| Literature DB >> 32596971 |
Wing-Fu Lai1,2, Wing-Tak Wong2.
Abstract
Hutchinson-Gilford progeria syndrome (HGPS) is an autosomal-dominant genetic disease that leads to accelerated aging and often premature death caused by cardiovascular complications. Till now clinical management of HGPS has largely relied on the treatment of manifestations and on the prevention of secondary complications, cure for the disease has not yet been established. Addressing this need cannot only benefit progeria patients but may also provide insights into intervention design for combating physiological aging. By using the systematic review approach, this article revisits the overall progress in the development of strategies for HGPS treatment over the last ten years, from 2010 to 2019. In total, 1,906 articles have been retrieved, of which 56 studies have been included for further analysis. Based on the articles analyzed, the trends in the use of different HGPS models, along with the prevalence, efficiency, and limitations of different reported treatment strategies, have been examined. Emerging strategies for preclinical studies, and possible targets for intervention development, have also been presented as avenues for future research.Entities:
Keywords: Hutchinson-Gilford progeria syndrome; laminopathy; premature aging; treatment
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32596971 PMCID: PMC7370734 DOI: 10.1111/acel.13175
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Aging Cell ISSN: 1474-9718 Impact factor: 9.304
FIGURE 1(a) Flow diagram depicting the review process. (b) The cumulative number of included articles retrieved from each year in the period under review
Different regimens reported for the treatment of HGPS
| Type | Treatment regimen | Ref. |
|---|---|---|
| Pharmacological treatment | Treatment with FTI‐276 | Wang et al. ( |
| Treatment with FTI‐277 | Pacheco et al. ( | |
| Treatment with a combination of pravastatin and zoledronate | Wang et al. ( | |
| Treatment with a combination of FTI‐277 and GGTI‐2147 | Mehta et al. ( | |
| Treatment with rapamycin | Cao et al. ( | |
| Treatment with leptomycin B | Garcia‐Aguirre et al. ( | |
| Treatment with various regimens containing FTI‐277 or rapamycin | Bikkul et al. ( | |
| Treatment with baricitinib | Liu et al. ( | |
| Treatment with a combination of levamisole and ARL67156 | Villa‐Bellosta ( | |
| Treatment with resveratrol | Liu et al. ( | |
| Treatment with Y‐27632 | Kang et al. ( | |
| Treatment with a combination of lonafarnib and sulforaphane | Gabriel et al. ( | |
| Treatment with N6‐isopentenyladenosine | Bifulco et al. ( | |
| Treatment with a combination of all‐trans retinoic acid and rapamycin | Pellegrini et al. ( | |
| Treatment with sulforaphane | Gabriel et al. ( | |
| Treatment with methylene blue | Xiong et al. ( | |
| Treatment with JH4 | Lee, Jung, et al. ( | |
| Treatment with 1α,25‐dihydroxyvitamin D3 | Kreienkamp et al. ( | |
| Treatment with lonafarnib/pravastatin/zoledronic acid triple therapy | Gordon et al. ( | |
| Treatment with temsirolimus | Gabriel et al. ( | |
| Treatment with metformin | Egesipe et al. ( | |
| Treatment with a combination of rapamycin and dimethylsulfoxide | Akinci et al. ( | |
| Treatment with lonafarnib monotherapy | Gordon et al. ( | |
| Treatment with MG132 | Harhouri et al. ( | |
| Treatment with small‐molecule NRF2‐activating agents | Kubben et al. ( | |
| Treatment with N‐acetyl cysteine (NAC) | Kubben et al. ( | |
| Treatment with ABT‐737 | Ovadya et al. ( | |
| Treatment with quercetin | Geng et al. ( | |
| Treatment with vitamin C | Geng et al. ( | |
| Treatment with S‐adenosyl methionine (SAMe) | Mateos et al. ( | |
| Treatment with BRL37344 | Ho et al. ( | |
| Treatment with spermidine | Ao et al. ( | |
| Treatment with CP‐466722 | Kuk et al. ( | |
| Treatment with tauroursodeoxycholic acid | Hamczyk et al. ( | |
| Treatment with sodium pyrophosphate tetrabasic decahydrate | Villa‐Bellosta et al. ( | |
| Treatment with KU55933 ATM inhibitor | Osorio et al. ( | |
| Treatment with sodium salicylate | Osorio et al. ( | |
| Protein therapy | Treatment with recombinant IGF‐1 | Marino et al. ( |
| Microbiota therapy | Fecal microbiota transplantation | Barcena et al. ( |
| Nucleic acid therapy | Genetic manipulation to deplete methyltransferase Suv39h1 | Liu et al. ( |
| Genetic manipulation to reduce the isoprenylcysteine carboxyl methyltransferase (ICMT) expression and activity | Ibrahim et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to overexpress SIRT6 | Endisha et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to knockdown the phospholipase A2 receptor | Griveau et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to inhibit DNA damage response at telomeres | Aguado et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to disrupt the last part of the | Santiago‐Fernandez et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to enhance the activity of telomerase | Li et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to cause lamin A/progerin‐specific transcriptional interference or RNA destabilization | Beyret et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to enhance caNRF2 expression | Kubben et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to knockdown CAND1 expression | Kubben et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to inhibit pathogenic | Harhouri et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to enhance lamin C production at the expense of prelamin A | Lee, Nobumori, et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to inhibit NF‐kB activation | Osorio et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to correct or silence the HGPS mutation | Liu et al. ( | |
| Genetic manipulation to express Yamanaka factors | Ocampo et al. ( | |
| Diet control | Methionine restriction | Barcena et al. ( |
Strategies of nucleic acid therapy reported for preclinical HGPS treatment
| Strategy | Objective | Effects | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prenatal genetic manipulation | To deplete methyltransferase Suv39h1 | Loss of Suv39h1 in progeroid mice delayed body weight loss, increased bone mineral density, and extended lifespan | Liu et al. ( |
| To reduce the expression and activity of isoprenylcysteine carboxyl methyltransferase (ICMT) | A hypomorphic allele of ICMT increased body weight, normalized grip strength, and extended the lifespan of progeroid mice | Ibrahim et al. ( | |
| To knockdown the phospholipase A2 receptor | Whole‐body knockout of | Griveau et al. ( | |
| To inhibit the NF‐κB pathway | The therapy increased body weight and extended the lifespan of the mouse model. In addition, after treatment, the spleen of the mouse model showed normal lymphoid follicles. The thymus of the mouse model also displayed normal tissue mass, cellularity, and architecture | Osorio et al. ( | |
| To overexpress Yamanaka factors | The therapy ameliorated organismal phenotypes associated with HGPS | Ocampo et al. ( | |
| To silence the HGPS mutation | The therapy normalized the bone morphology and mineralization in the mouse model, in which osteoblast‐ and osteocyte‐specific inducible transgenic expression of the HGPS mutation had been incorporated. It also normalized dentinogenesis, and increased the number of osteocytes in remodeled bone. | Strandgren et al. ( | |
| Antisense oligonucleotide therapy | To inhibit DNA damage response | Treatment with sequence‐specific telomeric antisense oligonucleotides led to a significant reduction in the number of telomere dysfunction‐induced foci in progeroid mice. Restoration of homeostatic proliferation in the suprabasal layer of the skin of the mice was also observed | Aguado et al. ( |
| To prevent pathogenic | The therapy reduced the accumulation of progerin, ameliorated progeroid phenotypes, and extended the lifespan of progeroid mice | Osorio et al. ( | |
| To increase lamin C production at the expense of prelamin A | The therapy ameliorated the aortic pathology observed in | Lee, Nobumori, et al. ( | |
| Ex vivo treatment of cells before implantation | To reactivate the NRF2 pathway by knocking down CAND1 | The therapy could not only restore the in vivo viability of MSCs obtained from the differentiation of the induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) derived from HGPS fibroblasts, but could also decrease the reactive oxygen species (ROS) level and could rescue nuclear defects in those cells | Kubben et al. ( |
| CRISPR/Cas9‐based therapy | To impede lamin A/progerin production | The therapy led to a significant reduction in the number of progerin‐positive nuclei in the liver, heart and skeletal muscles of the progeroid mice | Santiago‐Fernandez et al. ( |
| To cause lamin A/progerin‐specific transcriptional interference or RNA destabilization | The therapy suppressed epidermal thinning and dermal fat loss, ameliorated the degeneration of vascular smooth muscle cells of the aortic arch, attenuated the development of bradycardia, and increased the median survival rate of progeroid mice | Beyret et al. ( |
Treatment strategies verified only in vitro for tackling HGPS
| Type of agents | Strategy | Effects | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small‐molecule compound | Treatment with inhibitors to prevent progerin farnesylation and geranylgeranylation | Treatment of progeria cells with the farnesyltransferase inhibitor FTI‐277 and the geranylgeranyltransferase inhibitor GGTI‐2147 successfully corrected the disease‐associated changes in chromosome territory positions and chromosome dynamics | Mehta et al. ( |
| Treatment with rapamycin alone | Rapamycin treatment of progeria cells lowered the levels of progerin and wild‐type prelamin A. It could also increase the relative expression of ZMPSTE24, which is a prelamin A endoprotease | Cenni et al. ( | |
| Rapamycin treatment of progeria cells abolished nuclear blebbing, delayed the onset of cellular senescence, and enhanced progerin degradation | Cao et al. ( | ||
| Treatment of muscle‐derived stem/progenitor cells obtained from progeroid mice with rapamycin improved the capacity of myogenic and chondrogenic differentiation, and reduced the extent of apoptosis and senescence | Kawakami et al. ( | ||
| Treatment with a farnesyltransferase inhibitor alone | Treatment of GFP‐progerin marrow‐isolated adult multilineage inducible MIAMI cells with FTI‐277 reduced the number of abnormal nuclei, decreased the stiffness in both cytoplasmic and nuclear regions, and enhanced the self‐renewal capacity of those cells | Pacheco et al. ( | |
| Treatment with rapamycin and all‐trans retinoic acid | Treatment of progeria cells with rapamycin, along with all‐trans retinoic acid, reduced the levels of progerin and prelamin A, and increased the lamin A to progerin ratio. | Pellegrini et al. ( | |
| Treatment with rapamycin and DMSO | Treatment of progeria cells with DMSO and rapamycin ameliorated nuclear shape abnormalities | Akinci et al. ( | |
| Treatment with rapamycin and a farnesyltransferase inhibitor | Treatment of progeria cells with the farnesyltransferase inhibitor (viz., FTI‐277) and rapamycin restored the genome organization in progeria cells and improved the ability of the cells to repair damaged DNA | Bikkul et al. ( | |
| Treatment with N6‐isopentenyladenosine | Treatment of progeria cells with N6‐isopentenyladenosine ameliorated nuclear shape abnormalities and led to a redistribution of prelamin A away from the inner nuclear envelope | Bifulco et al. ( | |
| Treatment with sulforaphane | Treatment of progeria cells with sulforaphane enhanced progerin clearance, and reduced the extent of DNA damage associated with HGPS | Gabriel et al. ( | |
| Treatment with methylene blue | Treatment of progeria cells with methylene blue alleviated mitochondrial defects caused by HGPS, rescued nuclear shape abnormalities and perinuclear heterochromatin loss, and corrected misregulated gene expression | Xiong et al. ( | |
| Treatment with 1α,25‐dihydroxyvitamin D3 | Treatment of progeria cells with 1α,25‐dihydroxyvitamin D3 reduced progerin production, and alleviated some of the disease phenotypes, including nuclear morphological abnormalities, DNA repair defects, and premature senescence | Kreienkamp et al. ( | |
| Treatment with temsirolimus | Treatment of progeria cells with temsirolimus decreased the progerin level, enhanced cell proliferation, and reduced the number of misshapen nuclei | Gabriel et al. ( | |
| Treatment with metformin | Treatment of MSCs derived from progeria fibroblasts with metformin led to a reduction in progerin expression, and ameliorated nuclear shape abnormalities | Egesipe et al. ( | |
| Treatment of progeria cells with metformin delayed cell senescence caused by HGPS, reduced ROS production, and decreased the number of DNA damage foci | Park and Shin ( | ||
| Treatment with the ROCK inhibitor | Treatment of progeria cells with the ROCK inhibitor Y‐27632 decreased the number of misshapen nuclei and the frequency of DNA double‐strand breaks | Kang et al. ( | |
| Treatment with a farnesyltransferase inhibitor and sulforaphane | Treatment of progeria cells with lonafarnib and sulforaphane enhanced progerin clearance, prevented prelamin A accumulation, ameliorated nuclear shape abnormalities, and reduced the number of DNA damage foci | Gabriel et al. ( | |
| Treatment with baricitinib | Treatment of progeria cells with baricitinib restored cellular homeostasis, delayed cell senescence, and reduced the expression of proinflammatory markers | Liu et al. ( | |
| Treatment with leptomycin B | Treatment of progeria cells with leptomycin B reduced the number of senescent cells, ameliorated nuclear shape abnormalities, and rescued the loss of heterochromatin | Garcia‐Aguirre et al. ( | |
| Treatment with N‐acetyl cysteine (NAC) | Treatment of progeria cells with NAC rescued the ability to repair double‐strand breaks, and decreased the population‐doubling time | Richards et al. ( | |
| Treatment with vitamin C and/or quercetin | Treatment of HGPS hMSCs with vitamin C and/or quercetin inhibited progerin production, decreased the population‐doubling time, decreased senescence‐associated β‐galactosidase positivity, and increased the proliferative ability of the cells | Geng et al. ( | |
| Treatment with S‐adenosyl methionine (SAMe) | Treatment of progeria cells with SAMe increased the proliferative capacity of the cells, and decreased senescence‐associated β‐galactosidase positivity | Mateos et al. ( | |
| Treatment with CP‐466722 | Treatment of progeria cells with CP‐466722 induced mitochondrial functional recovery, reduced progerin accumulation, and ameliorated nuclear defects | Kuk et al. ( | |
| Therapeutic nucleic acid | Lentiviral infection for overexpression of SIRT6 | Overexpression of SIRT6 in progeria cells led to a reduction in the frequency of SA‐β‐gal positivity, and reduced the number of misshapen nuclei | Endisha et al. ( |
| Transduction with an adenoviral vector for the correction of the | Transduction of iPSCs derived from HGPS fibroblasts with the viral vector restored the expression of wild‐type lamin A. abolished progerin expression, decelerated senescence, and ameliorated nuclear shape abnormalities | Liu et al. ( | |
| Treatment with morpholino antisense oligonucleotides for progerin downregulation | Antisense‐based progerin downregulation reduced the accumulation of progerin and/or other truncated prelamin A isoforms, ameliorated nuclear shape abnormalities, and reduced senescence in HGPS‐like patients' cells | Harhouri et al. ( | |
| Transfection with human telomerase reverse transcriptase (hTERT) mRNA | Transfection of short telomere‐containing progeria cells with hTERT mRNA increased the proliferative capacity and lifespan of the cells, reduced the level of senescence, and ameliorated nuclear shape abnormalities | Li et al. ( |
Biological targets adopted for tackling HGPS
| Level | Target | Example | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Molecular level | Protein prenylation | Pravastatin | Gordon et al. ( |
| Zoledronate | Gordon et al. ( | ||
| GGTI‐2147 | Mehta et al. ( | ||
| Protein farnesylation | FTI‐276 | Wang et al. ( | |
| FTI‐277 | Bikkul et al. ( | ||
| Lonafarnib | Gordon et al. ( | ||
| N6‐isopentenyladenosine | Bifulco et al. ( | ||
| GH/insulin/IGF‐1 signaling | Recombinant IGF‐1 | Marino et al. ( | |
| Methionine‐restrict diet | Barcena et al. ( | ||
| Sirtuin pathway | Resveratrol | Liu et al. ( | |
| Plasmids for SIRT6 overexpression | Endisha et al. ( | ||
| ROS generation | Y‐27632 | Kang et al. ( | |
| NAC | Kubben et al. ( | ||
| Purine metabolism | SAMe | Mateos et al. ( | |
| NF‐κB signaling | siRNA to inhibit ATM expression | Osorio et al. ( | |
| KU55933 | Osorio et al. ( | ||
| Sodium salicylate | Osorio et al. ( | ||
| NRF2 pathway | Oltipraz | Kubben et al. ( | |
| CPDT | Kubben et al. ( | ||
| TAT‐14 | Kubben et al. ( | ||
| AI‐1 | Kubben et al. ( | ||
| Constitutively activated NRF2 | Kubben et al. ( | ||
| siRNA to knock down CAND1 expression | Kubben et al. ( | ||
| Sulforaphane | Gabriel et al. ( | ||
| Calcium‐phosphate deposition | Sodium pyrophosphate tetrabasic decahydrate | Villa‐Bellosta et al. ( | |
| JAK‐STAT pathway | Baricitinib | Liu et al. ( | |
| DNA repair and damage–response pathways | Sequence‐specific telomeric antisense oligonucleotides | Aguado et al. ( | |
| Methionine‐restrict diet | Barcena et al. ( | ||
| siRNA targeting Suv39h1 | Liu et al. ( | ||
| Production and binding of progerin/lamin A | All‐trans retinoic acid | Pellegrini et al. ( | |
| Metformin | Egesipe et al. ( | ||
| Therapeutic RNA targeting | Beyret et al. ( | ||
| Antisense oligonucleotides that reduce prelamin A production | Lee, Nobumori, et al. ( | ||
| 1α,25‐dihydroxyvitamin D3 | Kreienkamp et al. ( | ||
| JH1 | Lee, Jung, et al. ( | ||
| JH4 | Lee, Jung, et al. ( | ||
| JH13 | Lee, Jung, et al. ( | ||
| Antisense oligonucleotides that prevent pathogenic | Harhouri et al. ( | ||
| A helper‐dependent adenoviral vector designed to correct the HGPS mutation | Liu et al. ( | ||
| AMPK‐TOR signaling | Rapamycin | Akinci et al. ( | |
| Temsirolimus | Gabriel et al. ( | ||
| MG132 | Harhouri et al. ( | ||
| Lentiviral short hairpin RNA targeting isoprenylcysteine carboxyl methyltransferase | Ibrahim et al. ( | ||
| Metformin | Park and Shin ( | ||
| Cellular level | Nuclear protein export | Leptomycin B | Garcia‐Aguirre et al. ( |
| Cell senescence | shRNA targeting the phospholipase A2 receptor | Griveau et al. ( | |
| ABT‐737 | Ovadya et al. ( | ||
| Spermidine | Ao et al. ( | ||
| Vitamin C | Geng et al. ( | ||
| Quercetin | Geng et al. ( | ||
| Autophagy | MG132 | Harhouri et al. ( | |
| Telomere functioning | hTERT mRNA | Li et al. ( | |
| Mitochondrial functioning | Methylene blue | Xiong et al. ( | |
| CP‐466722 | Kuk et al. ( | ||
| Endoplasmic reticulum stress and unfolded protein response | Tauroursodeoxycholic acid | Hamczyk et al. ( | |
| Cellular physiology | Cellular reprogramming mediated by overexpression of Yamanaka factors | Ocampo et al. ( | |
| Physiological level | Gut microbiome | Fecal microbiota from healthy subjects | Barcena et al. ( |
| Bone marrow microenvironment | BRL37344 | Ho et al. ( | |
| Vascular calcification | ARL67156 | Villa‐Bellosta ( | |
| ATP | Villa‐Bellosta ( | ||
| Levamisole | Villa‐Bellosta ( |