Shuai Li1,2, Minh Bui1, John L Hopper1. 1. Centre for Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Melbourne School of Population and Global Health, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, VIC, Australia. 2. Centre for Cancer Genetic Epidemiology, Department of Public Health and Primary Care, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: We developed a method to make Inference about Causation from Examination of FAmiliaL CONfounding (ICE FALCON) using observational data for related individuals and considering changes in a pair of regression coefficients. ICE FALCON has some similarities to Mendelian randomization (MR) but uses in effect all the familial determinants of the exposure, not just those captured by measured genetic variants, and does not require genetic data nor make strong assumptions. ICE FALCON can assess tracking of a measure over time, an issue often difficult to assess using MR due to lack of a valid instrumental variable. METHODS: We describe ICE FALCON and present two empirical applications with simulations. RESULTS: We found evidence consistent with body mass index (BMI) having a causal effect on DNA methylation at the ABCG1 locus, the same conclusion as from MR analyses but providing about 2.5 times more information per subject. We found evidence that tracking of BMI is consistent with longitudinal causation, as well as familial confounding. The simulations supported the validity of ICE FALCON. CONCLUSIONS: There are conceptual similarities between ICE FALCON and MR, but empirically they are giving similar conclusions with possibly more information per subject from ICE FALCON. ICE FALCON can be applied to circumstances in which MR cannot be applied, such as when there is no a priori genetic knowledge and/or data available to create a valid instrumental variable, or when the assumptions underlying MR analysis are suspect. ICE FALCON could provide insights into causality for a wide range of public health questions.
BACKGROUND: We developed a method to make Inference about Causation from Examination of FAmiliaL CONfounding (ICE FALCON) using observational data for related individuals and considering changes in a pair of regression coefficients. ICE FALCON has some similarities to Mendelian randomization (MR) but uses in effect all the familial determinants of the exposure, not just those captured by measured genetic variants, and does not require genetic data nor make strong assumptions. ICE FALCON can assess tracking of a measure over time, an issue often difficult to assess using MR due to lack of a valid instrumental variable. METHODS: We describe ICE FALCON and present two empirical applications with simulations. RESULTS: We found evidence consistent with body mass index (BMI) having a causal effect on DNA methylation at the ABCG1 locus, the same conclusion as from MR analyses but providing about 2.5 times more information per subject. We found evidence that tracking of BMI is consistent with longitudinal causation, as well as familial confounding. The simulations supported the validity of ICE FALCON. CONCLUSIONS: There are conceptual similarities between ICE FALCON and MR, but empirically they are giving similar conclusions with possibly more information per subject from ICE FALCON. ICE FALCON can be applied to circumstances in which MR cannot be applied, such as when there is no a priori genetic knowledge and/or data available to create a valid instrumental variable, or when the assumptions underlying MR analysis are suspect. ICE FALCON could provide insights into causality for a wide range of public health questions.
Authors: C G Davey; C López-Solà; M Bui; J L Hopper; C Pantelis; L F Fontenelle; B J Harrison Journal: Psychol Med Date: 2016-09-08 Impact factor: 7.723
Authors: John L Hopper; Quang M Bui; Bircan Erbas; Melanie C Matheson; Lyle C Gurrin; John A Burgess; Adrian J Lowe; Mark A Jenkins; Michael J Abramson; E Haydn Walters; Graham G Giles; Shyamali C Dharmage Journal: J Allergy Clin Immunol Date: 2012-09-27 Impact factor: 10.793
Authors: Gillian S Dite; Lyle C Gurrin; Graham B Byrnes; Jennifer Stone; Anoma Gunasekara; Margaret R E McCredie; Dallas R English; Graham G Giles; Jennifer Cawson; Robert A Hegele; Anna M Chiarelli; Martin J Yaffe; Norman F Boyd; John L Hopper Journal: Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev Date: 2008-12 Impact factor: 4.254
Authors: Michael M Mendelson; Riccardo E Marioni; Roby Joehanes; Chunyu Liu; Åsa K Hedman; Stella Aslibekyan; Ellen W Demerath; Weihua Guan; Degui Zhi; Chen Yao; Tianxiao Huan; Christine Willinger; Brian Chen; Paul Courchesne; Michael Multhaup; Marguerite R Irvin; Ariella Cohain; Eric E Schadt; Megan L Grove; Jan Bressler; Kari North; Johan Sundström; Stefan Gustafsson; Sonia Shah; Allan F McRae; Sarah E Harris; Jude Gibson; Paul Redmond; Janie Corley; Lee Murphy; John M Starr; Erica Kleinbrink; Leonard Lipovich; Peter M Visscher; Naomi R Wray; Ronald M Krauss; Daniele Fallin; Andrew Feinberg; Devin M Absher; Myriam Fornage; James S Pankow; Lars Lind; Caroline Fox; Erik Ingelsson; Donna K Arnett; Eric Boerwinkle; Liming Liang; Daniel Levy; Ian J Deary Journal: PLoS Med Date: 2017-01-17 Impact factor: 11.069
Authors: Shuai Li; Ee Ming Wong; Minh Bui; Tuong L Nguyen; Ji-Hoon Eric Joo; Jennifer Stone; Gillian S Dite; Pierre-Antoine Dugué; Roger L Milne; Graham G Giles; Richard Saffery; Melissa C Southey; John L Hopper Journal: Int J Obes (Lond) Date: 2018-05-17 Impact factor: 5.095
Authors: Janine F Felix; Jonathan P Bradfield; Claire Monnereau; Ralf J P van der Valk; Evie Stergiakouli; Alessandra Chesi; Romy Gaillard; Bjarke Feenstra; Elisabeth Thiering; Eskil Kreiner-Møller; Anubha Mahajan; Niina Pitkänen; Raimo Joro; Alana Cavadino; Ville Huikari; Steve Franks; Maria M Groen-Blokhuis; Diana L Cousminer; Julie A Marsh; Terho Lehtimäki; John A Curtin; Jesus Vioque; Tarunveer S Ahluwalia; Ronny Myhre; Thomas S Price; Natalia Vilor-Tejedor; Loïc Yengo; Niels Grarup; Ioanna Ntalla; Wei Ang; Mustafa Atalay; Hans Bisgaard; Alexandra I Blakemore; Amelie Bonnefond; Lisbeth Carstensen; Johan Eriksson; Claudia Flexeder; Lude Franke; Frank Geller; Mandy Geserick; Anna-Liisa Hartikainen; Claire M A Haworth; Joel N Hirschhorn; Albert Hofman; Jens-Christian Holm; Momoko Horikoshi; Jouke Jan Hottenga; Jinyan Huang; Haja N Kadarmideen; Mika Kähönen; Wieland Kiess; Hanna-Maaria Lakka; Timo A Lakka; Alexandra M Lewin; Liming Liang; Leo-Pekka Lyytikäinen; Baoshan Ma; Per Magnus; Shana E McCormack; George McMahon; Frank D Mentch; Christel M Middeldorp; Clare S Murray; Katja Pahkala; Tune H Pers; Roland Pfäffle; Dirkje S Postma; Christine Power; Angela Simpson; Verena Sengpiel; Carla M T Tiesler; Maties Torrent; André G Uitterlinden; Joyce B van Meurs; Rebecca Vinding; Johannes Waage; Jane Wardle; Eleftheria Zeggini; Babette S Zemel; George V Dedoussis; Oluf Pedersen; Philippe Froguel; Jordi Sunyer; Robert Plomin; Bo Jacobsson; Torben Hansen; Juan R Gonzalez; Adnan Custovic; Olli T Raitakari; Craig E Pennell; Elisabeth Widén; Dorret I Boomsma; Gerard H Koppelman; Sylvain Sebert; Marjo-Riitta Järvelin; Elina Hyppönen; Mark I McCarthy; Virpi Lindi; Niinikoski Harri; Antje Körner; Klaus Bønnelykke; Joachim Heinrich; Mads Melbye; Fernando Rivadeneira; Hakon Hakonarson; Susan M Ring; George Davey Smith; Thorkild I A Sørensen; Nicholas J Timpson; Struan F A Grant; Vincent W V Jaddoe Journal: Hum Mol Genet Date: 2015-11-24 Impact factor: 6.150
Authors: Shuai Li; Ee Ming Wong; Minh Bui; Tuong L Nguyen; Ji-Hoon Eric Joo; Jennifer Stone; Gillian S Dite; Graham G Giles; Richard Saffery; Melissa C Southey; John L Hopper Journal: Clin Epigenetics Date: 2018-02-09 Impact factor: 6.551
Authors: Lucas Calais-Ferreira; Marcos E Barreto; Everton Mendonça; Gillian S Dite; Martha Hickey; Paulo H Ferreira; Katrina J Scurrah; John L Hopper Journal: Int J Epidemiol Date: 2022-10-13 Impact factor: 9.685