| Literature DB >> 32770653 |
Joshua G Kovoor1, David R Tivey2,3, Penny Williamson2, Lorwai Tan2, Helena S Kopunic2, Wendy J Babidge2,3, Trevor G Collinson4, Peter J Hewett3, Thomas J Hugh5,6, Robert T A Padbury7,8, Mark Frydenberg9,10, Richard G Douglas11, Jen Kok12, Guy J Maddern2,3.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Preoperative screening for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) aims to preserve surgical safety for both patients and surgical teams. This rapid review provides an evaluation of current evidence with input from clinical experts to produce guidance for screening for active COVID-19 in a low prevalence setting.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; imaging; screening; surgery; testing
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32770653 PMCID: PMC7436563 DOI: 10.1111/ans.16260
Source DB: PubMed Journal: ANZ J Surg ISSN: 1445-1433 Impact factor: 2.025
Recommendations from the working group on screening for COVID‐19 before surgery (1 July 2020)
| Patient history should be thoroughly examined for potential sources of SARS‐CoV‐2 exposure (especially close contact with groups at high risk of contracting the disease), and equal weight should be given to these findings as to clinical presentation. Preoperative testing for COVID‐19 is not recommended in patients with no risk factors |
| Assessment of patient symptoms is insufficient as a sole method of diagnosing COVID‐19, although it can inform necessary adjunctive investigations |
| Hyposmia (loss of smell) or hypogeusia (loss of taste) should be considered important in evaluating potential SARS‐CoV‐2 infection |
| Although crucial to the optimal management of patients with COVID‐19, non‐SARS‐CoV‐2 specific laboratory tests (such as haematology and biochemistry tests) have limited utility on their own within the diagnostic workup of potential SARS‐CoV‐2 infection |
| Reverse Transcription‐Polymerase Chain Reaction (RT‐PCR) is the gold standard laboratory test for diagnosing SARS‐CoV‐2 infection, and within Australia and New Zealand there is good concordance in analytical performance between in‐house developed and commercial tests. False negatives can decrease with repeated testing, however, the decision to repeat test should be made based on clinical history and the local supply of laboratory testing resources. Local microbiology services should be consulted regarding testing capability, particularly with regard to the availability of rapid RT‐PCR testing |
| Turnaround times for RT‐PCR results detecting SARS‐CoV‐2 infection may be within 24 hours in Australia and New Zealand. There is considerable postoperative morbidity and mortality associated with operating on COVID‐19 patients. Thus, any surgical operation that can be delayed for 24 hours or more without adverse effects to patients, should await the testing results prior to undertaking surgery in patients with suspected SARS‐CoV‐2 infection |
| At present, serological testing has limited use within the routine preoperative diagnostic workup for acute SARS‐CoV‐2 infection. However, it may be used in the diagnosis of COVID‐19, including where patients are RT‐PCR negative, or as a supplementary test with an unexpected positive or inconclusive RT‐PCR result. It can also be used for sero‐epidemiologic studies to determine population exposure and infection, and for evaluating vaccine effectiveness |
| The use of chest CT scanning alone to diagnose COVID‐19 is not recommended due to non‐specific findings that may overlap with other respiratory illnesses |
Proposed preoperative diagnostic workup for COVID‐19 (1 July 2020)
| Features of patient history | Advised preoperative investigation |
|---|---|
| Any risk of potential SARS‐CoV‐2 exposure, including: Close contact with a confirmed case of COVID‐19 in the past 2 weeks Close contact with someone who displays symptoms of hyposmia (loss of smell), hypogeusia (loss of taste), cough, sore throat or dyspnoea in the past 2 weeks (including the 3 days prior to onset of symptoms) Overseas or interstate (if state of journey's origin contains active cases of COVID‐19) travel in the past 2 weeks, either by plane or cruise ship, or close contact with someone who has Presence within an aged care facility in the past 2 weeks, either as a resident, worker or visitor Presence within a detention facility in the past 2 weeks, either as a resident, worker or visitor Presence within a group residential setting in the past 2 weeks, either as a resident, worker or visitor Presence within other facilities that have relatively high risk of COVID‐19 transmission Profession that includes regular interaction with COVID‐19 cases (e.g. workers in healthcare, allied health facilities, supermarkets, schools, delivery, factories, farming and transport) | RT‐PCR assay |
| Any of the following symptoms in the past 2 weeks: Hyposmia Hypogeusia Cough Sore throat Dyspnoea Unexplained fever | RT‐PCR assay |
| Over 70 years of age AND any new‐onset respiratory symptoms, including: Cough Sore throat Dyspnoea | RT‐PCR assay AND CT scan of chest |
| Surgery required within 24 h AND presence of ANY of the above history features | No preoperative investigation for SARS‐CoV‐2 infection |
Proceed to surgery with surgical staff wearing full PPE and taking appropriate intraoperative precautions, especially for potential aerosol‐generating procedures. , , Isolate patient postoperatively and test for SARS‐CoV‐2 infection when possible.
Findings from 31 selected studies with the most frequently reported symptoms associated with COVID‐19 , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
| Finding | No. studies | Cohort median | Interquartile range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sample size, n | 31 | 253 | 100.5–883.8 |
| Median age, years | 27 | 53.3 | 46.5–62.3 |
| ICU admission rate | 18 | 23% | 6.8–32 |
| Case‐fatality rate | 20 | 12.5% | 0.9–23.3 |
| Symptoms | |||
| Fever | 30 | 71.6% | 53.6–82.6 |
| Cough | 30 | 62.6% | 45.8–73.2 |
| Dyspnoea | 26 | 28.7% | 13–44 |
| Myalgia/arthralgia | 20 | 26.5% | 15.0–54.2 |
| Sore throat | 18 | 13.9% | 6.4–35 |
| Diarrhoea | 27 | 10.4% | 5.3–22.1 |
| Nausea/vomiting | 20 | 7.5% | 4.3–17.5 |
ICU, intensive care unit.
| No. | Reason | Query | Results (6 May 2020) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| COVID‐19 pandemic | ((((((“COVID‐19” [tiab]) OR “SARS‐CoV‐2” [tiab]) OR “2019‐nCoV” [tiab]) OR coronavirus [tiab]) OR “novel coronavirus” [tiab]) OR “corona virus” [tiab]) OR “severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus” [tiab] | 19 687 |
|
| Clinical presentation | (((((((((((infecti* [tiab]) OR pathology [tiab]) OR pathological [tiab]) OR sign [tiab]) OR signs [tiab]) OR symptom [tiab]) OR symptoms [tiab]) OR symptomatic [tiab]) OR asymptomatic [tiab]) OR “clinical presentation” [tiab]) OR “clinical findings” [tiab]) OR pneumonia [tiab] | 3 494 934 |
|
| Point‐of‐care and serologic testing | (((((((((((“Point‐of‐Care Testing"[Mesh]) OR (((point*of*care OR rapid OR bedside OR real*time OR near*patient OR fast OR prompt OR early) AND (test OR tests OR testing OR assay* OR PCR OR molecular OR diagnostic OR diagnosi* OR diagnostics OR diagnose* OR detection OR assessment* OR use*)))) OR ((Bedside AND (Computing OR Technology)))) OR ((“in field detection” OR POC OR POCT)))))) OR ((((((((((((“Serologic Tests”[Mesh]) OR “Molecular Diagnostic Techniques”[Mesh]) OR ((“IgM” OR “IgG” OR “Ag”))) OR ((Immunoglobulin OR “antiviral immunoglobulin‐G"))) OR ((Serologic* AND (test OR testing OR tests OR conversion* OR assay* OR analysis OR diagnostic OR diagnostics OR diagnosi* OR diagnose* OR screen*)))) OR ((Serology or seroconversion OR seroepidemiology OR serodiagnos* or seroprevalence*))) OR (((Antibod* AND (test OR tests OR testing OR serum OR detection* OR response*))))) OR ((Antigen OR antigeni* OR antigens*))) OR Immunoassa*) OR ((Molecular AND (diagnostic OR diagnostics OR diagnosi* OR diagnose*)))) OR Dynamic* profile)))) | 4 672 773 |
|
| Diagnosis | ((((((((((((((“Diagnosis”[Mesh]) OR ((“Diagnostic Techniques and Procedures”[Mesh]))) OR “Diagnostic Tests, Routine”[Mesh]) OR “Diagnostic Test Approval”[Mesh]) OR “Reagent Kits, Diagnostic”[Mesh]) OR “Predictive Value of Tests”[Mesh]) OR ((“Sensitivity and Specificity”[Mesh]))) OR ((detect* OR laboratory OR evaluat* OR validat* OR clinical OR perform* OR sensitivity OR specificity OR area under the curve OR positive predictive value OR PPV OR negative predictive value OR NPV OR predictive value OR feasibility OR accuracy OR likelihood ratio OR false negative OR false positive OR Positive rate OR validation OR diagnostic odds ratio OR DOR OR valid*))) OR ((Diagnostic AND (value OR panel OR tool*)))) OR ((diagnosa* OR diagnosi* OR diagnose* OR diagnoss* OR diagnostic OR diagnostics))) OR (((Test OR tests OR testing) AND (infection OR virus OR disease OR diseases OR disease, OR antibod* OR blood OR nucleic acid or diagnostic OR diagnostics OR diagnosi* OR diagnose* OR diagnose*)))))) | 17 661 043 |
|
| Computed tomography imaging | (((((((((((“Radiography, Thoracic”[Mesh]) OR “Tomography, X‐Ray Computed”[Mesh]) OR “Tomography, X‐Ray” [Mesh]) OR ((CT X*Ray* OR CT))) OR (((CT OR CAT OR chest OR lung or lungs or thoracic* OR thorax*) AND (Scan or screen* or imaging or film or radiograph* or radiogram or radiolog*)))) OR Compute* tomograph*) OR ((Cine‐CT or “Cine CT”))) OR (((Thoracic* OR thorax* OR lung OR lungs OR Chest) AND CT))) OR ((“Chest CT” AND (scan or imaging)))) OR ((X*ray* computed or x‐ray compute*))) OR ((Compute* assist* tomograph* OR compute* axial tomograph*))) OR ((chest radiological imaging OR Roentgenolog* or roentgen ray*or roentgen OR Grenz Ray* or X*Radiation*)) | 664 529 |
|
| X‐ray Imaging | ((((((“Radiography, Thoracic”[Mesh]) OR “Mass Chest X‐Ray”[Mesh]) OR “X‐Rays”[Mesh]) OR (((CXR OR CR OR x*ray* OR radiograph*)))) OR (((chest AND (film* OR radiograph*))))) OR ((((chest OR lung OR lungs OR thoracic* OR thorax*) AND (x*ray* OR radiograph* or radiogram* or radiolog*))))) OR (((Chest X‐ray radiography OR chest radiological imaging OR thoracic radiology OR Roentgenolog* or roentgen ray*or roentgen OR Grenz Ray* or X*Radiation*))) | 1 438 818 |
|
| RT‐PCR Testing | ((((((((((((((((((((((((((“Polymerase Chain Reaction”[Mesh]) OR “Reverse Transcriptase Polymerase Chain Reaction”[Mesh]) OR “Real‐Time Polymerase Chain Reaction”[Mesh]) OR (((polymerase chain reaction) OR “PCR” OR “PCRs” OR ((Inverse OR Nested OR Anchored OR Kinetic) AND (Polymerase Chain Reaction))))) OR ((reverse AND (transcriptase OR transcription) AND (PCR OR PCRs OR polymerase chain reaction)))) OR ((RT‐PCR OR RT‐PCR diagnostic panel OR RT‐PCR assay* OR rRT‐PCR OR qPCR OR qRT‐PCR OR RT‐qPCR OR mPCR OR WHO‐PCR))) OR ((RT‐PCR OR (RT‐PCR diagnostic panel) OR (RT‐PCR assay*) OR rRT‐PCR OR qPCR OR qRT‐PCR OR RT‐qPCR OR mPCR OR WHO‐PCR))) OR (((Real*Time AND (Polymerase Chain Reaction OR PCR OR PCRs OR RT‐PCR))))) OR ((Real*time AND ((reverse AND (transcriptase OR transcription)) AND (PCR OR PCRs OR polymerase chain reaction))))) OR ((Real*time AND RT‐PCR) OR ((reverse real*time) AND (PCR OR PCRs OR polymerase chain reaction)) OR ((real reverse AND (transcriptase OR transcription)) AND (PCR OR PCRs OR polymerase chain reaction)))) OR ((Quantitative Real*Time AND (Polymerase Chain Reaction OR PCR OR PCRs)))) OR ((((qualitative AND (real*time)) AND ((reverse AND (transcriptase OR transcription)) AND (PCR OR PCRs OR polymerase chain reaction)))))) OR ((Multiplex AND (PCR OR PCRs OR polymerase chain reaction)))) OR ((nucleic acid OR nucleic acid detection OR RNA))) OR ((“Hologic Panther Fusion” OR “Hologic” OR “Hologic Panther” OR “DiaSorin Simplexa” OR “DiaSorin” OR “Roche Cobas 6800” OR “DiaSorin Simplexa COVID*19 Direct” OR “Cepheid Xpert Xpress SARS*CoV*2” OR “Cepheid Xpert Xpress” OR “QIAstat‐Dx Respiratory SARS*CoV*2 Panel” OR “QIAstat‐SARS” OR “QIAstat”))) OR (((lateral flow immunoassay) OR “LFIA”))) OR “LAMP assay” [Supplementary Concept]) OR ((((reverse AND (transcriptase OR transcription)) AND (loop*mediated isothermal amplification)) OR “RT‐LAMP” OR (loop*mediated isothermal amplification) OR LAMP))) OR (((open reading frame 1ab) OR ORF1ab))) OR ((((magnetic chemiluminescence enzyme immunoassay) OR MCLIA)))) OR (((magnetic chemiluminescence enzyme immunoassay) OR MCLIA OR MCLA))) OR “Enzyme‐Linked Immunosorbent Assay”[Mesh]) OR (((enzyme*linked immunosorbent assay*) OR ELISA))) OR “Luminescent Measurements”[Mesh]) OR (((chemiluminescence immunoassay) OR CLIA OR chemiluminescence))) OR spike protein) OR nucleocapsid protein | 2 724 819 |
|
| Ultrasound imaging | (((((((“Ultrasonography”[Mesh]) OR ((POCUS OR LU OR LUS OR US))) OR ((((Point*of*care OR bedside OR rapid OR real*time OR near*patient OR fast OR prompt OR early))) AND ((Ultrasound OR ultrasonography OR ultrasonic OR sonography OR sonographic)))) OR ((((Chest OR thoraci* OR thorax* OR lung or lungs))) AND ((Ultrasound OR ultrasonography OR ultrasonic OR sonography OR sonographic)))) OR ((((Chest OR thoraci* OR thorax* OR lung or lungs))) AND US)) OR ((((Point*of*care OR bedside OR rapid OR real*time OR near*patient OR fast OR prompt OR early))) AND ((Image OR imaging OR images)))) OR ((((Chest OR thoraci* OR thorax* OR lung or lungs))) AND ((Image OR imaging OR images)))) OR ((((Ultrasound OR ultrasonography OR ultrasonic OR sonography OR sonographic))) AND ((diagnosa* OR diagnosi* OR diagnose* OR diagnoss* OR diagnostic OR diagnostics))) | 2 361 046 |
|
| Treatments for COVID‐19 in title | Ivermectin [TI] OR Stromectol [TI] OR Mectizan [TI] OR Eqvalan [TI] OR Ivomec [TI] OR “MK‐933” [TI] OR “MK 933” [TI] OR MK933 [TI] OR Macrolide* [TI] OR “extracorporeal membrane oxygenation” [TI] OR ECMO [TI] OR “life support” [TI] OR Paracetamol [TI] OR Acetaminophen [TI] OR Antipyretic [TI] OR Amide* [TI] OR Ibuprofen [TI] OR NSAID [TI] OR Ibumetin [TI] OR Motrin [TI] OR Nuprin [TI] OR Rufen [TI] OR Salprofen [TI] OR Dolgit [TI] OR Brufen [TI] OR Phenylproprionate* [TI] OR “anti‐inflammatory” [TI] OR “anti inflammatory” [TI] OR angiotensin [TI] OR “ACE‐inhibitor*” [TI] OR “ACE inhibitor*” [TI] OR renin [TI] OR steroid* [TI] OR methylprednisolone [TI] OR tocilizumab [TI] OR atlizumab [TI] OR actemra [TI] OR roactemra [TI] OR heparin [TI] OR liquaemin heparin OR hydroxychloroquine [TI] OR oxychlorochin [TI] OR oxychloroquine [TI] OR hydroxychlorochin [TI] OR plaquenil [TI] OR sulfate [TI] OR quinolone* [TI] OR chloroquine [TI] OR chlorochin [TI] OR chingamin [TI] OR nivaquine [TI] OR khingamin [TI] OR aralen [TI] OR arequin [TI] OR arechine [TI] OR remdesivir [TI] OR alanine [TI] OR antiviral [TI] OR “anti‐viral” [TI] OR “anti viral” [TI] OR vasodilator* [TI] OR corticosteroid* [TI] OR lipoic [TI] OR bevacizumab [TI] OR lopinavir [TI] OR protease [TI] OR pyrimidin* [TI] OR ritonavir [TI] OR cytochrome [TI] OR azole* [TI] OR interferon [TI] OR beta [TI] OR gamma [TI] OR “lopinavir‐ritonavir” [TI] OR “lopinavir/ritonavir” [TI] OR azithromycin [TI] OR antibiotic* [TI] OR sumamed [TI] OR toraseptol [TI] OR vinzam [TI] OR Zithromax OR Azitrocin [TI] OR Ultreon [TI] OR oseltamivir [TI] OR interleukin [TI] OR lenzilumab [TI] OR monoclonal [TI] | 1 115 209 |
|
| Sensitivity string |
| 19 561 598 |
|
| Specifying for COVID‐19 |
| 15 340 |
|
| Eliminating treatments for COVID‐19 in title |
| 14 178 |
|
| Specifying to timeframe since World Health Organization was alerted of SARS‐CoV‐2 | Apply filter: Publication date from 31 Dec 2019 | 5762 |
|
| Specifying for humans | Apply filter: Humans, and results imported into EndNote | 1395 |
| Question | Yes | No |
|---|---|---|
| Have you been | ||
| Over the past 2 weeks, have you been in | ||
|
Over the past 2 weeks, have you been Loss of smell Loss of taste Fever Cough Sore throat Shortness of breath or difficulty breathing Diarrhoea Nausea or vomiting Muscle aches | ||
| Over the past 2 weeks, have you been in | ||
| Have you | ||
| Have you | ||
| Have you been within an | ||
| Have you been within a | ||
| Do you live in a | ||
| Do you regularly interact with people with COVID‐19 as part of your |