| Literature DB >> 32887363 |
Ramez Kouzy1,2, Joseph Abi Jaoude1,2, Daniel Lin1,2, Nicholas D Nguyen1,2, Molly B El Alam1,2, Ethan B Ludmir1, Cullen M Taniguchi1,2.
Abstract
Pancreatic cancer and its treatment often dramatically impact patients' quality of life (QoL). Given this, as well as increased focus on QoL measures in clinical oncology, there has been a rise in the number of instruments that measure patient-reported outcomes (PROs). In this review, we describe the landscape of different PRO instruments pertaining to pancreatic cancer, with specific emphasis on PRO findings related to pancreatic cancer patients receiving radiotherapy (RT). Twenty-five of the most commonly utilized PROs are compared in detail. Notably, most of the PRO tools discussed are not specific to pancreatic cancer but are generic and have been used in various malignancies. Published findings concerning PROs in pancreatic cancer involving RT are also extracted and summarized. Among the measures used, the European Organization for Research and Treatment Cancer QLQ-C30 was the most commonly utilized. We recommend a careful selection of PRO measures in clinical pancreatic cancer research and care and encourage the use of a combination of symptom-specific and global QoL tools to more fully capture patients' perspectives.Entities:
Keywords: pancreatic cancer; patient reported outcomes; quality of life; radiotherapy
Year: 2020 PMID: 32887363 PMCID: PMC7563649 DOI: 10.3390/cancers12092487
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Cancers (Basel) ISSN: 2072-6694 Impact factor: 6.639
Patient-reported outcome (PRO) instruments available for use in pancreatic cancer.
| Instrument | Items | Average Time Needed | Population for Intended Use | Scope | Recall Period |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BFI [ | 4 items | 5 min | Cancer patients regardless of treatment status | Impact and severity of cancer-related fatigue | 24 h |
| BPI [ | 32 items | 10 min | Patients with chronic or acute pain | Severity and impact on daily functions of cancer-related pain | 24 h/ 1 week |
| BPI short form | 9 items | 5 min | |||
| CARES [ | 59 items | 30 min | Cancer patients regardless of treatment status | Functional, physical, emotional, social, and cognitive | 1 month |
| Distress Thermometer [ | 1 visual item | 1 min | Cancer patients regardless of treatment status | Distress level | 1 week |
| 35 item problem list | 3 min | Psychosocial and physical needs | |||
| Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale [ | 9 items | 5 min | Cancer patients regardless of treatment status | Psychosocial and physical needs | Dependent on clinical setting |
| EORTC-QLQ-C30 [ | 30 items | 10–15 min | Cancer patients regardless of treatment status | Functional, physical, emotional, social, and cognitive | 1 week |
| EORTC-QLQ-C15-PAL [ | 15 items | 5–10 min | Cancer patients in palliative care | Functional, physical, emotional, social, and cognitive | 1 week |
| EORTC-QLQ-PAN26 [ | 26 items | 10–15 min | Pancreatic cancer patients | Functional, physical, emotional, social, and cognitive | 1 week |
| EuroQoL (5Q-5D-5L) [ | 5 items 1 visual scale | 5 min | Cancer patients regardless of treatment status | Mobility, basic self-care, daily activities, and pain, discomfort | 1 week |
| FACIT-F [ | 13 items | 5–10 min | Patients with chronic fatigue | Impact and severity of cancer-related fatigue | 1 week |
| FACT-Hep [ | 45 items | 10–15 min | Pancreatic and hepatobiliary cancer patients | Functional, physical, emotional, social, and cognitive | 1 week |
| FHSI-8 [ | 8 items | 5–10 min | Pancreatic and hepatobiliary cancer patients | Functional, physical, emotional, social, and cognitive | 1 week |
| FHSI-18 [ | 18 items | 5–10 min | Pancreatic and hepatobiliary cancer patients | Functional, physical, emotional, social, and cognitive | 1 week |
| GIQLI [ | 36 items | 10–15 min | Patients with gastrointestinal diseases | GI symptoms, functional, physical function, social, and emotional | 2 weeks |
| MQOL [ | 17 items | 10–30 min | Cancer patients regardless of treatment status | Functional, physical, emotional, social, and cognitive | 48 h |
| MDASI [ | 13 items | 6 min | Cancer patients regardless of treatment status | Psychological and physical symptoms | 24 h |
| MDASI-GI [ | 24 items | 5 min | Cancer patients with symptoms caused by gastrointestinal cancer and its treatment | Functional, psychological, and gastrointestinal physical symptoms | 24 h |
| MSAS [ | 32 items | 15 min | Cancer patients regardless of treatment status | Psychological and physical symptoms | 1 week |
| PACADI [ | 8 items | <5 min | Pancreatic cancer patients | Psychosocial and physical needs | 1 week |
| PRO-CTCAE [ | 124 items | 20 items~3.4 min | Cancer patients in clinical trials | 78 symptoms from treatment toxicities that can be selected to build custom forms | 1 week |
| PROMIS [ | 4–8 items per symptom | 5 min | People with health conditions | Global health, distress, physical symptoms, cognitive function, etc. | 1 week |
| SF-36 [ | 36 items | 10–15 min | People with health conditions | Global health, distress, physical symptoms, cognitive function, etc. | 1 month/1 week |
| SF-12 [ | 12 items | 2–3 min | |||
| Spitzer Quality of Life (QLI) [ | 5 items | 1 min | Terminally ill patients | Daily activity, perceptions, behavior, and support | 1 week |
* = Validated in the pancreatic cancer population, BFI = Brief Fatigue Inventory, BPI = Brief Pain Inventory, CARES = Cancer Rehabilitation Evaluation System, EORTC-QLQC30 = European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire Core 30, EORTC-QLQ-C15-PAL = European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire for Palliative Care, EORTC-QLQ-PAN26 = European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire for Pancreatic Cancer, FACIT-F = Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy-Fatigue, FACT-Hep = Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy—Hepatobiliary Cancer, FHSI = Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy—Hepatobiliary Symptom Index, GIQLI = Gastrointestinal Quality of Life Index, MQOL = McGill Quality of Life, MDASI = MD Anderson Symptom Inventory, MDASI-GI = MD Anderson Symptom Inventory for gastrointestinal cancer, MSAS = Memorial System Assessment Scale, PACADI = Pancreatic Cancer Disease Impact, PRO-CTCAE = Patient-Reported Outcomes version of the Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events, PROMIS = Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System, and SF-36 = Short Form Health Survey.
Figure 1Patient-reported outcome (PRO) measure selection algorithm.
PRO in studies of pancreatic cancer involving radiation therapy.
| Author | Study Aim | PRO Measure | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Polistina et al. [ | Assessment of treatment response, local control, downstaging, pain, and QoL in patients with unresectable locally advanced PDAC undergoing SBRT. | SF-36 | No QoL difference between pretreatment vs. 3- or 6-month control follow-ups. |
| Quan et al. [ | Phase 2 clinical trial evaluating efficacy and safety of induction chemotherapy, followed by stereotactic ablative radiation therapy in borderline resectable and locally advanced PDAC. | FACT-G | No QoL difference between pretreatment and post chemotherapy, SABR, or surgery. |
| Krempien et al. [ | Phase 2 clinical trial evaluating Cetuximab and chemoradiation (IMRT) in locally advanced PDAC. | EORTC QLQ-C30, EORTC QLQ-PAN26 | Not available. |
| Morak et al. [ | Comparison between QoL in patients who underwent adjuvant CRT compared to those who did not. | EORTC QLQ-C30 | Better QoL in patients who underwent neoadjuvant CRT vs. observation only. |
| Knaebel et al. [ | Comparison between OS between adjuvant 5-fluorouracil, cisplatin, interferon alpha, and radiation therapy vs. folinic acid and 5-fluorouracil. | EORTC QLQ-C30, EORTC QLQ-PAN26, CES-D | Not available. |
| Herman et al. [ | Phase 2 clinical trial evaluating gemcitabine and SBRT in patients with locally advanced unresectable PDAC. | EORTC QLQ-C30, EORTC QLQ-PAN26 | Global QoL scores remained stable from baseline to after SBRT. Pain scores improved 4 weeks after SBRT. |
| Serrano et al. [ | To determine QoL during and after neoadjuvant CRT and surgery for patients with PDAC. | EORTC QLQ-C30, EORTC QLQ-PAN26, FACT-Hep | After neoadjuvant CRT, a transient increase in GI symptoms and a decrease in physical functioning were seen. After surgical resection, most QoL domains returned to baseline. |
| Short et al. [ | To determine QoL as part of a phase 2 trial using the 3D conformal CRT sandwich technique in PDAC. | EORTC QLQ-C30, EORTC QLQ-PAN26 | CRT improved local symptoms while not worsening global QoL. |
| Katz et al. [ | To compare the efficacy of preoperative 5-FU vs. 5-FU plus hypofractionated SBRT/HIGRT in borderline resectable PDAC, primarily focused on evaluating and estimating the 18-month OS rate. | PRO-CTCAE | Not available. |
| Haddock et al. [ | Phase 2 clinical trial to determine the efficacy, toxicity, and effects on QoL of radiotherapy with gemcitabine and cisplatin for patients with locally advanced PDAC. | SDS | No significant overall QoL difference between baseline and the last measurement. However, overall SDS scores indicated improved QoL (specifically insomnia, frequency of pain, and outlook). LASA pain scores improved. |
| Heras et al. [ | To analyze the effect of RT with 5-FU vs. RT with gemcitabine on QoL in patients with unresectable pancreatic cancer. | EORTC QLQ-C30 | Overall QoL for both arms with RT significantly improved notably for cognitive function, decreased fatigue, and reduced appetite loss. |
| Hurt et al. [ | To report QoL in patients with locally advanced pancreatic cancer during and after treatment with Cap- or Gem-CRT. | EORTC QLQ-C30, EORTC QLQ-PAN26 | QoL improved at the induction of CRT, experienced significant decline during CRT, and recovered after the end of CRT in patients. Slight QoL differences favoring Cap-CRT. |
| Loehrer Sr et al. [ | To evaluate Gem-CRT vs. Gem alone in patients with localized unresectable pancreatic cancer to determine if radiation improves survival or provides additional QoL. | FACT-Hep | No statistically significant QoL differences between Gem-CRT vs. Gem alone from the baseline comparison beyond week 6. However, there was a statistically significant decline in QoL among participants within each treatment arm from baseline to week 6. |
| Moore et al. [ | Phase III trial to evaluate the effects of the addition of Erlotinib with Gemcitabine in patients with unresectable, locally advanced, or metastatic pancreatic cancer. | EORTC QLQ-C30 | No significant difference in QoL between both treatment groups, with the exception of worsening diarrhea in the Erlotinib + Gemcitabine group. |
| Neoptolemos et al. [ | Randomized control trial to evaluate the role of adjuvant chemoradiation and chemotherapy in patients with resectable pancreatic cancer. | ESPAC-1 QoL Form (based on EORTC QLQ-C30) | Overall, QoL increased for treatment groups (adjuvant CRT and chemotherapy vs. null) over 3 months from the baseline. |
| Neoptolemos et al. [ | Phase 3 trial to evaluate the efficacy and safety of the combination of gemcitabine and capecitabine vs. gemcitabine alone in patients with resected pancreatic cancer. | EORTC QLQ-C30 | No significant effect in the longitudinal estimate of QoL by treatment group. |
| Oettle et al. [ | To determine whether adjuvant gemcitabine post-resection of pancreatic cancer improves disease-free survival by 6 months or more. | Spitzer QL-Index | QoL improved in both groups, with no significant differences between groups at any time point. |
| Conroy et al. [ | Phase 2 and 3 trials to explore the differences between 5-FU and single-agent gemcitabine as a first-line treatment in patients with metastatic pancreatic cancer. | EORTC QLQ-C30 | No overall differences in QoL between treatment groups, except 5-FU initially had higher scores for diarrhea, or of QoL in the 5-FU group as compared with the gemcitabine group. |
PDAC = Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma, SBRT = Stereotactic body radiation therapy, SF-36 = Short Form Health Survey, QoL = Quality of life, FACT-G = Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy—General, SABR = stereotactic ablative body radiotherapy, IMRT = Intensity modulated radiation therapy, EORTC-QLQC30 = European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire Core 30, EORTC-QLQ-PAN26 = European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire for Pancreatic Cancer, CRT = Chemoradiation, OS = Overall survival, CES-D = Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale, FACT-Hep = Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy—Hepatobiliary Cancer, GI = Gastrointestinal, HIGRT = Hypofractionated image-guided radiation therapy, PRO-CTCAE = Patient-Reported Outcomes version of the Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events, SDS = Symptom Distress Scale, LASA = Linear Analog Self-Assessment, and RT = Radiation therapy.