| Literature DB >> 32975376 |
Iuliana Coti1, Sabine Wenda2, Alexandra Andreeva1, Alfred Kocher1, Guenther Laufer1, Gottfried Fischer2, Martin Andreas1.
Abstract
This study aims to compare the immunogenicity of fresh decellularized with cryopreserved native heart valve allografts to identify potential immunological risks in subsequent organ transplantations. We measured the induction of allogeneic HLA class I and II specific antibodies and characterized donor-specific antibodies by Luminex-based single beads assay in both groups. Serum samples were collected before valve replacement, at 3 and 24 months postoperatively. Donor-specific HLA antibodies were assessed positive if the mean fluorescent intensity (MFI) was >1000. Between November 2016 and April 2017 patients with fresh decellularized homografts (n = 4) and cryopreserved native homografts (n = 4) were analyzed. Patients receiving cryopreserved native allografts reacted with broad HLA-specific antibody response. Antibodies were directed against mismatched HLA antigens of the donors but also against HLA specificities not present on the homograft with many antibodies having mean fluorescence intensity values >10 000. While HLA class I specific antibodies showed a significant increase (P = .002) in their MFI values on day 90, HLA class II specific antibodies did not show a significant increase (P = .069). In the fresh decellularized homografts group, no significant antibody induction was observed. Consequently, the native group presented significantly higher MFIs for HLA antibodies on day 90 compared with the patients receiving decellularized allografts (P = .021). No detectable HLA antibody response was observed after implantation of decellularized in comparison with cryopreserved native allografts. Lower immunogenicity as compared with native homografts might increase the chance of receiving a transplant if will be required later in the life of the patients.Entities:
Keywords: cryopreserved native allografts; donor-specific HLA antibodies; fresh decellularized allografts
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32975376 PMCID: PMC7702054 DOI: 10.1111/tan.14077
Source DB: PubMed Journal: HLA ISSN: 2059-2302 Impact factor: 4.513
Patient characteristics
| Factor | Cryopreserved (N = 4) | Fresh decellularized (N = 4) |
|---|---|---|
| Age, y, (SD) years | 51 (9) | 39 (18) |
| Gender, female (%) | 0 | 1 (25%) |
| Height (SD) cm | 175 (7) | 176 (8) |
| Weight (SD) kg | 79 (8) | 73 (8) |
| Body mass index (SD) kg/m2 | 25 (3) | 24 (1) |
| History of blood transfusions (%) | 0 | 0 |
| Perioperative blood transfusions (%) | 2 (50) | 1 (25) |
| Pregnancies | – | 0 |
| Previous cardiac surgery | 0 | 0 |
Note: Continuous data are presented as the mean and SD; categorical data as total number and percentage.
FIGURE 1Legend: Median MFIs on d = 0 and d = 90 grouped by homografts (native cryopreserved—“cryo” and fresh decellularized—“decel”). The black bold line in the boxplots denotes the median MFI value for pre‐homograft implantation samples; data show either MFIs of HLA class I and class II (“cryo,” “decel”) or MFIs of HLA class I (“cryo_I,” “decel_I”) and of HLA class II (“cryo_II,” “decel_II”)
Mean MFI values of HLA specific antibodies
| Mean MFI (SD) | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| d = 0 | d = 90 |
| |
| Cryo | 193.9 (10.8) | 7160.1 (314.1) | .001 |
| Cryo I | 166.1 (8.0) | 8719.7 (437.5) | .002 |
| Cryo II | 232.9 (23.1) | 4967.5 (404.7) | .069 |
| Decel | 241.8 (13.2) | 331.9 (22.1) | .327 |
| Decel I | 205.2 (10.9) | 263.0 (15.4) | .368 |
| Decel II | 293.2 (27.6) | 428.6 (48.0) | .308 |
Note: the mean MFIs for patient groups receiving different homografts (cryopreserved—Cryo and decellularized—Decel) both pre‐ (d = 0) and posttransplant (d = 90). Total values and a separate analysis of HLA class I and class II for both cryopreserved (Cryo I, Cryo II) and decellularized (Decel I, Decel II) homografts were provided, and the P‐value obtained by comparing the baseline values (d = 0) with the values at 3‐months (d = 90) in for all groups.
Virtual panel reactive antibodies
| vPRA in percent | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Type of homograft | d = 0 | d = 90 | |
| pat_1 | cryopreserved | 0% | 95,6% |
| pat_2 | cryopreserved | 0% | 99,6% |
| pat_3 | cryopreserved | 0% | 98,57% |
| pat_4 | cryopreserved | 0% | 95,01% |
| pat_1 | decellularized | 0% | 0% |
| pat_2 | decellularized | 0% | 0% |
| pat_3 | decellularized | 0% | 0% |
| pat_4 | decellularized | 0% | 0% |
Note: For each of the patients the pre‐ and posttransplant panel reactivity, that is, the expected frequency of donors within the Eurotransplant area that would have a positive virtual crossmatch, vPRAs have been calculated with the Eurotransplant vPRA calculator (ETRL HLA database 2.0). The P value designates the development of PRA between the two groups.
FIGURE 2A, Tracking of HLA antibodies for class I (left column) and class II (right column) at d = 0, d = 90, and d = 720 of each one patient receiving a decellularized homograft. The x‐axis shows the time course, where d = 0 denotes the day of implantation, d = 90 and d = 720 denotes the days of the measurements of HLA‐specific antibodies after implantation; the y‐axis indicates MFI values as a measure of the amount of HLA‐specific antibodies (MFI max = 25 000). Time course of the MFI levels has been interpolated by the Fusion software. Each colored line represents the course of an antibody with defined HLA‐specificity (indicated in the lowest part of each plot). The horizontal black bold line indicates an MFI of 1000. Antibody profiles for a patient with a fresh decellularized homograft are shown. The upper lane shows all detected HLA Class I or HLA Class II antibodies with an MFI > 1000. The lower lane shows donor‐specific HLA Class I (DSA Class I) or HLA Class II (DSA Class II) antibodies. They are directed to HLA antigens of the donor of the homograft. B, Tracking of HLA antibodies for class I (left column) and class II (right column) at d = 0, d = 90, and d = 720 of each one patient receiving a cryopreserved native homograft. The x‐axis shows the time course, where d = 0 denotes the day of implantation, d = 90 and d = 720 denotes the days of the measurements of HLA‐specific antibodies after implantation; the y‐axis indicates MFI values as a measure of the amount of HLA‐specific antibodies (MFI max = 25 000). Time course of the MFI levels has been interpolated by the Fusion software. Each colored line represents the course of an antibody with defined HLA‐specificity (indicated in the lowest part of each plot). The horizontal black bold line indicates an MFI of 1000. Antibody profiles for patients with cryopreserved native homograft are shown. The upper lane shows all detected HLA Class I or HLA Class II antibodies with an MFI > 1000. The lower lane shows donor specific HLA Class I (DSA Class I) or HLA Class II (DSA Class II) antibodies. They are directed to HLA antigens of the donor of the homograft