Ángeles Pérez-San-Gregorio2.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: In recent years, quality of life (QoL) in multiple sclerosis (MS) has been gaining considerable importance in clinical research and practice. Against this backdrop, this systematic review aimed to provide a broad overview of clinical, sociodemographic and psychosocial risk and protective factors for QoL in adults with MS and analyse psychological interventions for improving QoL.Entities:
Keywords: adult neurology; mental health; multiple sclerosis
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 33257490 PMCID: PMC7705559 DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041249
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Open ISSN: 2044-6055 Impact factor: 2.692
Figure 1Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) flow diagram of selection process. MS, multiple sclerosis; QoL, quality of life.
Methodological quality of articles (n=106)
| Inclusion criteria | Design | Attrition | Attrition between groups | Exclusion after | Follow-up period | Occasion of measurement | Same pre–post measurement | Normalisation of DV measurement | Control techniques | Construct definition | Imputing missing data | |||||||||||
| Yes | No or N/A* | Pre-experimental | Quasi experimental | Experimental | Yes | No or N/A* | Yes | No or N/A* | Yes | No or N/A* | Yes | No or N/A* | One | Two or more | Yes | No | Yes | No or N/A* | Yes | No or N/A* | ||
| 99 | 1 | 7.7 | 33.7 | 58.7 | 48.1 | 51.9 | 28.9 | 62.9 | 22.1 | 77.9 | 32.7 | 67.3 | 70.2 | 29.8 | 70.2 | 29.8 | 100 | 70.2 | 29.8 | 100 | 19.2 | 80.8 |
*No or N/A=the item is not proceeded or does not appear.
Characteristics of included articles
| Authors, | Study design | Quality of life measurement | Sample size (N) | Main results | |
| Risk factors | Protective factors | ||||
| Gupta | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 12 (SF-12) | N=74 451 | EDSS (PCS) | |
| Gross | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=810 | Progressive MS type (PCS) | |
| Zhang | Cross-sectional | EuroQol 5-Dimensions (EQ-5D) | N=1958 | Progressive MS type onset | |
| Rezapour | Cross- sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=171 | Relapses in the last 3 months | Mild EDSS |
| Marck | Cross- sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=2296 | Pain | |
| Milinis | Cross- sectional | Leeds MS Quality of Life Scale (MSQoL) | N=701 | Spasticity | |
| Zettl | Cross- sectional | EuroQol 5-Dimensions (EQ-5D) | N=414 | Spasticity | |
| Leonavicius | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=137 | Fatigue (MCS) | |
| Garg | Cross- sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=89 | Fatigue | |
| Fernández-Muñoz | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=108 | Fatigue | |
| Weiland | Cross-sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=2738 | Fatigue | |
| Aygünoğlu | Cross- sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=120 | Fatigue | |
| Vister | Cross- sectional | WHO Disability Assessment Schedule (WHODAS) 2.0 | N=210 | Fatigue | |
| Tabrizi | Cross- sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=217 | Fatigue | |
| White | Cross- sectional | EuroQol 5-Dimensions (EQ-5D) | N=531 | Sleep disorder | |
| Barin | Cross- sectional | EuroQol 5-Dimensions (EQ-5D) | N=855 | Fatigue | |
| Kratz | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=180 | Fatigue (MCS) | |
| Colbeck | Cross- sectional | RAND-36 Health Item Survey (RAND-36) | N=30 | Cognitive fatigue | |
| Grech | Cross- sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=107 | Cognitive inflexibility | |
| Sgaramella | Cross- sectional | Quality of life questionnaire (QoL) | N=39 | Executive function | |
| Khalaf | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=1048 | Lower urinary tract symptoms | |
| Vitkova | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=223 | Bladder dysfunction (PCS) | |
| Qaderi | Cross- sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=132 | Sexual problems | |
| Schairer | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 12 (SF-12) | N=6138 | Sexual dysfunction | |
| Ma | Cross- sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Impact Scale (MSIS-29) | N=231 | Sleep disorders | |
| Hernández-Ledesma | Cross- sectional | WHO Quality of Life Questionnaire (WHOQoL-BREF) | N=26 | Problem avoidance | Problem resolution |
| Grech | Cross- sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=107 | Behavioural disengagement | Acceptance |
| Zengin | Cross- sectional | WHO Quality of Life Questionnaire (WHOQoL-BREF) | N=214 | Self-distraction | Planning |
| Farran | Cross- sectional | Multiple Sclerosis International Quality of Life Questionnaire (MusiQoL) | N=34 | Self-criticism | Emotional social support |
| Mikula | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=113 | Problem focused coping | |
| Van Damme | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=117 | Acceptance (PCS and MCS) | |
| Wilski | Cross- sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Impact Scale (MSIS-29) | N=257 | Self-efficacy | |
| Nery-Hurwit | Cross- sectional | Function Neutral Health-Related Quality of Life Short Form (FuNHRQoL-SF) | N=259 | Resilience | |
| Calandri | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 12 (SF-12) | N=90 | Sense of coherence | |
| Fernández-Muñoz | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=108 | Depression | |
| Pham | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 12 (SF-12) | N=310 | Anxiety | |
| Prisnie | Longitudinal (T1=basal level/T2=2 weeks later) | Short Form Health Survey 12 (SF-12) | N=139 | Anxiety | |
| Alsaadi | Cross- sectional | WHO Quality of Life Questionnaire (WHOQoL-BREF) | N=80 | Anxiety | |
| Labiano-Fontcuberta | Cross- sectional | Functional Assessment of Multiple Sclerosis (FAMS) | N=157 | Depression | |
| Paziuc | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=60 | Trait anxiety | Extraversion |
| Phillips | Cross-seccional | WHO Quality of Life Questionnaire (WHOQoL-BREF) | N=32 | Emotional problems | |
| Salhofer-Polanyi | Cross-sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=139 | Depressive temperament | Hyperthymic temperament |
| Demirci | Cross-sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=74 | Type D personality | |
| Mikula | Cross-sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=116 | Social participation (MCS y PCS) | |
| Costa | Cross-sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=150 | Social support | |
| Nakazawa | Cross-sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=63 | EDSS level | Resilience |
| Ciampi | Cross-sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Impact Scale (MSIS-29) | N=43 | EDSS level | |
| Fernández-Jiménez | Cross-sectional | Functional Assessment of Multiple Sclerosis (FAMS) | N=97 | EDSS level | |
| Klevan | Cross-sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=93 | EDSS (PCS) | |
| Williams | Cross-sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=447 | Pain (PCS) | |
| Hyncicova | Cross-sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=67 | Number and severity of symptoms | |
| Shahrbanian | Cross- sectional | Person Generated Index (PGI) | N=188 | Pain | |
| Strober | Cross-sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=69 | Pain | Acceptance |
| Dymecka | Cross-sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Impact Scale (MSIS-29) | N=137 | Fatigue | |
| Samartzis | Cross-sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=100 | Perceived planning/organisation dysfunction | |
| Brola | Cross-sectional | EuroQol 5-Dimensions (EQ-5D) | N=2385 | EDSS level | |
| Brola | Cross-sectional | EuroQol 5-Dimensions (EQ-5D) | N=765 | EDSS | |
| Abdullah | Cross-sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=200 | Motor symptoms | |
| Nickel | Cross-sectional | Multiple Sclerosis International Quality of Life (MusiQoL) | N=1220 | EDSS | High educational level |
| Campbell | Cross-sectional | Functional assessment of multiple sclerosis (FAMS) | N=62 | Cognitive deficit | |
| Chiu | Cross-sectional | Short Form Health Survey 12 (SF-12) | N=157 | Be unemployed | Disability adjusted employment |
| Boogar | Cross-sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 (MSQoL-54) | N=193 | High disability | Positive story treatment |
| Bishop | Cross-sectional | Quality of Life Scale (QoLS) | N=1839 | Number and severity of symptoms | High educational level |
| Cioncoloni | Cross-sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=57 | EDSS level | |
| Cichy | Cross-sectional | Quality of Life Scale (QoLS) | N=703 | Progressive MS | |
| Mikula | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=156 | Coping strategies | Personality type D and MCS |
| Mikula | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=154 | Coping strategies | Fatigue and MCS and PCS |
| Mikula | Cross- sectional | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=74 | Self-esteem | Social participation and MCS |
| Koelmel | Longitudinal (T1=basal level/T2=10 weeks later/T3=26 weeks later/T4=52 weeks later) | Short Form Health Survey 8 (SF-8) | N=163 | Resilience | Social support and MCS |
| Valvano | Cross- sectional | Leeds MS Quality of Life Scale (MSQoL) | N=128 | Cognitive fusion | Stigma and QoL |
DMD, disease modifying drug; EDSS, expanded disability status scale; MCS, Mental Composite Score; MS, multiple sclerosis; PCS, physical composite; QoL, quality of life; RRMS, remittent remitting; SPMS, secondary progressive.
Characteristics of included studies
| Authors, publication year | Study design (T1: /T2:…) | Quality of life measurement | Sample size (N) | Main results |
| Possa | Cross-sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N=38 | Decrease in MCS (38%) and PCS (19%) in the first year after diagnosis. |
| Calandri | Cross-sectional | Short Form Health Survey 12 (SF-12) | N=102 | Problem solving ( |
| Nourbakhsh | Longitudinal (T1=basal level/T2=3 months after diagnosis/T3=6 months after diagnosis/T4=12 months after diagnosis/T5=18 months after diagnosis/T6=24 months after diagnosis/T6=36 months after diagnosis) | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=43 | Baseline severity of fatigue and depression predicts PCS and cognitive function and fatigue MCS in the first 3 years of diagnosis. |
| Kinkel | Longitudinal (T1=CIS diagnosis/T2=5 years after diagnosis/T3=10 years after diagnosis) | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life Inventory (MSQLI) | N=127 | A second clinic event consistent with CDMS, higher EDSS at the diagnosis and an earlier onset CDMS predicts a decrease in PCS. |
| Bueno | Cross-sectional (25–30 years after diagnosis) | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N=61 | Patient changing from benign (EDSS<3) to non-benign (EDSS>3) decreases PCS. |
| Baumstarck | Longitudinal (T1=basal level/T2=24 months later) | Multiple Sclerosis International Quality of Life questionnaire (MusiQol) Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=526 | Low levels of QoL, higher MS duration and higher EDSS level at T1 predicted worse QoL at T2. |
| Tepavcevic | Longitudinal (T1=basal level/T2=3 years later/T3=6 years later) | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N=93 | Higher EDSS and depression at basal level predicted a decrease of QoL at T1 and T2. |
| Young | Longitudinal (T1=basal level/T2=7 years later/T3=10 years later) | Assessment of Quality of life (AQoL) | N=70 | Higher pain predicts a decrease in QoL. |
| Chruzander | Longitudinal (T1=basal level/T2=10 years later) | EuroQol 5-Dimensions (EQ-5D) EuroQol Visual Analogue Scale (EQ-VAS) Sickness Impact Profile (SIP) | N=118 | Cognitive impairment, depressive symptoms and EDSS predicted a decrease in QoL at T2. |
| Stern | Cross-sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N=57 | The youngest group (35–44) presents worst PCS vs the oldest (55–65). |
| Buhse | Cross-sectional | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life–54 (MSQoL-54) | N=211 | Risk of neurologic impairment, physical disability, depression and the comorbidity of thyroid disease was associated with decrease in PCS. Being widowed and employed was associated with increase in PCS. |
CDMS, clinical defined multiple sclerosis; CIS, clinical isolated syndrome; EDSS, Expanded Disability Status Scale; MCS, Mental Composite Score; MS, multiple sclerosis; PCS, Physical Composite Score; QoL, quality of life.
Characteristics of the included articles
| Authors, | Programme name | Study design | Quality of life measurement | Sample size (N) | Main results |
| Carletto | Body-affective mindfulness (BAM) | Longitudinal (T1=basal level/T2=post-treatment/T3=6 months later) | Functional Assessment of Multiple Sclerosis (FAMS) | N=45 | Increase in general score FAMS from T1 to T2 (p<0.001) and from T2 to T3 (p=1). |
| Besharat | Mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=post-treatment) | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N intervention/control=12/11 | Increase in general QoL score in the intervention group (p<0.05). |
| Blankespoor | Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction (MBSR) | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=post-treatment) | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N=25 | Increase PCS (p<0.001). |
| Simpson | Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction (MBSR) | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=post-treatment/T3=3 months later) | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life Inventory (MSQLI) | N=25 | Small and insignificant increase QoL from T1 to T2 (p=0.48) and insignificant increase from T2 to T3 (p=0.71). |
| Spitzer | Community-based group mindfulness | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=post-treatment/T3=8 weeks later) | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=23 | Increase MCS from T1 to T2 (p=0.008). |
| Ghodspour | Mindfulness-based Cognitive Therapy (MBCT) | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=post-treatment) | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N intervention/control=15/15 | Increase in health distress (p=0.032), mental well-being (p=0.001), role limitation due to emotional problems (p=0.005) and cognitive performance (p=0.04) subscales. |
| Case | Trial of healing light guided imagery (HLGI) | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=post-treatment) | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N intervention/control=9/8 | Increase in PCS (p=0.01) and MCS (p<0.01) in the intervention group. |
| Blair | Dialectical Behaviour Group Therapy (TCD) | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=post-treatment/T3=6 months later) | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N intervention/control=10/10 | Increase in MSQoL-54 from T1 to T3 (p=0.01). |
| Calandri | Group-based cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=6 month post-treatment/T3=1 year post-treatment) | Short Form Health Survey 12 (SF-12) | N intervention/control=54/31 | Increase in MCS T2 in the CBT group vs control (p=0.036). |
| Graziano | Group-based cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=post-treatment/T3=6 months later) | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N intervention/control=41/41 | Increase in MSQoL-54 at T3 in the CBT group vs control group (p<0.05). |
| Kiropoulos | Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) for depressive symptoms | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=post-treatment/T3=20 weeks later) | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N intervention/control=15/15 | Differences between control and CBT group MCS and PCS in T2 and T3 (p<0.001). |
| Chruzander | Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) focused on depressive symptoms | Longitudinal (T1=basal level/T2=3 weeks post-treatment/T3=3 months post-treatment) | Multiple Sclerosis Impact Scale (MSIS-29) | N=15 | Improvement in QoL from MSIS-29 and EQ-5D in T2 and T3 (p<0.05). |
| Kikuchi | Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) on depression | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=mind-treatment/T3=post-treatment) | Functional Assessment of Multiple Sclerosis (FAMS) | N=7 | Positive but not significant increase in FAMS (p>0.05). |
| Pakenham | Resilience Training Programme (ACT) | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=post-treatment/T3=3 months later) | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life-54 Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N=37 | Increase in PCS (p<0.001) and MCS (p<0.006) from T1 to T2, maintained at T3, without significant changes. |
| Proctor | Telephone-supported acceptance and commitment bibliotherapy (ACT) | Longitudinal (T1=pre-randomisation/T2=12 weeks after randomisation) | EuroQol 5-Dimensions (EQ-5D) | N intervention/control=14/13 | No significant increase in QoL (p=0.62). |
| Liu (2017) | Hope-Based Group Therapy (HBGT) | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=post-treatment) | Multiple Sclerosis Impact Scale (MSIS-29) | N intervention/control=18/14 | Physical and psychological QoL increase in HBT group |
| Abolghasemi | Supportive–Expressive Therapy (SE) | Longitudinal (T1=pre-treatment/T2=post-treatment | WHO Quality of Life questionnaire (WHOQoL-BREF) | N intervention/control=16/16 | Increase QoL from T1 to T2 (p<0.001). |
| Jongen | Intensive social cognitive treatment (can do treatment) with participation of support partners | Longitudinal (T1=basal level/T2=12 months post-treatment) | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N=38 | PCS increase (p=0.032) and MCS (p=0.087) in the RR group. |
| Jongen | Intensive social cognitive wellness programme with participation of support partners | Longitudinal (T1=basal level/T2=1 months post-treatment/T3=3 months post-treatment T4=6 months post-treatment | Multiple Sclerosis Quality of Life Instrument (MSQoL-54) | N=44 | MCS increase at T2, T3 and T4 and PCS at T4 (p<0.05). |
| Eliášová | Self-Help group (SH) | Cross-sectional (T1=after the treatment) | WHO Quality of Life questionnaire (WHOQoL-BREF) | N intervention/control=46/35 | Increase in physical (p<0.001), psychological (p<0.001) and social relationships (p<0.001) in the SH group. |
| Mulligan | Fatigue self-management programme ‘Minimise Fatigue, Maximise Life: Creating Balance with Multiple Sclerosis (MFML)’ | Longitudinal (T1=1 month pre-treatment/T2=pre-treatment/T3=post-treatment). | Short Form Health Survey 12 (SF-12) | N=24 | Positive but not significant changes in SF-12 (p>0.05). |
| Thomas | Group-based fatigue management (FACETS) | Longitudinal (T1=1 week before treatment/T2=1 month post-treatment/T3=4 month post-treatment/T4=12 month post-treatment) | Multiple Sclerosis Impact Scale (MSIS-29) | N intervention/control=84/80 | Changes in physical health MSIS-29 (p=0.046) and vitality SF-36 (p=0.03) at T4. |
| Ehde | Telephone-Delivered Self-Management (SM) | Longitudinal (T1=before group randomisation/T2=post-treatment/T3=6 month post-treatment/T4=12 month post-treatment) | Short Form Health Survey 8 (SF-8) | N intervention/control=75/88 | MCS and PCS increase at T2, T3 and T4 (p<0.05). |
| Feicke | Education programme for self-management competencies (S.MS) | Longitudinal (T1=1 basal level/T2=post-treatment/T3=6 month post-treatment) | Hamburg quality of life questionnaire in multiple sclerosis (Sclerosis Quality) | N intervention/control=31/33 | Stable positive changes in QoL (p=0.007). |
| LeClaire | Group Positive Psychology | Longitudinal (T1=basal level/T2=post-treatment) | Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) | N=11 | Increase in SF-36 vitality subscale score (p=0.016). Increase in mental health SF-36 subscale (p=0.098) that did not reach statistical significance. |
HBT, hope-based group therapy; MCS, mental component score; PCS, physical component score; QoL, quality of life; RR, relapsing–remitting.