| Literature DB >> 33005118 |
Brendan J Nolan1,2, Ada S Cheung1,2.
Abstract
Venous thromboembolism is a documented risk of some estradiol formulations, but evidence evaluating the perioperative risk of continuation of estradiol therapy is limited. This narrative review summarizes literature related to the perioperative venous thromboembolic risk of estradiol, with a focus on feminizing genitoplasty for trans people undergoing feminizing hormone therapy. Given the dearth of evidence underlying gender-affirming hormone therapy regimens, much of the risk is based on the menopausal hormone therapy literature. However, the doses used for trans people undergoing feminizing hormone therapy can be significantly higher than those used for menopausal hormone therapy and escalating estradiol dose is associated with an increased thrombotic risk. Transdermal formulations are not associated with an increased risk in postmenopausal people. Feminizing genitoplasty is associated with a low thromboembolic risk. However, many patients are instructed to cease estradiol therapy several weeks preoperatively based on reports of increased thrombotic risk in trans people undergoing feminizing hormone therapy and hemostatic changes with the oral contraceptive pill. This can result in psychological distress and vasomotor symptoms. There is insufficient evidence to support routine discontinuation of estradiol therapy in the perioperative period. There is a need for high-quality prospective trials evaluating the perioperative risk of estradiol therapy in trans people undergoing feminizing hormone therapy to formulate evidence-based recommendations.Entities:
Keywords: estradiol; hormone; surgery; thrombosis; transgender; venous thromboembolism
Year: 2020 PMID: 33005118 PMCID: PMC7513447
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Yale J Biol Med ISSN: 0044-0086
Typical estradiol doses in trans and postmenopausal individuals.
| Oral estradiol or estradiol valerate | 2-6mg daily | 0.5-2mg daily |
| Transdermal patch | 100-150mcg daily | 25-100mcg daily |
Venous thromboembolism in trans individuals undergoing feminizing hormone therapy.
| Asscheman | Retrospective cohort | 303 | EE 100mcg | 19 (6.3%) | 4/235 (1.7%) |
| Prior | Prospective cohort | 61 | CEE 2.5 mg BD ¾ weeks | 0 | N/A |
| van Kesteren | Retrospective cohort | 816 | EE 100mcg Transdermal estradiol ( | 45 (5.5%) | 5 |
| Schlatterer | Retrospective cohort | 46 | Intramuscular estradiol valerate 40-100mg every 2 weeks | 0 | N/A |
| Dittrich | Prospective cohort | 60 | Oral estradiol valerate + GnRHa | 1 (1.7%) | Nil |
| Wilson | Prospective cohort | 30 | CEE ( | 0 | N/A |
| Ott | Retrospective cohort | 162 | Transdermal estradiol 100mcg/24hr | 0 | N/A |
| Seal | Retrospective, | 330 | Estradiol valerate ( | 4 (1.2%) | Not reported |
| Wierckx | Cross-sectional study | 50 | Various transdermal preparations ( | 3 (6%) | Nil |
| Wierckx | Cross-sectional study | 214 | Various transdermal preparations ( | 11 (5.1%) | 3 |
| Wierckx | Prospective cohort study | 53 | Oral estradiol valerate ( | 0 | N/A |
| Arnold | Retrospective cohort | 676 | Oral estradiol ( | 1 (0.15%) | Nil |
| Getahun | Electronic medical record-based cohort study | 2842 | Not reported | 61 (2.1%) | Not reported |
| Meyer | Retrospective cohort study | 155 | Transdermal preparations ( | 3 (1.9%) | 2 |
CEE, conjugated equine estrogens; EE, ethinyl estradiol; GnRHa, gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonist
Studies evaluating VTE risk by estradiol formulation.
| Scarabin | Case-control | 155 with VTE | 62/155 (40%) VTE cases – 32 (51%) used oral E2 | OR oral E2 vs. non-users: 3.5 (1.8-6.8) |
| Canonico | Case-control | 271 with VTE | 124/271 (45%) VTE cases – 57 (46%) used oral E2 | OR oral E2 vs. non-users: 4.2 (1.5-11.6) |
| Renoux | Case-control | 23505 with VTE | 1004/23505 (4.3%) VTE cases – 729 (72%) used oral E2 | EE oral E2 vs. non-users: 1.49 (1.37-1.63) |
| Canonico | Cohort study | 98995 individuals | 549 VTE cases | HR oral E2 vs. non-users: 1.7 (1.1-2.8) |
| Sweetland | Cohort study | 1058259 individuals | 2200 VTE cases | RR oral E2 vs. non-users: 1.42 (1.22-1.66) |
| Simon | Matched cohort study | 2551 individuals treated with transdermal E2 matched to 2551 individuals treated with oral E2 | 13/2551 VTE events in transdermal E2 group | OR transdermal E2 vs. oral E2: 0.42 (0.19-0.96) |
| Laliberté | Matched cohort study | 27018 individuals treated with transdermal E2 matched to 27018 individuals treated with oral E2 | 115/27018 VTE events in transdermal E2 group | IRR transdermal E2 vs. oral E2: 0.67 (0.49-0.92) |
| Vinogradova | Case-control | 80396 with VTE | 5795/80396 (7.2%) VTE cases – 4915 (85%) used oral E2 | OR oral E2 vs. non-users: 1.58 (1.52-1.64) |
CEE, conjugated equine estrogen; E2, estradiol; HR, hazard ratio; OR, odds ratio; IRR, incidence rate ratio; VTE, venous thromboembolism
Studies evaluating perioperative VTE risk with estradiol treatment.
| Vessey | Case-control | Oral contraceptives | 30 women with postoperative (various surgeries) VTE | 12/30 (40%) women used OC in month prior to surgery vs. 9/60 (15%) controls
( |
| Greene | Case-control | Oral contraceptives | 60 women with postoperative, post-infection or post-traumatic VTE | 21/60 (35%) women used OC in month prior to admission vs. 10/60 (16.7%)
controls |
| Sagar | Case-control | Oral contraceptives | 31 women with postoperative (Emergency abdominal surgery) VTE detected by
fibrinogen uptake | 6/31 (19%) women used OC (2 symptomatic and 4 asymptomatic) vs. 0/19 (0%)
controls. ( |
| Astedt | Prospective cohort | Ethinyl estradiol 50mcg or 200mcg | 19 women aged >50 undergoing uterine prolapse surgery taking EE 50mcg
( | Fibrin deposits found in 6/11 women taking 50mcg EE; 4/8 women taking 200mcg EE;
18/157 controls ( |
| Bernstein | Prospective cohort | Estrogens, not otherwise specified | 276 women aged >50 undergoing gynecological surgery | 12/31 (39%) women using estrogens vs. 35/245 (14%) those not using estrogens
( |
| Gallus | Prospective cohort | Oral contraceptive | 221 women aged 21-49 undergoing abdominal or gynecological surgery | 0/99 (0%) women taking OC vs. 1/122 (0.8%) women not taking OC |
| Vessey | Prospective cohort | Oral contraceptive | 4359 not taking OC undergoing various surgeries | 12/1244 (0.96%) women taking OC in month prior to surgery vs. 22/4359 (0.5%)
( |
| Hurbanek | Case-control | Oral or transdermal estrogens | 108 patients with postoperative VTE following hip or knee arthroplasty | 18/108 (16.7%) women used estrogens vs. 49/210 (23.3%) controls: OR: 0.66 [95% CI, 0.35-1.18; p=0.17] |
| Barsoum | Case-control | Oral contraceptive, oral or transdermal estrogens | 726 women with VTE (302 hospitalized with or without surgery) | OC OR: 3.29 [95% CI, 1.72-6.27; ( |
| Acuna | Case-control | Oral contraceptive ( | 31 women with VTE following trauma | OC use vs. no use. OR: 0.70 [95% CI, 0.70-0.80]; |
| Schulte | Retrospective cohort | Estrogens, not otherwise specified | 1469 patients following spine surgery | Estrogens vs. no estrogens. Univariate RR: 6.2 [95% CI, 1.4-26.1];
|
| Park | Retrospective cohort | Estrogens, not otherwise specified ( | 21261 patients who underwent spine surgery | 10 patients treated with estrogens, none with VTE |
EE, ethinyl estradiol; OC, oral contraceptives; OR, odds ratio; RR, relative risk; VTE, venous thromboembolism.