Xiao-Gang Yang1,2, Zhi-Min Zhai1, Xiao-Min Lu1, Lu-Fang Ma1, Dongpeng Yan2. 1. College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Luoyang Normal University, Henan Province Function-Oriented Porous Materials Key Laboratory, Luoyang 471934, P. R. China. 2. College of Chemistry, Beijing Normal University, Beijing Key Laboratory of Energy Conversion and Storage Materials, Beijing 100875, P. R. China.
Abstract
Molecular cocrystals have received much attention for tuning physicochemical properties in pharmaceutics, luminescence, organic electronics, and so on. However, the effective methods for the formation of orderly cocrystal thin films are still rather limited, which have largely restricted their photofunctional and optoelectronic applications. In this work, a fast crystallization-deposition procedure is put forward to obtain acridine (AD)-based cocrystals, which are self-assembled with three typical isophthalic acid derivatives (IPA, IPB, and TMA). The obtained donor-acceptor cocrystal complexes exhibit an adjustable energy level, wide range of photoluminescence color, and rotational angle-dependent polarized emission. The orderly and uniform cocrystal thin films further present tunable one-/two-photon up-conversion and different semiconductor properties. Particularly, AD-TMA cocrystal thin film shows a rare example of a molecule level heterojunction with the alternating arrangement of AD electronic acceptor layers and TMA electronic donor layers, and thus, provides a way for efficient mobility and separation of electron-hole pairs. A large on-off photocurrent ratio of more than 104 can be achieved for the AD-TMA thin film, which is higher than state-of-the-art molecular semiconductor systems. Therefore, this work extends the application scopes of orderly cocrystal thin film materials for future luminescent and optoelectronic micro-/nanodevices.
Molecular cocrystals have received much attention for tuning physicochemical properties in pharmaceutics, luminescence, organic electronics, and so on. However, the effective methods for the formation of orderly cocrystal thin films are still rather limited, which have largely restricted their photofunctional and optoelectronic applications. In this work, a fast crystallization-deposition procedure is put forward to obtain acridine (AD)-based cocrystals, which are self-assembled with three typical isophthalic acid derivatives (IPA, IPB, and TMA). The obtained donor-acceptor cocrystal complexes exhibit an adjustable energy level, wide range of photoluminescence color, and rotational angle-dependent polarized emission. The orderly and uniform cocrystal thin films further present tunable one-/two-photon up-conversion and different semiconductor properties. Particularly, AD-TMA cocrystal thin film shows a rare example of a molecule level heterojunction with the alternating arrangement of AD electronic acceptor layers and TMA electronic donor layers, and thus, provides a way for efficient mobility and separation of electron-hole pairs. A large on-off photocurrent ratio of more than 104 can be achieved for the AD-TMA thin film, which is higher than state-of-the-art molecular semiconductor systems. Therefore, this work extends the application scopes of orderly cocrystal thin film materials for future luminescent and optoelectronic micro-/nanodevices.
Recently, the rational
design and controlled synthesis of molecule-based
optoelectronic materials have attracted great attention owing to their
potential applications in the fields of solar cells, photodetectors,
photoswitches, phototransistors, and optical data storage.[1−6] To obtain a high performance of optoelectronic materials, several
key factors need to be considered, such as a broad light harvesting
range, tunable band gap, high charge carrier mobility, and efficient
dissociation of photogenerated excitons, particularly for those of
solution-processed thin films.[7,8] In this context, molecular
cocrystals, assembled by two or more molecular components via hydrogen
bonds, halogen bonds, π–π, and/or charge transfer
interactions, have recently received increasing attention due to the
advantages of a facile synthesis route, adjustable molecular arrangement,
easy functionality, and low cost.[9−15]Among different types of cocrystals, donor–acceptor
(D–A)
complexes can be regarded as crystalline heterojunction materials,
which are constructed by the alternating arrangement of an electron-rich
donor and electron-deficient acceptor at the molecule level. The strategy
to integrate advantages of D–A cocrystals has provided a platform
for the development of photofunctional materials and molecular optoelectronics.[16] For example, our previous work showed that the
introduction of the coformers can change the geometric arrangement
of the 1,4-bis-p-cyanostyrylbenzene chromophore within
cocrystals, resulting in tuned fluorescence.[17] To achieve large circular polarization, Duan and co-workers demonstrated
a chiral charge-transfer (CT) cocrystal system with chiral electron
donor and acceptor by various approaches.[5] By crafting a periodic molecular barrier into cocrystal matrices,
Zhang and co-workers provided a new approach to preventing the formation
of dark triplet states in organic semiconductors.[2] Additionally, we also illustrated that the construction
of D–A cocrystal materials can provide an energy transfer route
to accelerate the generation of triplet states for long-lived room-temperature
phosphorescence.[18] To date, tremendous
effects have been paid on the development of macrosized bulk cocrystal
systems and the study of the basic mechanism on structure–properties
relationship. However, the construction of cocrystals at the micro-/nanoscale,
and particularly their orderly thin films, is still rather limited.[12] From the fundamental and practical application
perspectives, it is of significance to explore novel crystalline micro-/nanoscaled
thin films by the organization of D–A assembled units, which
would greatly extend the scope for the optoelectronic application
based on the facile cocrystal designs.[19,20] Therefore,
the development of an effective procedure to fabricate orderly cocrystal
thin films is still highly desired.The π-conjugated acridine
(AD) compound is a well-known chromophore,
which plays an important role in molecular luminescence and optoelectronic
materials. For example, an AD-based hybrid microbelt could exhibit
an excellent optical waveguide performance due to a close and alternating
arrangement of protonated AD layers, as stabilized through electrostatic
and hydrogen bond interactions.[21] The modification
of molecular stacking and potential protonation of AD may further
tailor its electronic structures and photophysical properties. To
date, at least five AD polymorphs have been found with different packing
motifs and physicochemical properties.[22,23] It has also
been found that the approach of template-assisted crystallization
can result in different molecular packing and thus forms a new polymorph.
In this work, the AD molecule is selected as the electron acceptor
to construct cocrystals with different electronic donors, since the
AD with the coordinate nitrogen atom can potentially self-assemble
with different coformers as molecular templates by strong hydrogen
bonds. The coformers, isophthalic acid (IPA) modified by 5-position
substituents with a different template effect and steric hindrance,
can result in the formation of new types of D–A cocrystals,
in which the stacking fashions of AD are obviously alternated from
those in as-known AD polymorphs. The polarized photoemission of AD
can be extremely tuned from blue to orange-yellow during the cocrystallization
process. Furthermore, through a fast crystallization-deposition (FCD)
process, the cocrystal thin films can be facilely fabricated, which
display tunable up-conversion luminescence and semiconductor properties,
in which AD-TMA exhibits a large on–off photocurrent ratio
of more than 104. Therefore, this work not only develops
new AD cocrystal materials with high-efficiency luminescence and photon-to-current
conversion performances but also establishes an easy and scale-up
method to assemble well-defined cocrystal thin films toward novel
photofunctional and optoelectronic applications.
Results and Discussion
Synthesis
and Structural Determination
Three compounds
containing carboxylic groups and halogen atoms (IPA = isophthalic
acid, IPB = 5-bromoisophthalic acid, TMA = trimesic acid) were selected
as coformers to assemble with AD through supramolecular interactions
(Scheme S1 and Figure a). In contrast to the low crystalline quality
of the pristine AD, high-grade single crystals of AD-based two-component
complexes (AD-IPA, AD-IPB, AD-TMA) can be readily obtained by a solvothermal
process or slow evaporation of ethanol solutions containing AD and
the coformers with a 1:1 (AD-IPA and AD-TMA) or 2:1 (AD-IPB) stoichiometry.
Their crystallographic details are listed in Table S2. Powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) patterns indicate that
all of the diffraction peaks are well indexed to the simulated results,
implying the high purity of the AD precursor and corresponding cocrystallized
samples (Figure S1a–d). Both AD-IPA
and AD-TMA are organic salt forms with protons transferring from carboxylic
groups to N atoms of AD, while the AD-IPB cocrystal consists of neutral
AD and IPB molecules. The FT-IR spectra (Figure S1e) of the samples reveal strong bands at 1683 and 1695 cm–1 for the protonated carboxylate groups, indicating
the deprotonation of IPA and TMA. The characteristic bands at 1730
cm–1 can be attributed to the protonated carboxylic
groups of IPB. Thermogravimetric differential thermal analysis (TG-DTA)
measurements (Figure S2) show that the
melting points of all these multicomponent complexes occur at higher
temperatures (214–285 °C) than the pure AD (110 °C),
confirming that the thermal stability of the AD can be improved by
the formation of the cocrystal.
Figure 1
(a) Chemical structures of AD, IPA, IPB,
and TMA molecules in this
work. Supramolecular interactions between AD and IPA (b), IPB (d),
and TMA (f). Template-assisted crystallization results in structure
diversity of AD motifs in AD-IPA (c), AD-IPB (e), and AD-TMA (g).
(a) Chemical structures of AD, IPA, IPB,
and TMA molecules in this
work. Supramolecular interactions between AD and IPA (b), IPB (d),
and TMA (f). Template-assisted crystallization results in structure
diversity of AD motifs in AD-IPA (c), AD-IPB (e), and AD-TMA (g).The pristine crystalline sample of AD is commercially
available,
which shows the III form[22] (Figure S1a) and crystallizes in the monoclinic
crystal system P21/c space
group. Its asymmetric unit contains two independent AD molecules with
a dihedral angle of 67.09° (Figure S3a). A pair of AD molecules are joined together to form a dimer through
C–H···Nhydrogen bonds, which is further stabilized
by C–H···π and π···π
stacking interactions (Figure S3b), giving
rise to a 3D supramolecular architecture (Figure S3c,d). By assembly with the isophthalic acid (IPA) unit modified
by different 5-position substituents, obviously different stacking
patterns of AD can be obtained compared with its typical polymorphs.
Upon formation of the AD-IPA two-component crystal, proton transfer
occurs from the carboxylic acid of IPA to the nitrogen atom of AD.
In AD-IPA, the dihedral angle between AD and IPA is 62.11° (Figure S4a). The IPA molecule shows a plane conformation,
and the neighboring IPA molecules connect to each other through O–H···O
and C–H···O hydrogen bonds and π···π
stacking interactions (with the centroid–centroid distances
of 4.00 Å) to form a 1D double stand chain along the a direction (Figure b and Figure S4b). The AD molecules
arranging in an antiparallel packing mode are fixed together by double-standing
IPA chains through N–H···O and C–H···O
hydrogen bonds, giving rise to a 2D layered structure (Figure c). Analysis of the crystal
packing shows that the AD-IPA exhibits an alternating arrangement
of AD cations and IPA anions (Figure S4c).Single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis reveals that AD-IPB
forms
a neutral cocrystal, which crystallizes in the monoclinic C2/c space group, and the asymmetric unit
consists of one AD and half of IPB molecules. The dihedral angle between
AD and IPB is 84.69° (Figure S5a).
In AD-IPB, the IPB molecule exhibits a nonplane conformation with
the dihedral angles between carboxylic groups and the benzene ring
of 12.95°. Such a twisty conformation can provide a greater chance
for the formation of hydrogen bonds. Each IPB molecule is surrounded
by eight AD molecules through N–H···O and C–H···O
hydrogen bonds (Figure d), generating a 2D double layer structure with Br atoms hanging
on two sides (Figure S5b,c). The AD molecules
display face-to-face antiparallel π···π
stacking interactions, with centroid–centroid distances of
3.77 and 3.97 Å, respectively (Figure e). Adjacent layers are further extended
to a 3D supramolecular framework through C–H···Brhydrogen bonds. Viewed along the c direction, the
IPB guests are closely encapsulated within the AD host (Figure S5d).When the 5-position −Br
substituent is instead −COOH
under the same conditions, a distinct structure of AD-TMA can be obtained.
Similar to AD-IPA, proton transfer is also observed in the AD-TMA
system. Within TMA, carboxylic groups form the dihedral angles of
13.07° and 4.84° with the central benzene ring plane for
−COO– and −COOH, respectively. A pair
of TMA molecules interact with each other in a head-to-tail arrangement
to form a dimer through O–H···O hydrogen bonds
(Figure f), which
is further extended by guest water molecules through O–H···O
hydrogen bonds, generating a 2D TMA-H2O layer (Figure S6b). Strictly different from those of
the discrete AD dimer in AD-IPA (Figure c) and AD-IPB (Figure e), the AD molecules in AD-TMA are arranged
into an infinite π-conjugated chain featuring compact H-aggregation
(Figure g), which
is expected to benefit the migration of charge carriers.[24] Among the reported AD-based polymorphs and multicomponent
complexes,[22] only one example of organic–inorganic
hybrid perovskite [(AD)Pb2Cl5] possesses such
a packing arrangement,[21] in which the orderly
arrangement of the organic AD cation layers is confined between the
rigid lead chloride inorganic layer (Figure S7). In AD-TMA, the infinite AD chains are fixed between TMA-H2O layers via N–H···O and C–H···O
hydrogen bonds. Viewing from the b direction (Figure S6c), AD-TMA shows an alternating arrangement
of the AD π-conjugated system and TMA-H2O anionic
layer. Therefore, it is concluded that the packing mode and intermolecular
interactions of AD can be completely alternated after cocrystallization
through the introduction of different aromatic carboxylic acid coformers.
The structural diversity of these compounds would further result in
different luminescence and photoelectric performances.
Absorption
and Photoluminescence Analyses
The photophysical
properties of cocrystals AD-IPA, AD-IPB, AD-TMA, and pristine AD were
investigated by UV–vis absorption, photoluminescence (PL) spectra,
PL quantum yield (PLQY), and lifetime measurements. As shown in Figure a, AD exhibits absorption
ranging from 200 to 450 nm, whereas its cocrystal samples can effectively
extend the absorption band to the visible region in a wide range.
Upon excitation at 310 nm, AD exhibits a weak blue fluorescence emission
at 396 nm with low PLQY of 0.97%. In comparison with the pristine
samples of AD, IPA, IPB, and TMA (Figure b and Figure S8), the three cocrystal complexes AD-IPA, AD-IPB, and AD-TMA emerge
with a longer wavelength photoemission (maxima at 542, 502, and 612
nm, respectively) and higher PLQY of 17.49%, 15.74%, and 1.75%, respectively.
Herein, the red-shifted PL of these cocrystals may originate from
the charge-transfer interaction between two components.[12] Upon irradiation with 365 nm UV, these well-defined
bright yellow (under daylight) cocrystal samples reveal different
emission colors: light-green for AD-IPA, cyan for AD-IPB, and orange-yellow
for AD-TMA (Figure c). Thus, the emission color of AD can be vastly adjusted from blue
to orange-yellow (Figure S9) via cocrystallization
with different assembled units.
Figure 2
Normalized UV–vis absorption (a),
fluorescence spectra (b),
photographs of crystal images under daylight and UV (c), and fluorescence
decay curves (d) for AD-IPA, AD-IPB, AD-TMA, and pure AD.
Normalized UV–vis absorption (a),
fluorescence spectra (b),
photographs of crystal images under daylight and UV (c), and fluorescence
decay curves (d) for AD-IPA, AD-IPB, AD-TMA, and pure AD.To further investigate the nature of the excited states,
the PL
lifetimes (τ) of these cocrystal samples were measured as shown
in Figure d. The τ
value for AD is 2.88 ns, while that of the AD-IPA, AD-IPB, and AD-TMA
is largely enhanced to 21.19, 15.80, and 10.22 ns, respectively. A
comparison of the photophysical properties (Table S1) reveals that the photoemission performances of AD can be
modified obviously by coassembly with suitable coformers. The large
enhancement of PLQY and PL lifetime for AD-IPA and AD-IPB can be assigned
to the fact that the orderly AD molecules are highly restricted and
stabilized in the cocrystal matrices through strong hydrogen bonds
and/or electrostatic interactions, inhibiting the molecular thermal
vibration and nonradiative relaxation. In addition, the isolation
of coformers could minimize the serious aggregation-caused quenching
AD chromophores. The large separation of AD in AD-IPA leads to the
prolonged lifetime. The relatively high concentration of AD in AD-IPB
results in a decrease of lifetime compared with AD-IPA. The alternating
arrangement of AD layers and TMA layers in AD-TMA shows the shortest
lifetime among three cocrystals; this can be attributed to the quenching
from guest water molecules. By contrast, the higher degree of overlap
of π-conjugation in AD-TMA provides much denser crystal packing,
resulting in the H-aggregation of AD chromophores, leading to an obvious
red-shift in the PL emission and visible light absorption. In spite
of the relatively low PL performance, it can be predicted that the
infinite 1D AD π-conjugation chains in AD-TMA may afford a platform
of efficient charge carrier mobility for potential optoelectronic
applications.[7]
Theoretical Calculations
To better understand the variable
photophysical properties of these crystalline compounds, density functional
theory (DFT) based on the generalized gradient approximation (GGA)
was used to calculate the molecular orbital and energy levels of cocrystals
and their components.[25,26] As shown in Figure a–c, it is observed
that the electron density of the highest occupied molecular orbital
(HOMO) and the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) is mainly
localized on the IPA/IPB/TMA and AD molecules, respectively. The calculated
HOMO, LUMO, and HOMO–LUMO energy gaps are summarized in Figure d, which indicate
that the introduction of coformers can reduce the HOMO (−4.904
eV) and LUMO (−2.462 eV) energy level of AD to a large extent:
−5.660 and −3.291 eV for AD-IPA, −5.516 and −3.115
eV for AD-IPB, and −5.973 and −3.946 eV for AD-TMA.
This can be attributed to the lower energy level of IPA (−6.521
and −3.167 eV), IPB (−6.497 and −3.351 eV), and
TMA (−6.547 and −3.046 eV) coformers. Meanwhile, the
HOMO–LUMO energy gap of AD can also be decreased from 2.442
to 2.369 eV for AD-IPA, 2.361 eV for AD-IPB, and 2.027 eV for AD-TMA.
In particular, AD-TMA shows the lowest HOMO and LUMO energy level
and the smallest energy gap. In all, the three cocrystals have a reduced
energy gap and red-shifted wavelength of emission as compared to that
of the pristine IPA, IPB, and TMA coformers and AD. The trend of these
results are well consistent with their optical performances in experiment.
Figure 3
HOMO (down)
and LUMO (top) profiles for AD-IPA (a), AD-IPB (b),
and AD-TMA (c). (d) HOMO and LUMO energy levels and energy gap values
of cocrystals and their components from DFT calculations.
HOMO (down)
and LUMO (top) profiles for AD-IPA (a), AD-IPB (b),
and AD-TMA (c). (d) HOMO and LUMO energy levels and energy gap values
of cocrystals and their components from DFT calculations.
Angle-Dependent Polarized Fluorescence Emission
Based
on different alignment fashions of AD chromophores in three cocrystal
complexes, their angle-dependent polarized fluorescence spectra were
measured on a microspectrometer by rotating the polarizer at different
polarization angles. Figure and Figures S10 and S11 illustrate
the relationship between the polarization fluorescence intensity of
the individual single crystal and the polarization angle (θ)
irradiated under unfocused UV light. It is observed that three cocrystals
present obviously different maximum (Imax) and minimum (Imin) fluorescence intensity
values. AD-IPA has the maximum and minimum values at 60° and
150°, respectively. AD-IPB shows the maximum at 0° and the
minimum at 90°, while AD-TMA displays the opposite values compared
with those of AD-IPB. To evaluate the polarization performance, the
emission dichroic ratio Rd and polarization
anisotropy σ were calculated by Rd = Imax/Imin and σ = (Rd – 1)/(Rd + 1).[27−29] The polarization anisotropy values
of 0.50, 0.26, and 0.32 are obtained for AD-IPA, AD-IPB, and AD-TMA,
respectively. The diversity in polarization emission for these cocrystals
can be assigned to the different packing mode of AD molecules.
Figure 4
(a) Polarized
fluorescence spectra of AD-IPB at variant angles
(0–360°). (b) Fluorescence intensity of the AD-IPB as
a function of the polarizer rotation angle. Fluorescence spectra (c)
and corresponding PL microscope images (d) of AD-IPB measured at 0°
and 90°.
(a) Polarized
fluorescence spectra of AD-IPB at variant angles
(0–360°). (b) Fluorescence intensity of the AD-IPB as
a function of the polarizer rotation angle. Fluorescence spectra (c)
and corresponding PL microscope images (d) of AD-IPB measured at 0°
and 90°.Interestingly, AD-IPB exhibits
a remarkable fluorescence color
transformation from cyan (maxima at 485 nm) to green (maxima at 530
nm) measured at 0° and 90°, as shown in Figure c,d. To the best of our knowledge,
such alternant photoemission between different polarized directions
has been seldomly reported, particularly in molecular crystals.[30] The cyan to green color switching of AD-IPB
is an instantaneous and completely reversible process, which endows
it as potential candidates for display, data storage, color filters,
and so on. The emission switching demonstrated in the AD-IPB cocrystal
system is assigned to the nearly perpendicular arrangement of molecule
packing between AD and IPB (with a dihedral angle of 84.69°).
Fabrication and Photophysical Properties of Cocrystal Thin Films
To make molecular cocrystals into potential luminescent and optoelectronic
applications, it is important to fabricate well-defined thin films.
Herein, thin films of AD and its cocrystals were obtained by a fast
crystallization-deposition (FCD) method using thermal evaporation
at 100 °C deposited on indium tin oxide (ITO) substrate. To regulate
the crystallization process and produce high-quality films with a
controllable morphology, several key factors are worth noting. First,
the two-component raw materials should be completely dissolved in
the selected solvents with relatively low boiling point. Second, the
volatilization rate or the control of temperature has a great influence
on film morphology. Slow evaporation of solvent coated on the ITO
substrate could only provide large-scale crystal samples. Thermal
evaporation of fast crystallization-deposition could obtain micro-/nanoscaled
cocrystal thin films. The temperature should be higher than the boiling
point of solvent to generate instantaneous evaporation of solvent.
The airflow formed by solvent vapor favors the crystallization of
uniform micro-/nanostructures. Generally, increasing the temperature
is conducive to the formation of high-quality micro-/nanocrystals.
However, a phase transition would occur when the temperature is higher
than the melting point of AD (110 °C). Finally, it is found that
the organic salt form of AD-IPA and AD-TMA shows a higher crystallinity
than the neutral AD-IPB two-component crystal and pure AD.These
thin films show strikingly different morphologies as observed by scanning
electron microscopy (SEM). Figure a reveals that the fast evaporation of AD and AD-IPB
solution could lead to the formation of uniform and orderly thin films
with pinholes. By contrast, thin films of AD-IPA and AD-TMA are highly
crystalline. It is worth noting that the block nanocrystals can be
observed for AD-IPA, while the thin film of AD-TMA exhibits a nanorod
morphology with the length and width distributed in the ranges 500–800
and 100–120 nm, respectively. The atomic force microscopy (AFM)
topographical images also show uniform and continuous film surfaces
with root-mean-square (RMS) roughness values of 15.5–23.8 nm
over a 2 μm × 2 μm area (Figure b). Side-view SEM images (Figure S12) suggest that the average thicknesses of these
thin films are in the range 1–3 μm. The PXRD patterns
of the three cocrystal thin films (Figure c and Figure S13) match well with their simulated ones. The diffraction peaks are
narrow and strong for AD-IPA and AD-TMA, indicating their high crystallinity.
The thin film of AD-IPB shows a relatively lower crystallinity compared
with those of AD-IPA and AD-TMA, which is in accordance with the morphology
analysis. This can be assigned to the high concentration distribution
of AD (with AD-IPB stoichiometry of 2:1). Irradiated under UV light,
distinct dark blue, cyan, green, and orange emission can be observed
for thin films of AD, AD-IPA, AD-IPB, and AD-TMA, respectively (Figure d). Fluorescence
spectra (Figure S14a) of these thin films
show a slight blue-shift compared with their bulk crystal samples,
which can be assigned to the decrease in the size of the nano-cocrystals.
The formation of thin films also leads to a decrease of PL lifetime
for AD, AD-IPA, and AD-IPB films, while a slight enhancement for the
film of AD-TMA (Figure S14b).
Figure 5
SEM images
(a), AFM topography images (b), PXRD patterns (c), and
photographs (d) of as-obtained AD, AD-IPA, AD-IPB, and AD-TMA films
irradiated under UV light. Scale bar: 500 nm.
SEM images
(a), AFM topography images (b), PXRD patterns (c), and
photographs (d) of as-obtained AD, AD-IPA, AD-IPB, and AD-TMA films
irradiated under UV light. Scale bar: 500 nm.
Up-Converted Fluorescence Emission of Cocrystal Thin Films
By changing the power of the long-wavelength laser, the up-converted
fluorescence emission of these cocrystal thin films can be obtained
(Figure ). Excited
by a femtosecond pulse laser at 980 nm, short wavelength up-conversion
emissions for all these thin films are observed except for AD. Compared
with the fluorescence emission for those of large-scale crystal samples,
the as-prepared thin film samples also show a blue-shifted emission,
which may be related to the fact that the PL performances of organic
materials are highly affected by their size, shape, and morphology.[21] Insets show the changes in up-conversion emission
intensity with increasing pump powers. It can be observed that all
of these samples exhibit a nearly linear relationship between the
up-conversion intensity and pump powers with the slopes of 1.956,
0.837, and 0.983 for AD-IPA, AD-IPB, and AD-TMA, respectively, indicating
that the emission process involves two-photon excited states to the
ground state for AD-IPA, while a one-photon process for AD-IPB and
AD-TMA. These results reveal that the optical gain can be highly enhanced
by the formation of orderly cocrystal thin films.
Figure 6
Up-conversion fluorescence
spectra of AD-IPA, AD-IPB, and AD-TMA
thin films excited by a 980 nm laser under different pump powers.
Insets show the changes in intensity with increasing pump powers.
Up-conversion fluorescence
spectra of AD-IPA, AD-IPB, and AD-TMA
thin films excited by a 980 nm laser under different pump powers.
Insets show the changes in intensity with increasing pump powers.
Optoelectronic Performance of Cocrystal Thin
Films
It is well recognized that the efficient separation
of photogenerated
electron–hole pairs plays a key role in organic semiconductors
for optoelectronic applications. Thus, photoelectric responses of
AD-IPA, AD-IPB, and AD-TMA were tested in 0.5 M sodium sulfate aqueous
solution at a standard three-electrode system, in which the three
cocrystal thin film modified ITO serves as the working electrode with
a working area of 1.0 cm2, a platinum wire electrode as
a counter electrode, and Ag/AgCl as a reference electrode. Figure a and Figure S15 are the transient photocurrent–time
curves with the on–off cycle’s illumination (30 s) in
a three-electrode system. It can be observed that photocurrent density
(Ilight) for the AD-TMA thin film electrode
sharply increases to 27.79 μA/cm2 when the light
source is turned on without applying an external potential. The value
is 81 and 5 times higher than those of AD-IPB (0.34 μA/cm2) and AD-IPA (5.16 μA/cm2), respectively.
By switching off the irradiation, the photocurrent density returns
to nearly zero with low dark current (Idark = 0.002 μA/cm2). Generally, the on–off current
ratio reveals the sensitivity of the photoelectric materials to certain
irradiation.[31] Herein, the maximal current
on/off ratio (Ilight/Idark) is calculated as high as 13 895 for AD-TMA,
indicating the extremely high sensitivity of the thin film to light.
This value is 2.7 times higher than those of carbon nitride nanotube
membrane (5000),[32] and 3 orders of magnitude
in comparison with the metal–organic framework (MOF) material
in electrolyte.[33] Meanwhile, this value
is also higher than those of inorganic perovskite[34] and organic single crystal-based[35] state-of-the-art optoelectronic devices. The better photogenerated
charge separation efficiency of AD-TMA makes it a potential candidate
for efficient photoswitches and photodetectors. Despite the photocurrent
densities gradually decreasing for AD-IPA and AD-TMA as time increases,
the stability test suggests that the maximal photocurrent density
presenting in the first on–off cycle can also reappear by additional
recycling tests, which exhibit the same decay tendency (Figure S16). Differently, the photocurrent density
for AD-IPB keeps constant during the on–off cycle’s
illumination. The largest photocurrent of AD-IPA/TMA in the first
impulse stems from the existence of the donor–acceptor (D–A)
heterojunction, which highly promotes the separation of electron–hole
pairs. With the increase in the illumination time, the gradually decreased
photocurrent can be related to an electron accumulation balance process.
Under the inner electric field, more and more electrons migrate from
IPA/TMA to AD. With the accumulation of more electrons, the inner
electric field is in turn weakened. Hence, it exhibits inefficient
separation of photogenerated carriers, showing decreasing photocurrent.
After a long-term release of electrons, it recovers a strong inner
electric field for efficient electron migration again. As a result,
a large photocurrent can still be observed in the first on–off
cycle.
Figure 7
(a) Transient current density–time characteristic of AD-TMA
thin film for 9 times reusable tests without bias potential. The inset
shows the maximal current density of the first on–off cycle
measured at different reusable tests. IPCE (b) and electrochemical
impedance spectroscopy (EIS) Nyquist plots (c) of three cocrystal
thin films measured at a bias of −0.5 V. (d) Schematic diagram
of the alternating arrangement of electrons and holes transport layers
at the molecule level in AD-TMA.
(a) Transient current density–time characteristic of AD-TMA
thin film for 9 times reusable tests without bias potential. The inset
shows the maximal current density of the first on–off cycle
measured at different reusable tests. IPCE (b) and electrochemical
impedance spectroscopy (EIS) Nyquist plots (c) of three cocrystal
thin films measured at a bias of −0.5 V. (d) Schematic diagram
of the alternating arrangement of electrons and holes transport layers
at the molecule level in AD-TMA.Incident photon-to-current efficiency (IPCE) was measured by monochromatic
light irradiation (Figure b). AD-TMA shows the highest IPCE value of 3.6% (at 380 nm)
among the three cocrystal thin films. Further electrochemical impedance
spectroscopy (EIS) performed at the potential of −0.5 V vs
Ag/AgCl (Figure c)
reveals that the charge transfer resistance of AD-TMA is significantly
lower than those of AD-IPA and AD-IPB, suggesting the fastest charge
transfer rate for AD-TMA. The semiconductor types of three cocrystal
thin films were further conducted by Mott–Schottky (M–S)
curves. A V-shaped M–S plot indicates a p–n junction characteristic for AD-TMA thin film, while the positive
slope of the M–S plot suggests an n-type semiconductor
for both AD-IPA and AD-IPB (Figure S17).
To the best of our knowledge, the fabrication of the molecule level
heterojunction cocrystal thin film conducting both holes and electrons
has rarely been reported.From the above results, it is concluded
that the high optoelectronic
performance of AD-TMA can be assigned to the following aspects: (a)
The infinite π–π stacking between AD molecules
results in a narrow band gap (2.027 eV), decreasing the energy levels
for both HOMO and LUMO. Therefore, the solar-energy-harvesting can
be extended from the UV to visible region for high photon-to-current
transfer ability. (b) The large Stokes’ shift of fluorescence
emission from absorption rules out the probability of self-absorption.
(c) The high crystallinity of the AD-TMA thin film also benefits the
efficient transfer of charge carriers. (d) As for the D–A cocrystals,
the integration of electron-donating/electron-accepting molecules
provide a way for the effective migration and separation of electron–hole
pairs, since the electric field between carboxyl groups of TMA and
AD molecules can highly enhance the separation efficiency of charge
carriers. The photogenerated electrons migrate along the continuous
AD π-conjugated chains with long-range π electron delocalization,
while the holes transfer along the outside TMA molecules.[36,37] As a result, it presents an alternating arrangement of electron
and hole transport layers at the molecule level (Figure d). The charge density distribution
(Figure S18) reveals that the deprotonated
carboxyl anions of TMA are electron accumulation, and protonated AD
cations are electron depletion. The photogenerated electron can directly
transfer from the carboxyl groups to the AD π-conjugated chain.
The holes prefer to migrate between the carboxyl groups. Herein, the
high-order π-conjugated chains provide a large electron channel
for efficient charge transport; the internal electric field formed
between the TMA anion layer and AD cation layer promotes the separation
efficiency of charge carriers. Therefore, the rational design and
construction of cocrystals could effectively tailor the semiconductor
behaviors and types for molecule-based thin films.
Conclusion
In summary, new types of acridine (AD) cocrystals were fabricated
as models to illustrate the tuning of photofunctional and electronic
properties of molecular solids. The template effect of different substituents
on the coformer IPA derivatives could highly modify the molecular
arrangement of AD in the cocrystals, resulting in an adjustable energy
level and multicolor emission from blue to orange-yellow. The instantaneous
and reversible angle-dependent polarized emission of AD-IPB can be
potentially used in displays, data storage, and color filters. Furthermore,
a facile and fast crystallization-deposition process has been developed
to construct orderly thin films of cocrystals, which show tunable
up-conversion luminescence and semiconductor properties. The AD-TMA
thin film exhibits an obvious enhancement of optoelectronic performance,
by virtue of molecular heterojunction assembled by the alternating
arrangement of π-conjugated AD electronic acceptor layers and
TMA electronic donor layers, which provides an efficient way for mobility
and separation of electron–hole pairs. To the best of our knowledge,
this work highlights the first examples of cocrystal thin films with
tunable p/n semiconductor performances
for photon-to-current conversion. It is anticipated that the fast
crystallization-deposition of cocrystal thin films can vastly open
up their practical applications in various luminescent and optoelectronic
fields.
Authors: Michele Buscema; Joshua O Island; Dirk J Groenendijk; Sofya I Blanter; Gary A Steele; Herre S J van der Zant; Andres Castellanos-Gomez Journal: Chem Soc Rev Date: 2015-06-07 Impact factor: 54.564
Authors: Valentin A Milichko; Sergey V Makarov; Alexey V Yulin; Alexandr V Vinogradov; Andrei A Krasilin; Elena Ushakova; Vladimir P Dzyuba; Evamarie Hey-Hawkins; Evgeny A Pidko; Pavel A Belov Journal: Adv Mater Date: 2017-01-23 Impact factor: 30.849
Authors: Kai Xiao; Bin Tu; Lu Chen; Tobias Heil; Liping Wen; Lei Jiang; Markus Antonietti Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2019-08-02 Impact factor: 15.336
Authors: Sebastian G Mucha; Marta Piksa; Lucyna Firlej; Agnieszka Krystyniak; Mirosława O Różycka; Wioletta Kazana; Krzysztof J Pawlik; Marek Samoć; Katarzyna Matczyszyn Journal: ACS Appl Mater Interfaces Date: 2022-08-26 Impact factor: 10.383