| Literature DB >> 32975187 |
Anita Wm Suijkerbuijk1, Marie-Josee J Mangen2,1, Manon R Haverkate2,1, Floriana S Luppino3, Sabine E Bantjes1, Leo G Visser4,5, Corien M Swaan1, Wilhelmina Lm Ruijs1, Eelco Ab Over1.
Abstract
BackgroundThe risk of contracting rabies is low for travellers. However, the number of Dutch travellers potentially exposed abroad following an animal-associated injury and needing post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) has increased, resulting in increased costs.AimHere, we evaluated the costs and the cost-effectiveness of different pre- and post-exposure interventions in the Netherlands, taking into account the 2018 World Health Organization (WHO) recommendations for the prevention of rabies.MethodsA decision tree-based economic model was constructed. We calculated and compared the cost of different WHO pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) recommendations, intramuscular vs intradermal vaccination and PEP subsequent to increased vaccination coverage in risk groups. We estimated cost-effectiveness, expressed as incremental costs per rabies immunoglobulin (RIG) administration averted, using a societal perspective. Statistical uncertainty regarding number of travellers and vaccination coverage was assessed.ResultsTotal costs at the national level were highest using previous WHO recommendations from 2012, estimated at EUR 15.4 million annually. Intradermal vaccinations in combination with the current recommendations led to the lowest costs, estimated at EUR 10.3 million. Higher vaccination uptake resulted in higher overall costs. The incremental costs per RIG administration averted varied from EUR 21,300-46,800.ConclusionsThe change in rabies PrEP and PEP recommendations in 2018 reduced total costs. Strategies with increased pre-travel vaccination uptake led to fewer RIG administrations and fewer vaccinations after exposure but also to higher total costs. Although larger scale intradermal administration of rabies vaccine can reduce total costs of PrEP and can positively influence vaccination uptake, it remains a costly intervention.Entities:
Keywords: Netherlands; cost analysis; cost-effectiveness analysis; costs; post-exposure prophylaxis; pre-exposure prophylaxis; rabies; vaccination
Year: 2020 PMID: 32975187 PMCID: PMC7533619 DOI: 10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2020.25.38.1900716
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Euro Surveill ISSN: 1025-496X
Post-exposure prophylaxis scheme for rabies, the Netherlands, 2018
| Category of exposure | PrEP | PEP |
|---|---|---|
| Category I (intact skin) | None | None |
| Category II (minor scratches or abrasions without bleeding) | Yes | 2 × RV (day 0, 3) |
| No | 4 × RV (day 0, 3, 7, 14–28) | |
| Category III (broken skin; contamination of mucous membrane with saliva) | Yes | 2 × RV (day 0, 3) |
| No | 4 × RV (day 0, 3, 7, 14–28) + RIG (day 0) |
PEP: post-exposure prophylaxis; PrEP: pre-exposure prophylaxis; RIG: rabies immunoglobulin; RV: rabies vaccination.
Source: [9,10].
Rabies vaccination dosage in current and former recommendations, the Netherlands, 2018
| Rabies vaccination | Current recommendations | Former recommendations |
|---|---|---|
| PrEP | 2 doses | 3 doses |
| PEP (not previously immunised) | 4 doses | 5 doses |
| PEP (previously immunised people) | 2 doses | 2 doses |
| RIG | 2–10 mL with a maximum based on body weight | 20/40 IU/kg |
IU: international units; PEP: post-exposure prophylaxis; PrEP: pre-exposure prophylaxis; RIG: rabies immunoglobulin.
Annual number of people possibly exposed to rabies virus, the Netherlands, 2016–2018 (n = 1,400)
| Type of PEP | n | PrEP | Percentages |
|---|---|---|---|
| Category III injury needing RIG and full series of vaccinationsa | 413 | No | 29.5% |
| Category III injury, no RIG indicationb, full series of vaccinationsa | 540 | No | 38.6% |
| Category III injury needing two vaccinations | 285 | Yes | 20.3% |
| Category II injury needing full series of vaccinationsa | 125 | No | 8.9% |
| Category II injury needing two vaccinations | 37 | Yes | 2.7% |
NA: not applicable; PEP: post-exposure prophylaxis; PrEP: pre-exposure prophylaxis; RIG: rabies immunoglobulin.
a Persons without PrEP, using current recommendations: four vaccinations; using former recommendations: five vaccinations.
b >7 days after start of PEP vaccination series RIG is not indicated anymore and according to Dutch guidelines, RIG is not indicated for injuries inflicted by monkeys.
Costs for rabies PrEP and PEP in Euros, the Netherlands
| Costs before travelling | MHS cost in EUR | GP cost in EUR | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| First consultation (per person) | 13.10 | 67.56 | Own calculations based on surveya |
| Follow up consultation (per person) | 5.45 | 16.89 | Own calculations based on surveya |
| Vaccine costs per IM administration | 51.64 | 51.64 | [ |
| Vaccine costs per ID administration | 6.81b | NA | Own calculations based on surveya |
| Delivery fee for pharmacy (first time) | NA | 14 | [ |
| Delivery fee for pharmacy (second time and further) | NA | 7 | [ |
| Vaccination card | 4.09 | 4 | Mean price found on travel clinic websites [ |
| Management MHS for persons needing RIG | 276 | Own calculations based on surveya | |
| Management RIVM for persons needing RIG | 371 | Own calculations based on surveya | |
| Transportation RIG | 125 | Mean costs, retrieved from RIVM | |
| RIG old recommendations (new recommendations), administered in the Netherlands | 2,000 (800) | Own calculations (2 mL = EUR 375) | |
| RIG, administered abroad | 2,731 | Mean costs per case, ECA | |
| Administration RIG | 31.76 | Own calculations based on surveya | |
| Management MHS for persons not needing RIG | 98.64 | Own calculations based on surveya | |
| Vaccine | 51.64 | [ | |
| Administration vaccination | 7.63 | Own calculations based on surveya | |
| Mean repatriation costs | 1,650 | Costs per case, ECAc | |
| Mean evacuation costs | 1,844 | Costs per case, ECAd | |
ECA: Eurocross Assistance; GP: general practitioner; ID: intradermal administration; IM: intramuscular administration; MHS: Municipal Health Service; NA: not applicable; PEP: post-exposure prophylaxis; PrEP: pre-exposure prophylaxis; RIG: rabies immunoglobulin; RIVM: National Institute for Public Health and the Environment.
All costs are expressed in Euros 2017.
a For details see Supplement (time costs of medical personnel including overhead expenses).
b The two-site ID regimen is included, therefore four doses in total.
c 9.5% of all persons needing RIG have repatriation costs.
d 7.4% of all persons needing RIG have evacuation costs.
Annual costs of rabies PrEP and PEP using different regimens, assuming no change in vaccination uptake, the Netherlands, 2018
| Former recommendations IM | Current recommendations IM | ID | |
|---|---|---|---|
| National costs for prevention (before travel) in EUR | |||
| Consultation | 7,050,700 | 6,807,800 | 6,807,800 |
| Vaccination | 5,878,700 | 3,927,200 | 1,353,100 |
| National costs for prevention after an AAI in EUR | |||
| Vaccinations and RIG | 1,401,300 | 1,086,400 | 1,086,400 |
| Consultation and coordination | 480,900 | 480,900 | 480,900 |
| Repatriation | 64,800 | 64,800 | 64,800 |
| Evacuation | 56,400 | 56,400 | 56,400 |
| Lost holidays | 423,000 | 423,000 | 423,000 |
| Costs in EUR per person vaccinated before travel | 411 | 336 | 275 |
ID: intradermal administration; IM: intramuscular administration; PEP: post-exposure prophylaxis; PrEP: pre-exposure prophylaxis; RIG: rabies immunoglobulin.
Costs, RIG administrations and ICER as a result of a 1.5-fold increased rabies vaccination uptake for diverse risk groups, the Netherlands, 2018
| Risk group | Travellers < 35 years | Travellers to south-eastern and western Asia | Men | Travellers to South America | Travellers having at least one risk factor | Travellers having all risk factors togethera |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Additional vaccinated persons | 11,970 | 9,800 | 8,570 | 1,800 | 17,290 | 3,410 |
| 95% UI | 2,850–22,100 | 1,880–18,530 | 1,280–16,540 | −3,280–6,730b | 51,60–31,160 | −1,750–8,810b |
| Avoided number of RIG administrations | 45 | 41 | 29 | 4 | 60 | 16 |
| Additional costs | 1,206,000 | 966,400 | 867,100 | 188,900 | 1,755,100 | 333,100 |
| 95% UI | 226,000–2,413,900 | 421,000–2,290,000 | 77.400–1,819,800 | −391,900–765,300b | 482,700–3,341,000 | −260,600–941,800b |
| ICER: Incremental costs per additional vaccinated person | 101 | 99 | 101 | 105 | 102 | 98 |
| 95% UI | 82–116 | 71–116 | 0.75–118.0 | 71–151 | 88–116 | 26–181 |
| ICER: Incremental costs per avoided RIG administration | 26,970 | 23,760 | 30,370 | 46,750 | 29,220 | 21,320 |
| 95% UI | 9,530–52,460 | 5,790–49,510 | 5,323–64,110 | −129,950–229,830b | 14,250–53,000 | −24,010–70,190b |
ICER: incremental cost-effectiveness ratio; RIG: rabies immunoglobulin; UI: uncertainty interval.
a This group consist of men younger than 35 years travelling to south-eastern and western Asia.
b Owing to low numbers in this specific risk group, the UI are not interpretable.
The table presents averages with 95% UI. Note that in Table 4 total costs per vaccinated persons are presented, whereas in Table 5 the incremental costs per additional vaccinated person are presented, and they are therefore not comparable. For full details see Supplementary Table S3.