| Literature DB >> 32825085 |
Jose Manuel Jurado-Castro1, Mercedes Gil-Campos1,2,3, Hugo Gonzalez-Gonzalez4, Francisco Jesus Llorente-Cantarero1,2,5.
Abstract
Despite the existence of global recommendations for physical activity and lifestyle to avoid childhood obesity, there are no specific recommendations for school-age children. The aim of this meta-analysis was to measure the effects of current interventions with a physical activity component on body mass index (BMI) Z-score and on the moderate and vigorous physical activity (MVPA) time, measured by accelerometry, and focused on children with obesity. Randomized controlled trial studies (RCTs) based on physical activity interventions focused on children with obesity (6 to 12 years old) from January 1991 to August 2018 were included. The post-intervention mean and standard deviation of the BMI Z-score and MVPA engaged time were extracted to calculate the results using random effects models. Of a total of 229 studies considered potentially eligible, only 10 RCTs met the inclusion criteria. There were improvements in the BMI Z-score for physical activity intervention groups, compared with non-intervention children in addition to a significant increase in time engaged in MVPA. In conclusion, interventions with a physical activity component in school-children with obesity seem to be effective at reducing BMI and producing an increase in time spent engaged in physical activity. Therefore, interventions based on physical activity should be considered one of the main strategies in treating childhood obesity.Entities:
Keywords: accelerometry; active life; child; exercise; schools
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32825085 PMCID: PMC7503305 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph17176031
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Figure 1Flow diagram for the scientific paper selection from databases. RCTs, randomized controlled trials.
Characteristics of selected studies by interventions content physical activity and accelerometry [30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38,39].
| Study | Group | Sample (n) | Included Only Obese Children (Yes/No) /Obese Children (%) | Gender (%F) | Treatment Length | Intervention | Treatment Content PA | Accelerometer | Accelerometer Time | Author Accelerometer Protocol |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arauz-Boudreau et al. (2013) | Control | 12 | No/NR | 61% | 6 months | Lifestyle educational classes and PA training sessions | 5 consecutive weekly sessions, increased to six 3 months later. | ActiGraph GT1M | Complete week; ≥8 | Trost, 2005 |
| Cliff et al. (2011) | Control | 42 | No/78% | 58% | 12 months | PA skill development program and dietary modification programs aimed at parents | 6 months intervention divided into two components: 10-week face to face and 3 months with minimal contact. The first phase of treatment included weekly 2 h group sessions (90 min PA per session) and weekly ‘‘home challenge’’ activities. | ActiGraph 7164 | ≥8 consecutive days during waking hours | Freedson, 1997 |
| Davis et al. (2013) | Control | 27 | Yes/100% | 39% | 8 months | Multidisciplinary actions based on psychoeducational group sessions delivered via telemedicine | Session over the phone with parents to encourage healthy habits. 1-h duration for 8 weeks | ActiGraph | Complete week; ≥6 h on ≥3 days | Sirard, 2000 |
| Farpour-Lambert et al. (2009) | Control | 22 | Yes/100% | 64% | 3 months (3 months post-intervention) | PA training sessions | The exercise group trained 60 min 3 times/week for 3 months. | ActiGraph MT 6471 | Complete week; 24 h/day on ≥4 days (including 1 weekend day) | Ekelund, 2001 |
| Maddison et al. (2011) | Control | 162 | No/NR | 37% | 6 months | Active video games | Children were encouraged to meet the current PA recommendations by supplementing periods of inactivity or substituting periods of traditional non-active video games for playing AVG. | ActiGraph AM7164-2.2C | Complete week | Freedson, 2005 |
| O’Connor et al. (2013) | Control | 20 | Yes/100% | 80% | 7 months | Healthy family activity and nutritional recommendations | Promote healthy child lifestyle behavior with effective behavior-specific parenting practices | ActiGraph 7064 | ≥5 days; ≥800 min/day | Treuth, 2004 |
| Serra-Paya et al. (2015) | Control | 59 | No/NR | 44% | 8 months | PA sessions, theoretical and practical sessions for parents, behavior strategy sessions for both children and parents, and weekend activities. | 90 min PA session—3 ses/w for 8 months | ActiGraph GT3X+ | ≥8 consecutive days during waking hours | NR |
| Taylor et al. (2015) | Control | 102 | No/NR | 55% | 24 months | Family-based intervention with specific goals based on dietary intake and PA | Families attended monthly multidisciplinary sessions to develop specific goals suitable for the first year. Thereafter, every third month for another 12 months to discuss progress and provide support. | ActiGraph GT3X | Complete week; ≥8 | Evenson, 2008 |
| Trost et al. (2014) | Control | 41 | No/35,7% | 55% | 4 months | Lifestyle educational parents and programmed active gaming | 24 session topics about aspects of nutrition, sleep hygiene, PA, screen time, and AVG 60 min PA AVG session | ActiGraph GT3X / GT3X+ | Complete week; ≥9 h on ≥3 days | Evenson, 2008 |
| Wafa et al. (2011) | Control | 55 | Yes/100% | 50% | 6 months | Information based nutrition and health education | 60 min PA intervention sessions (8 sessions for 6 months) | ActiGraph GT1M | 5 days; ≥10 h on ≥4 days | Reilly, 2003 |
| Puyau, 2002 |
AVG, active video games; F, female; NR, not referred; PA, physical activity; ses/w, sessions per week.
Figure 2Effect interventions on BMI Z-score reduction. (A) BMI Z-score values forest plot. (B) Sensitivity analysis of BMI Z-score forest plot (O’Connor et al. study [32] not included). CI, confidence interval.
Figure 3Effect interventions on BMI Z-score reduction in studies only including children with obesity. (A) BMI Z-score values forest plot. (B) Sensitivity analysis of BMI Z-score forest plot (O’Connor et al. [32] study not included). CI, confidence interval.
Figure 4Effect interventions on increased moderate to vigorous physical activity time in minutes. (A) Moderate to vigorous physical activity levels forest plot. (B) Sensitivity analysis of moderate to vigorous physical activity forest plot (O’Connor et al. [32] not included). CI, confidence interval.