The green and environmentally friendly synthesis of highly valuable organic substances is one possibility for the utilization of laccases (EC 1.10.3.2). As reactants for the herein described syntheses, different o-substituted arylamines or arylthiols and 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid and its derivatives were used. In this way, the formation of phenothiazines, phenoxazines, and phenazines was achieved in aqueous solution mediated by the laccase of Pycnoporus cinnabarinus in the presence of oxygen. Two types of phenothiazines (3-hydroxy- and 3-oxo-phenothiazines) formed in one reaction assay were described for the first time. The cyclization reactions yielded C-N, C-S, or C-O bonds. The syntheses were investigated with regard to the substitution pattern of the reaction partners. Differences in C-S and C-N bond formations without cyclization are discussed.
The green and environmentally friendly synthesis of highly valuable organic substances is one possibility for the utilization of laccases (EC 1.10.3.2). As reactants for the herein described syntheses, different o-substituted arylamines or arylthiols and 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid and its derivatives were used. In this way, the formation of phenothiazines, phenoxazines, and phenazines was achieved in aqueous solution mediated by the laccase of Pycnoporus cinnabarinus in the presence of oxygen. Two types of phenothiazines (3-hydroxy- and 3-oxo-phenothiazines) formed in one reaction assay were described for the first time. The cyclization reactions yielded C-N, C-S, or C-O bonds. The syntheses were investigated with regard to the substitution pattern of the reaction partners. Differences in C-S and C-N bond formations without cyclization are discussed.
Laccases (EC 1.10.3.2, benzenediol/dioxygen oxidoreductase) are
of general interest for biotechnological applications. The enzyme-mediated
oxidations demand only atmosphericoxygen and no depletive cofactors
such as NADPH. Laccases oxidize substrates by one-electron reactions
via four copper atoms, which are situated in the catalyticcenter.[1−4] The enzyme can oxidize a broad range of substrates such as phenols,
thiols, or amines.[5−11] The laccase-mediated oxidations result in the formation of radicals
that can undergo three different reaction mechanisms. The first mechanism
involves the cleavage, while the second and third mechanisms involve
coupling/bond formation. The oxidized laccase substrate can react
with molecules of the same kind (homomolecular reaction) or with other
radicals or molecules, which can be either laccase substrates or nonlaccase
substrates (heteromolecular reaction).[9,12] The homomolecular
reaction may result in the formation of C–C,[13−15] C=C,[16,17] C–O,[18,19] N=N,[12] or S–S bonds.[10,11] The heteromolecular
reaction allows the combination of compounds via C–C,[20,21] C=C,[17] C–O,[22] C–N,[23−35] C=N,[17,23,25] or C–S.[7,11,16,36] The bond formations result in the synthesis
of di-, tri-, and polymers whereby novel ring-closure mechanisms forming
cyclic products are also possible but less explored.[7,37−39] These reactions are the basis for the derivatization
of biologically active substances such as catechin,[40] mithramycin,[21] pyrimidines,[41] epinephrine (adrenaline),[39] azoles,[33,42] penicillins, and cephalosporins.[27,31]Other important targets for laccase-mediated reactions are phenothiazines,
phenoxazines, and phenazines. Phenothiazines such as chlorpromazine
are widely used in medicine as neuroleptics.[43] Phenothiazines, phenoxazines, and phenazines have anticancer[44−46] and antimicrobial[47−49] activities. In addition, phenothiazines have been
reported to possess multidrug resistance reverting activity.[50,51] Phenothiazines are also part of dyes such as methylene blue or act
as electron donors in photovoltaiccells.[52,53] Phenoxazinones and phenazinescan also be used in optoelectronics
such as in organic light-emitting diodes.[54,55] Chemical methods to synthesize phenothiazinescomprise catalyses
with transition metals such as copper iodide, iron salt, or palladium
in organic solvents and in part at elevated temperatures above 90
°C.[56−59] Alternatively, KI or Cs2CO3 in organic solvents
can be used.[60,61] The phenothiazinescan be oxidized
to the respective phenothiazinones, e.g., by K2Cr2O7 or Na2Cr2O7 in boiling
acetic acid.[62] Other biologically active
heterocycles such as benzoxazepinescan be synthesized in organic
solvents at a temperature of 100 °C.[63] The successful laccase-mediated synthesis of different substance
classes (including in part also isomer formation) in comparison with
traditional organic reactions catalyzed by oxidants such as silver
oxide, sodium iodate, or manganese dioxide was described previously.[24,64−68] This recommends the laccase for various industrial applications.[69,70]The utilization of mild and environmentally friendly reaction conditions
such as room temperature, atmospheric pressure, and the avoidance
of organic solvents makes the laccase-mediated reaction a valuable
tool in green chemistry for the synthesis of novel organiccompounds
as fine chemicals.The literature of laccase-mediated syntheses is mainly focused
on Michael addition reactions. Thus, the reaction of substituted hydroquinones
and amines results in mono- or diaminated quinones[24,25,32,67] or quinonimines.[25,71] The formation of cyclic products may be a cascade reaction involving
also Michael addition with subsequent 1,2-addition or addition–elimination
reaction. After 1,2-addition, also spiro-cyclization or rearomatization
is conceivable.[37] Other reactions involve
further laccase-mediated oxidations, additional Michael additions,
or 1,3-additions.[39,41]The introduction of newly synthesized substances that were formed
during ring-closure mechanisms is a further possibility to broaden
the application field for laccase-mediated reactions. Thus, we derivatized
substituted para-hydroquinones using the laccase-mediated
reaction with thiols and amines. The formed products were different
homo- and heteromolecular products. The cyclization reactions resulted
in the synthesis of phenothiazines, phenoxazines, or phenazines.Phenoxazines and phenazines are, in contrast to phenothiazines,
naturally occurring substances. Thus, fungi of the genus Pycnoporus produce orange-red pigments of the phenoxazinone type such as cinnabarin,
tramesanguin, or cinnabarinic acid in the fruiting bodies.[72,73] Phenoxazinescan be synthesized by heating 2-aminophenol and 2-aminophenol
hydrochloride in an equimolar mixture.[74] Other methods comprise, e.g., potassium or cesium carbonate with
copper in organic solvents.[75,76] The phenazinepyocyanin
is one of the pigments that is produced by most of the strains of
the pathogenic bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa.[77] The chemical production of phenazines
may be accomplished, among others, by the Wohl–Aue reaction,
which includes heating upon 200 °C, or the Beirut reaction. Transition
metals may be used as catalysts similar to the syntheses of phenothiazines
and phenoxazines (for reviews, see Laursen and Nielsen[78] or Chaudhary and Khurana[79]).We developed a one-pot reaction with a nonstoichiometric and environmentally
friendly catalyst, which can be performed in an aqueous solution (with
less than 5% methanol, which can be easily replaced by solvents such
as ethanol[80] due to similar characteristics)
at room temperature. The reactions were performed in the presence
of oxygen, at atmospheric pressure, and at a moderate pH value (pH
5). These characteristics of the introduced laccase-mediated reactions
are valuable for the green synthesis of cyclic products as well as
dimers and trimers. The use of reaction partners with amino, hydroxyl,
and/or thiol groups presented the possibility to form new heterocycles
bio-enzymatically.
Results
General Observations
The thiols and amines used in
this study consist of a benzene ring with two functional groups in ortho-position to each other. The compounds contain a thiol
group and/or amino group. Hydroxyl, amino, methyl, or nitro groups
can be second substituents. The thiols and amines were incubated with
2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid or with one of its derivatives and the laccase
of Pycnoporus cinnabarinus. Oxidative
C–N bond formation followed by cyclization was the predominant
reaction, resulting in phenothiazines, phenoxazines, and phenazines.All reactions were performed with 0.5 U laccase of P. cinnabarinus as the catalyst in sodium acetate
buffer (pH 5) at room temperature with a reactant concentration of
1 mM. The reactions were analyzed in the course of an incubation time
of 24 h.
Reactions of 2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic Acid and Its Derivatives
The laccase-mediated reactions of 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid
(1a), 2,5-dihydroxy-N-(2-hydroxyethyl)benzamide
(1b), and 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid methylester (1c) may result in the formation of the respective benzoquinone
and/or a radical (2, Scheme ).[81] These intermediates
can be attacked by water or solvents such as methanol, resulting in
hydroxylated and methoxylated benzoquinonoid products.[81,82] These side reactions may diminish the yield of products formed with
additional coupling partners such as thiols and amines.
Scheme 1
Laccase-Catalyzed Reaction of 2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic Acid Derivatives 1a–1c for the Synthesis of the Respective
Benzoquinone (2) Using 0.5 U Laccase of P. cinnabarinus as the Catalyst in Sodium Acetate
Buffer (pH 5; Reactant Concentration, 1 mM)
Under the chosen reaction conditions, none of these products were
formed in controls (without laccase).
Reactions of 2-Aminothiophenol with 2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic
Acid
The reactions of 1a–1c with 2-aminothiophenol (3a) resulted in laccase-mediated
formation of adducts (4a–4c) and
phenothiazines (5a–5c, Scheme and Table ). The yields of the phenothiazines ranged
from 5% (5c) to 29% (5b).
Scheme 2
Laccase-Catalyzed Reaction of 2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic Acid Derivatives 1a–1c with 2-Aminothiophenol 3a for the Synthesis of Adducts 4a–4c and the Cyclization Products 4a-Hydroxy-2-oxo-phenothiazines 5a–5c using 0.5 U Laccase of P. cinnabarinus as the Catalyst in Sodium Acetate
Buffer (pH 5; Reactant Concentration, 1 mM)
Table 1
Reactions of 1a–1c with 3a and Formed Products Using 0.5 U Laccase
of P. cinnabarinus as the Catalyst
in Sodium Acetate Buffer (pH 5) within an Incubation Time of 24 h
(Reactant Concentration, 1 mM)
reactant 1
R1
reactant 3
product
yielda
1a
OH
3a
4a
-
5a
-
7a
-
9a
-
10a
-
1b
NHC2H4OH
3a
4b
5b
29%
7b
-
9b
6%
10b
1c
OCH3
3a
4c
-
5c
5%
7c, 8c
-, 5%
9c
-
10c
-, not determined; no isolation
of products was performed.
-, not determined; no isolation
of products was performed.Under the chosen reaction conditions, none of these products were
formed in controls (without laccase).The products 4a–4c were not stable
and cannot be isolated under the used conditions. Nevertheless, the
recorded mass spectra of the reaction assays allowed the identification
of the products (Figures S6, S8, S10, S12, Supporting Information).The incubation of 3a resulted in the formation of
a disulfide (6, Scheme ).
Scheme 3
Laccase-Catalyzed or Autocatalytic Reaction of 2-Aminothiophenol
(3a) for the Synthesis of the Disulfide 6 Using 0.5 U Laccase of P. cinnabarinus as the Catalyst in Sodium Acetate Buffer (pH 5; Reactant Concentration,
1 mM)
Retention time, UV–vis maxima, and LC/MS analyses in comparison
with the commercially available reference 2-aminophenyl disulfideconfirmed the proposed dimeric structure for 6 (Table S1, Supporting Information for product
6: Rf (HPLC) 11.54 min; UV−vis (MeOH) λmax 215, 334 nm; LC/MS m/z (rel. intensity)
AP-ESI pos. mode [M + H]+ 249.0 (100); Table S2, Supporting Information for reference 2-aminophenyl
disulfide: Rf (HPLC) 12.02 min, UV−vis (MeOH) λmax 218, 335 nm; LC/MS m/z (rel. intensity)
AP-ESI pos. mode [M + H]+ 249.0 (100)). The two molecules
of 3a are connected via a S–S bond.The laccase-mediated reaction of 1a–1c and 6 resulted in the formation of 7a–7c (Scheme ).
Scheme 4
Laccase-Catalyzed Reaction of 2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic Acid Derivatives 1a–1c with 2-Aminothiophenol 3a for the Synthesis of Adducts 7a–7c and 8c Using 0.5 U Laccase of P. cinnabarinus as the Catalyst in Sodium Acetate Buffer (pH 5; Reactant Concentration,
1 mM)
Products 7a–7c were not stable
and cannot be isolated under the used conditions. Nevertheless, the
recorded mass spectra of the reaction assays allowed the identification
of the products (Figures S33, S35, S37, S39, S40 and Tables S11–S14, Supporting Information). In addition,
the NMR data of 8c in the mixture with 5c support the structure of [2-[(2-aminophenyl)disulfanyl]anilino]-3,6-dihydroxy-benzoic
acid.The reactions of 1b and 3a or 2-aminophenyl
disulfide (reference for product 6) were chosen to determine
the laccase-mediated reaction in more detail: The reaction of 1b and 3a resulted in the formation of 6, 4b, 5b, and 7b.
The amount of product 5b increased with concomitant decrease
of products 4b and 7b (Figure ). Products 4b and 7b peaked after 20 and 10 min, respectively, and
decreased afterward, whereas the product 5b was detected
after 20 min and increased rapidly up to 100 min. Afterward, 5b was stable within 24 h (data not shown).
Figure 1
Reaction course of product formation for 4b (cross), 5b (filled triangle), and 7b (open circle) at
equimolar concentrations (1 mM) of reactants 2,5-dihydroxy-N-(2-hydroxyethyl)benzamide (1b) and 2-aminothiophenol
(3a) using 0.5 U laccase of P. cinnabarinus as the catalyst in sodium acetate buffer (pH 5; reactant concentration,
1 mM).
Reaction course of product formation for 4b (cross), 5b (filled triangle), and 7b (open circle) at
equimolar concentrations (1 mM) of reactants 2,5-dihydroxy-N-(2-hydroxyethyl)benzamide (1b) and 2-aminothiophenol
(3a) using 0.5 U laccase of P. cinnabarinus as the catalyst in sodium acetate buffer (pH 5; reactant concentration,
1 mM).This supports the assumption that products 4b and/or 7b are possible reactants for the formation of 5b (Scheme ).
Scheme 5
Laccase-Catalyzed Reactions of 2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic Acid Derivatives 1a–1c with 2-Aminothiophenol 3a, with Its Dimer 6 or with the Commercially Available
Reference 2-Aminophenyl Disulfide (6(ref)) for the Synthesis
of Adducts 4a–4c and 7a–7c and the Cyclization Products 4a-Hydroxy-2-oxo-phenothiazines 5a–5c Using 0.5 U Laccase of P. cinnabarinus as the Catalyst in Sodium Acetate
Buffer (pH 5; Reactant Concentration, 1 mM)
The laccase-mediated reaction of 1b with 2-aminophenyl
disulfide (reference for product 6) resulted also in
the formation of products 4b, 5b, and 7b in similar product yields. The formation of products 4b and 5b require the cleavage of 2-aminophenyl
disulfide or the 2-aminophenyl disulfide part in 7b (Scheme ), but no 3a was detected in the homomolecular reaction of 2-aminophenyl disulfide.
Nevertheless, in the heteromolecular reactions of 1b with 3a or 1b and 2-aminophenyl disulfide, a product
with a retention time of 5.57 min was detected, which possessed a
similar UV–vis spectrum as 3a. Additionally, the
retention time of the product was only 1 min later compared with 3a (Rf (HPLC) 4.59 min). The concurrent
formation of this product with the increase of product 5b may explain the synthesis of 4b and 5b in the reaction of 1b and 2-aminophenyl disulfide.The disulfide 6 was detected in the reactions without
addition of laccase but none of the further formed heteromolecular
products.A parallel pathway can be hypothesized for the reaction of 1a–1c with 3a because of
the additional formation of products 9a–9c and 10a–10c (in parallel
to products 4, 5, 7, and 8). For the formation of products 9 and 10, the amino group of 3a reacted with the C-2
atom of the aromatic ring of 1a–1c followed by a ring closure via the thiol group on the C-3 atom of
the aromatic ring of 1a–1c. In contrast
to that reaction, the formation of products 4, 5, 7, and 8 started with an attack
of the amino group of 3a at the C-6 atom of the aromatic
ring of 1a–1c. The attack at the
C-6 atom of 1a–1c resulted in the
formation of adducts 4a–4c, 7a–7c, and 8c and the cyclization
products 4a-hydroxy-2-oxo-phenothiazines 5a–5c, whereas the attack at the C-2 atom of 1a–1c resulted in the formation of 3-hydroxy-phenothiazines 9a–9c. The product 9b was
not detected in the reaction of 1b and 2-aminophenyl
disulfide (6(ref)).In the course of the LC/MS analyses, phenothiazines 9a–9c and 10a–10c were detected (Scheme ).
Scheme 6
Laccase-Catalyzed Reaction of 2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic Acid Derivatives 1a–1c and 2-Aminothiophenol 3a for the Synthesis of 3-Hydroxy-10H-phenothiazines 9a–9c and 3-Oxo-phenothiazines 10a–10c Using 0.5 U Laccase of P.
cinnabarinus as the Catalyst in Sodium Acetate Buffer
(pH 5; Reactant Concentration, 1 mM)
The LC/MS spectra contain both masses for 3-oxo-phenothiazines
and 3-hydroxy-10H-phenothiazines (such as for 9b: m/z (rel. intensity)
AP-ESI pos. mode [M + H]+, 303.0 (5); for 10b: m/z (rel. intensity) AP-ESI pos.
mode [M + H]+, 301.0 (100); Figure S44 and Table S16) but in very low intensity for 3-hydroxy-phenothiazines
(9a–9c).The NMR data of 9b clearly identify this product as
3-hydroxy-N-(2-hydroxyethyl)-10H-phenothiazine-1-carboxamide (Figures S44-S48 and Table S16), which may be easily transformed via oxidation
to the respective 3-oxo-phenothiazine.
Reactions of 2-Aminophenol or ortho-Phenylenediamine
with 2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic Acid Derivatives
In the laccase-catalyzed
reaction of 1a–1c and 2-aminophenol
(3b), the phenoxazines (11a–11c) were formed (Scheme and Table ). At first, amination in the ortho-position
to the side chain—in the case of the product 11b in the ortho-position of the amide group—took
place with subsequent bond formation between the hydroxyl group of 3b and C-5 of the aromatic ring.
Scheme 7
Laccase-Catalyzed Reaction of 2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic Acid Derivatives 1a–1c and 2-Aminophenol 3b for the Synthesis of Phenoxazines 11a–11c Using 0.5 U Laccase of P. cinnabarinus as the Catalyst in Sodium Acetate Buffer (pH 5; Reactant Concentration,
1 mM)
Table 2
Reactions of 1a–1c with 3b–3f and Formed
Products Using 0.5 U Laccase of P. cinnabarinus as the Catalyst in Sodium Acetate Buffer (pH 5) within an Incubation
Time of 24 h (Reactant Concentration, 1 mM)
reactant 1
R1
reactant 3
product
yielda
1a
OH
3b
11a
-
3c
12a
-
1b
NHC2H4OH
3b
11b
8%
3c
12b
71%
3d
13a
15%
14a
15%
15a
-
3e
13b
16%
14b
15b
-
3f
13c
-
15c
-
1c
OCH3
3b
11c
-
3c
12c
7%
-, not determined; no isolation
of products was performed.
-, not determined; no isolation
of products was performed.The reactions of 1a–1c and ortho-phenylenediamine (3c) resulted in the
formation of phenazines (12a–12c; Scheme ) due to the two
neighboring amino groups of 3c. The reaction of 3c and 1b resulted in almost one heteromolecular
product, whereas for the reaction with 1c, at least two
main products were detected. This may explain the small yield of 12c in comparison with 12b. (We were unable to
isolate the second product of the reaction of 3c with 1c.)
Scheme 8
Laccase-Catalyzed Reaction of 2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic Acid Derivatives 1a–1c and ortho-Phenylenediamine 3c for the Synthesis of Phenazines 12a–12c Using 0.5 U Laccase of P. cinnabarinus as the Catalyst in Sodium Acetate Buffer (pH 5; Reactant Concentration,
1 mM)
In the course of the reactions of 3b or 3c with a second reactant and laccase, for 3b and 3c, also ring-closure mechanisms were detected. These reactions
resulted in phenazines and phenoxazinones that were not further characterized
due to only limited influence on the product formation with 1a–1c. Such phenazines and phenoxazinones
formed from ortho-diamines and ortho-aminophenols with laccase were also described previously.[83,84]
Reactions of 2-Methylaniline, 2-Nitroaniline, or 2-Methylbenzenethiol
with 2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic Acid Derivatives
Although all laccase-mediated
reactions of 3a–3c resulted in the
formation of cyclic products, we determined no cyclization between
2-methylaniline (3d), 2-nitroaniline (3e), or 2-methylbenzenethiol (3f) and 1b,
respectively. In these reactions, different adducts were detected
(Scheme ). The adduct
of the reaction of 1b and 3d was isolated
as a mixture of the quinonoid (13a) and hydroquinonoid
(14a) forms, which were also described previously for
the reaction with 2-aminobenzoic acid.[37] Similarly, 14b was described by NMR analyses, whereas 13b was only detected by LC/MS. For the formation of 13c–15c, a C–S bond was assumed.
Scheme 9
Laccase-Catalyzed Reaction of 2,5-Dihydroxy-N-(2-hydroxyethyl)benzamide 1b and 2-Methylaniline 3d, 2-Nitroaniline 3e, or 2-Methylbenzenethiol 3f for the Synthesis
of Quinonoid 13a–13c or Hydroquinonoid 14a and 14b and Adducts 15a–15c Using 0.5 U Laccase of P. cinnabarinus as the Catalyst in Sodium Acetate Buffer (pH 5; Reactant Concentration,
1 mM)
Detailed Structural Characterization of Products
The
various cyclic products possessed different UV–vis spectra.
The phenothiazines (5a–5c) and phenoxazines
(11a–11c) had an orange-brown color,
whereas the phenazines (12a–12c)
were red or yellow. The phenothiazine 9/10b was violet.
Phenothiazines 5a–5c were characterized
by three maxima under 300 nm and one intense maximum around 390 nm,
whereas phenothiazines 9/10a–10c had
an intense maximum around 240 nm, two to three maxima under 400 nm,
and another one around 500 nm. The phenoxazines (11a–11c) had two maxima under 300 nm and one intense maximum around
380 nm. The phenazines (12a–12c)
possessed one intense maximum around 250 nm and two maxima above 360
nm, which is in line with the literature.[77]In the laccase-mediated reaction of 1b and 3a, the phenothiazine 5b was isolated for mass
spectroscopy (LC/MS m/z AP-ESI pos.
mode [M + H]+, 319.0 (100); neg. mode [M – H]−, 316.9 (100)). These mass data can be attributed to
the amination of 3a on the quinonoid form of 1b and cyclization via the thiol group of 3a on the carbonyl
group of the quinone (C-5 in the reactant and C-4a in the product),
resulting in a six-membered nonaromatic ring. The NMR analyses confirmed
the formation of two bonds between 1b and 3a (Figure ).
Figure 2
Product 5b: (A) HMBC spectrum of product 5b with HMBC correlation numbers: red, correlations that confirm the
novel structure; blue, correlations that are similar to that of the
parent compounds. (B) Numbering of C-atoms. (C) 1H (blue)
and 13C (red) assignments (chemical shifts are expressed
in d (ppm) calibrated on the resonances of the residual
nondeuterated solvent DMSO) and multiplicity of the 1H
signals and J values (black). J values
are in Hz. (D) HMBC correlations (H → C): red, correlations
that confirm the novel structure; blue, correlations that are similar
to that of the parent compounds.
Product 5b: (A) HMBC spectrum of product 5b with HMBCcorrelation numbers: red, correlations that confirm the
novel structure; blue, correlations that are similar to that of the
parent compounds. (B) Numbering of C-atoms. (C) 1H (blue)
and 13C (red) assignments (chemical shifts are expressed
in d (ppm) calibrated on the resonances of the residual
nondeuterated solvent DMSO) and multiplicity of the 1H
signals and J values (black). J values
are in Hz. (D) HMBCcorrelations (H → C): red, correlations
that confirm the novel structure; blue, correlations that are similar
to that of the parent compounds.Multiplicity of H-4 and H-3 suggested that the amination step took
place at C-10a. The HMBCcorrelations (Figure ) of the proton H-10 unambiguously identified
this amination at C-10a. A signal for the hydroxyl group at C-4a (7.53
ppm) was observed. This signal of 5b was a broad signal
without any HMBCcorrelations, but this signal of 5c (7.50
ppm) showed HMBCcorrelations to C-4a (69.7 ppm) and C-10a (154.6
ppm), supporting the concept of cyclization of the thiol group at
C-4a and the removal of the para-quinonoidcharacter.
The chemical shift to a higher field (69.6 ppm) of the C-4a of 5b resulted in the assumption of a nonaromatic, noncarbonyl
carbon atom. Additionally, 13CNMR showed only one typical
signal for quinones in the range of 180 ppm, indicating only one quinonoidcarbonyl group for 5b. The chemical shifts within the
transformed structure of 1b and 1c are similar
to previously described structures.[37] The
analyses and the comparison led to the identification of 5b as 4a-hydroxy-N-(2-hydroxyethyl)-2-oxo-10H-phenothiazine-1-carboxamid.Products 9b and 10b could only be isolated
as a mixture with MS data AP-ESI in positive mode for the oxo structure
and with NMR data for the hydroxyl structure. The molecular mass of
300 was attributed to the amination of 3a on the quinonoid
form of 1b and cyclization via the thiol group of 3a, resulting in 10b. The postulated product
structure of 9b was confirmed by NMR. 1HNMR
spectral data of 9b showed characteristic signals for
both reactants (Figure ). Multiplicity of H-2 and H-4 suggested that the amination step
took place at C-10a. The HMBCcorrelations (Figure ) of the proton H-10 clearly confirmed this
amination at C-10a. The HMBC spectrum showed also correlations between
protons H-2 and H-4 and the aminated C-10a atom in the typical range
of 130–150 ppm and between protons H-2 and H-4 and the hydroxylated
C-3 atom (152.4 ppm), unambiguously showing 9b to be
a nonquinonoid aminated and hydroxylated structure substituted at
C-10a and C-4a. All MS and NMR results led to the identification of 10b as N-(2-hydroxyethyl)-3-oxo-phenothiazine-1-carboxamide
and 9b as 3-hydroxy-N-(2-hydroxyethyl)-10H-phenothiazine-1-carboxamide.
Figure 3
Product 9b: (A) HMBC spectrum of product 9b with HMBC correlation numbers: red, correlations that confirm the
novel structure; blue, correlations that are similar to that of the
parent compounds. (B) Numbering of C-atoms. (C) 1H (blue)
and 13C (red) assignments (chemical shifts are expressed
in d (ppm) calibrated on the resonances of the residual
nondeuterated solvent DMSO) and multiplicity of the 1H
signals and J values (black). J values
are in Hz. (D) HMBC correlations (H → C): red, correlations
that confirm the novel structure; blue, correlations that are similar
to that of the parent compounds.
Product 9b: (A) HMBC spectrum of product 9b with HMBCcorrelation numbers: red, correlations that confirm the
novel structure; blue, correlations that are similar to that of the
parent compounds. (B) Numbering of C-atoms. (C) 1H (blue)
and 13C (red) assignments (chemical shifts are expressed
in d (ppm) calibrated on the resonances of the residual
nondeuterated solvent DMSO) and multiplicity of the 1H
signals and J values (black). J values
are in Hz. (D) HMBCcorrelations (H → C): red, correlations
that confirm the novel structure; blue, correlations that are similar
to that of the parent compounds.In the laccase-mediated reaction of 1b and 3b, the phenoxazine 11b was isolated. The mass spectroscopy
data (LC/MS m/z AP-ESI pos. mode
[M + H]+, 303.0 (100)) confirmed the formation of an adduct
similar to that described above for 5b. The mass data
can also be attributed to amination of 3b on the quinonoid
form of 1b, but the cyclization took place via the hydroxyl
group of 3b, yielding 11b. The carbonyl
group (C-4a) of the quinone intermediate of 1b is the
C-atom for cyclization for both 5b and 11b, resulting in six-membered nonaromatic rings with an ether bridge
in the structure of 11b but with a thioether bridge for 5b. The NMR analyses of 11b also confirmed the
formation of two bonds between 1b and 3b (Figure ) as described
for 5b. The HMBCcorrelations (Figure ) of the proton H-10 also supported the amination
at C-10a for 11b. The signal for the hydroxyl group at
C-4a (8.20 ppm) showed HMBCcorrelations to C-4a (86.8 ppm), C-4 (137.5
ppm), and C-10a (156.1 ppm) and 1H-1HCOSY correlations
to H-3 (6.22 ppm), H-4 (6.92 ppm), and H-9 (7.43 ppm), supporting
the concept of cyclization of the hydroxyl group of 3b at C-4a and the removal of the para-quinonoidcharacter.
The chemical shift to a higher field (86.8 ppm) of the C-4a of 11b resulted also in the assumption of a nonaromatic, noncarbonyl
carbon atom. Additionally, as described for 5b, 13CNMR showed only one typical signal for quinones at 180
ppm, indicating only one quinonoidcarbonyl group and the structure
of 4a-hydroxy-N-(2-hydroxyethyl)-2-oxo-10H-phenoxazine-1-carboxamid for 11b.
Figure 4
Product 11b: (A) HMBC spectrum of product 11b with HMBC correlation numbers: red, correlations that confirm the
novel structure; blue, correlations that are similar to that of the
parent compounds. (B) Numbering of C-atoms. (C) 1H (blue)
and 13C (red) assignments (chemical shifts are expressed
in d (ppm) calibrated on the resonances of the residual
nondeuterated solvent DMSO) and multiplicity of the 1H
signals and J values (black). J values
are in Hz. (D) HMBC correlations (H → C): red, correlations
that confirm the novel structure; blue, correlations that are similar
to that of the parent compounds.
Product 11b: (A) HMBC spectrum of product 11b with HMBCcorrelation numbers: red, correlations that confirm the
novel structure; blue, correlations that are similar to that of the
parent compounds. (B) Numbering of C-atoms. (C) 1H (blue)
and 13C (red) assignments (chemical shifts are expressed
in d (ppm) calibrated on the resonances of the residual
nondeuterated solvent DMSO) and multiplicity of the 1H
signals and J values (black). J values
are in Hz. (D) HMBCcorrelations (H → C): red, correlations
that confirm the novel structure; blue, correlations that are similar
to that of the parent compounds.
Discussion
The structural characterization of the products by MS and NMR analyses
together with UV–vis data led to the description of cyclic
products as well as different additional products (Scheme ). The type of product was
dependent on the coupling partners and the amount of reactive groups.
Thus, the homomolecular reaction of 3a resulted in the
formation of a disulfide (6). Heteromolecular products 4a–4c and disulfides 7a–7c and 8c were formed in the reactions of 3a with 1a–1c, whereby the
disulfide 6 is part of adducts 7a–7c and 8c. The reactions of 1a–1c and coupling partners with one amino group and an adjacent
thiol group (3a) or, instead, a hydroxyl group (3b) as well as substances with two amino groups (3c) resulted in cyclic products such as phenothiazines (5a–5c and 9/10a–10c), phenoxazines (11a–11c), or phenazines
(12a–12c). Compounds with only one
reactive group (3d–3f) for the laccase-mediated
heteromolecular coupling resulted in quinonoid (13a−13c, and 15a−15c) and hydroquinonoid
(14a, 14b) products. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first description of cyclic products 5a–5c and 9/10a–10c for laccase-mediated reactions.
Scheme 10
Possible Reaction Mechanisms
All heteromolecular reactions started with the laccase-mediated
oxidation of the respective 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid derivative,
which resulted in the formation of quinonoid derivatives (2).Two reaction pathways for the formation of different phenothiazines
were described. The main pathway for products 5a–5ccomprised the intermolecular Michael addition (1,4-addition)
of 3a via the amino group on the quinonoid derivative 2 of 1a–1c. After the second
oxidation, the heteromolecular products (4a–4c) were formed, which undergo intramolecular 1,2-addition.
Similar reactions were described previously for 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic
acid derivatives and five- or six-membered aminescontaining an amino
group and carboxamide group.[37] The key
difference of the present research results is that C–S and
C–N bonds were formed within one single product, whereas the
bond formation of C–O and C–N bonds has been described
until now. Another possibility is the dimerization of 3a, which is the prerequisite for the reaction with 1a–1c forming the disulfides 7a–7c, which may react to the phenothiazines (5a–5c) or additional products (4a–4c). In this case, a laccase-mediated bond cleavage may be
conceivable, similar to the previously described cleavage processes
for amino compounds.[12] The second pathway
for phenothiazine synthesis (9a–9c and 10a–10c) started with amination
of 3a on the C-2 atom of the aromatic ring of 1a–1c with subsequent C–S bond formation
via the thiol group and the aromatic ring of 1a–1c. But we were unable to rule out the possibility that the
thiolation on the C-3 atom of the aromatic ring of 1a−1c took place first and afterward the amination.
However, compared to all of our previous described reaction pattern,
this is the first time that we detected bond formations on C-2 and
C-3 atoms of the laccase substrate 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid and its
derivatives (1a–1c). A plausible
explanation is based on the different nature of the thiol group compared
to the amino and hydroxyl groups.However, it must be taken into account that the p-hydroquinone substrates are very different from 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic
acid and its derivatives. Thus, a similar pathway was described for
the laccase-mediated reactions of p-hydroquinone
or its derivatives with 5-substituted-4-amino-3-mercapto-1,2,4-triazoles
or 2-amino-thiophenol described by Bhalerao et al.[7] and Cannatelli and Ragauskas,[10] respectively. In the case of 9a–9c and 10a–10c, the reaction of the
thiol group of the reaction partner took place on the carbonyl group
of the quinonoid form of 1a–1c and
the reaction of the amino group on the adjacent unsubstituted CH group,
whereas Cannatelli and Ragauskas[10] described
the reaction of the amino group on the carbonyl group of the quinonoid
form of the laccase substrates and the reaction of the thiol group
on the adjacent unsubstituted CH group.The authors proposed an addition–reaction of the amino group
with the C-atom at the carbonyl group of the quinone, resulting in
a quinonimine, with subsequent reaction of the thiol group with the
adjacent C-atom of the benzene ring. Bhalerao et al.[7] described the reaction of p-hydroquinone
with 5-substituted-4-amino-3-mercapto-1,2,4-triazoles. The coupling
partners were connected via C–S and C=N bonds in the
formed benzothiadiazinones. Again, a quinonimine was formed due to
the reaction of the amino group with the C-atom at the keto group
of the quinone.Bhalerao et al.[7] as well as Cannatelli
and Ragauskas[10] used p-hydroquinone or its derivatives. This may explain the different
reaction pathway for the herein used 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid derivatives.The formation of products 7a–7c was supported by the NMR analyses of 5c. The disulfide
(6) of 3a was described previously by Cannatelli
and Ragauskas.[10] For laccase-mediated reactions,
disulfides 7a–7c are unusual. In
most cases, the reaction of two amino compounds with dihydroxybenzoic
acid derivatives proceeded via two C–N bonds in the para-position.[32] The UV–vis
spectra of products 7a–7c (7a: 210, 455 nm; 7b: 209, 492 nm; 7c: 210, 473 nm) resembled more monoaminated quinonamines with at least
one absorption spectrum under 300 nm and one around 500 nm than diaminated
quinonamines with at least two maxima under 400 nm.[12,25,85] These absorption maxima were not only in
line with those for the mono- and diaminated products (13a, 13b, and 15a, 15b) but also
those for the monothiolated product 13c and dithiolated
product 15c. These products were formed by nucleophilic
addition of one or two molecules of 3f with 1b, forming C–S bonds. In this case, the thiol groups and not
the amino groups (as for 13a, 13b, 15a, and 15b) were the donors in the Michael
addition.[86] The reaction of para-hydroquinones and thiols resulting in different adducts was described
previously.[11,36,87] Cyclization involving two SH groups, which resulted in 2,3-ethylenedithio-1,4-quinones
with yields of 37–74%, was also described.[38]In summary, the cyclic products described in our study were isolated
with yields of 4% up to 68%. This confirms the complexity, in comparison
to the so-called “easy” and “straightforward”
laccase-catalyzed reactions of 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid derivatives
and reaction partners with only one amino group,[24,26−29] of such cyclization reactions accompanied by simultaneous formation
of homomolecular products of the amines and by-products, which diminished
the yields. Further studies will lead to strategies for a higher product
yield through variations of reaction parameters such as the kind of
laccase, pH value of the reaction assay, or concentration of reactants.
Conclusions
The introduced one-pot laccase-mediated reactions of cyclic products
as well as additional products are consistent with the principles
of green chemistry defined by Anastas and Warner.[88] The utilization of laccases as nonstoichiometriccatalysts
in an aqueous solution with less than 5% solvent (which is only necessary
for the solubilization of the reagents and can be replaced in most
cases by water) and the room temperature make this process an attractive
alternative to chemical syntheses.
Experimental Section
Enzymes
The used laccase was obtained from P. cinnabarinus SBUG-M 1044. The white rot fungus
was isolated from an oak tree in northern Germany and is deposited
at the strain collection of the Department of Biology of the University
of Greifswald (SBUG).Cultivation of P. cinnabarinus SBUG-M 1044 and crude preparation of laccase were carried out as
we reported previously.[19] This enzyme preparation
contains only isoenzymes of laccase but no other enzymes and was used
always in 20 mM sodium acetate buffer (SAB; pH 5) because of the pH
optimum around pH 5.[19,89]
Measurement of Laccase Activity
The activity of laccase
was determined spectrophotometrically at 420 nm with ABTS (2,2′-azino-bis(3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-sulfonic
acid) diammonium salt) as the substrate[90] using the method described by Jonas et al.[19] One unit (1 U) is defined as 1 μmol·mL–1·min–1.
Experimental Procedures
Analytical Procedure
For analytical experiments, amines,
thiols (1 mM), and the respective dihydroxylated compound (1 mM) were
incubated with laccase (activity, 0.5 U). Reaction mixtures were incubated
with agitation at 200 rpm at room temperature in the dark. The reaction
mixtures were analyzed by HPLC. The separation of the substances was
achieved with a RP18 column at a flow rate of 1 mL/min. A solvent
system consisting of methanol (eluent A) and 0.1% phosphoric acid
(eluent B), starting from an initial ratio of 10% A and 90% B and
reaching 100% methanol within 14 min, was used. Controls were performed
without the addition of laccase.
Product Isolation
All reaction mixtures for product
isolation were performed with laccase of P. cinnabarinus (final activity, 0.5 U) in SAB. Isolation steps were performed by
solid-phase extraction with a RP18 silica gelcolumn (60 mL, 10 g
of adsorbent material, Phenomenex, Strata, Germany). The product 5b was isolated from the reaction mixture (320 mL) after an
incubation period of 24 h (1b:3a, 1:1 mM
assay). After charging the column with 40 mL of reaction mixture,
20 mL of methanol/distilled water (20:80, v/v) and 40 mL of methanol/distilled
water (40:60, v/v) were used to remove undesired impurities. Elution
of the orange fraction was performed with 30 mL of methanol. The product 5c (mixture with 8c) was isolated from the reaction
mixture (400 mL) after an incubation period of 4.5 h (1c:3a, 1:1 mM assay). After charging the column with 40
mL of reaction mixture, 30 mL of methanol/distilled water (20:80,
v/v) and 30 mL of methanol/distilled water (40:60, v/v) were used
to remove undesired impurities. Elution of the orange fraction was
performed with 30 mL of methanol.The product 9/10b was isolated from the reaction mixture (320 mL) after an incubation
period of 20 min (1b:3a, 1:1 mM assay).
After charging the column with 40 mL of reaction mixture and washing
steps with 20 mL of methanol/distilled water (20:80, v/v) and 40 mL
of methanol/distilled water (50:50, v/v), the product was eluted with
20 mL of methanol/distilled water (50:50 v/v). The product 11b was isolated from the reaction mixture (280 mL) after an incubation
period of 4 h (1b:3b, 1:1 mM assay). After
charging the column with 40 mL of reaction mixture, 40 mL of methanol/distilled
water (40:60, v/v), 15 mL of methanol/ distilled water (60:40, v/v),
and 5 mL of methanol/distilled water (80:20, v/v) were used to remove
undesired impurities. The product was eluted with additional 10 mL
of methanol/distilled water (80:20, v/v). The product 12b was isolated from the reaction mixture (240 mL) after an incubation
period of 20 min (1b:3c, 1:1 mM assay).
After charging the column with 40 mL of reaction mixture, 20 mL of
methanol/distilled water (20:80, v/v) and 50 mL of methanol/distilled
water (60:40, v/v) were used to remove undesired impurities. The product
was eluted with 25 mL of methanol. The product 12c was
isolated from the reaction mixture (520 mL) after an incubation period
of 3.5 h (1c:3c, 1:1 mM assay). After charging
the column with 40 mL of reaction mixture, 40 mL of methanol/distilled
water (40:60, v/v), 15 mL of methanol/distilled water (60:40, v/v),
5 mL of methanol/distilled water (80:20, v/v), and 10 mL of methanol/distilled
water (80:20, v/v) were used to remove undesired impurities. The product
was eluted with additional 20 mL of methanol/distilled water (80:20,
v/v). The product 13/14a was isolated from the reaction
mixture (120 mL) after an incubation period of 2 h (1b:3d, 1:1 mM assay). After charging the column with 40
mL of reaction mixture, 20 mL of distilled water, 20 mL of methanol/distilled
water (10:90, v/v), 10 mL of methanol/distilled water (30:70, v/v),
and 20 mL of methanol/distilled water (50:50, v/v) were used to remove
undesired impurities. The product was eluted with additional with
40 mL of methanol (50:50, v/v). The product 13/14b was
isolated from the reaction mixture (160 mL) after an incubation period
of 2 h (1b:3e, 1:1 mM assay). After charging
the column with 40 mL of reaction mixture, 40 mL of methanol/distilled
water (20:80, v/v) was used to remove undesired impurities. The product
was eluted with 50 mL of methanol (50:50, v/v).For nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, the isolated
products were dried by lyophilization. The lyophilized products and
reaction mixtures were characterized using an LC/MS system. The atmospheric
pressure ionization (API) mass spectrometry experiments were performed
on an Agilent Series 1200 HPLC system with a diode array detector
and Agilent 6120 quadrupole mass spectrometer (Waldbronn, Germany).
The high-resolution mass spectra (HRMS) were recorded on a QExactive
classic system (Thermo Scientific, Bremen, Germany).
N-(2-Hydroxyethyl)-2-(2-methylanilino)-3,6-dioxocyclohexa-1,4-diene-1-carboxamide
(13a) and 3,6-Dihydroxy-N-(2-hydroxyethyl)-2-(2-methylanilino)benzamide
(14a)
N-(2-Hydroxyethyl)-2-(2-nitroanilino)-3,6-dioxocyclohexa-1,4-diene-1-carboxamide
(13b) and 3,6-Dihydroxy-N-(2-hydroxyethyl)-2-(2-nitroanilino)benzamide
(14b)