Literature DB >> 33237552

Co-production as an Emerging Methodology for Developing School-Based Health Interventions with Students Aged 11-16: Systematic Review of Intervention Types, Theories and Processes and Thematic Synthesis of Stakeholders' Experiences.

Hayley Reed1, Danielle Couturiaux2, Marianne Davis2, Amy Edwards2, Edward Janes2, Hyun Sue Kim2, G J Melendez-Torres2, Simon Murphy2, Torill Alise Rotevatn3, Jesse Smith2, Rhiannon Evans2.   

Abstract

Co-production affords an intervention's target population the opportunity to participate in intervention theory decision-making during the development process. This addresses the over-reliance on developing interventions through academic theories which can be devoid of contextual understanding and result in challenges to implementing school-based health programmes. There is an emergent empirical literature on co-producing school-based health interventions, but an understanding of appropriate theoretical types and processes and stakeholders' experiences is lacking. Through the conduct of a systematic review, this study seeks to understand the types and underlying theories and processes for co-production in school-based health interventions with students aged 11-16. A thematic synthesis explored stakeholders' experiences of the different types of co-production. A systematic search of five electronic bibliographic databases, citation tracking of included studies, and consultation with an expert international panel were employed. Of 27,433 unique papers, 30 papers representing 22 studies were retained to describe types, and 23 papers of 18 studies used to synthesise stakeholders' experiences. Three types were identified: external, individual-level, and system-level capacity-building. Whilst this review showed variability in co-production types, stakeholders involved and processes, shared functions were identified. Students', school staff, facilitators' and researchers' experiences in terms of acceptability, feasibility and undertaking decision-making are discussed. Recommendations for conceptualising and reporting co-production and process evaluations of co-produced school-based health interventions are highlighted.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Co-production; Intervention development; School health; Students; Systematic review; Thematic synthesis

Year:  2020        PMID: 33237552     DOI: 10.1007/s11121-020-01182-8

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Prev Sci        ISSN: 1389-4986


  21 in total

1.  Standards of Evidence for Efficacy, Effectiveness, and Scale-up Research in Prevention Science: Next Generation.

Authors:  Denise C Gottfredson; Thomas D Cook; Frances E M Gardner; Deborah Gorman-Smith; George W Howe; Irwin N Sandler; Kathryn M Zafft
Journal:  Prev Sci       Date:  2015-10

2.  Adaptation and Fidelity: a Recipe Analogy for Achieving Both in Population Scale Implementation.

Authors:  Lynn Kemp
Journal:  Prev Sci       Date:  2016-05

Review 3.  Theorising interventions as events in systems.

Authors:  Penelope Hawe; Alan Shiell; Therese Riley
Journal:  Am J Community Psychol       Date:  2009-06

4.  The school environment and student health: a systematic review and meta-ethnography of qualitative research.

Authors:  Farah Jamal; Adam Fletcher; Angela Harden; Helene Wells; James Thomas; Chris Bonell
Journal:  BMC Public Health       Date:  2013-09-03       Impact factor: 3.295

5.  Replication of a whole school ethos-changing intervention: different context, similar effects, additional insights.

Authors:  Penelope Hawe; Lyndal Bond; Laura M Ghali; Rosemary Perry; Colleen M Davison; David M Casey; Helen Butler; Cynthia M Webster; Bert Scholz
Journal:  BMC Public Health       Date:  2015-03-19       Impact factor: 3.295

6.  Development of a framework for the co-production and prototyping of public health interventions.

Authors:  Jemma Hawkins; Kim Madden; Adam Fletcher; Luke Midgley; Aimee Grant; Gemma Cox; Laurence Moore; Rona Campbell; Simon Murphy; Chris Bonell; James White
Journal:  BMC Public Health       Date:  2017-09-04       Impact factor: 3.295

Review 7.  Taxonomy of approaches to developing interventions to improve health: a systematic methods overview.

Authors:  Alicia O'Cathain; Liz Croot; Katie Sworn; Edward Duncan; Nikki Rousseau; Katrina Turner; Lucy Yardley; Pat Hoddinott
Journal:  Pilot Feasibility Stud       Date:  2019-03-12

8.  Advancing complexity science in healthcare research: the logic of logic models.

Authors:  Thomas Mills; Rebecca Lawton; Laura Sheard
Journal:  BMC Med Res Methodol       Date:  2019-03-12       Impact factor: 4.615

9.  Implementation of a school-based social and emotional learning intervention: understanding diffusion processes within complex systems.

Authors:  Rhiannon Evans; Simon Murphy; Jonathan Scourfield
Journal:  Prev Sci       Date:  2015-07

10.  From complex social interventions to interventions in complex social systems: Future directions and unresolved questions for intervention development and evaluation.

Authors:  Graham F Moore; Rhiannon E Evans; Jemma Hawkins; Hannah Littlecott; G J Melendez-Torres; Chris Bonell; Simon Murphy
Journal:  Evaluation (Lond)       Date:  2018-10-31
View more
  4 in total

1.  Defining research priorities for youth public mental health: reflections on a coproduction approach to transdisciplinary working.

Authors:  Andrea Taylor; Christina McMellon; Tara French; Alice MacLachlan; Rhiannon Evans; Ruth Lewis; Mark McCann; Laurence Moore; Simon Murphy; Sharon Simpson; Jo Inchley
Journal:  Health Res Policy Syst       Date:  2022-06-20

2.  Using Co-Design to Develop a Health Literacy Intervention with Socially Disadvantaged Adolescents.

Authors:  Hannah R Goss; Craig Smith; Laura Hickey; Johann Issartel; Janis Morrissey; Celine Murrin; Ailbhe Spillane; Sarahjane Belton
Journal:  Int J Environ Res Public Health       Date:  2022-04-19       Impact factor: 4.614

3.  Development of an educational package for the universal human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination programme: a co-production study with young people and key informants.

Authors:  Harriet Fisher; Tracey Chantler; Adam Finn; Joanna Kesten; Matthew Hickman; Louise Letley; Sandra Mounier-Jack; Clare Thomas; Katie Worthington; Julie Yates; Suzanne Audrey
Journal:  Res Involv Engagem       Date:  2022-04-25

4.  The involvement matrix as a framework for involving youth with severe communication disabilities in developing health education materials.

Authors:  Shakila Dada; Adele May; Kirsty Bastable; Alecia Samuels; Kerstin Tönsing; Jenny Wilder; Maureen Casey; Constance Ntuli; Vasu Reddy
Journal:  Health Expect       Date:  2022-02-11       Impact factor: 3.318

  4 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.