John Snowdon1,2. 1. Discipline of Psychiatry, Sydney Medical School, Sydney, Australia. johnamblersnowdon@gmail.com. 2. Centre for Mental Health, Concord Hospital, Sydney, Australia. johnamblersnowdon@gmail.com.
Abstract
PURPOSE: There is a widespread belief that suicides around the world are under-counted. A substantial proportion of suicides may have been inappropriately registered as accidental or of undetermined cause or intent. There is reason to explore to what extent low suicide rates in some nations could be partly attributable to under-counting. METHODS: Mortality statistics of most countries are available on-line. Numbers of suicide deaths in Spain, and in England and Wales (E & W), in male and female 5-year age groups, in each year between 2014 and 2018, were documented, along with deaths coded to ICD-10 accident or 'undetermined death' categories. Crude mortality rates were calculated using official population figures. Single year suicide, undetermined death, and non-transport accidental death rates of 12 other nations were calculated. RESULTS: Spain's crude suicide rate per 100,000 remains low (7.89) compared to other nations; its event of undetermined intent (EUI) death rate was 0.09 (contrasting with E & W's 1.74). Its accidental poisoning rate is much lower than that of E & W. The study showed much higher rates of ill-defined/unknown cause deaths in late life in Spain (both genders) than in E & W, and age-associated increases in accidental drowning rates parallel with increased suicide by drowning. CONCLUSIONS: Reportedly low suicide rates in Spain could be partly attributable to increased rates of 'hidden suicide' (accidental drowning, male accidental poisoning, and possibly ill-defined/unknown cause deaths, but not EUIs). It would be appropriate (and not just in Spain) to increase numbers of verbal and/or forensic autopsies in questionable 'undetermined' cases.
PURPOSE: There is a widespread belief that suicides around the world are under-counted. A substantial proportion of suicides may have been inappropriately registered as accidental or of undetermined cause or intent. There is reason to explore to what extent low suicide rates in some nations could be partly attributable to under-counting. METHODS:Mortality statistics of most countries are available on-line. Numbers of suicide deaths in Spain, and in England and Wales (E & W), in male and female 5-year age groups, in each year between 2014 and 2018, were documented, along with deaths coded to ICD-10 accident or 'undetermined death' categories. Crude mortality rates were calculated using official population figures. Single year suicide, undetermined death, and non-transport accidental death rates of 12 other nations were calculated. RESULTS: Spain's crude suicide rate per 100,000 remains low (7.89) compared to other nations; its event of undetermined intent (EUI) death rate was 0.09 (contrasting with E & W's 1.74). Its accidental poisoning rate is much lower than that of E & W. The study showed much higher rates of ill-defined/unknown cause deaths in late life in Spain (both genders) than in E & W, and age-associated increases in accidental drowning rates parallel with increased suicide by drowning. CONCLUSIONS: Reportedly low suicide rates in Spain could be partly attributable to increased rates of 'hidden suicide' (accidental drowning, male accidental poisoning, and possibly ill-defined/unknown cause deaths, but not EUIs). It would be appropriate (and not just in Spain) to increase numbers of verbal and/or forensic autopsies in questionable 'undetermined' cases.
Entities:
Keywords:
Age patterns; England and Wales; Mortality rates; Spain; Suicide rates; Undetermined deaths
Authors: Chee Hon Chan; Eric D Caine; Shu Sen Chang; Won Jin Lee; Eun Shil Cha; Paul Siu Fai Yip Journal: PLoS One Date: 2015-05-20 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Ian R H Rockett; Eric D Caine; Hilary S Connery; Gail D'Onofrio; David J Gunnell; Ted R Miller; Kurt B Nolte; Mark S Kaplan; Nestor D Kapusta; Christa L Lilly; Lewis S Nelson; Sandra L Putnam; Steven Stack; Peeter Värnik; Lynn R Webster; Haomiao Jia Journal: PLoS One Date: 2018-01-10 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Peter Höfer; Ian R H Rockett; Peeter Värnik; Elmar Etzersdorfer; Nestor D Kapusta Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2012-08-11 Impact factor: 3.295
Authors: Konstantinos N Fountoulakis; Isaia Chatzikosta; Konstantinos Pastiadis; Prodromos Zanis; Wolfram Kawohl; Ad J F M Kerkhof; Alvydas Navickas; Cyril Höschl; Dusica Lecic-Tosevski; Eliot Sorel; Elmars Rancans; Eva Palova; Georg Juckel; Goran Isacsson; Helena Korosec Jagodic; Ileana Botezat-Antonescu; Janusz Rybakowski; Jean Michel Azorin; John Cookson; John Waddington; Peter Pregelj; Koen Demyttenaere; Luchezar G Hranov; Lidija Injac Stevovic; Lucas Pezawas; Marc Adida; Maria Luisa Figuera; Miro Jakovljević; Monica Vichi; Giulio Perugi; Ole A Andreassen; Olivera Vukovic; Paraskevi Mavrogiorgou; Peeter Varnik; Peter Dome; Petr Winkler; Raimo K R Salokangas; Tiina From; Vita Danileviciute; Xenia Gonda; Zoltan Rihmer; Jonas Forsman; Anne Grady; Thomas Hyphantis; Ingrid Dieset; Susan Soendergaard; Maurizio Pompili; Per Bech Journal: Ann Gen Psychiatry Date: 2016-08-09 Impact factor: 3.455
Authors: V Pérez; M Elices; G Vilagut; E Vieta; J Blanch; E Laborda-Serrano; B Prat; F Colom; D Palao; J Alonso Journal: Eur Neuropsychopharmacol Date: 2021-11-19 Impact factor: 5.415