| Literature DB >> 32895262 |
Claude Julie Bourque1,2, Sonia Dahan2,3, Ginette Mantha4, Martin Reichherzer3, Annie Janvier5,2,3,6.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Although stakeholders' participation in healthcare is increasingly recommended, bereaved parents are often excluded for perceived potential risks to them. The objective of this study is to describe the ongoing involvement and the perspectives of bereaved parents engaged in different types of activities in Neonatal Intensive Care Units and providers who work with them. DESIGN/Entities:
Keywords: neonatal intensive & critical care; neonatology; paediatric palliative care; qualitative research; quality in health care
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32895262 PMCID: PMC7476470 DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-034817
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Open ISSN: 2044-6055 Impact factor: 2.692
Characteristics of bereaved resource parents and their children
| Bereaved resource parents (n=8) | |
| Gender | Five mothers, 3 fathers (two couples) |
| Level of education | 2 x high school |
| 6 x college/university | |
| Occupation | Science, engineering, public or retail management, law, education, healthcare, public service, home parent |
| First time parents | n=5 |
| Experienced multiple birth and discordant survival | n=4 |
| Age of parent at child’s death | Min: 28; max: 43 |
| Year of birth/death of babies | 2005 to 2014 |
| Type of birth | 2 x triplets |
| 2 x twins | |
| 5 x singletons | |
| Gestational age (in weeks) | 1×39 weeks |
| 8 x less than 28 weeks | |
| Length of hospital stay before death (deaths all occurred in the NICU) | 1 x>3 months |
| 1×1–3 months | |
| 7x<1 month | |
| Number of babies who had surgery | 3 |
| Main diagnosis leading to death | 8 x complications associated with prematurity |
| 3 x necrotising enterocolitis | |
| 3 x sepsis | |
| 2 x pulmonary insufficiency | |
| 1 x congenital anomaly | |
*One participating parent lost two babies, which explains the difference in numbers (eight parents and nine babies)
NICU, Neonatal Intensive Care Unit.
Types of initiatives involving bereaved resource parents
| Types of initiatives | Total number of activities | Number of BRPs involved |
| Presentation at conferences, panels (testimonial, workshops, study results) | 24 | 3 |
| Co-redaction, co-author, sole author of articles or abstracts | 52 | 4 |
| Co-creation, review, editing research protocols, production of research tools, reviewing and co-creating consent forms | 46 | 4 |
| Data analysis, coding, interpretation of results | 22 | 4 |
| Member of Parent Advisory Board, member of Data Safety and Monitoring Committee | 8 | 1 |
| Collaboration in the recruitment of families, data acquisition | 6 | 4 |
| Testimonials and narratives integrated in courses | 18 | 1 |
| Co-teaching with providers and educators, co-evaluation of trainees during simulations, parental presence/feedback during simulations (workshops, case-based learning) | 8 | 3 |
| Interventions in the media and social media management | 53 | 1 |
| Staff/interdisciplinary meetings and presence at clinical care committees | 51 | 2 |
| Welcome visit for new parents | 37 | 2 |
| Creation, evaluation and dissemination of information resources for new parents (and bereaved parents) | 7 | 5 |
| Involvement in the coordination of resource-parent programme: matching provider’s projects with selected parents, recruitment, training and support of new resource parents | 42 | 3 |
| Hospital design/redesign, development of clinical care protocols, quality control projects, evaluation of clinical care | 32 | 4 |
| ‘Matched buddies’ for new bereaved parents (including contacts via internet or phone) | 28 | 3 |
| Fund raising (clinical care, resource parent initiatives, hospital foundation) | 21 | 2 |
| Structured meetings with NICU-parents: information sessions (filling forms, discharge planning, and so on) | 10 | 2 |
BRPs, bereaved resource parents; NICU, Neonatal Intensive Care Unit.
Preferences of bereaved resource parents for activities in palliative care
| Description of preferences | N BRPs |
Talk about my personal experience. Share my story with parents and families. | 7 |
Talk about my personal experience. Share my story with clinicians, students and researchers. | 7 |
Talk about my personal experience. Share my story with a wider public (conferences, fundraising activities, media). | 7 |
Communicate by internet or phone with bereaved parents and/or their families. | 6 |
Review and give my opinion on documents and/or information given to new bereaved parents. | 5 |
Be consulted by bereavement/palliative care teams to give my opinion on clinical care: committees, case presentations, and so on. | 5 |
Meet bereaved parents/families in person in the hospital. | 5 |
Meet bereaved parents/families in person outside the hospital setting. | 5 |
Communicate by Internet or by phone with NICU parents facing life and death decisions. | 4 |
Meet in person NICU parents who need to make life and death decisions (in the NICU). | 3 |
I prefer not participating in initiatives that take place in the hospital. | 2 |
I prefer not participating in initiatives that take place in the NICU. | 2 |
I prefer not being in contact with NICU parents or NICU babies. | 2 |
BRPs, bereaved resource parents; NICU, Neonatal Intensive Care Unit.
Positive experience and perceived impacts from parents
| Specific themes | Quotes |
| General theme: Helping others, making things better | |
| Giving the family perspective (7/8) | “I wanted to help. I can see things with the eyes of a parent.” (father) “Participating in this research gave a voice to families who are generally not able to write in the medical literature.” (mother) “I feel I was able to look at the research protocol through different eyes, those of a parent. I was able to give articles a parent voice.” (father) |
| Helping bereaved parents (6/8) | “I want to participate in a good cause. Help families the best we can.” (father) “We hope we have helped other families who mourn.” (mother) |
| Improving the system (6/8) | |
| Giving back (4/8) | “I find it important to give because we had the chance to meet wonderful people through this ordeal.” (mother) “Improve services and give back to the hospital and the team.” (mother) |
| General theme: Helping self, making sense | |
| Meaning making (6/8) | “Participating in these activities gives sense to all the experiences we had, no matter how difficult it was. I would even say that it fills and answers a need.” (mother) |
| Memory/legacy (5/8) | “I want to do this in memory of my son.” (mother) “This research project is a legacy from my child's life. She enabled this, she made it possible, and she made life better for other families.” (mother) |
| Empowerment (5/8) | “I like feeling useful.” (mother) “Collaborating in research projects that had to do with what my daughter had, it is some kind of control that I did not have during the hospitalisation.” (father) |
| Repairing/reinvesting the relationship with providers (4/8) | |
NICU, Neonatal Intensive Care Unit.
Figure 1Pyramid of complexity and risks: adaptable classification of types of initiatives in which bereaved resource parents can be integrated. NICU, Neonatal Intensive Care Unit.