| Literature DB >> 33026628 |
Aniello Maiese1, Alice Chiara Manetti1, Raffaele La Russa2, Marco Di Paolo1, Emanuela Turillazzi1, Paola Frati2, Vittorio Fineschi3.
Abstract
Although many clinical reports have been published, little is known about the pathological post-mortem findings from people who have died of the novel coronavirus disease. The need for postmortem information is urgent to improve patient management of mild and severe illness, and treatment strategies. The present systematic review was carried out according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review (PRISMA) standards. A systematic literature search and a critical review of the collected studies were conducted. An electronic search of PubMed, Science Direct Scopus, Google Scholar, and Excerpta Medica Database (EMBASE) from database inception to June 2020 was performed. We found 28 scientific papers; the total amount of cases is 341. The major histological feature in the lung is diffuse alveolar damage with hyaline membrane formation, alongside microthrombi in small pulmonary vessels. It appears that there is a high incidence of deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism among COVID-19 decedents, suggesting endothelial involvement, but more studies are needed. A uniform COVID-19 post-mortem diagnostic protocol has not yet been developed. In a time in which international collaboration is essential, standardized diagnostic criteria are fundamental requirements.Entities:
Keywords: Autopsy; COVID-19; Findings; Pathophysiology
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2020 PMID: 33026628 PMCID: PMC7538370 DOI: 10.1007/s12024-020-00310-8
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Forensic Sci Med Pathol ISSN: 1547-769X Impact factor: 2.007
Fig. 1An appraisal based on titles and abstracts as well as a hand search of reference lists was carried out. The resulting 125 references were screened to exclude duplicates, which left 48 articles for further consideration. In addition, non-English papers were excluded and the following inclusion criteria were used: (1) original research articles, (2) reviews and mini-reviews, and (3) case report/series. These publications were carefully evaluated taking into account the main aims of the review. This evaluation left 28 scientific papers (8 concerning minimally invasive autopsies, 20 concerning complete autopsies), distributed as original research articles, case report/series, reviews, and mini-reviews
Review of the literature on COVID-19 related-death autopsies, what kind of examination and analysis has been performed
| N° of Cases | Complete autopsy | Minimally invasive autopsy | Histology | Immunohistochemistry | Electron microscopy | Post-mortem imaging | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Xu et al | 1 | - | 1 | 1 | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported |
| Zhang et al | 1 | - | 1 | 1 | 1 | Not reported | Not reported |
| Dolhnikoff et al | 10 | - | 10 | 10 | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported |
| Yao et al | 3 | - | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | Not reported |
| Tian et al | 4 | - | 4 | 4 | 1 (in a case with CLL) | Not reported | Not reported |
| Duarte-Neto et al | 10 | - | 10 | 10 | 10 | Not reported | Not reported |
| Ramon y Cajal Hospital | 1 | - | 1 | 1 | 1 | Not reported | Not reported |
| Magro et al | 2 (5 including in life biopsies) | - | 2 | 2 | 2 | Not reported | Not reported |
| Su et al | 26 | 26 | - | 26 | 26 | 26 | Not reported |
| Barton et al | 2 | 2 | - | 2 | 2 | Not reported | 2 (full body a-p radiographs) |
| Grimes et al | 2 | 2 | - | 2 | Not reported | 2 | Not reported |
| Varga et al | 2 (3 including 1 intestine resection) | 2 | - | 3 | Not reported | 1 | Not reported |
| Bradley et al | 12 | 5 | 7 | 12 | Not reported | 12 | Not reported |
| Paniz-Mondolfi et al | 1 | Not specified | Not specified | 1 | Not reported | 1 | Not reported |
| Lacy et al | 1 | 1 | - | 1 | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported |
| Konopka et al | 1 | 1 | - | 1 | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported |
| Prilutskiy et al | 4 | 4 | - | 4 | 4 | Not reported | Not reported |
| Yan et al | 1 | 1 | - | 1 | 1 | 1 | Not reported |
| Fitzek et al | 1 | 1 | - | 1 | Not reported | Not reported | 1 (PMCT) |
| Edler et al | 80 | 80 | - | 12 | Not reported | Not reported | 80 (PMCT) |
| Bryce et al | 67 | 67 | - | 25 | Not specified | Not specified | Not reported |
| Menter et al | 21 | 17 | 4 | 21 | 11 | 2 | Not reported |
| Remmelink et al | 17 | 17 | - | 17 | 17 | Not reported | Not reported |
| Wichmann et al | 12 | 12 | - | 12 | 12 | 12 (only lung samples) | 10 (PMCT) |
| Schaller et al | 10 | 10 | - | 10 | Not reported | Not reported | Not reported |
| Aguiar et al | 1 | 1 | - | 1 | 1 | Not reported | 1 (PMCT) |
| Fox et al | 10 | 10 | - | 10 | 10 | 10 | Not reported |
| Carsana et al | 38 | 38 | - | 38 | On the most representative areas of randomly selected cases | 10 | Not reported |
| Total | 341 | 297 | 44 | 232 | 101 | 80 | 94 (2 RX, 92 PMCT) |
Review of the literature on COVID-19 related autopsies, summary of macroscopic and microscopic findings
| Minimally invasive autopsies | N° of Cases | Average age | Sex | Positive swab | Comorbidities | Cause of death | Main macroscopic pulmonary findings | Main microscopic pulmonary findings | Other findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Xu et al | 1 | 50 y | 1 male | 1 | Not reported | COVID-19 | - | DAD with hyaline membranes, oedema, inflammatory interstitial infiltration | Hepatic microvescicular steatosis, few cardiac inflammatory infiltrations |
| Zhang et al | 1 | 72 y | 1 male | 1 | Diabetes mellitus, hypertension | COVID-19 | - | Organizing DAD, fibrinous exudate, interstitial fibrosis, chronic inflammatory infiltrates | - |
| Dolhnikoff et al | 10 | 67.8 y (range 33–83) | 5 male, 5 female | 10 (not directly reported) | 7/10 patients had comorbidities: hypertension, diabetes mellitus, ischemic heart disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease | COVID-19 | - | Diffuse exudative and proliferative DAD, foci of alveolar haemorrhage, little lymphocytic infiltration, viral cytopathic damage of epithelium of alveoli and small airways, fibrin microthrombi in small pulmonary arterioles with a large number of megakaryocytes within pulmonary capillaries; in six cases, secondary bacterial pneumonia | Rare small fibrinous thrombi in glomerular and dermal vessels |
| Yao et al | 3 | Not reported | Not reported | 3 | Not reported | COVID-19 | - | DAD, inflammatory interstitial infiltration (macrophages and CD4-positive T cells), hyaline thrombi in small vessels, focal haemorrhage, pulmonary interstitial fibrosis | Spleen had less lymohocytes and necrosis; features of other chronic diseases in other organs |
| Tian et al | 4 | 59–81 y | 3 male, 1 female | 4 (not directly reported) | At least one of: CLL, cirrhosis, hypertension, diabetes, renal transplantation | COVID-19 | - | DAD, hyaline membranes, type II pneumocytes activation, fibrin cluster and fibroblastic proliferation, congestion, haemorrhages | Not specific changes, sinusoidal dilatation in hepatic tissue, irregular shaped myocardium with no signs of myocarditis |
| Duarte-Neto et al | 10 | 69 y (range 33–83) | 5 male, 5 female | 9 positive at nasopharyngeal swab and/or lung tissue | Hypertension, diabetes mellitus, chronic ischemic cardiopathy | Not reported | - | Exudative/proliferative DAD, cytopathic respiratory epithelium damage, fibrinous thrombi within alveolar arterioles (eight cases), abundance of alveolar megakaryocytes | Comorbidity-associated findings; shock signs; other findings: perivascular mononuclear infiltration of the skin in eight cases; myositis in two cases; orchitis in two cases; small vessels endothelial changes; microthrombi in various organs |
| Ramon y Cajal Hospital | 1 | 54 y | 1 male | 1 in life nasopharyngeal swab | Hypertension, gout, migraine, obstructive sleep apnea, obesity | Not reported | Heavy, firm and congested lungs | Minimal septal thickening and capillary congestion, rare mononuclear inflammatory infiltrate, alveolar cell desquamation, pneumocyte hyperplasia with cytopathic changes; diffuse exudative DAD with hyaline membranes and organizing DAD, platelet thrombi in small and medium vessels | Kidney cortical necrosis |
| Magro et al | 2 | 62 and 73 y | 2 male | 2 in life swab | In one case: coronary artery disease, diabetes mellitus, heart failure, prior treatment for hepatitis C virus infection, end-stage renal disease; the other case: obesity, prediabetes | Respiratory failure (not directly reported) | Congested lungs with hemorraghes | Hemorrhagic pneumonitis, septa congestion and fibrin deposition, in one case some evidence of DAD | Not reported |
| Complete autopsies | |||||||||
| Su et al | 26 | 69 y (range 39–87) | 19 male, 7 female | All | 11/26 hypertension, diabetes mellitus or both, 6/26 tumor in the past, 2/26 chronic kidney disease | COVID-19 | - | - | ATI, red cells aggregation into microvessels of the kidneys |
| Barton et al | 2 | 59,5 y (range 42–77) | 2 male | Both (post-mortem, nasopharyngeal and lung tissue swabs, + lung parenchyma for microbiologic cultures) | One of them: hypertension, cardiovascular disorder (autopsy finding), remote deep vein thrombosis and obesity (bmi 31,8); the other one: myotonic muscular dystrophy and obesity (bmi 31,3) | One case: COVID-19; coronary artery disease as “other contributing factors”; the other case: complications of hepatic cirrhosis; muscular dystrophy, aspiration pneumonia and COVID 19 as “other contributing factors” | Heavy lungs, red to maroon in color, edematous parenchyma that had diffusely firm consistency without focal lesions | In one case: DAD in the acute stage with numerous hyaline membranes and without interstitial organization; thrombi within a few small pulmonary artery branches; congestion and edema fluid focally; mucosal edema within the bronchial mucosa. In the other case: foci of acute bronchopneumonia along with rare aspirated food particles. In both immunohistochemistry showed CD3-, CD4 and CD8-positive T-lymphocytes | Not reported |
| Grimes et al | 2 | Middle-aged | 2 male | Both in life nasopharyngeal swabs | Well-controlled hypertension in one case; asthma, hypertension, HIV-infection under antiretroviral therapy in the other case | COVID-19 complicated by pulmonary thromboembolism (not directly reported as the cause of death) | Pulmonary thromboembolism; bilateral pulmonary consolidation | Confirmed thromboembolism (Zhan lines); viral inclusion within the pneumocytes; fibrin inside and outside capillaries alongside platelet thrombi | In both cases deep vein thrombosis; cardiomegaly and left ventricular hypertrophy |
| Varga et al | 3 | 58–71 y | 2 male, 1 female | 2 in life swab, for the third positive swab is not directly reported | Kidney transplantation, coronary arteries disease, hypertension in one case; hypertension, obesity, diabetes mellitus in the other case | 1 mesenteric ischemia, 1 multi organ failure, 1 still alive | Not reported | DAD, vessels endothelitis | Small bowel mucosa ischemia alongside with endothelitis of various districts. Viral inclusion in the kidney transplants |
| Bradley et al | 12 | 70.4 y (range 42–84) | Not reported | All in life or post-mortem | All patients had significant comorbidities: hypertension, chronic kidney diseas, obstructive sleep apnea, metabolic disease were the most common | COVID-19 | Heavy, edematous lungs with intraparenchymal hemorrhages in one case. In two cases pulmonary emboli were found | DAD at acute or organizing stage with reactive type II pneumocytes; focal areas of acute bronchiolitis and bronchopneumonia in two cases. Viral particles were detected in the lungs and trachea | Non-specific chronic damage of some organs at gross examination; in one case there was also acute tubular injury; some cases showed periportal lymphocytic inflammation. Viral particles were detected in the kidney and large intestines |
| Paniz-Mondolfi et al | 1 | 74 y | 1 male | 1 in life | Parkinson’s disease | Not reported | - | - | Viral particles in the frontal lobe and endothelial cells |
| Lacy et al | 1 | 58 | 1 female | 1 post-mortem bronchial swab | Type 2 diabetes mellitus, obesity (BMI 38), hyperlipidemia, hypertension, asthma, chronic lower extremity swelling and ulceration | COVID-19; contributory factors: type 2 diabetes mellitus, hypertension, obesity | Heavy, firm, and oedematus lungs, with some hemorrhage areas and thick mucus in the airways. Enlarged mediastinal lymph nodes | Oedema, hyaline membranes, mild mononuclear infiltrates of the septae, desquamated hyperplastic pneumocytes alongside multinucleated cells; no viral inclusion or cytopathic changes | Hepatic steatosis in a contest of congestion and central lobular pallor; mesangial sclerosis |
| Konopka et al | 1 | 37 y | 1 male | 1 in life swab | Asthma and type 2 diabetes mellitus | COVID-19 | Heavy lung with mucus within the airways | Chronic asthmatic alterations of the airways; DAD, fibrinous airspace exudate, and rare fibrin thrombi within the small pulmonary vessels | Not reported |
| Prilutskiy et al | 4 | 64–91 y | 3 male, 1 female | 4 in life positive swabs | Not reported | COVID-19 | - | Acute exudative DAD | Enlargement of mediastinal and pulmonary hilar lymph nodes, enlarged spleen only in one case |
| Yan et al | 1 | 44 y | 1 female | 1 in life nasopharyngeal swab | Obesity, probably unrecognized systemic lupus erythematous | Multi-organ failure | Heavy lungs with signs of pleuritis and enlarged peribronchial lymph nodes | Pulmonary edema and infarction areas; acute lung injury with lymphocytic infiltrates and hyaline membranes DAD; cytopathic damage of pneumocytes alongside viral particles; perivascular lymohocytic cuffing and few lymphocytic infiltration of the vessel wall; fibrin aggregates within blood vessels | Streaking of the right atrial wall myocardial tissue and right ventricle dilatation, microscopically mild myxoid edema, myocyte hypertrophy, focal nuclear pyknosis, CD45 + lymphocytes in the left ventricular papillary muscle; focal acute tubular injury, congestion of peritubular capillaries |
| Fitzek et al | 1 | 59 y | 1 male | Oropharyngeal post-mortem swab | Obesity, hypertension, cardiac hypertrophy, cor adiposum (seen at external examination and/or autopsy) | Cardiorespiratory failure with other comorbidities contribution (suspicion of viral pneumonia) | Firm, edematous lungs with greyish-yellow multifocal areas, signs of hemorrhagic tracheobronchitis | DAD with diffuse hyaline membranes, vascular compression and microthrombi, edema, mild lymphocyte infiltration and inflammatory cells within the septa | Congestive cardiomyopathy with cor adiposum as pre-existing pathology |
| Edler et al | 80 | 79,2 y (range 52–96) | 46 male, 34 female | All (74 in life swab, 6 post-mortem nasopharyngeal or pulmonary swab) | 38% overweight (13/80 cases) or obesity (17/80 cases), 85% cardiovascular disorder, 55% lung diseases, 35% CNS diseases, 34% kidney diseases, 21% diabetes mellitus, 16% carcinomas/haematological diseases In 2/80 cases no comorbidity identified | 76/80 cases COVID-19 (mostly pneumonia, 8/76 of which complicated by fulminant pulmonary artery embolism, 9/76 by peripheral pulmonary artery embolism); competing causes of death were noticed in 11% of total death;in 4/80 cases virus-independent cause of death | Heavy lungs, with mosaic-like pattern on the surface and evident capillary drawing; firm and fragile tissue | In 8/12 cases DAD at different phases; lymphocytes and plasma cells infiltrate in the small arteries. In 4/12 cases, granulocyte focal confluent bronchopneumonia | deep vein thrombosis (32/80) complicated in 17/32 with vary grade of pulmonary embolism; signs of other chronic diseases; 4/12 shock changes in liver, kidneys or intestine |
| Bryce et al | 67 | 69 y (range 34–94) | Not reported | All (in life nasopharyngeal swab) | Hypertension 62.7%, diabetes mellitus 40.3%, coronary artery disease 31.3%, chronic kidney disease 26.7%, asthma 17.9%, heart failure 14.9%, atrial fibrillation 13.4%, obesity 11.9%, co-infections 10.4%, cancer 7.5%, transplantation 7.5%, COPD 6% | COVID-19 | Lung parenchyma appearance ranged from patchy to diffusely consolidated; in one case, multiple cavitary lesions; 4/67 cases showed pulmonary emboli in the main pulmonary arteries | Acute/exudative stage DAD (22 cases), diffuse or focal hyaline membranes, pneumocytes atypia, in two cases intranuclear inclusions. 7 cases acute pneumonia (2/7 extensive and necrotizing); 14 cases showed capillary inflammation; CD61 stains (23 cases) revealed thombi in small and medium pulmonary arteries | Viral particles and replicative structures in the lymph nodes cells; in two cases, patchy mild myocardial interstitial chronic inflammation, in 15 cases patchy epicardial mononuclear infiltrates and predominantly CD4-positive lymphocytes infiltrate associated with small vessel thrombi in three cases and with hemophagocytosisi in another case; bone marrow hemophagocytosis in four cases, spleen hemophagocytosis in nine cases; acute tubular injury in six cases; in five cases liver showed zone 3 ischemic coagulative necrosis, five cases acute outflow obstruction, portal venules thrombi in 15 cases; in six cases microthrombi and acute infarction of the brain |
| Menter et al | 21 | 76 y (range 53–96) | 17 male, 4 female | All (in life nasopharyngeal swab, bronchoalveolar lavage or sputum) | All cases had at least one comorbidity. Hypertension and pre-obesity/obesity were the most common; in 14/21 cases renin–angiotensin–aldosterone system-modulating drug intake; in 2 cases immunosuppressive drugs intake; 1 case presented acquired immunodeficiency | Respiratory failure | Heavy, firm and congested lungs | DAD (mainly exudative, in 8/21 cases proliferative), with superimposed bacterial bronchopneumonia in 10/21 cases; capillary congestion; oedema; alveolar haemorrhage; in 5/11 microthrombi in alveolar capillaries | senile cardiac amyloidosis (more prevalent than in past), diffuse shock signs, diffuse acute tubular injury |
| Remmelink et al | 17 | 72 y (range 62–77) | 12 male, 5 female | All in life swab (not directly reported) | All except two had at least one comorbidity: hypertension (10/17), diabetes mellitus (9/17), cerebrovascular disease (4/17), coronary artery disease (4/17), solid cancer (4/17) | Respiratory failure (9/17) and multi-organ failure (8/17) | Heavy, firm lungs with haemorrhage areas; thrombi in the large pulmonary arteries in 2/17 cases; | Diffuse exudative DAD (15/17), alongside late-stage DAD, microthrombi in small lung arteries (11/17), lung infarcts (4/17) | 1/17 ischemic enteritis; kidneys often enlarged with pale cortex and petechiae, hemosiderin in the tubules lumen; 2/17 acute myocardial infarctions; |
| Wichmann et al | 12 | 73 y (range 52–87) | 9 male, 3 female | All (in life swab) | All cases had at least one comorbidity. In particular coronary heart disease (50%), COPD/asthma (25%), obesity, peripheral artery disease, diabetes mellitus 2, neurodegenerative diseases | COVID -19; in 4/12 complicated by cases massive pulmonary embolism | Heavy, firm and congested lungs, with pleurisy and patchy pattern | DAD, microvascular thromboemboli, capillary congestion, oedema; granulocytic infiltration when bacterial bronchopneumonia | 7/12 cases had bilateral deep vein thrombosis, 4 of them had also massive pulmonary embolism, 3/12 fresh deep venous thrombosis and no PE; not-specific histologic findings of viral infection; shock changes |
| Schaller et al | 10 | 79 y (range 64–90) | 7 male, 3 female | All (at hospital admission and post-mortem) | All cases had at least one comorbidity. In particular cardiovascular disease (most frequent), chronic kidney failure, obesity | COVID -19 | Not reported | Disseminated DAD at different phases, in particular in middle and lower lobes | 1 case with mild lymphocytic myocarditis, 1 case with sings of epicarditis; periportal lymphoplasmacellular infiltration and fibrosis at liver histology |
| Aguiar et al | 1 | 31 | 1 female | 1 post-mortem (tracheobronchial swab) | Obesity (BMI 61,2) | COVID-19 | Heavy and firm lungs, with bilateral haemorrhagic oedema | Oedema, DAD with hyaline membranes, focal intraalveolar haemorrhage, no viral inclusions or giant cells. CD3 + Tcell and megakaryocytes in the interstitium | Mild chronic tracheitis and microabscesses in the liver |
| Fox et al | 10 | Range 44–78 | Not reported | All (at hospital admission) | All cases had at least one comorbidity. In particular hypertension (most common), type 2 diabetes, obesity. One patient was immunosuppressed | COVID-19 | Heavy lungs (all but one) with diffuse oedema, firm tissue and patchy haemorrhage; thrombi in sections of the peripheral parenchyma | Bilateral DAD (2/10 early exudative phase, 7/10 transition to proliferative phase, 1/10 proliferative to fibrotic phase), thrombosed small vessels with associated haemorrhage | Cardiomegaly and right ventricular dilatation with single myocyte necrosis |
| Carsana et al | 38 | 69 y (range 32–86) | 33 male, 5 female | All (at hospital admission) | 9 cases diabetes; 18 cases hypertension; 4 cases past malignancies; 11 cases cardiovascular disorders; 3 cases mild chronic obstructive pulmonary disorders (available data only for 31 subjects) | COVID-19 | Pulmonary oedema and congestion with spotty involvement of the lungs | Acute or intermediate DAD in all cases, with atypical pneumocytes and diffuse peripheral small vessels thrombosis | Not reported |
Fig. 2Typical histological findings described in the literature: a–b lung tissue showed edema, early stage DAD with hyaline membranes (arrows) and intraalveolar hemorrhages (H&E, × 40, × 100). c Lung: microvascular thrombi (arrows) (H&E, × 60), capillary congestion, and edema. DAD: d exudative phases (arrows) (Anti-Surfactant Protein A Antibody, × 40) with microvascular thrombi (arrows) e (Weigert, × 20)