| Literature DB >> 33169909 |
Andrea L Zaenglein1, Moise L Levy2, Nicole S Stefanko3, Latanya T Benjamin4, Anna L Bruckner5, Keith Choate6, Brittany G Craiglow6, John J DiGiovanna7, Lawrence F Eichenfield8, Peter Elias9, Philip Fleckman10, Leslie P Lawley11, Richard A Lewis12, Anne W Lucky13, Erin F Mathes9,14, Leonard M Milstone6, Amy S Paller15, Sonali S Patel16, Dawn H Siegel17, Joyce Teng18, Sherry A Tanumihardjo19, Lauren Thaxton20, Mary L Williams14.
Abstract
Topical and systemic retinoids have long been used in the treatment of ichthyoses and other disorders of cornification. Due to the need for long-term use of retinoids for these disorders, often beginning in childhood, numerous clinical concerns must be considered. Systemic retinoids have known side effects involving bone and eye. Additionally, potential psychiatric and cardiovascular effects need to be considered. Contraceptive concerns, as well as the additive cardiovascular and bone effects of systemic retinoid use with hormonal contraception must also be deliberated for patients of childbearing potential. The Pediatric Dermatology Research Alliance (PeDRA) Use of Retinoids in Ichthyosis Work Group was formed to address these issues and to establish best practices regarding the use of retinoids in ichthyoses based on available evidence and expert opinion.Entities:
Keywords: adverse drug effects; bone health; contraception; depression; disorder of cornification; drug monitoring; ectropion; hyperlipidemia; iPLEDGE; ichthyosis; quality of life; retinoid; safety monitoring; systemic therapy; topical therapy
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2020 PMID: 33169909 PMCID: PMC7984068 DOI: 10.1111/pde.14408
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Pediatr Dermatol ISSN: 0736-8046 Impact factor: 1.588
Consensus statements: retinoid effects on skin
| Both topical and systemic retinoids can improve scaling in patients with select forms of ichthyosis. | II, B |
|
In generalized disorders that feature prominent scale, there is evidence for the utilization of retinoids. Subtypes that have shown improvement with use of oral or topical retinoids include: congenital ichthyosiform erythroderma (select genotypes), epidermolytic ichthyosis, erythrokeratodermia variabilis, harlequin ichthyosis, ichthyosis with confetti, IFAP syndrome, KIDsyndrome, KLICKsyndrome, lamellar ichthyosis, loricrin keratoderma, neutral lipid storage disease with ichthyosis, recessive X‐linked ichthyosis, and Sjogren‐Larsson syndrome. | II, B |
|
Subtypes for which there are either no data for the use of retinoids, or there has been data showing no improvement, include: CHILD syndrome, CHIME syndrome, Conradi‐Hunermann‐Happle syndrome, ichthyosis‐hypotrichosis syndrome, ichthyosis‐hypotrichosis‐sclerosing cholangitis, ichthyosis prematurity syndrome, MEDNIK syndrome, peeling skin disease, Refsum syndrome, and trichothiodystrophy. | III, C |
| Utilization of retinoids in some disorders with skin fragility, peeling skin, atopic diathesis, or excessive desquamation (eg, Netherton syndrome) may exacerbate disease and should be used with caution. | II, B |
| Both adults and children with moderate to severe disorders of keratinization with significant functional or psychological impairment should be offered the opportunity to make a benefit/risk assessment of treatment with a systemic. | III, C |
Consensus statements: topical retinoid use
| SORT | |
|---|---|
|
Topical retinoids are useful in treating scale, digital contractures, and ectropion in patients with ichthyosis. | IIIC |
|
Systemic laboratory monitoring is not recommended with use of topical retinoids for ichthyosis. | IIB |
Retinoid dosing in ichthyosis and other disorders of cornification
| Formulation | Dosage | Considerations |
|---|---|---|
|
| ||
|
10 mg, 25 mg capsule |
Child: 0.5 ‐ 1 mg/kg/day Adult: 0.5 ‐ 1 mg/kg/day Typical dose: 10‐25 mg/day Maximum dose: 75 mg/day |
Start at low dose Long half‐life Cautious use in patients of childbearing potential Avoid getting pregnant for 3 years after discontinuing medication Consider lower dose in warmer, humid weather |
|
10 mg, 20 mg, 30 mg, 40 mg capsule (contains soy) |
Child: 0.5 ‐ 1 mg/kg/day Adult: 0.5 ‐ 1 mg/kg/day |
Regulatory restraints of iPLEDGE Consider lower dose in warmer, humid weather Consider “holidays” from administration |
|
| ||
|
0.05%, 0.1% gel 0.05%, 0.1% cream | Daily |
May improve ectropion Monitor for irritation, particularly around eyes and in folds |
|
0.025%, 0.05%, 0.1% cream | Daily |
May be compounded with 2% salicylic acid for palmoplantar use |
|
0.1%, 0.3% gel | Daily |
May be less irritating |
Tips for administering retinoid capsule to child*
|
Keep out of direct sunlight, use capsule immediately after removing from packaging |
| Capsule can be swallowed whole or chewed |
| Poke a hole in capsule with sharp knife or nail clippers and add to food (note: capsule is very tough) |
| The capsule may be softened by placing in a small cup with warm water or milk for 2‐3 minutes |
| Add to limited amount (1 oz) of breast milk or formula for infants |
| Give with high fat food (such as whole milk, ice cream, peanut, or other nut butter) for best absorption |
| Freeze capsule in bite sized, soft centered chocolate and chew chocolate and capsule |
| *Adapted from |
Consensus statements: retinoid dosing
| SORT | |
|---|---|
|
When choosing a systemic retinoid for treatment of disorders of cornification, isotretinoin should be considered first line for patients of reproductive potential. | IA |
|
Because of the prolonged half‐life of acitretin (up to 3 years), clinicians should consider transitioning patients of childbearing potential from acitretin to isotretinoin before puberty if at risk of pregnancy. | IIIC |
| The optimal dose of a systemic retinoid is the lowest dose that will achieve and maintain the desired therapeutic effect with acceptable mucocutaneous and systemic toxicities. | IA |
| Systemic retinoid treatment of the disorders of cornification is often long term. Therefore, the clinician must counsel patients about potential long‐term toxicities. | IA |
| Neonates with harlequin ichthyosis whose constrictive scales significantly restrict breathing or threaten viability of distal extremities may benefit from treatment with systemic retinoids. | IIIC |
|
Neonates with milder phenotypes of harlequin ichthyosis may not require a systemic retinoid. | IIIC |
Consensus statements: retinoid effects on bone
| SORT | |
|---|---|
| Long‐term use of systemic retinoids in ichthyosis/ DOC is associated with skeletal concerns. | I, A |
| The toxic effects of systemic retinoid use on bone are strongly dependent on dose and duration. | I, A |
| Potential bone toxicity should not preclude long‐term systemic retinoid use in patients with ichthyosis if there is a clear clinical benefit. | III, C |
| Genetic risk and modifiable factors that affect bone health, such as diet and physical activity, may impact susceptibility to systemic retinoid bone toxicity and should be discussed with the patient. | II, C |
Recommended bone monitoring for patients on long‐term systemic retinoid therapy
|
The following evaluation and testing should be considered for children (less than 18 years of age): Comprehensive family and personal medical history for risk factors for skeletal toxicity Annual growth assessment (height, weight, BMI, and growth curve) Inquire regularly about musculoskeletal symptoms; follow‐up with appropriate imaging Inquire about diet (including sufficient vitamin D intake and no additional vitamin A sources) At full growth (16‐18 years), a baseline skeletal radiographic survey, which may include imaging of the lateral cervical and thoracic spine, lateral view of the calcanei to include Achilles tendon, hips and symptomatic areas; and bone density evaluation (eg, DEXA scan) |
|
The following evaluation and testing should be considered for adults: Comprehensive family and personal medical history for risk factors for skeletal toxicity Inquire regularly about musculoskeletal symptoms; follow‐up with appropriate imaging Inquire about diet (including sufficient vitamin D intake and additional vitamin A sources) If therapy is likely to continue long‐term, a baseline skeletal radiographic survey which may include imaging of the lateral cervical and thoracic spine, lateral view of the calcanei to include Achilles tendon, hips and symptomatic areas; and bone density evaluation (eg, DEXA scan) Repeat radiographic bone evaluation every 3‐5 years or if symptomatic |
Consensus statements: systemic retinoid effects on the eye
|
| |
|---|---|
|
Systemic retinoid therapy can cause retinal dysfunction, night blindness and dry eyes. Use may exacerbate existing eye symptoms related to underlying ichthyosis. | I, A |
| For patients who are on long‐term systemic retinoid therapy, evaluation by ophthalmology is recommended 4‐6 months after initiation of systemic retinoid therapy, with routine follow‐up every 6‐12 months. | III, C |
Consensus statements: systemic retinoid effects on lipids and liver
| SORT | |
|---|---|
| Severe lipid abnormalities and hepatotoxicity with the use of systemic retinoids are very rare. | II, B |
|
Serum lipid panels and liver function tests should be performed at baseline and, if in an acceptable range, repeated in 1‐2 months after starting treatment. If the levels remain within the acceptable range, subsequent testing can be done every 6‐12 months. | II, B |
|
Patients on long‐term systemic retinoids with persistent, abnormal, clinically significant elevations in serum lipids may continue retinoid treatment with effective lipid management. | II, C |
Consensus statements: psychiatric effects of systemic retinoid therapy
| SORT | |
|---|---|
|
All patients, regardless of history, should be monitored for the development of psychiatric symptoms when they are taking systemic retinoids. | I, A |
|
Patients with a personal history of depression, anxiety, and other affective disorders prior to initiation of systemic retinoid treatment should be monitored carefully for exacerbation of symptoms. Co‐management with a mental health provider should be considered. | II, B |
Pharmacokinetics of systemic retinoids
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
4‐oxo‐isotretinoin retinoic acid (tretinoin) 4‐oxo‐retinoic acid |
Half‐life: isotretinoin: 21.0 ± 8.2 hours 4‐oxo‐isotretinoin: 24.0 ± 5.3 hours |
|
|
13‐cis acitretin With alcohol: etretinate |
Half‐life: acitretin: 49 hours (range 33 to 96 hours) 13‐cis acitretin: 63 hours (range 28 to 157 hours) etretinate: 120 days (84 to 168 days) Greater than 98% of acitretin is eliminated within 2 months (assuming a mean elimination half‐life of 49 hours) Greater than 98% of etretinate formed is eliminated in 2 years (assuming a mean half‐life of 120 days) Greater than 98% of etretinate formed is eliminated in 3 years (based on half‐life of 168 days) |
Consensus statements: contraception considerations of long‐term systemic retinoid use
| SORT | |
|---|---|
|
Highly effective forms of contraception, such as intrauterine devices (IUD) or progestin implants, should be considered in shared decision‐making with sexually active adolescent patients of childbearing potential on systemic retinoid therapy. | I,A |
| Patients of childbearing potential who are sexually active should use two forms of contraception, including one highly effective form, while on any systemic retinoid therapy. | I,A |
Consensus statements: the impact of iPLEDGE
| SORT | |
|---|---|
|
All patients and prescribers of isotretinoin in the United States must comply with current iPLEDGE guidelines. | I, A |
|
The iPLEDGE program was not designed for long‐term use of isotretinoin in patients with ichthyosis and imposes a significant burden on this patient population. | III, C |
Practice gaps/ unmet needs
|
Retinoid Effects on the Skin: 1. The exact mechanism of action of retinoids on the skin and their effects in DOC has not been adequately examined. |
|
Retinoid Dosing: 2. The optimal formulation of retinoid, as well as dosing amount and frequency, based on ichthyosis subtype and individual features is not known. 3. The adverse effects of long‐term retinoid treatment and the optimal means to monitor for them need more thorough examination. 4. Whether there is a benefit to intermittent therapy with respect to risk of toxicity and maintenance of efficacy is unknown. 5. Evaluation of optimal timing of initiation of retinoid therapy regarding safety and efficacy is needed. |
|
Topical Effects of Retinoids: 6. The potential for systemic absorption of topical retinoids is not known. 7. Best practices to minimize the local adverse effects of topical retinoids needs examination. |
|
Retinoid Effects on Bone: 8. A “bone‐safe” duration of retinoid therapy (if it exists) requires further study. 9. Which individuals are at greater risk for bone toxicity from retinoid treatment is not known. 10. The best formulation and timing of initiation of a systemic retinoid on potential bone toxicity needs to be determined. 11. How to minimize symptoms and progression of DISH‐like changes, if feasible, is not known. |
|
Systemic Retinoid Effects on the Eye: 12. Further study of the long‐term effects of systemic retinoid therapy on patients with ichthyosis is needed. 13. A better understanding of the ophthalmologic concerns from the use of topical retinoids on the eyelids is required. |
|
Systemic Retinoid Effects on Lipids and Liver 14. The chronic effects of systemic retinoids on lipids and liver function are unknown. 15. Optimal monitoring frequency of lipids and liver function with long‐term use of systemic retinoids should be examined. 16. The potential effects of systemic retinoid therapy on patients’ long‐term cardiovascular health are not known. |
|
Psychiatric Effects of Retinoids: 17. Data on the prevalence of psychiatric disorders in ichthyosis patients are lacking. 18. Studies exploring the psychiatric effects of retinoids on patients taking long‐term systemic retinoids have not been performed. |
|
Contraception Considerations of Long‐Term Systemic Retinoid Use 19. The combined effects of using hormonal contraception and systemic retinoids on cardiovascular and bone health in females are unknown. |
|
The Impact of iPLEDGE: 20. The financial burden of iPLEDGE program on patients and their families has not been determined. 21. The iPLEDGE program should be modified to accommodate the use of isotretinoin in the management of ichthyoses and disorders of cornification to reduce undue burden. |
Clinical questions identified by work group members
| Retinoid Effects on Skin |
|
What disorders of cornification/types of ichthyosis have been shown to benefit from use of retinoids? Are there types of ichthyosis for which retinoids might not be indicated? |
| Systemic Retinoid Dosing |
|
What is the optimal dosing and duration of therapy? Is there a benefit to intermittent therapy? What are the indications for starting systemic retinoids? What considerations are there when choosing a systemic retinoid? Are there any side effects on skin? |
| Topical Retinoid Use |
|
What are the indications for starting topical retinoids in ichthyosis/DOC? Are there differences in mechanism of action, efficacy, and side effects of various topical retinoids used in disorders of cornification? When is a child with ichthyosis/DOC at risk of substantial systemic absorption of a topical retinoid? Has topical retinoid absorption been shown to be of clinical concern? Is any monitoring required when using topical retinoids in ichthyosis/DOC? |
| Retinoid Effects on Bone |
|
What are the clinical considerations and consequences of long‐term systemic retinoid use on bone health? What bone specific monitoring is recommended with the use of systemic retinoids for ichthyosis and disorders of cornification? |
| Systemic Retinoid Effects on the Eye |
|
What are the clinical considerations and consequences of long‐term systemic retinoid use on eye health? What eye specific monitoring is recommended with the use of systemic retinoids for ichthyosis and disorders of cornification? |
| Systemic Retinoid Effects on Lipids and Liver |
|
What are the clinical considerations and consequences of long‐term systemic retinoid use on the liver and lipid metabolism? What lipid and liver specific monitoring is recommended with the use of systemic retinoids for ichthyosis? |
| Psychiatric Effects of Systemic Retinoid Therapy |
|
What are the psychiatric considerations and consequences of long‐term, systemic retinoid use? What psychiatric monitoring is recommended for patients with ichthyosis on long‐term systemic retinoid therapy? |
| Contraception Considerations of Long‐Term Systemic Retinoid Use |
|
What are the contraceptive considerations for the long‐term use of systemic retinoids? What are the long‐term health consequences of combined contraceptive and systemic retinoid therapy? What are the contraceptive considerations for the long‐term use of systemic retinoids? |
| The Impact of iPLEDGE |
|
What are iPLEDGE considerations and requirements when using long‐term systemic isotretinoin in patients with ichthyosis? Does the iPLEDGE program result in any barriers to care for patients with ichthyosis? |