Ruoxiao Xie1,2, Anastasia Korolj2,3, Chuan Liu2, Xin Song3, Rick Xing Ze Lu2, Boyang Zhang2, Arun Ramachandran3, Qionglin Liang1, Milica Radisic2,3. 1. MOE Key Laboratory of Bioorganic Phosphorus Chemistry & Chemical Biology, Beijing Key Lab of Microanalytical Methods & Instrumentation, Department of Chemistry, Centre for Synthetic and Systems Biology, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, P. R. China. 2. Institute for Biomaterials and Biomedical Engineering, University of Toronto, 164 College Street, Toronto, Ontario M5S 3G9, Canada. 3. Department of Chemical Engineering and Applied Chemistry, University of Toronto, 200 College Street, Toronto, Ontario M5T 3A1, Canada.
Abstract
Kidney-on-a-chip devices may revolutionize the discovery of new therapies. However, fabricating a 3D glomerulus remains a challenge, due to a requirement for a microscale soft material with complex topography to support cell culture in a native configuration. Here, we describe the use of microfluidic spinning to recapitulate complex concave and convex topographies over multiple length scales, required for biofabrication of a biomimetic 3D glomerulus. We produced a microfluidic extruded topographic hollow fiber (h-FIBER), consisting of a vessel-like perfusable tubular channel for endothelial cell cultivation, and a glomerulus-like knot with microconvex topography on its surface for podocyte cultivation. Meter long h-FIBERs were produced in microfluidics within minutes, followed by chemically induced inflation for generation of topographical cues on the 3D scaffold surface. The h-FIBERs were assembled into a hot-embossed plastic 96-well plate. Long-term perfusion, podocyte barrier formation, endothelialization, and permeability tests were easily performed by a standard pipetting technique on the platform. Following long-term culture (1 month), a functional filtration barrier, measured by the transfer of albumin from the blood vessel side to the ultrafiltrate side, suggested the establishment of an engineered glomerulus.
Kidney-on-a-chip devices may revolutionize the discovery of new therapies. However, fabricating a 3D glomerulus remains a challenge, due to a requirement for a microscale soft material with complex topography to support cell culture in a native configuration. Here, we describe the use of microfluidic spinning to recapitulate complex concave and convex topographies over multiple length scales, required for biofabrication of a biomimetic 3D glomerulus. We produced a microfluidic extruded topographic hollow fiber (h-FIBER), consisting of a vessel-like perfusable tubular channel for endothelial cell cultivation, and a glomerulus-like knot with microconvex topography on its surface for podocyte cultivation. Meter long h-FIBERs were produced in microfluidics within minutes, followed by chemically induced inflation for generation of topographical cues on the 3D scaffold surface. The h-FIBERs were assembled into a hot-embossed plastic 96-well plate. Long-term perfusion, podocyte barrier formation, endothelialization, and permeability tests were easily performed by a standard pipetting technique on the platform. Following long-term culture (1 month), a functional filtration barrier, measured by the transfer of albumin from the blood vessel side to the ultrafiltrate side, suggested the establishment of an engineered glomerulus.
Organ-on-a-chip
devices are poised to revolutionize pathophysiological
studies and drug discovery. Specifically, kidney-on-a-chip devices
are of particular interest, since the incidence of diabetic and hypertensive
nephropathy is on the rise as the population continues to age, and
nephrotoxicity is also one of the key reasons for the withdrawal of
already approved drugs.[1−3] The kidney is an incredibly complex organ, consisting
of 26 different cell types in a precise geometrical and structural
arrangement.[4] It is the precise structure
and orientation of these cells that are responsible for the remarkable
filtration function of the kidney.Most kidney diseases have
been recognized to begin with the dysfunction
of the glomerulus.[5,6] The glomerulus functions as the
major filtration unit of the kidney, where plasma is filtered to form
concentrated urine. Considerable efforts have, therefore, been made
to build an in vitro glomerulus model to better understand
this filtration unit.Developed from the self-organization of
pluripotent or adult stem
cells, kidney organoids have offered a notable approach for the modeling
of kidney development and diseases in vitro.(7−9) While cells with the characteristics of glomerular podocytes and
glomerulus-like compartments were present in these organoids, vascular
flow and functional tests through the in vitro kidney
organoids were never realized due to their immaturity.[10,11] Though early glomerulus models, which made use of a transwell device
where cells were cultured on the porous membrane, allow functional
tests of cell barrier function, these static models can hardly recapitulate
the flow environment of the glomerulus.[12,13] Recently,
advances in microfluidics have made it possible to further mimic the
biomechanical microenvironment in vitro.(14,15) Flow or dynamic mechanical strain, focused on reproducing aspects
of the glomerular environment, was exerted onto the glomerulus-derived
cells, which have been cultured on a membrane within the microfluidic
chip.[16−18] The fluid was demonstrated to enhance the survival
of isolated glomerular microtissues and the modeling of physio-pathological
fluid environments to enable more biomimetic glomerulus models.[19,20] By combining strain with physiological flow, Musah et al. demonstrated
that the differentiation of human induced pluripotent stem cells into
podocytes was enhanced, enabling the fabrication of a human glomerulus-on-a-chip
model.[21] However, even in these advanced
models, cells are still cultured in a simplified 2D geometry without
recapitulating the structure of a 3D glomerulus.The kidney
glomerulus is a knot of capillaries with endothelial
cells (ECs) lying inside the lumen at the blood vessel side and podocytes
covering the external surface at the ultrafiltrate side (Figure A).[22,23] To enhance the function of in vitro models, appropriate
structures with the intricate architecture and complexity of native
organs are required.[24−27] Significant efforts have been invested in the fabrication of tubular
structures to mimic blood vessels by various engineering methods.[28,29] It was demonstrated that 3D tubular structures could enable physiological
force-driven endothelial behaviors, while a flat and stiff substrate
would influence cell–cell signaling pathways related with the
barrier function.[30−32] However, despite the feasibility of constructing
various tubular scaffolds, the absence of a microscale soft material
with complex topography, to enable cell coculture in a native configuration,
has limited the progress toward a biomimetic 3D glomerular structure.
Figure 1
Design
of the biologically inspired h-FIBER. (A) Glomerulus structure.
(B) 3D structure of the h-FIBER. (C) Perfusable glomerulus model based
on h-FIBER. A scale bar in part A shows the size of a typical adult
kidney glomerulus.[59] A scale bar in part
B shows the size of a typical knot. The knot is about 3–4 times
bigger than a typical glomerulus.
Design
of the biologically inspired h-FIBER. (A) Glomerulus structure.
(B) 3D structure of the h-FIBER. (C) Perfusable glomerulus model based
on h-FIBER. A scale bar in part A shows the size of a typical adult
kidney glomerulus.[59] A scale bar in part
B shows the size of a typical knot. The knot is about 3–4 times
bigger than a typical glomerulus.Here, we describe the use of microfluidic spinning to recapitulate
complex concave and convex topographies over multiple length scales,
required for biofabrication of a biomimetic 3D glomerulus. The technique
combines high-throughput production, as meter long hollow microfibers
can be generated within minutes, with chemically induced inflation
of the hydrogel for instantaneous production of microscale topographical
cues on the 3D microfiber surface. We term this scaffold h-FIBER,
consisting of a perfusable circular channel to mimic the vascular
lumen, a spindle knot to model the globular architecture of a whole
glomerulus, and microconvex topography on the knot surface to recapitulate
the varying patterns of capillary loops (Figure B,C). Different from flat 2D membranes for
endothelial cell/podocyte coculture, our 3D biomimetic glomerulus
is situated in a custom-made hot-embossed 96-well plate fabricated
from tissue culture polystyrene to enable cell seeding, maintenance,
and perfusion via gravity-driven flow, requiring no external pumps
and allowing for facile liquid handling. Enhanced podocyte interdigitation
was demonstrated on the knot regions of h-FIBER, compared to the tube
regions. Interdigitation was further enhanced to support appropriate
barrier function when these knot regions were decorated with microtopography.
With the EC layer in the circular lumen, a functional glomerulus-on-a-plate
platform was established, demonstrating a potential use in bioengineering
and biomedical applications.
Results and Discussion
The h-FIBERs were first generated from a coaxial microfluidic device
by hydrogel polymerization (Figure S1).[33] Hollow microfibers with 10 knots can be fabricated
within 1 min, which were then cut and used to build 10 glomerulus
models in the custom designed 96-well plates. A novel chemically induced
inflation method was developed to generate microconvex topography
on the hydrogel surface (Figure A–C, Figure S2).
Similar to how we blow soap bubbles by expanding air inside a soap
solution, microconvex topography on the h-FIBER was created by a simple
chemical reaction between CaCO3 and H+, to generate
CO2 gas. These gas bubbles were trapped, expanding the
hydrogel and leaving convex structures on the hydrogel surface (Figure D–F). The
generated knot sizes were 650–950 μm (Figure S3).
Figure 2
Fabrication of glomerulus-on-a-plate platform. (A–C)
The
generation of the microconvex topography on the hydrogel knot surface
using chemically induced inflation method. (A) Knotted hydrogel microfiber
with embedded CaCO3 beads. (D) Fluorescent image of the
h-FIBER (TRITC-conjugated fluorescent beads were embedded in the hydrogel).
(E) Low-magnification and (F) high-magnification SEM image showing
the microconvex topography on the scaffold surface. (G) Assembly of
the h-FIBERs into a 96-well plate. (H) Gravity-driven perfusion of
the h-FIBER. (I) Perfusion of the h-FIBER by the syringe pump. (J)
Schematics of the syringe pump connection. (K) Pump-driven flow at
70 μL/min (blue food dye indicator). Scale bars: 200 μm.
Fabrication of glomerulus-on-a-plate platform. (A–C)
The
generation of the microconvex topography on the hydrogel knot surface
using chemically induced inflation method. (A) Knotted hydrogel microfiber
with embedded CaCO3 beads. (D) Fluorescent image of the
h-FIBER (TRITC-conjugated fluorescent beads were embedded in the hydrogel).
(E) Low-magnification and (F) high-magnification SEM image showing
the microconvex topography on the scaffold surface. (G) Assembly of
the h-FIBERs into a 96-well plate. (H) Gravity-driven perfusion of
the h-FIBER. (I) Perfusion of the h-FIBER by the syringe pump. (J)
Schematics of the syringe pump connection. (K) Pump-driven flow at
70 μL/min (blue food dye indicator). Scale bars: 200 μm.To facilitate cell attachment, RGD-conjugated alginate
was used
for all experiments. The diffusivity of various molecules in alginate
has been reported to be high (Table S1),[34−38] suggesting its feasibility for constructing a glomerulus model.
By assembling and sealing the base, together with the scaffolds, onto
a bottomless custom-made 96-well plate, the h-FIBERs were then fixed
inside the plate with the knot in the chamber of the middle well and
the two ends in the inlet and outlet wells (Figure G). Up to 20 h-FIBERs were assembled into
one plate at the same time. Gravity-driven perfusion was realized
in these scaffolds by applying the hydrostatic pressure difference
between inlet and outlet (Figures H and 3A–C, Video S1).[39−41] By connecting the plate to a
syringe pump, fluid could also be pumped in the channel without leaking
(Figure I–K).
The perfusion of FITC-conjugated bovine serum albumin (FITC-BSA) solution
in the lumen (Figure D) further demonstrated that the perfused media remained in the lumen,
flowing from the inlet to the outlet (Figure E), while molecules (e.g., BSA) from the
media could permeate the hydrogel and diffuse into the middle well.
By reversibly tilting the plate every 3 h, long-term perfusion was
easily realized. The calculated shear stress induced by the gravity-driven
flow in the lumen ranges from 0.3 to 0.9 Pa, which is within the physiological
range of blood flow-induced shear stress in a glomerulus (about 0.1–9.5
Pa).[42]
Figure 3
Assembled h-FIBERS are perfusable. (A–C)
Fluorescence images
of the inlet, middle, and outlet wells perfused with the fluorescent
beads. The arrow shows the direction of the flow. (D) Fluorescence
image showing the perfusion and permeation of FITC-BSA. The arrow
shows the direction of the flow. The dotted line shows the location
of the glomerulus-mimicking knot. (E) Quantitative results of perfusion.
The p-value of one-way repeated measures ANOVA over
time for volume of media in inlet, middle, and outlet well is 0.0087
(**), 0.0694 (n.s.), and 0.0113 (*) respectively. Data are shown as
average ± s.d., n = 3. * p <
0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p <
0.001, **** p < 0.0001. Scale bars: 200 μm.
Assembled h-FIBERS are perfusable. (A–C)
Fluorescence images
of the inlet, middle, and outlet wells perfused with the fluorescent
beads. The arrow shows the direction of the flow. (D) Fluorescence
image showing the perfusion and permeation of FITC-BSA. The arrow
shows the direction of the flow. The dotted line shows the location
of the glomerulus-mimicking knot. (E) Quantitative results of perfusion.
The p-value of one-way repeated measures ANOVA over
time for volume of media in inlet, middle, and outlet well is 0.0087
(**), 0.0694 (n.s.), and 0.0113 (*) respectively. Data are shown as
average ± s.d., n = 3. * p <
0.05, ** p < 0.01, *** p <
0.001, **** p < 0.0001. Scale bars: 200 μm.To fabricate the glomerulus model, a podocyte barrier
should be
established on the external surface of the glomerulus-mimicking h-FIBER.
As cells tended to slip to the bottom rather than settle down on the
microscaffold during seeding (Figure S4A–C), we developed a hanging-droplet cell seeding technique to improve
cell attachment on the scaffold (Figure A, Figure S4D–F). To maintain the integrity of h-FIBERs, CaCl2 was added
to the culture media in a concentration that did not affect cell viability
(Figure S5). In proliferation media, the
attached podocytes gradually covered the majority of the h-FIBER surface.
Upon additional cultivation under differentiation conditions for 2
weeks, nuclear staining (Figure B) demonstrated that podocytes covered almost the entire
external surface of the scaffold. The surface area of the knot is
about 1 899 072 μm2, which is about
28% of the total surface area. Interestingly, though cell density
on the tube and knot showed no significant difference (Figure C), the cell nuclei on the
knot region were less elongated than on the tube region (Figure D).
Figure 4
Podocytes envelop the
h-FIBER forming a barrier layer. (A) Hanging-droplet
cell seeding technique. (B) DAPI nuclear staining. (C) Cell density
on the tube and knot. (D) Nuclear elongation on the tube and knot.
(E–G) Confocal microscopy images showing the differentiated
podocytes. (E) F-actin and (F) nephrin staining. (G) The merged image
of F-actin and nephrin staining (the inset shows a longitudinal cross-section).
(H) High-magnification image showing the merged image of F-actin,
nephrin, and DAPI staining. The arrow points to the cells expressing
more nephrin. (I) Timeline of cell culture for control and differentiation
groups. (J) Cell density for the two groups at Day 14. (K) The transferred
albumin concentration was measured at Day 0, Day 6, Day 10, and Day
14. The concentrations in the middle well were normalized to the concentration
of transferred albumin measured for the cell-free h-FIBER on day 0.
The p-value of one-way repeated measures ANOVA over
time for the “Ctr” and “Diff” group is
0.1608 (n.s.) and 0.0015 (**), respectively. Data are shown as average
± s.d., n = 6. * p < 0.05,
** p < 0.01. Scale bar in part B is 200 μm.
The other scale bars are 100 μm.
Podocytes envelop the
h-FIBER forming a barrier layer. (A) Hanging-droplet
cell seeding technique. (B) DAPI nuclear staining. (C) Cell density
on the tube and knot. (D) Nuclear elongation on the tube and knot.
(E–G) Confocal microscopy images showing the differentiated
podocytes. (E) F-actin and (F) nephrin staining. (G) The merged image
of F-actin and nephrin staining (the inset shows a longitudinal cross-section).
(H) High-magnification image showing the merged image of F-actin,
nephrin, and DAPI staining. The arrow points to the cells expressing
more nephrin. (I) Timeline of cell culture for control and differentiation
groups. (J) Cell density for the two groups at Day 14. (K) The transferred
albumin concentration was measured at Day 0, Day 6, Day 10, and Day
14. The concentrations in the middle well were normalized to the concentration
of transferred albumin measured for the cell-free h-FIBER on day 0.
The p-value of one-way repeated measures ANOVA over
time for the “Ctr” and “Diff” group is
0.1608 (n.s.) and 0.0015 (**), respectively. Data are shown as average
± s.d., n = 6. * p < 0.05,
** p < 0.01. Scale bar in part B is 200 μm.
The other scale bars are 100 μm.In vivo, podocyte slit diaphragms maintain glomerular
filtration function. Nephrin and podocin are podocyte-specific proteins
and vital components of the slit diaphragm.[43,44] Nephrin and podocin expression were confirmed in the podocyte layer
formed on our scaffold (Figure F–H, Figure S6). Probably
due to the artifacts coming from the staining and imaging processes,
the staining is inhomogeneous across the different knot regions. During
the staining process, part of the cell layer will touch the base of
the container and thus be less exposed to the antibodies. The possible
inhomogeneous binding of antibodies onto the 3D cell layer might cause
the inhomogeneous signal distribution. Moreover, we acquired the fluoresce
image from different layers by using confocal microscopy and then
did z-stacking to get the fluorescence image of the whole knot. Because
the liquid and the hydrogel would cause light scattering and affect
the signal, the fluorescence signals from different layers naturally
vary. The above problems made it difficult to compare the intensity
of the signal from the 3D cell layer. Thus, we did not use the fluorescence
intensity of the immunostaining images to make a comparison for the
following experiments.Due to the perfusable bioreactor, the
permeability test can be
used to test the cell barrier function. The development of podocyte
barrier function during differentiation (Diff) was tracked by the
permeability test and compared with the nondifferentiated group (Ctr)
(Figure I). The cell
density of the two groups on day 14 showed no significant difference
(Figure J). However,
the transferred albumin decreased significantly over time for the
“Diff” group but not for the “Ctr” group
(Figure K), suggesting
that podocyte differentiation was important for the development of
barrier function over time.To demonstrate the effect of microtopography,
we compared the arrangement
of actin fibers, together with the podocyte morphology, on the normal
flat PDMS surface, hydrogel tube, and the hydrogel knot with and without
microtopography (Figure A–J). In vivo, most of the glomerular F-actin
is concentrated in the foot processes, which envelop the looping capillaries
and interdigitate with neighboring podocytes via slit diaphragms.[45] Cytoskeletal changes in podocytes are related
to foot process effacement and impaired glomerular filtration.[46] More branched and interdigitated actin fibers
were found on the knot with microconvex topography (Figure A–D). These interdigitated
actin fibers are most likely used by the podocytes to remain positioned
on the soft curved surface similar to the surface provided by the
looping capillaries. In vivo, podocytes are exposed
to tremendous physical forces, requiring concentrated F-actin to provide
mechanical support and efficient attachment.[47] Similar cytoskeletal structure is reported to be induced by stretch,[21,48] flow stimulation,[49] and topographic stimulation.[27]
Figure 5
The topographical microenvironment guides podocytes’
morphology
and function. Merged images of F-actin and DAPI nuclear staining (A–D)
and SEM images showing the cell morphology (E–H) of podocytes,
cultured on the flat PDMS (Flat), hydrogel tube (Tube), hydrogel knot
without microconvex topography (Knot (-topo)), and hydrogel knot with
microconvex topography (Knot (+topo)), respectively. Quantification
of digitation ratio (I) and process length of podocytes (J). Digitation
ratio is defined as the digitated length over the boundary length.
The process length (μm) is the average length of the measured
processes. The quantification method is described in Figure S7. Data were analyzed by one-way ANOVA. (K) The concentration
of transferred albumin in the middle well for the hydrogel tube (Tube),
hydrogel tube with knot (Knot (-topo)), and hydrogel tube with knot
and microconvex topography (Knot (+topo)) with cells being differentiated
for 0, 6, 10, and 14 days was tested. The concentration was normalized
to the concentration of transferred albumin measured for the cell-free
scaffold on day 0. The normalized concentrations of each group were
analyzed by one-way repeated measures ANOVA over time. The normalized
concentrations of the three groups on Day 0, Day 6, Day 10, and Day
14 were analyzed by one-way ANOVA. Data are shown as average ±
s.d., * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01.
The topographical microenvironment guides podocytes’
morphology
and function. Merged images of F-actin and DAPI nuclear staining (A–D)
and SEM images showing the cell morphology (E–H) of podocytes,
cultured on the flat PDMS (Flat), hydrogel tube (Tube), hydrogel knot
without microconvex topography (Knot (-topo)), and hydrogel knot with
microconvex topography (Knot (+topo)), respectively. Quantification
of digitation ratio (I) and process length of podocytes (J). Digitation
ratio is defined as the digitated length over the boundary length.
The process length (μm) is the average length of the measured
processes. The quantification method is described in Figure S7. Data were analyzed by one-way ANOVA. (K) The concentration
of transferred albumin in the middle well for the hydrogel tube (Tube),
hydrogel tube with knot (Knot (-topo)), and hydrogel tube with knot
and microconvex topography (Knot (+topo)) with cells being differentiated
for 0, 6, 10, and 14 days was tested. The concentration was normalized
to the concentration of transferred albumin measured for the cell-free
scaffold on day 0. The normalized concentrations of each group were
analyzed by one-way repeated measures ANOVA over time. The normalized
concentrations of the three groups on Day 0, Day 6, Day 10, and Day
14 were analyzed by one-way ANOVA. Data are shown as average ±
s.d., * p < 0.05, ** p < 0.01.The podocytes’ morphologies on the flat
substrate, tube,
and knot with/without microtopographies were also analyzed by SEM
(Figure E–H).
On the tube region, podocytes tended to elongate and align along the
long axis of the tube (Figure F). Podocytes cultivated on the flat substrate (Figure E) and the knot without microtopography
(Figure G) were more
spread out compared to those on the tube but did not develop an appreciable in vivo-like arborized morphology. On the hydrogel knot
with microtopography, podocytes exhibited more and longer in vivo-like branched interdigitations (Figure H). To confirm the morphology
differences, we quantified the digitation ratio and the average process
length of podocytes cultivated on the different substrates (Figure I,J) according to
the previously published method.[27] The
digitation ratio and process length of podocytes on the knot with
microtopography are greater than that of podocytes on the knot without
microtopography and are significantly greater than that of podocytes
on the tube, suggesting that the microconvex topography improves the
digitation and extension of processes in podocytes. Collectively,
these data indicate that the knot region with microtopography is essential
for providing the in vivo-like microenvironment for
podocytes.The development of podocyte barrier function during
differentiation
on the tube (Tube), the knotted tube (Knot (-topo)), and the knotted
tube with microtopography (Knot (+topo)) was tracked by the permeability
test (Figure K). One-way
repeated measures ANOVA showed that the transferred BSA decreased
significantly over time for the “Knot (-topo)” group
and the “Knot (+topo)” group, but not for the “Tube”
group. Thus, the knot region is important for the development of podocyte
barrier function. On day 14, the transfer of albumin from the lumen
to the middle well for the “Knot (-topo)” group was
significantly higher than that for the “Knot (+topo)”
group, indicating that the microtopography is important for maintaining
the in vivo-like cell function. Thus, the “concave
and convex” geometries facilitated the formation of podocytes’
actin fibers, arborized morphology, as well as the establishment of
higher barrier function.To observe differences in transport
properties as a result of molecule
type, Ficoll-70 (70 kDa, ∼49.5 Å) and Ficoll-40 (40 kDa,
∼40 Å) permeability across the podocyte barrier was tested
alongside both BSA and inulin (5.5 kDa). A planar transwell insert
with a layer of RGD-alginate was used as a control. It was observed
that cells on planar controls grew poorly, with a tendency to detach
from the surface or become elongated in morphology (Figure A). We suspect that, in the
h-FIBER configuration, the factors of curvature, microtopography,
and flow all contributed to allowing cells to grow and develop with
higher success rates than on planar 2D alginate surfaces. Permeability
tests also demonstrated that the cells grown on planar alginate surfaces
did not contribute significantly to barrier function compared to cell-free
controls, and barrier function did not improve significantly with
the differentiation time, as transfer levels remained nearly equivalent
(1.0) when normalized to cell-free controls (Figure B). This is different from h-FIBER permeability
results, where differentiated cells reduced transfer of BSA to below
0.2 (Figure K). Moreover,
inulin was nearly 4 times more permeable across the h-FIBER with the
podocyte layer than BSA, whereas Ficoll 49.5 Å and Ficoll 40
Å were less permeable than BSA, with Ficoll 40 Å having
the most similar (∼70%) permeability values to BSA (Figure C). While the fixed
podocyte h-FIBERs had a size-discriminating effect on the concentration
of transferred molecules, the cell-free h-FIBERs did not significantly
or preferentially influence the transport properties of the molecules
(Figure C). Overall,
these data confirm the contribution of 3D cell barrier function to
size discrimination.
Figure 6
The 3D topography of h-FIBER contributes to a biomimetic
size-discriminant
barrier function. (A) Podocytes on planar alginate. (B) Permeability
on planar controls. Permeability results for various FITC-labeled
molecules across podocytes grown on planar alginate membranes, normalized
to cell-free controls. Midpoint measurements were taken between days
6 and 9; endpoint measurements were taken between days 13 and 16. n = 5 samples with cells were normalized to the average
of n = 4 cell-free samples. Repeated measures 2-way
ANOVA confirms no significant difference over time between molecule
transfer at midpoint and endpoint of differentiation time. At the
endpoint, inulin had significantly more molecule transfer than Ficoll-40
(Ficoll 40 Å) and Ficoll-70 (Ficoll 49.5 Å), p < 0.05, but there was no significant difference between BSA and
inulin. (C) Concentration of FITC-labeled BSA, inulin, Ficoll 40 Å,
and Ficoll 49.5 Å, that was transferred across h-FIBERs with
fixed podocytes or cell-free h-FIBERs, normalized to average BSA transfer,
respectively. ANOVA confirms molecular-weight-dependent barrier function
in configuration with fixed cells, whereas there was no significant
difference in cell-free h-FIBERs. * p < 0.05.
The 3D topography of h-FIBER contributes to a biomimetic
size-discriminant
barrier function. (A) Podocytes on planar alginate. (B) Permeability
on planar controls. Permeability results for various FITC-labeled
molecules across podocytes grown on planar alginate membranes, normalized
to cell-free controls. Midpoint measurements were taken between days
6 and 9; endpoint measurements were taken between days 13 and 16. n = 5 samples with cells were normalized to the average
of n = 4 cell-free samples. Repeated measures 2-way
ANOVA confirms no significant difference over time between molecule
transfer at midpoint and endpoint of differentiation time. At the
endpoint, inulin had significantly more molecule transfer than Ficoll-40
(Ficoll 40 Å) and Ficoll-70 (Ficoll 49.5 Å), p < 0.05, but there was no significant difference between BSA and
inulin. (C) Concentration of FITC-labeled BSA, inulin, Ficoll 40 Å,
and Ficoll 49.5 Å, that was transferred across h-FIBERs with
fixed podocytes or cell-free h-FIBERs, normalized to average BSA transfer,
respectively. ANOVA confirms molecular-weight-dependent barrier function
in configuration with fixed cells, whereas there was no significant
difference in cell-free h-FIBERs. * p < 0.05.Doxorubicin, widely used in antitumor therapy,
is known to cause
podocyte injury and induce proteinuria.[50,51] To model the
intravenous injection of doxorubicin, we added culture medium with
1 μg mL–1 doxorubicin into the inlet and outlet.
BSA transferring through the drug-treated podocyte barrier increased
in comparison to the control group (Figure S8), however, with milder cell barrier injury than previously reported.[16,21] The slope of permeability changes over time shows a significant
difference between the drug-treated group and control group (Figure S8B), suggesting that the changes might
be more significant if the drug exposure time is extended. These results
demonstrated the potential application of the 3D glomerulus model
in building a nephropathy model in vitro. This milder
cell barrier injury might be because the drug in our model was perfused
in the lumen, and thus, the podocytes on the outer surface of the
h-FIBER scaffold were not directly exposed to the drug in high concentration.
Another possible reason is that greater maturation in 3D tissues makes
it more difficult for a drug to saturate a tissue and fulfill its
targeted effect and thus contributes to greater robustness and resistance
to drugs, which was also demonstrated in other 3D models previously.[52] The value of organ-on-a-chip systems is in reducing
both false positives and false negatives in preclinical drug discovery
and testing of new chemical entities. With a view of eliminating false
positives, this feature may be desirable. We will explore the application
of the platform in drug screening with more experiments in the future.
Overall, with the current system and results, we can define specific
advantages of our platform in drug testing. For example, our platform
allows robust permeability tests by facile fluid sampling from the
open-access wells, which will be suitable for regular workflow in
the pharmaceutical industry.At the blood vessel side in vivo, there is a layer
of ECs in the capillary lumen, which is an important component of
the functional filtration barrier.[23] The
perfusable lumen in the h-FIBER is ideal for mimicking vascular lumen.
Since the h-FIBER has been robustly assembled in the 96-well bioreactor,
the seeding of ECs in the microscale hydrogel lumen was easily realized
using the standard pipetting technique (Figure A). As the ECs proliferated and spread, a
confluent EC layer covering the luminal surface was formed as confirmed
with staining for ZO-1 (Figure B–D), a tight junction protein, as well as VE-Cadherin,
an endothelial cell-specific protein (Figure S9). Compared to the cell-free h-FIBER, the permeability of the h-FIBER
with ECs reduced significantly (Figure G), which further demonstrated the formation of a functional
vascular barrier.
Figure 7
Endothelialization and the formation of the glomerular
filtration
barrier. (A) Illustration of cell seeding in the lumen of h-FIBER.
(B–D) Confocal microscopy images showing ZO-1 (red) and DAPI
(blue) staining of EC barrier formed in the lumen. Part B shows the
bottom plane with inset showing the enlarged view. Part C shows the
middle plane. Part D shows the 3D view of the EC barrier. (E) Front
view of the glomerular structure stained for F-actin. (F) Longitudinal
cross-sectional view of the glomerular structure formed on the h-FIBER
with EC layer in the lumen and podocyte layer on the external surface
both stained for F-actin. (G) Normalized concentration of transferred
BSA through the h-FIBERs without cells (w/o) (tested on day 0), with
EC barrier (EC) (tested on day 8 after EC seeding), with podocyte
barrier (pod) (tested on day 14 after podocyte differentiation), and
with both EC and podocyte barrier (co) (tested on day 8 after EC seeding).
(H) Comparison of the permeability of the h-FIBER and glomerulus.
Though the radius of BSA is around 36 Å, the fractional clearance
of albumin was reported to be similar to the fractional clearances
of Ficoll with Stokes–Einstein radius of 54 Å.[60] Thus, the permeability of Ficoll of similar
sizes (38, 48, and 62 Å) from the intact glomerulus and acellular
GBM tested in vitro were chosen as comparisons.[61] Data were analyzed by one-way ANOVA and are
shown as average ± s.d., **** p < 0.0001.
The scale bar in the inset of part B is 20 μm. The other scale
bars are 100 μm.
Endothelialization and the formation of the glomerular
filtration
barrier. (A) Illustration of cell seeding in the lumen of h-FIBER.
(B–D) Confocal microscopy images showing ZO-1 (red) and DAPI
(blue) staining of EC barrier formed in the lumen. Part B shows the
bottom plane with inset showing the enlarged view. Part C shows the
middle plane. Part D shows the 3D view of the EC barrier. (E) Front
view of the glomerular structure stained for F-actin. (F) Longitudinal
cross-sectional view of the glomerular structure formed on the h-FIBER
with EC layer in the lumen and podocyte layer on the external surface
both stained for F-actin. (G) Normalized concentration of transferred
BSA through the h-FIBERs without cells (w/o) (tested on day 0), with
EC barrier (EC) (tested on day 8 after EC seeding), with podocyte
barrier (pod) (tested on day 14 after podocyte differentiation), and
with both EC and podocyte barrier (co) (tested on day 8 after EC seeding).
(H) Comparison of the permeability of the h-FIBER and glomerulus.
Though the radius of BSA is around 36 Å, the fractional clearance
of albumin was reported to be similar to the fractional clearances
of Ficoll with Stokes–Einstein radius of 54 Å.[60] Thus, the permeability of Ficoll of similar
sizes (38, 48, and 62 Å) from the intact glomerulus and acellular
GBM tested in vitro were chosen as comparisons.[61] Data were analyzed by one-way ANOVA and are
shown as average ± s.d., **** p < 0.0001.
The scale bar in the inset of part B is 20 μm. The other scale
bars are 100 μm.By culturing podocytes
on the external surface and ECs on the lumen
surface, a 3D glomerular filtration barrier was formed on the h-FIBER.
The established glomerulus-like structure was demonstrated by F-actin
staining (Figure E,F),
demonstrating two cell layers in a precise geometrical arrangement.
The permeability of the h-FIBER with both podocyte and EC layers was
reduced significantly when compared to the h-FIBER with the EC layer
only but did not show a significant difference when compared to the
h-FIBER with the podocyte layer alone (Figure G). This result suggests that, in our glomerulus
model, the podocyte layer contributed more to the barrier function,
which is consistent with in vivo data showing that
podocyte injury is a pivotal event resulting in proteinuria.[53] Moreover, the permeability of the h-FIBER was
estimated according to the method and the mathematical model described
in the experimental section. The results are shown in Figure H, suggesting that the h-FIBER
is slightly less permeable than acellular glomerulus basement membrane
(GBM), and the cellularized h-FIBER is also slightly less permeable
than the intact glomerulus. Though the physical separation of the
two cell types in our model is much greater than in vivo (0.3 μm), and the cells were from nonhuman cell sources, limiting
utility of this work in modeling a human system with proper cell–cell
crosstalk, these results demonstrate the potential and the feasibility
of this platform. In future work, we plan to use human cells (e.g.,
podocytes from human induced pluripotent stem cells[21]) and try to minimize the thickness of the alginate layer
to further develop a more physiological model.The generation
of shape-controlled hydrogel scaffolds using microfluidics
has drawn considerable attention for its ability to mimic different
tissue constructs.[54] Through precise control
of fluids in the microdevices, various hollow microfibers with straight,[55] folded,[56] helical,[57] and multiple channels[58] have been mass-produced to mimic complex vascular microenvironments.
However, achieving a perfusable vascular barrier within these microscaffolds
was still a challenge. This limitation was rooted in the lack of a
suitable bioreactor to provide reliable perfusion and the difficulty
in seeding and culturing cells inside the fragile microscale hydrogel
scaffolds. Here, we described a 96-well plate platform based on the
h-FIBER that overcame these limitations and provided a functional
glomerulus-on-a-plate.
Conclusions
In summary,
a novel perfusable 3D engineered glomerulus based on
a microfluidic extruded topographic hydrogel scaffold has been demonstrated
here. The h-FIBERs were produced by microfluidic spinning technology
with a chemically induced inflation method, developed to fabricate
microconvex topographies on the 3D hydrogel surface for mimicking
microcurved features of the looping capillaries. The assembly of the
h-FIBERs into a 96-well plate allowed perfusion, cell maintenance,
and a permeability test to be realized using a standard pipetting
technique. Endothelial cells were seeded in the perfusable lumen to
generate the vascular barrier. The podocyte layer with better barrier
function was formed on capillary loop-like structures. The permeability
of albumin from the vascular channel to the ultrafiltrate side was
tested, demonstrating the successful fabrication of a 3D glomerulus
filtration barrier. The combination of the newly developed h-FIBERs
using microfluidics and coculture in a 96-well plate setting to control
cell arrangement demonstrates a new approach to assemble a biomimetic
glomerulus in 3D.
Authors: Khoon S Lim; Marissa Baptista; Shahana Moon; Tim B F Woodfield; Jelena Rnjak-Kovacina Journal: Trends Biotechnol Date: 2019-05-07 Impact factor: 19.536
Authors: V Ruotsalainen; P Ljungberg; J Wartiovaara; U Lenkkeri; M Kestilä; H Jalanko; C Holmberg; K Tryggvason Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 1999-07-06 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Ioannis Bantounas; Parisa Ranjzad; Faris Tengku; Edina Silajdžić; Duncan Forster; Marie-Claude Asselin; Philip Lewis; Rachel Lennon; Antonius Plagge; Qi Wang; Adrian S Woolf; Susan J Kimber Journal: Stem Cell Reports Date: 2018-02-08 Impact factor: 7.765
Authors: Claudio Colombo; Min Li; Shojiro Watanabe; Piergiorgio Messa; Alberto Edefonti; Giovanni Montini; Davide Moscatelli; Maria Pia Rastaldi; Francesco Cellesi Journal: ACS Omega Date: 2017-02-20
Authors: Sarah Williams; Joseph L Charest; Martin R Pollak; Balajikarthick Subramanian Journal: Tissue Eng Part B Rev Date: 2021-12-08 Impact factor: 7.376
Authors: Marta G Valverde; João Faria; Elena Sendino Garví; Manoe J Janssen; Rosalinde Masereeuw; Silvia M Mihăilă Journal: Pediatr Nephrol Date: 2022-03-14 Impact factor: 3.651
Authors: Marta G Valverde; Luis S Mille; Kianti P Figler; Ernesto Cervantes; Vanessa Y Li; Joseph V Bonventre; Rosalinde Masereeuw; Yu Shrike Zhang Journal: Nat Rev Nephrol Date: 2022-01-21 Impact factor: 28.314