| Literature DB >> 32815497 |
Sundus Ahmed1, Richard Reithinger2, Stephen K Kaptoge1, Jeremiah M Ngondi3.
Abstract
By sustaining transmission or causing malaria outbreaks, imported malaria undermines malaria elimination efforts. Few studies have examined the impact of travel on malaria epidemiology. We conducted a literature review and meta-analysis of studies investigating travel as a risk factor for malaria infection in sub-Saharan Africa using PubMed. We identified 22 studies and calculated a random-effects meta-analysis pooled odds ratio (OR) of 3.77 (95% CI: 2.49-5.70), indicating that travel is a significant risk factor for malaria infection. Odds ratios were particularly high in urban locations when travel was to rural areas, to more endemic/high transmission areas, and in young children. Although there was substantial heterogeneity in the magnitude of association across the studies, the pooled estimate and directional consistency support travel as an important risk factor for malaria infection.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32815497 PMCID: PMC7543864 DOI: 10.4269/ajtmh.18-0456
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Am J Trop Med Hyg ISSN: 0002-9637 Impact factor: 3.707
Figure 1.Flowchart of the studies included in the review and reasons for exclusion.
Summary of studies assessing travel as a risk factor for malaria infection
| Location (date) | Study design ( | Sample population | Sampling/recruitment method | Case definition (malaria diagnosis) | Exposure (definition of travel history) | OR (95% CI), | Confounders adjusted for | Reference | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BotswanaTubo village (June 2012) | Retrospective case–control ( | Inhabitants of one village | Interviewed 71 household heads | Self-reported | Travel outside village in the past 8 months | 2.70 (1.00–7.26) | None | ||
| Burkina FasoOuagadougou (November–December 2002) | Case–control ( | Patients presenting to health facilities in Ouagadougou (one health facility was selected from each of three areas) | 200 patients with fever + 200 non-fever controls selected from each health facility | Travel to a rural area in the past 90 days | 1.14 (0.70–1.90), 0.6 | Participants matched for age and residence | |||
| Burkina FasoOuagadougou (urban areas) (April–May and September–October 2004) | Cross-sectional ( | Children aged 6 months to 12 years in select households across eight areas/four ecological strata | Residents of Ouagadougou for ≥ 5 years were included; two surveys conducted in separate time periods to account for seasonal variations | Travel outside of Ouagadougou in the past month | 1.11 (0.78–1.58), 0.593 | None | |||
| Ethiopia Oromia region (June–October 2011) | Unmatched case–control ( | Adult patients (18+ years old) presenting to Bulbula health facility | Adult patients presenting with fever or a history of fever in the past 72 hours and tested for malaria | Travel overnight away from home village in the past 30 days | AOR = 1.64 (1.07–2.52), = 0.02 | Gender, age, SES, household characteristics, and use of ITNs | |||
| Ethiopia Dabat district (high-altitude villages) (August 2012–May 2013) | Unmatched case–control ( | Patients presenting to four health facilities | Patients ≥ 15+ years presenting to the health facilities, permanent residents of the Dabat district, and had a history of fever ≤ 72 hours tested for malaria | Travel away from home in past month | AOR = 2.01 (1.56–2.58), < 0.0001 | Sex, occupation, plants used for fencing, forests near house, borehole near house, and ITNs availability | |||
| Ethiopia Hadiya zone (May–June 2014) | Cross-sectional ( | Patients presenting to 12 health facilities in Hadiya Zone (low transmission area) | Facilities randomly selected and participants selected by systematic sampling of febrile patients | Travel to a malaria-endemic area in the past 30 days | AOR = 2.59 (1.24–5.38) | Gender, ever heard about malaria, had home visit by health extension worker, knowledge score level, bed net ownership, practice score level, family size, and distance from stagnant water | |||
| Ethiopia Amhara region (August–September 2014) | Case–control ( | Household members aged > 6 months | Households in six villages across eight districts of region selected because of having higher transmission surveyed | Positive RDT | Spent at least one night away from home in the past month | < 10 years old: AOR = 10.16 (1.18–87.58). > 10 years old: AOR = 6.07 (2.48–14.81) | Gender, age, occupation of the household head, village, and malaria risk factors (vector control methods, febrile, taking antimalarial drugs in the last 2 weeks, > 1 RDT-positive individual in the household, and ≥ 1 individual in the household spent ≥ 1 night away from home in the last month) | ||
| Ethiopia Lake Tana surroundings (northwest, ∼1,750–2,500 m above sea level) (October 2016–June 2017) | Matched case–control ( | Patients aged ≥ 5 months from 11 villages of Gondar Zuriya district and one village of Dembia district | Patients resident in the villages were invited to participate + controls (matched for age and gender) | Symptoms of malaria or fever in previous 48 hours + | Travel to malarious lowlands in the past month | AOR = 7.32 (2.40–22.34), < 0.0001 | Matched for age and gender; adjusted for marital status, occupation, education status, household wealth index, roofing materials, flooring materials, travel history within study area, household member travel to malarious lowlands, received health information on malaria, LLIN ownership, household elevation, and house proximity to health center/water body/Lake Tana | ||
| Ethiopia (August–December 2014) | Matched case–control ( | Residents of seven villages > 2,000 m above sea level of Tahtay-Maychew district | Cases were randomly selected across villages + controls (three per case) were randomly selected from nearby households | Positive RDT | Travel outside of home village to a malaria-endemic area in the past month | AOR = 11.40 (6.91–18.82), < 0.001 | Matched by gender and village; adjusted for age, education level, owns livestock, and main occupation (agricultural vs. nonagricultural) | ||
| Ghana Accra and Kumasi (October 2002–February 2003) | Cross-sectional ( | Children aged 6 months to 5 years | Children selected from households in 23 communities selected for being close to/far away from urban agricultural sites | Travel to a rural area in the past 3 weeks | Accra: NS Kumasi: 7.0, 0.0005 | SES, being anemic, education level of caregiver, use of windows/door nets, use of mosquito coils, and the presence of ceiling in house | |||
| Ghana Kumasi (two neighboring communities, Moshie Zongo and Manhyia) (April–May 2005) | Cross-sectional ( | Children aged < 5 years in select households | Systematic selection of households until 10 children reached per cluster; all children present in household were invited to participate | Positive RDT | Travel to a rural area in the past 3 weeks | AOR = 23.45 (3.28, 167.75) | Education level of caregiver > middle school, ethnic group, SES, use of repellent/coils/spray, distance to nearest health facility, and age-group | ||
| Ivory Coast Abidjan (Yopougon municipality) (September 2002) | Cross-sectional ( | Patients at multiple health facilities (one selected per geographical zone of the municipality—urban and peri-urban areas) | 200 patients currently with fever + 200 non-fever controls selected from each health facility | Travel to a rural area in the past 90 days | 1.75 (1.25–2.45), < 0.001 | Matched for age and residence | |||
| Kenya (Western highlands) (1998–2002) | Case–control ( | Kericho tea estate workers | Interview of asymptomatic persons on Kerenga tea estate from 1999 to 2000 and outpatients presenting to Kerenga health center with symptoms suggestive of malaria from 1998 to 2002 | Travel away from the Kericho tea estates in past 2 months | Well persons: 1.59 (1.20–2.1). Outpatients: 2.38 (2.17–2.6) | None | |||
| Malawi Blantyre (low transmission, urban area) (2010) | Matched case–control ( | Children aged < 5 years presenting to a health facility in Ndirandi (township in Central Blantyre) | Febrile children and children positive for malaria at health facility + controls children presenting to clinic and randomly selected when visiting households | Axillary temperature of 37.5°C or a history of fever within the last 48 hours and | Travel to rural areas | 6.66 (4.79–9.61) | Matched for age ± 6 months and gender; adjusted for SES, household proximity to garden, standing water and proximity to river, marital status, and woman employment status | ||
| Malawi Blantyre (four urban and two peri-urban areas) (April 2012–October 2015) | Matched case–control ( | Children aged 6 months to 5 years presenting to 6 health facilities (four urban and two peri-urban) | Febrile children testing positive for malaria infection (blood smear and PCR) + controls (two controls per case) | Temperature ≥ 37.5°C or a history of fever within the last 48 hours, malaria-confirmed blood smears for all | Travel for at least one night outside city limits in the past month | Overall: 2.35 (1.04–5.3), 0.04. Urban: AOR = 2.36 (1.31–4.2). Peri-urban: AOR = 1.17 (0.64–2.15), < 0.02 | Matched by age category (6–24 or 25–59 months), zone of residence within the health facility catchment area, and time of diagnosis (within 4 weeks); and adjusted for having electricity in household and tertiary education | ||
| Mozambique Maputo city (urban, peri-urban, and rural areas) | Case–control ( | Patients presenting to 28 public outpatient health facilities (urban, peri-urban, and rural) | Patients with fever presenting for the first time and weighing more than 5 kg | Temperature ≥ 37.5°C or a history of fever in the past 24 hours, and | Travel for at least one night outside city limits in the past 3 months | Overall: AOR = 1.82 (1.08–3.07), 0.025. Urban: 3.93 (1.56–9.89) | Age-group (≥ 5 or < 5 years old), fever at enrollment, house close to water, health facility location (peri-urban vs. urban), and health facility location (rural vs. urban) | ||
| Namibia North central area along border with Angola (December 2012–July 2014) | Case–control ( | Patients presenting to 46 health facilities across Engela, Outapi, and Oshikuku health districts | Patients with confirmed malaria resident in study area + controls (RDT-negative individuals residing in randomly selected households) | Positive RDT | Travel in the past 4 weeks | AOR for travel to Angola within gender strata: male = 43.58 (2.12–896). Female = 1.65 (0.36–7.47) | Age-group, location slept the previous night, predicted travel time to clinic, distance from the Angolan border, enhanced vegetation index, total rainfall in prior month, and district | ||
| UgandaKabale (highland site ∼2,200 m above sea level) and Rukungiri (highland fringe site ∼1,500 m above sea level) (2007) | Matched case–control ( | Patients presenting to two health facilities | Patients presenting malaria symptoms and residents in study area + controls (one per case) | Positive RDT | Travel for at least one night in the past 4 weeks outside subcounty of residence (classified as travel to area of low/equal transmission risk or high transmission risk) | Highland: AOR = 4.7 (1.4–16.3), 0.01 (overall); AOR = 1.5 (0.3–7.9), 0.7 (low/equal risk); AOR = 6.9 (1.4–33.1), 0.01 (high risk). Highland fringe: AOR = 2.1 (1.1–3.9), 0.04 (overall); AOR = 2.9 (1.6–5.2), < 0.0001 (low/equal risk); AOR = 0.7 (0.1–3.7), 0.7 (high risk) | Matched for age, gender, village of residence, and date of presentation; adjusted for SES and altitude | ||
| Swaziland (January 2010–June 2014) | Cross-sectional ( | Patients presenting to multiple health facilities across country | Confirmed malaria cases at health facility were followed up at the household level within 7 days, and “fever screening” was conducted to identify additional nearby cases | Positive RDT and/or microscopy | Travel within or outside country in past 8 weeks | Overall: AOR = 63.4 (16.2–311.07), < 0.0001. Travel within country: AOR = 3.56 (2.72–4.61), < 0.0001. Travel outside country: AOR = 31.76 (25.76–39.26), < 0.0001 | Age, occupation, gender, and nationality | ||
| Tanzania Dar es Salaam (June–August 2003) | Cross-sectional ( | Patients presenting to select health facilities/schools (1–2 in each of four zones) | 200 patients with fever + 200 non-fever controls selected from each health facility | Fever ≥ 37.5°C or a history of fever in the past 36 hours, | Travel to rural area in past 3 months | Age ≤ 5 years: AOR = 3.62 (1.48–8.88), < 0.05. > 5 years old: AOR = 2.80 (1.23–6.37), < 0.01 | Matched for age and residence | ||
| TanzaniaZanzibar (2015) | Case–control ( | Patients presenting to 157 public and 77 private health facilities in Zanzibar | Patients with confirmed malaria were followed up at the household level | Positive RDT | Travel for at least one night outside Zanzibar in the past 30 days | 9.8 (8.3–11.6) | Age-group, gender, slept under LLINs the previous night, history of fever in the last 2 weeks, household characteristics, and net density | ||
| TanzaniaZanzibar (May–June between 2003 and 2015) | Case–control ( | North A district in Unguja Island and Micheweni district in Pemba Island | Shehias and households were randomly selected; multiple surveys were conducted at the household level | Positive blood smear, RDT, PCR, or serological testing | Travel within or outside Zanzibar in the past 30 days | Travel within Zanzibar: AOR = 1.1 (0.7–1.6). Travel outside Zanzibar: AOR = 70.2 (50.0–100.6) | Gender, sleeping under bed net, and using indoor residual spraying | ||
AOR = adjusted odds ratio; ITNs = insecticide-treated nets; LLINs = long-lasting insecticidal nets; OR = odds ratio; RDT = rapid diagnostic test; SES = social economic status.
Figure 2.Forest plot and measures of association for meta-analysis. This figure appears in color at
Figure 3.Funnel plot assessing potential for small-study effects.