Martin Wilkovitsch1, Maximilian Haider1, Barbara Sohr1, Barbara Herrmann1, Jenna Klubnick2, Ralph Weissleder2,3, Jonathan C T Carlson2,4, Hannes Mikula1. 1. Institute of Applied Synthetic Chemistry, TU Wien, Getreidemarkt 9, 1060 Vienna, Austria. 2. Center for Systems Biology, Massachusetts General Hospital Research Institute, Boston, Massachusetts 02114, United States. 3. Department of Systems Biology, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, United States. 4. Cancer Center, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts 02114, United States.
Abstract
Bioorthogonal chemistry is bridging the divide between static chemical connectivity and the dynamic physiologic regulation of molecular state, enabling in situ transformations that drive multiple technologies. In spite of maturing mechanistic understanding and new bioorthogonal bond-cleavage reactions, the broader goal of molecular ON/OFF control has been limited by the inability of existing systems to achieve both fast (i.e., seconds to minutes, not hours) and complete (i.e., >99%) cleavage. To attain the stringent performance characteristics needed for high fidelity molecular inactivation, we have designed and synthesized a new C2-symmetric trans-cyclooctene linker (C2TCO) that exhibits excellent biological stability and can be rapidly and completely cleaved with functionalized alkyl-, aryl-, and H-tetrazines, irrespective of click orientation. By incorporation of C2TCO into fluorescent molecular probes, we demonstrate highly efficient extracellular and intracellular bioorthogonal disassembly via omnidirectional tetrazine-triggered cleavage.
Bioorthogonal chemistry is bridging the divide between static chemical connectivity and the dynamic physiologic regulation of molecular state, enabling in situ transformations that drive multiple technologies. In spite of maturing mechanistic understanding and new bioorthogonal bond-cleavage reactions, the broader goal of molecular ON/OFF control has been limited by the inability of existing systems to achieve both fast (i.e., seconds to minutes, not hours) and complete (i.e., >99%) cleavage. To attain the stringent performance characteristics needed for high fidelity molecular inactivation, we have designed and synthesized a new C2-symmetric trans-cyclooctene linker (C2TCO) that exhibits excellent biological stability and can be rapidly and completely cleaved with functionalized alkyl-, aryl-, and H-tetrazines, irrespective of click orientation. By incorporation of C2TCO into fluorescent molecular probes, we demonstrate highly efficient extracellular and intracellular bioorthogonal disassembly via omnidirectional tetrazine-triggered cleavage.
Biologically compatible
click chemistries have become powerful
tools for the design, synthesis, and tracking of labeled (bio)molecules.[1−6] The toolbox of these bioorthogonal reactions has expanded substantially
in the past decade, providing chemists and chemical biologists with
highly selective methods to achieve efficient ligation in complex
biological environments.[7] Nevertheless,
the application of bioorthogonal chemistries to solve important clinical
problems has remained at an early stage, still focused on exploratory
models. While this is in large part a function of the tremendous biological
complexity that confronts any new chemical tools, it is also the case
that a range of important reaction capabilities have not yet been
invented (vide infra).Among these chemistries,
the inverse electron demand Diels–Alder
(IEDDA)-initiated reaction of tetrazines (Tz) and trans-cyclooctenes (TCO) is increasingly used, chiefly due to its exceptionally
high reaction rates but also as a consequence of significant molecular
versatility.[8,9] The highly tunable Tz/TCO click
reaction has thus become a method of choice for time-critical applications
and fast bioorthogonal ligation even at low concentrations of both
reactants. Applications range from the synthesis of molecular probes
and rapid radiolabeling of biomolecules[10−15] to bioorthogonal ligations carried out in live cells[16−19] and even in vivo, enabling pretargeting strategies
for molecular imaging and therapy.[20−24] The development of fluorogenic turn-on tetrazines
(Figure a, upper panel)
has enabled no-wash cellular imaging,[25−28] even at super-resolution as shown
very recently.[29]
Figure 1
(a) Bioorthogonal ligation
of tetrazines (Tz) and trans-cyclooctenes (TCO) for
the fluorogenic labeling of biomolecules,
targeting compounds or ligands (top) and Tz-triggered cleavage from trans-cyclooctene modified in allylic position (release-TCO,
rTCO) for the bioorthogonal activation of prodrugs or rTCO-caged biomolecules
(bottom). (b) Concept of bioorthogonal cleavage to disassemble molecular
probes (top) or inactivate fused biomolecules. (c) Limitations of
the IEDDA pyridazine elimination with emphasis on Tz/TCO click rates,
release yield, and release kinetics.
(a) Bioorthogonal ligation
of tetrazines (Tz) and trans-cyclooctenes (TCO) for
the fluorogenic labeling of biomolecules,
targeting compounds or ligands (top) and Tz-triggered cleavage from trans-cyclooctene modified in allylic position (release-TCO,
rTCO) for the bioorthogonal activation of prodrugs or rTCO-caged biomolecules
(bottom). (b) Concept of bioorthogonal cleavage to disassemble molecular
probes (top) or inactivate fused biomolecules. (c) Limitations of
the IEDDA pyridazine elimination with emphasis on Tz/TCO click rates,
release yield, and release kinetics.In parallel, the concept of bioorthogonal bond-cleavage has further
expanded the repertoire of chemical methods to control the function
of (bio)molecules. In recent years, several reactions of this type
have been developed, including metal-induced as well as click-triggered
bond-cleavage.[30,31] Robillard and co-workers were
first to show the release of amino-functionalized compounds from trans-cyclooctene modified in allylic position (release-TCO,
rTCO) upon IEDDA reaction with tetrazines and coined the term click-to-release.[32] In this IEDDA-initiated
pyridazine elimination, the Tz reacts with rTCO to form a dihydropyridazine
intermediate that can spontaneously lead to release of the leaving
group in allylic position via a 1,4-elimination. Application of this
reaction has emerged in recent years mainly in the field of targeted
drug delivery. On the basis of their initial report, Robillard et
al. designed antibody-drug conjugates comprising a cleavable TCO linker
and achieved targeted drug release in a xenograft mouse model upon
pretargeting of the antibody conjugate followed by systemic administration
of the Tz.[33,34] An inverse strategy was developed
by Mejia Oneto et al. using Tz-modified hydrogels that can locally
activate systemically dosed rTCO-modified prodrugs.[35,36] In addition, rTCO-lysine was successfully incorporated into proteins
for the design of caged biomolecules that can be activated upon reaction
with Tz (Figure a,
lower panel).[37,38]In contrast to these and
other turn-ON applications, bioorthogonal
cleavage/release has not yet been implemented for controlled inactivation
of probes or (bio)molecules in biological environments. In this light,
we envision bond-cleavage reactions to be powerful tools to develop
new turn-OFF methods and deactivation strategies for chemical biology
and biomedical research. Bioorthogonal cleavage of fluorescent probes
(Figure b) might enable
superior methods for applications that require the removal or deactivation
of the dye after analysis, such as multiplexed imaging.[39] Compared to other methods using either (i) harsh
destaining/quenching conditions,[40−42] (ii) complex DNA-based
cycling and imaging techniques,[43−47] or (iii) the combination of clickable fluorophores and quenchers,[48] bioorthogonal cleavage would allow rapid, gentle,
biocompatible removal of the dye by using small molecules as chemical
scissors. More broadly, the incorporation of cleavable linkers into
(bio)molecules would enable molecular inactivation for spatiotemporal
control of biological function (Figure b).Envisaging the IEDDA pyridazine elimination
for bioorthogonal disassembly
of molecular probes, we noted the current limitations of this chemistry,
which remains unable to achieve both fast (i.e., seconds to minutes)
and complete (>99%) cleavage. Unlike target activation approaches,
in which a relatively broad range of yields may generate discernible
signal and/or relevant downstream activity, the combination of fast
AND complete cleavage/release is essential for turn-off strategies
to reach minimal residual signals and/or function within a useful
time frame.We have recently uncovered the critical role of
tautomerization
and isomerization events after ligation—the postclick reaction
network—and identified intramolecular cyclization as the main
reason for incomplete release when using first-generation bis-alkyl-tetrazines,
such as 3,6-dimethyltetrazine (DMT, 1) with rTCO. The
blocking of this undesired pathway by N-methyl substitution
at the leaving carbamate moiety enabled us to achieve complete release.[49] Nonetheless, the relatively low click reactivity
of bis-alkyl-tetrazines (when compared to other Tz) and the slow release
of the resulting dihydropyridazine intermediates limit further applications
(Figure c). Improved
click kinetics have been achieved by TCO-triggered cleavage of Tz-carbamates,
as reported very recently by Robillard et al. Applying this inverse
approach for bioorthogonal turn-off, however, is limited due to only
slow (>24 h) and incomplete release (67–93%).[50] Likewise, second-generation 2-pyrimidyl-substituted
tetrazines 2(51) and 3(52) (Figure c) achieve higher click rates with rTCO and accelerated
release,
especially when using the aminoethyl-substituted Tz 3 (PymK).[52] These improvements are offset
by the penalty of incomplete release (<80%)—consistent with
previous findings showing limited rTCO cleavage with aryl-tetrazines[32,33,37]—even though no intramolecular
cyclization was observed.[52] We thus set
out to elucidate the postclick reaction network for aryl-tetrazines
and develop new chemical tools that facilitate fast and complete cleavage
for bioorthogonal ON/OFF control.
Results and Discussion
The “Aryl-Tz
Problem”
Upon the IEDDA
reaction of Tz and rTCO-conjugates, the initial click product A, a 4,5-dihydropyridazine (4,5-DHP) is known to be able to
tautomerize to either the 1,4-dihydropyridazine B1 or
its 2,5-isomer B2; release proceeds via 1,4-elimination
from the B1 tautomer, while formation of B2 leads to a nonreleasing and thus undesired intermediate (Figure a).[49,53] In theory, aryl substituents could alter these equilibria to interfere
with release via either preferential formation of the nonreleasing B2 tautomer or inefficient elimination from B1. In prior work, we discovered that modified Tz capable of intramolecular
proton donation (Tz-acids) can significantly accelerate tautomerization
and subsequent elimination, a capability shared by pH-independent
ammonium-functionalized Tz.[52] Directed
tautomerization to B1 is, however, only possible if the
directing group (XH = NH3+, COOH) is in ‘head-to-head’ position to the leaving group on the
TCO scaffold (Figure a), while the reciprocal ‘head-to-tail’
click product leads to preferred formation of B2. We
have previously shown that this results in (i) biphasic release when
using Tz-monoacids (fast via B1, and slow via B2
⇆ A ⇆ B1) and (ii) slow release (hours) when
using a Tz-diacid at physiologic pH.[49]
Figure 2
(a) The
critical role of postclick tautomerization (left; DHP =
dihydropyridazine); directed and accelerated formation of B1 as well as enhanced 1,4-elimination with directing groups (CO2H, NH3+) in head-to-head position (right).
(b) Stopped-flow measurements verified the significantly higher click
reactivity of aryl-Tz 4a, 4b, and 5 with the water-soluble rTCO-derivative 6. (c)
Investigation of the reactions of PyrMe (4a), PymMe (4b), and PyrPA (5) with rTCO-Alexa Fluor 350
(7) by LCMS revealed the irreversible formation of B2 tautomers with Pyr/Pym in head-to-head position, as confirmed
by NMR for the reactions of 4a and 4b with
rTCO-glycine[49] (see Supporting Information).
(a) The
critical role of postclick tautomerization (left; DHP =
dihydropyridazine); directed and accelerated formation of B1 as well as enhanced 1,4-elimination with directing groups (CO2H, NH3+) in head-to-head position (right).
(b) Stopped-flow measurements verified the significantly higher click
reactivity of aryl-Tz 4a, 4b, and 5 with the water-soluble rTCO-derivative 6. (c)
Investigation of the reactions of PyrMe (4a), PymMe (4b), and PyrPA (5) with rTCO-Alexa Fluor 350
(7) by LCMS revealed the irreversible formation of B2 tautomers with Pyr/Pym in head-to-head position, as confirmed
by NMR for the reactions of 4a and 4b with
rTCO-glycine[49] (see Supporting Information).In both cases, the slow release step takes up to several hours,
which not only increases the risk of oxidation of the DHP-intermediates,
thus preventing further release,[49] but
also makes the Tz-acid/rTCO combination unsuitable for turn-off applications
that require complete and rapid cleavage (i.e., minutes, not hours).Alkyl-aryl-Tz are known to be significantly more reactive in the
initial click step than bis-alkyl-Tz,[32,54] which we verified
in this study by measuring the second order rate constants for the
reactions of DMT (1), PyrMe (4a), PymMe
(4b), and PyrPA (5, PA = propionic acid)
with the PEGylated rTCO 6, observing a rate enhancement
of up to 30-fold (4b vs 1, Figure b). Similar to our previous
study,[49] we used an rTCO-AlexaFluor 350
conjugate (7, Figure b) to further investigate the release step. Reactions
were carried out in buffered aqueous solution at pH 7 and 25 °C,
selecting concentrations of PyrMe (4a), PymMe (4b), or PyrPA (5) (200 μM) and 7 (125 μM) such that the click reaction was done in less than
4 min, allowing temporal monitoring of postclick reactions by LCMS.
With PyrMe (4a) and PymMe (4b), we observed
slow monophasic release that reached a yield of approximately 50%
within ∼8 h. For PyrPA (5), an initial fast phase
of release (too rapid to resolve by HPLC) reached a very similar release
yield (Figure c),
whereupon no further release was observed (>24h). We inferred that
these different kinetic profiles result from the methyl group (slow
release) and the propionic acid (PA) moiety (fast release) being in
head-to-head position, as we had demonstrated for PA-functionalized
alkyl Tz,[49] implying in turn that the nonreleasing
fraction is due to formation of the respective head-to-tail intermediates
with 2-pyridyl (Pyr) or 2-pyrimidyl (Pym) in head-to-head position.
To verify these hypotheses, we reacted PyrMe (4a) and
PymMe (4b) with rTCO-glycine[49] (see Supporting Information), allowed
the release reactions to proceed to completion, and isolated the nonreleasing
isomers. NMR analysis confirmed the aryl-substituent in the head-to-head
position, as hypothesized, and revealed these undesired products to
be respective B2 tautomers (Figure c). We were thus able to show that tautomerization
is no longer an equilibrium (cf. Figure a) and that incomplete release for aryl-Tz
is due to the preferential and irreversible formation of a stable B2 tautomer for one of the two possible click orientations
(Pyr/Pym in head-to-head). This key finding is in line with the observations
of van Kasteren et al., who achieved approximately 80% release with
PymK (3) and invoked the preferred formation of the releasing
adduct with the ethylammonium moiety in head-to-head position (due
to preclick interaction of NH3+ with the carbamate
functionality of the leaving group) to explain this increased conversion.[52]
Design and Synthesis of C2TCO
In principle,
a strategy to bias click orientation even more strongly in favor of
the head-to-head geometry could further improve release performance,
though at the risk of kinetic penalties imposed by added steric bulk.
Recognizing the limits of unstructured molecular interactions in aqueous
solution and the strict priority of complete fast
release, we instead envisioned a C2-symmetric trans-cyclooctene (C2TCO) with leaving groups at each of the
two allylic positions of TCO. Upon click reaction, the directing group
(CO2H, NH3+) on the Tz inevitably
aligns head-to-head with one of the two release positions, irrespective
of the click orientation, leading to fast and complete omnidirectional
cleavage (Figure a).
As axially configured rTCO is known to be significantly more reactive
than its equatorial isomer,[32] we aimed
for the axial configuration of both leaving groups. Starting from
1,3-cyclooctadiene (8), we were able to prepare the desired
C2TCO-diol (bis-axial 11) in three steps (Figure b). Tetraphenylporphyrin
(TPP)-sensitized photooxygenation of 8 followed by DBU-catalyzed
in situ Kornblum-DeLaMare rearrangement[55] afforded lactol 9 (63%), which was then reduced by
reaction with sodium triacetoxyborohydride[56] to obtain cyclooct-2-ene-1,4-diol (10) with an anti/syn-ratio
of 10/1 (45%). Flow-photoisomerization of 10 and continuous
active removal of trans-cyclooctene products by using
Ag(I) immobilized on tosic silica gel (TAg silica)[57] finally gave bis-axial-11 (47%) and bis-equatorial-11 (30%). 13C NMR analysis of the separated products
showed only four signals for each compound, strongly indicating the
C2-symmetry of both obtained TCOs (Figure b, overlay of 13C NMR spectra),
which results from the rigid “crown” (or twist) conformation[58−60] of the trans-cyclooctene core structure.
Figure 3
(a) Design
of a C2-symmetric trans-cyclooctene enabling
directed tautomerization and enhanced elimination for fast and complete
cleavage irrespective of the click orientation. (b) Synthesis of bis-axial
and bis-equatorial C2TCO-diol (11) and overlay
of schematic 13C NMR spectra of the separated and purified
compounds, which indicate C2-symmetry of both isomers resulting
from the rigid “crown” (or twist) conformation of the
TCO core structure.
(a) Design
of a C2-symmetric trans-cyclooctene enabling
directed tautomerization and enhanced elimination for fast and complete
cleavage irrespective of the click orientation. (b) Synthesis of bis-axial
and bis-equatorial C2TCO-diol (11) and overlay
of schematic 13C NMR spectra of the separated and purified
compounds, which indicate C2-symmetry of both isomers resulting
from the rigid “crown” (or twist) conformation of the
TCO core structure.
Tz-Triggered Cleavage of
C2TCO
In preparing
to investigate the click and release reactions of C2TCO,
we took into account that its unbiased click with Tz poses a characterization
challenge. While the randomness of omnidirectional release enhances
bioorthogonal turn-off applications, reacting a nonsymmetric C2TCO derivative with nonsymmetric Tz yields problematically
complex mixtures. To facilitate chromatographic analysis, we therefore
sought to modify both allylic OH-groups to obtain symmetrical probes.Activation of both OH-functionalities as p-nitrophenyl
(PNP) carbonates afforded an inseparable mixture of C2TCO-bis(PNP)-carbonate
and p-nitrophenol (see Supporting Information), but we were able to obtain the bis-imidazolium-carbamate 12 as an activated intermediate by reacting bis-axial-11 with 1,1′-carbonyldiimidazole (CDI), similar to
the activation of bioorthogonal cyclopropene tags,[61] followed by N-methylation using methyl
iodide (Figure a). In situ conversion of 12 with sarcosine methyl
ester followed by saponification gave bis(sarcosinyl)-C2TCO (13). We incorporated sarcosine into this cleavable
C2TCO-linker to prevent any potential formation of tricyclic
dead-end isomers upon reaction with tetrazines.[49] TSTU-mediated coupling of 13 with mono-Fmoc-1,3-diaminopropane
and subsequent deprotection afforded bis-amine 14. This
compound was reacted with AlexaFluor 594 (AF594)-NHS to obtain AF594-C2TCO-AF594 (15) as a fluorescently labeled C2TCO probe (Figure a) for subsequent investigations.
Figure 4
(a) Modification of C2TCO (bis-axial-11) via bis-imidazolium-carbamate 12 to obtain bis(sarcosinyl)-C2TCO (13) and fluorescent AF594-C2TCO-AF594
(15) for further investigation of the Tz-triggered cleavage
of C2TCO. (b) Reacting 15 with selected tetrazines
at pH 7.4 and end point analysis by HPLC at 24 h revealed high cleavage
efficiency for DMT and quantitative cleavage with tetrazines modified
with a directing group (MPA (17), PyrPA (5), PymPA (18), PymK (3)). (c) Second order
rate constants as determined by stopped-flow spectrophotometry showed
decreased reactivity of C2TCO compared to rTCO (cf. Figure b), and significantly
higher click kinetics for ammonium-functionalized PymK (3) compared to the respective Tz-acid PymPA (18). (d)
Steric hindrance of the aryl substituent as well as interactions of
directing groups affect the click kinetics with C2TCO.
(a) Modification of C2TCO (bis-axial-11) via bis-imidazolium-carbamate 12 to obtain bis(sarcosinyl)-C2TCO (13) and fluorescent AF594-C2TCO-AF594
(15) for further investigation of the Tz-triggered cleavage
of C2TCO. (b) Reacting 15 with selected tetrazines
at pH 7.4 and end point analysis by HPLC at 24 h revealed high cleavage
efficiency for DMT and quantitative cleavage with tetrazines modified
with a directing group (MPA (17), PyrPA (5), PymPA (18), PymK (3)). (c) Second order
rate constants as determined by stopped-flow spectrophotometry showed
decreased reactivity of C2TCO compared to rTCO (cf. Figure b), and significantly
higher click kinetics for ammonium-functionalized PymK (3) compared to the respective Tz-acid PymPA (18). (d)
Steric hindrance of the aryl substituent as well as interactions of
directing groups affect the click kinetics with C2TCO.As an initial assessment of cleavage efficiency,
we reacted 15 with an excess of selected tetrazines in
buffered solution
at pH 7.4 and analyzed the reaction mixtures at an end point of 24
h by HPLC with fluorescence detection. We observed nearly complete
cleavage with DMT (1) and quantitative cleavage (>99%)
with the Tz-acidsMPA (17), PyrPA (5), and
PymPA (18) as well as with PymK (3). In
contrast, reaction with bis(2-pyridyl)tetrazine (Pyr2Tz, 16) resulted in only 23% cleavage (Figure b), in line with previous observations for
rTCO.[32,33,37] We hypothesize
that this is due to not only slow tautomerization but also limited
elimination of the respective B1/B2 intermediate.
The inability to achieve complete release with Pyr2Tz (16) highlights the advantages of a cleavage-directing group
and an ongoing need for further molecular innovations.We next
sought to analyze release kinetics by serial HPLC measurement,
which requires rapid click conversion to kinetically segregate click
and release and enable monitoring of the release process exclusively.
We thus first determined the second order rate constants for the click
reaction of C2TCO with a range of tetrazines. Stopped-flow
spectrophotometry in PBS revealed rate constants ranging from 3.3
M–1 s–1, for the reaction of MPA
(17) with 13, to 240 M–1 s–1 for PymK (3) + 13 (Figure c). We hypothesize
that the PA-carboxylate anion (pKa of
PA-Tz: ∼4.5[49]) leads to repulsion
with the carbamate functionality of the leaving group, in contrast
to the previously observed click enhancement caused by interaction
of ammonium substituents.[52] These effects
(Figure d) might thus
account for the 5-fold lower reactivity of MPA (17) (carboxylate-repulsion)
compared to DMT and the 10-fold higher rate constant for PymK (3) (NH3+-interaction) than for PymPA
(18) (Figure c). Notably, comparing the click reactions of PyrPA (5) with bis(sarcosinyl)-C2TCO (13)
and the rTCO derivative 6 (Figure b) revealed a 23-fold lower reactivity of
C2TCO in contrast to rTCO. We attributed this significant
drop in reactivity to the increased steric hindrance of an additional
allylic modification (Figure d), which is consistent with previous reports showing approximately
20-fold lower reactivity upon modification of one allylic position.[32]
H-Tetrazines for Fast and Complete Cleavage
To reduce
the adverse effect of steric hindrance in reactions with C2TCO, we aimed to develop H-tetrazines (H-Tz) modified with CO2H and NH3+ directing groups. Similar
reaction rates have been reported for aryl-Tz and H-Tz,[54] but in the case of C2TCO, we anticipated
that the significantly reduced steric demand of H-Tz might lead to
even higher click reactivities (Figure a). H-Tz have been shown to lead to incomplete or even
negligible release with rTCO;[37,48,52] the mechanism of this effect is as yet unresolved but sufficiently
robust for aryl-H-Tz that its pH dependence can be exploited to enforce
nonrelease of rTCO species.[48] In this case,
however, given that reaction with C2TCO will lead to a
directing group being in head-to-head position irrespective of the
click orientation (analogous to aryl-Tz, cf. Figure a), we speculated that the rapid release-directing
effect might supersede whatever pathways impede H-Tz-mediated release
for rTCO. Thus, we prepared HPA (19) and HK (20)[52] and proceeded to assess their global
click/release performance. As for their pyridyl and pyrimidyl-substituted
counterparts, HPA (19) and HK (20) achieved
quantitative cleavage (>99%) and, moreover, significantly increased
reaction rates (Figure a). As expected, HK (20) is more reactive, but HPA (19) showed even higher stability when using PBS solutions
for serial experiments over prolonged timeframes (Supporting Information). At higher concentrations (up to 200
μM) of the fastest tetrazines (HK (20) and PymK
(3)), we observed complete cleavage when analyzing the
mixture after a reaction time of just 2 min, leaving us unable to
disentangle the release rate from the initial click rate. The reaction
of AF594-C2TCO-AF594 (15) with selected tetrazines
at lower concentrations (10 μM C2TCO + 20 μM
Tz) confirmed our impression that release/cleavage is no longer the
rate-determining step, as observed release rates track closely with
click kinetics. Even with less reactive tetrazines, such as MPA (17) or PymPA (18), we could not detect any postclick
intermediates (e.g., A, B1, B2) but only
the as-yet-unreacted starting material 15 and the cleaved
product (see Supporting Information). On
this time scale, directing groups appear to trigger near-instantaneous
release, such that cleavage of C2TCO is controlled only
by click kinetics and Tz concentration. For the fastest tetrazines
tested, this enables fast and complete cleavage (>99%) with HK
(20) and PymK (3) at just 20 μM concentration
(Figure b). More generally,
C2TCO-Tz pairs enable direct control of the time required
for complete cleavage, as varying the Tz concentration can tune overall
reaction rates to the demands of a particular application. While cleavage
of the known cTCO-linker[33,49] by reaction with DMT
takes >1 h (using previously developed AF350-cTCO-Sar;[49] see Supporting Information), complete bioorthogonal cut of C2TCO can be achieved
within minutes (Figure c).
Figure 5
(a) H-tetrazines modified with a directing group enable complete
cleavage of C2TCO with significantly improved click rates
due to decreased steric hindrance. (b) Cleavage experiments at low
concentrations (10 μM C2TCO + 20 μM Tz) revealed
instantaneous release upon click (no intermediates detected) and complete
overall cleavage (>99%) with HK (20) and PymK (3) after 30 min. (c) Cleavage of C2TCO triggered
by HPA (19) or HK (20) is readily accelerated
by increasing the Tz concentration enabling complete bioorthogonal
cut in minutes (click = rate-determining). In contrast, the cleavage
of a known TCO-linker (cTCO) triggered by DMT (1) requires
>1 h to reach completeness (release = rate-determining).
(a) H-tetrazines modified with a directing group enable complete
cleavage of C2TCO with significantly improved click rates
due to decreased steric hindrance. (b) Cleavage experiments at low
concentrations (10 μM C2TCO + 20 μM Tz) revealed
instantaneous release upon click (no intermediates detected) and complete
overall cleavage (>99%) with HK (20) and PymK (3) after 30 min. (c) Cleavage of C2TCO triggered
by HPA (19) or HK (20) is readily accelerated
by increasing the Tz concentration enabling complete bioorthogonal
cut in minutes (click = rate-determining). In contrast, the cleavage
of a known TCO-linker (cTCO) triggered by DMT (1) requires
>1 h to reach completeness (release = rate-determining).
Extracellular Cleavage of Antibody-C2TCO Conjugates
Having developed C2TCO
as a new chemical tool to achieve
fast and complete cleavage triggered by acid- or ammonium-functionalized
Tz, we aimed to show its applicability in bioorthogonal turn-off strategies,
such as the rapid disassembly of fluorescently labeled antibodies.
Therefore, we modified bis(sarcosinyl)-C2TCO (13) to obtain DBCO-C2TCO-AF594 (21) as a stable
multifunctional click- and cleavable fluorescent tag (Figure a; for synthetic procedures
and details, see Supporting Information). The anti-EGFR-antibody cetuximab was labeled with 6-azidohexanoic
acid sulfo-NHS ester, and the resulting cetuximab-N3 was
then click-conjugated to 21 via strain-promoted azide–alkyne
cycloaddition (Figure a).
Figure 6
(a) DBCO-C2TCO-AF594 (21) as a click- and
cleavable fluorescent tag for conjugation with azide-labeled antibodies.
(b) Staining of EGFR-positive A431 cells with Cetux-C2TCO-AF594
(ON-state) and subsequent cleavage with HPA (19) (OFF-state).
(c) Cell imaging confirmed near-quantitative bioorthogonal disassembly
of Cetux-C2TCO-AF594 within 6 min.
(a) DBCO-C2TCO-AF594 (21) as a click- and
cleavable fluorescent tag for conjugation with azide-labeled antibodies.
(b) Staining of EGFR-positive A431 cells with Cetux-C2TCO-AF594
(ON-state) and subsequent cleavage with HPA (19) (OFF-state).
(c) Cell imaging confirmed near-quantitative bioorthogonal disassembly
of Cetux-C2TCO-AF594 within 6 min.We tested azido-antibodies at different degrees of labeling (DOL)
and analyzed the C2TCO cleavage of the clicked conjugates
after reaction with Tz. Unexpectedly, when clicked to the antibody,
we noted a consistent trend toward lower C2TCO reactivity
as the number of azides per antibody increased. Conversely, cleavage
yields improved as a function of the concentration of 21 in the antibody labeling reaction (higher concentrations = faster
intermolecular N3-DBCO click), strongly suggestive of an
intramolecular reaction of antibody-bound N3-groups with
C2TCO (see Supporting Information). We therefore recommend bioconjugation methods other than azide–alkyne
chemistry when designing C2TCO probes with a higher DOL.Nevertheless, at an average DOL of 0.9, Cetux-C2TCO-AF594
achieved >97% cleavage (for labeling procedures and details, see Supporting Information) and the respective probe
was therefore carried forward for further investigation. EGFR-positive
A431 cells were stained with Cetux-C2TCO-AF594, washed,
and imaged to establish target-specific staining and baseline brightness
(ON-state). Cells were then treated with HPA (19)[62] at a concentration of 500 μM in PBS to
ensure complete click in less than 3 min (Figure b). Serial imaging of the same field of view
demonstrated rapid cleavage upon addition of HPA (19),
with a dramatic reduction in brightness by the first measurement at
2 min (see Supporting Information) and
near-complete elimination of the signal within 6 min of Tz addition
(OFF-state). A quantitative line-intensity profile demonstrates the
excellent cleavage efficiency, exhibiting no discernible difference
between the regions with and without cells (Figure c). Hence, bioorthogonal disassembly of antibody-C2TCO probes will enable multiplexed imaging without any potential
rebound in brightness as the dye is cleaved and thus removed upon
reaction with Tz.
Intracellular Cleavage of Fluorescent C2TCO-Probes
Having shown the performance of C2TCO for extracellular
cleavage of antibody conjugates, we next aimed to test whetherC2TCO can be incorporated into probes that bind to intracellular
targets. Therefore, we first investigated the stability of C2TCO under physiological conditions. Incubation of bis(sarcosinyl)-C2TCO (13) in full cell growth media (10% FBS)
at 37 °C followed by titration with DMT revealed superb stability
(>97%) of C2TCO for up to 48 h (see Supporting Information).We have previously shown that
the covalent BTK (Bruton’s tyrosine kinase) inhibitor ibrutinib
(Ib) can be modified with several fluorescent dyes (e.g., silicon
rhodamine, SiR) while maintaining selective binding to BTK.[63,64] We thus prepared Ib-C2TCO-SiR (22, Figure a) and tested its
cell uptake and binding to BTK in live HT1080 cells stably transfected
with BTK-mCherry, followed by intracellular cleavage of C2TCO with HK (20) (Figure b). Live cells were incubated with 22 (2
μM), washed, fixed, and permeabilized (to facilitate efficient
removal of released SiR-compounds, which would otherwise interfere
with monitoring intracellular cleavage kinetics). Cell imaging by
fluorescence microscopy confirmed uptake and selective binding of 22 to BTK, as shown by excellent colocalization of mCherry
and SiR with a Pearson coefficient of 0.89 (Figure c, ON-state, top row). The cells were then
treated with HK (20) (20 μM) for 30 min, rinsed
with PBS, and imaged, showing efficient bioorthogonal turn-off (Figure c, OFF-state, bottom
row). In control experiments with native (BTK-negative) HT1080 cells,
we observed only minor nonspecific binding of 22 (see Supporting Information). Overall, we have been
able to show that (i) C2TCO can be incorporated into molecular
probes binding to intracellular targets and (ii) these compounds can
be disassembled on-target via fast bioorthogonal cleavage, (iii) even
after extended incubation (up to 5 h) in live cells demonstrating
excellent intracellular stability.
Figure 7
(a) Chemical structure of Ib-C2TCO-SiR (22) as a cleavable fluorescent ibrutinib conjugate.
(b) Cellular uptake
and binding to BTK of 22 upon treating HT1080-BTK-mCherry
cells, and subsequent intracellular cleavage with HK (20). (c) Fluorescence microscopy imaging showed excellent colocalization
of mCherry (green) and SiR (red), confirming selective binding of
Ib-C2TCO-SiR (22) to BTK (ON-state, top row);
efficient intracellular cleavage was observed upon treatment with
20 μM HK (20) for 30 min (OFF-state, bottom row).
(a) Chemical structure of Ib-C2TCO-SiR (22) as a cleavable fluorescent ibrutinib conjugate.
(b) Cellular uptake
and binding to BTK of 22 upon treating HT1080-BTK-mCherry
cells, and subsequent intracellular cleavage with HK (20). (c) Fluorescence microscopy imaging showed excellent colocalization
of mCherry (green) and SiR (red), confirming selective binding of
Ib-C2TCO-SiR (22) to BTK (ON-state, top row);
efficient intracellular cleavage was observed upon treatment with
20 μM HK (20) for 30 min (OFF-state, bottom row).
Conclusion
Although configured for
click-triggered elimination, the outcome
of the rTCO-Tz reaction nevertheless hinges on a complex array of
factors, including environmental conditions, click orientation, and
tautomerization events driven by the Tz side-chain(s). Informed by
our finding that aryl-Tz preferentially generate a nonreleasing tautomer,
we developed C2TCO as a new chemical tool to achieve fast
and complete bioorthogonal cleavage. We show that its C2 symmetry is key to achieving omnidirectional cleavage with acid-
and ammonium-functionalized Tz, irrespective of the orientation of
the initial IEDDA click reaction. Increased steric hindrance due to
the additional leaving group in the allylic position of the TCO scaffold
can be circumvented by using less sterically demanding H-tetrazines
modified with directing groups (CO2H, NH3+) that accelerate postclick tautomerization and enhance 1,4-elimination.
We observed second order rate constants for the initial click reaction
of up to ∼400 M–1 s–1 and
instantaneous release that is no longer the rate-determining step.
Complete cleavage (>99%) of C2TCO conjugates could thus
be achieved within minutes even at low μM concentrations of
both reactants and accelerated accordingly at higher Tz concentrations.Due to the unbiased click with Tz, one cannot control which one
of the two groups is released. While this is clearly not an obstacle
for bioorthogonal turn-off applications, it would lead to randomization
of the pyridazine moiety to either side of the cleaved linkage, highlighting
the need for further developments that can recapitulate the chemical
performance of C2TCO in the controlled delivery of molecular
cargo.Incorporating C2TCO into an antibody-dye conjugate,
we successfully developed a strategy to achieve fast extracellular
bioorthogonal cleavage within minutes. In a similar approach, using
the covalent inhibitor ibrutinib as a targeting moiety, we were able
to demonstrate fast intracellular cleavage of an ibrutinib-C2TCO-dye conjugate bound to its target (BTK).Fast and complete
disassembly is a prerequisite for bioorthogonal
turn-off and efficient molecular inactivation. The development of
C2TCO probes might thus enable not only new methods for
advanced multiplexed imaging but also Tz-triggered cleavage in vivo, for instance, the removal of fluorescent tags or
radionuclides from long-circulating compounds and thus the reduction
of background signal or prolonged radiation of healthy tissue. Moreover,
the design of C2TCO-fused (bio)molecules (e.g., bispecific
active compounds or C2TCO-embedded molecular scaffolds/backbones)
might allow temporal regulation of molecular function inside living
cells by Tz-triggered cleavage, significantly expanding the scope
of bioorthogonal ON/OFF control.
Authors: Walter Schubert; Bernd Bonnekoh; Ansgar J Pommer; Lars Philipsen; Raik Böckelmann; Yanina Malykh; Harald Gollnick; Manuela Friedenberger; Marcus Bode; Andreas W M Dress Journal: Nat Biotechnol Date: 2006-10-01 Impact factor: 54.908
Authors: Jina Ko; Juhyun Oh; Maaz S Ahmed; Jonathan C T Carlson; Ralph Weissleder Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2020-03-06 Impact factor: 15.336
Authors: Gergely Knorr; Eszter Kozma; Judith M Schaart; Krisztina Németh; György Török; Péter Kele Journal: Bioconjug Chem Date: 2018-02-20 Impact factor: 4.774
Authors: Labros G Meimetis; Jonathan C T Carlson; Randy J Giedt; Rainer H Kohler; Ralph Weissleder Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2014-06-10 Impact factor: 15.336
Authors: Alexi J C Sarris; Thomas Hansen; Mark A R de Geus; Elmer Maurits; Ward Doelman; Herman S Overkleeft; Jeroen D C Codée; Dmitri V Filippov; Sander I van Kasteren Journal: Chemistry Date: 2018-11-08 Impact factor: 5.236
Authors: Sinem K Saka; Yu Wang; Jocelyn Y Kishi; Allen Zhu; Yitian Zeng; Wenxin Xie; Koray Kirli; Clarence Yapp; Marcelo Cicconet; Brian J Beliveau; Sylvain W Lapan; Siyuan Yin; Millicent Lin; Edward S Boyden; Pascal S Kaeser; German Pihan; George M Church; Peng Yin Journal: Nat Biotechnol Date: 2019-08-19 Impact factor: 54.908
Authors: Jina Ko; Martin Wilkovitsch; Juhyun Oh; Rainer H Kohler; Evangelia Bolli; Mikael J Pittet; Claudio Vinegoni; David B Sykes; Hannes Mikula; Ralph Weissleder; Jonathan C T Carlson Journal: Nat Biotechnol Date: 2022-06-02 Impact factor: 68.164
Authors: Hannah M Peterson; Lip Ket Chin; Yoshi Iwamoto; Juhyun Oh; Jonathan C T Carlson; Hakho Lee; Hyungsoon Im; Ralph Weissleder Journal: Adv Sci (Weinh) Date: 2022-05-04 Impact factor: 17.521
Authors: E Johanna L Stéen; Jesper T Jørgensen; Christoph Denk; Umberto M Battisti; Kamilla Nørregaard; Patricia E Edem; Klas Bratteby; Vladimir Shalgunov; Martin Wilkovitsch; Dennis Svatunek; Christian B M Poulie; Lars Hvass; Marina Simón; Thomas Wanek; Raffaella Rossin; Marc Robillard; Jesper L Kristensen; Hannes Mikula; Andreas Kjaer; Matthias M Herth Journal: ACS Pharmacol Transl Sci Date: 2021-02-16
Authors: Jina Ko; Kilean Lucas; Rainer Kohler; Elias A Halabi; Martin Wilkovitsch; Jonathan C T Carlson; Ralph Weissleder Journal: Adv Sci (Weinh) Date: 2022-06-24 Impact factor: 17.521
Authors: Chuanqi Wang; He Zhang; Tao Zhang; Xiaoyu Zou; Hui Wang; Julia E Rosenberger; Raghu Vannam; William S Trout; Jonathan B Grimm; Luke D Lavis; Colin Thorpe; Xinqiao Jia; Zibo Li; Joseph M Fox Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2021-07-12 Impact factor: 16.383