| Literature DB >> 32816230 |
Jerome R Lechien1,2,3,4, Thomas Radulesco5,6, Justin Michel5,6, Sven Saussez5,7,8, Christian Calvo-Henriquez5,9, Carlos M Chiesa-Estomba5,10, Stéphane Hans5,11, Maria R Barillari5,12, Giovanni Cammaroto5,13, Géraldine Descamps5,7, Julien Hsieh5,14, Luigi Vaira5,15, Giacomo De Riu5,15, Leigh Sowerby5,16, Isabelle Gengler5,17.
Abstract
To review the data regarding the expression of angiotensin converting enzyme-2 (ACE2) and transmembrane protease serine-2 (TMPRSS2) in head and neck tissue. Scopus, Cochrane Library, Medrxiv, Google Scholar and PubMED/MEDLINE were searched by four independent investigators for studies investigating ACE2 or TMPRSS2 expressions in head and neck tissues. The following outcomes were considered: sample origin (animal versus human); detection method; anatomical location and cell types. PRISMA checklist and modified population, intervention, comparison, outcome, timing and setting (PICOTS) framework were used to perform the review. Of the 24 identified studies, 17 met our inclusion criteria. Thirteen studies were conducted during the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2) pandemic. ACE2 and TMPRSS2 were expressed in oral, pharyngeal, sinusonasal human mucosa. The following cell types expressed ACE2: basal, apical, goblet, minor salivary, and endothelial cells. TMPRSS2 was found in goblet and apical respiratory cells. ACE2 and TMPRSS2 were found in the olfactory region, especially in sustentacular non-neural and neural stem cells. Animal studies suggested that ACE2 expression may vary regarding age. There was an important heterogeneity between studies in the methods used to detect ACE2 and TMPRSS2, leading to a potential identification bias. The SARS-CoV-2 receptors, ACE2 and TMPRSS2, are both expressed in many head and neck tissues, enabling the viral entry into the host organism.Entities:
Keywords: ACE2; COVID; Coronavirus; Head Neck; SARS-CoV-2; TMPRSS2
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32816230 PMCID: PMC7439628 DOI: 10.1007/s12105-020-01212-5
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Head Neck Pathol ISSN: 1936-055X
Studies reporting ACE2 or TMPRSS2 head and neck expression
| Authors | Design | Samples | Methods | ACE2 & TMPRSS2 expression | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vaarala | Mixed | Human | 1. TMPRSS2 is expressed in human salivary gland tissues | ||
| 2001 [ | Study | Mouse | RNAseq | ||
| Hamming | Human | Human | 1. ACE2 was found in endothelial (arteries & veins) and epithelial cells of nasal, rhinopharyngeal and oral mucosa. Precisely, the epithelium expression concerned the basal layer cells | ||
| 2004 [ | Study | IHC | |||
| Jia | Human | Human | 1. ACE2 was more expressed on the apical than the basolateral surface of polarized airway epithelia | ||
| 2005 [ | Study | IHC & biotinylation | |||
| Liu | Experimenal | Monkey | 1. ACE2 is expressed in salivary gland ducts of the pharyngeal glands | ||
| 2011 [ | Study | IHC | 2. ACE2 was expressed in epithelial cells (lamina propria, respiratory tract) | ||
| 3. Virus was found in saliva of infected monkeys | |||||
| Bilinska | Animal | Mouse | 1. ACE2 & TMPRSS2 are expressed in sustentacular cells of the olfactory epithelium but not/much less in most olfactory receptor neurons | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | RNAseq, RT-PCR, | |||
| In situ hybridization, | 2. Expression of the entry proteins increases in animals of old age | ||||
| WB & IHC | |||||
| Brann | Mixed | Mouse | 1. In human, ACE2 & TMPRSS2 were not identified in purified olfactory neurons | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | Human | RNAseq | ||
| 2. ACE2 was identified in glial cells & olfactory stem cells | |||||
| Butowt | Mixed | Mouse | 1. Nasal epithelial cells have lower levels of ACE2 & TMPRSS2 compared with epithelial cells of the lower respiratory tract | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | Human | RNAseq | ||
| 2. ACE2 has non-neuronal expression in olfactory epithelium | |||||
| 3. The expression of ACE2 & TMPRSS2 (mouse) were increased in elderly mouse | |||||
| Cao | Human | Human | No localization provided | 1.15 unique expression quantitative trait loci variants were found for ACE2 | |
| 2020 [ | Study | Genetic Analyzis | 2. The genotypes of ACE2 gene polymorphism may be characterized by higher expression levels of ACE2 in East Asian population | ||
| 3. There would be different susceptibility or response to SARS-CoV2 in different populations | |||||
| Chen | Human | Human | 1. ACE2 is expressed in human granular cells of salivary glands | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | RNAseq | |||
| Hikmet | Human | Human | 1. There was no ACE2 expression in nasopharyngeal cells | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | IHC | ACE2 (human): no expression in nasopharynx | ||
| Lee | Human | Human | 1. ACE2 is expressed in ciliated epithelial cells (cilia organelle) | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | IHC | 2.There was no ACE2 expression in the non-ciliated goblet cells | ||
| 3. ACE2 expression is influenced by patient demographics, clinical characteristics, co-morbidities, or medication use. The use of ACE inhibitor drugs did not increase ACE2 protein expression | |||||
| Li | Human | Human | 1. ACE2 is expressed by thyroid cells | ||
| Hikmet | Human | Human | 1. There was no ACE2 expression in nasopharyngeal cells | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | IHC | ACE2 (human): no expression in nasopharynx | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | RNAseq | ACE2 human:+ | ||
| Sungnak | Human | Human | 1. ACE2 was expressed in airway epithelial cells | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | RNAseq | 2. ACE2 is more expressed in nasal epithelial cells compared with other respiratory cells (goblet & ciliated cells) | ||
| 3. TMPRSS2 is only expressed in a subset of ACE2 + cells | |||||
| Xu | Human | Human | 1. ACE2 is expressed in the oral cavity epithelial cells | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | RNAseq | 2. ACE2 expression was higher in tongue than buccal and gingival tissues | ||
| Xu | Human | Human | 1. ACE2 is expressed in minor salivary glands | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | RNAseq | |||
| Wu | Human | Human | 1. ACE is expressed in nasal epithelial cells | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | RNAseq | ACE2 (human):+ | 2. The was a higher virus concentration in the nasal-swab comparing with throat-swab, which is attributed to ACE2-expression in nasal epithelial cells | |
| Ziegler | Mixed | Human | 1. ACE2 & TMPRSS2 are co-expressed in nasal goblet secretory cells | ||
| 2020 [ | Study | Monkey | RNAseq |
ACE2 Angiotensin Converting Enzyme-2, IHC Immunohistochemistry, RT-PCR reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction, SARS-CoV-2 severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2, TMPRSS2 transmembrane protease serine-2, WB Western Blotting
Fig. 1Flow chart. ACE2 Angiotensin Converting Enzyme-2, TMPRSS2 transmembrane protease serine-2
Summary of Cell Expression of ACE2 and TMPRSS2
| Authors | Samples | Tissue | Cell types | ACE2 | TMPRSS2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bilinska [ | Mouse | Olfactory | Sustentatorial | + | + |
| Brann [ | Human & Mouse | Olfactory | Sustentatorial | + | + |
| Neuronal | - | - | |||
| Stem Neuronal | + | + | |||
| Butowt [ | Human & Mouse | Nasal | Epithelial | + | + |
| Olfactory | Sustentatorial | + | − | ||
| Neuronal | − | − | |||
| Chen [ | Human | Major Salivary Gland | Granular | + | NA |
| Hamming [ | Human | Oral, Nasal, Nasopharyngeal | Basal layer | + | NA |
| Endothelial | + | NA | |||
| Hikmet [ | Human | Nasopharyngeal | Epithelial | − | NA |
| Jia [ | Human | Apical Epithelial | + | NA | |
| Endothelial | + | NA | |||
| Lee [ | Human | Tracheal, Nasal, Sinusal | Apical Epithelial | + | NA |
| Goblet | − | NA | |||
| Li [ | Human | Thyroid | Unspecified | + | NA |
| Liu [ | Monkey | Pharyngeal | Minor salivary ductal | + | NA |
| Tracheal | Basal layer | + | NA | ||
| Sungnak [ | Human | Tracheal & Nasal | Goblet | + | + |
| Apical Epithelial | + | + | |||
| Vaarala [ | Human & Mouse | Major Salivary Gland | Unspecified | NA | + |
| Xu [ | Human | Oral | Apical Epithelial | + | NA |
| Fibroblast | + | NA | |||
| T- and B-cells | + | NA | |||
| Xu [ | Human | Minor Salivary Gland | Unspecified | + | NA |
| Wu [ | Human | Nasal | Unspecified | + | NA |
| Oral | Basal layer | + | NA | ||
| Ziegler [ | Human, Mouse & | Nasal & Sinusal | Goblet | + | + |
| Monkey |
ACE2 Angiotensin Converting Enzyme-2, NA not available, transmembrane protease serine-2
Fig. 2Epithelium of Olfactory Cleft. The figure summarizes the olfactory cleft epithelium