Xingchen Jiao1, Kai Zheng1, Zexun Hu1, Yongfu Sun1,2, Yi Xie1,2. 1. Hefei National Laboratory for Physical Sciences at Microscale, CAS Centre for Excellence in Nanoscience, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230026, China. 2. Institute of Energy, Hefei Comprehensive National Science Center, Hefei 230031, China.
Abstract
The poor conversion efficiency of carbon dioxide photoreduction has hindered the practical application at present, and one of the prime reasons for this obstacle is the inefficient solar energy utilization of photocatalysts. Generally speaking, it is contradictory for a photocatalyst to concurrently possess the broad-spectral response and appropriate band-edge positions for coinstantaneous carbon dioxide reduction and water oxidation. In this Outlook, we summarize a series of strategies for realizing visible-light and IR-light-driven carbon dioxide photoreduction under the guarantee of suitable band-edge positions. In detail, we overview the absorbance of visible light enabled by narrow band gaps in photocatalysts, the extended photoabsorption from UV into the visible light range induced by defect levels and dopant energy levels in photocatalysts, and a more negative conduction band and positive valence band acquired by Z-scheme heterojunctions in photocatalysts. Then, we highlight the expansive photoresponse of IR light caused by intermediate bands in semiconductor photocatalysts and partially occupied bands in conductor photocatalysts. Finally, we end this Outlook concerning more design strategies and application fields of broad-spectral-response photocatalysts.
The poor conversion efficiency of carbon dioxide photoreduction has hindered the practical application at present, and one of the prime reasons for this obstacle is the inefficient solar energy utilization of photocatalysts. Generally speaking, it is contradictory for a photocatalyst to concurrently possess the broad-spectral response and appropriate band-edge positions for coinstantaneous carbon dioxide reduction and water oxidation. In this Outlook, we summarize a series of strategies for realizing visible-light and IR-light-driven carbon dioxide photoreduction under the guarantee of suitable band-edge positions. In detail, we overview the absorbance of visible light enabled by narrow band gaps in photocatalysts, the extended photoabsorption from UV into the visible light range induced by defect levels and dopant energy levels in photocatalysts, and a more negative conduction band and positive valence band acquired by Z-scheme heterojunctions in photocatalysts. Then, we highlight the expansive photoresponse of IR light caused by intermediate bands in semiconductor photocatalysts and partially occupied bands in conductor photocatalysts. Finally, we end this Outlook concerning more design strategies and application fields of broad-spectral-response photocatalysts.
Anthropogenic emission
of excessive carbon dioxide (CO2) by the combustion of
fossil fuels has threatened the global climate
and human activity, while the continuous decrease of fossil fuels
has also resulted in the energy shortage.[1−4] In this respect, it is highly
desired to convert CO2 into high-value-added chemicals
for the purpose of simultaneous environmental protection and energy
regeneration. Compared with the thermocatalytic[5] and electrocatalytic[6] CO2 reduction, CO2 reduction driven by solar energy
is considered as the most competitive approach thanks to its outstanding
merits of nonpollution, inexhaustibility, and nonenergy inputs.[7,8] However, owing to the insufficient utilization of sunlight energy,
the previously reported photocatalysts usually suffer from very low
conversion efficiency, which restricts their widespread applications
in CO2 photoreduction.It is well-known that CO2 can be reduced into carbonaceous
fuels by the photoexcited electrons in the conduction band (CB), while
water (H2O) would be oxidized into oxygen (O2) by the photogenerated holes in the valence band (VB) of a photocatalyst
in the photocatalytic system of an aqueous solution or H2O vapor (Figure ).[9,10] That is to say, to successfully realize the CO2 photoreduction,
the CB position of the photocatalyst should be negative as compared
to the standard potentials of CO2 reduction (Table ); meanwhile, its VB position
should be positive as compared to the standard potential of H2O oxidation. However, there is commonly a tremendous conflict
between the sufficient sunlight energy utilization and the appropriate
band edge positions of a photocatalyst. In detail, as for the most
conventional wide-band-gap photocatalysts, their large band gaps enable
the CB and VB positions to simultaneously meet the redox potentials
of CO2 reduction and H2O oxidation, whereas
they can only absorb the UV light that accounts for ca. 5% of the
whole sunlight for CO2 photoreduction.[11] With regard to the narrow-band-gap photocatalysts, they
can utilize the visible light occupying ca. 43% of solar spectrum
for CO2 photoreduction;[12] however,
only few of the narrow-band-gap photocatalysts possess the suitable
band edge positions for coinstantaneous CO2 reduction and
H2O oxidation. More importantly, although some photocatalysts
with extremely narrow band gaps can absorb the IR light that occupies
ca. 52% of full sunlight, they have to photocatalyze CO2 into fuels with the aid of sacrificial agents because their band
edge positions are unable to simultaneously match the standard potentials
of CO2 reduction and H2O oxidation. That is
to say, the use of sacrificial agents can enable the occurrence of
CO2 photoreduction when the VB position of photocatalysts
is negative as compared to the standard potential of H2O oxidation, while it can also accelerate the separation rates of
electron–hole pairs and hence enhance the CO2 photoreduction
property.[13,14] However, the sacrificial agents are usually
costly and pollution-carrying; in addition, the presence of sacrificial
agents also leads to the complex photocatalytic system, which is detrimental
to exploring the internal mechanism of CO2 reduction. Therefore,
many strategies should be developed to obtain the broad-spectral-response
photocatalysts with befitting band edge positions, with efforts to
achieving efficient CO2 photoreduction in aqueous solutions
or H2O vapors without the usage of any sacrificial agent.
Figure 1
Scheme of the CO2 photoreduction over broad-spectral-response
photocatalysts.
Table 1
Standard Potentials
(V vs NHE) of
CO2 Reduction in Aqueous Solutions/H2O Vapors
at pH = 7
reduction potentials of CO2
E0 (V)
CO2 + 2H+ + 2e– → HCOOH
–0.610
CO2 + 2H+ + 2e– → CO + H2O
–0.530
2CO2 + 2H+ + 2e– → H2C2O4
–0.913
CO2 + 4H+ + 4e– → HCHO + H2O
–0.480
CO2 + 6H+ + 6e– → CH3OH + H2O
–0.380
CO2 + 8H+ + 8e– → CH4 + 2H2O
–0.240
2CO2 + 12H+ + 12e– → C2H4 + 4H2O
–0.349
2CO2 + 12H+ + 12e– → C2H5OH + 3H2O
–0.329
2CO2 + 14H+ + 14e– → C2H6 + 4H2O
–0.270
3CO2 + 18H+ + 18e– → C3H7OH + 5H2O
–0.310
Scheme of the CO2 photoreduction over broad-spectral-response
photocatalysts.Up to now, there have been many reviews focusing on the selection
of suitable photocatalysts and the possible catalytic mechanisms for
CO2 photoreduction.[15,16] However, there has
never been a systematic overview on how to promote the CO2 photoreduction property through the effective utilization of solar
energy. For that reason, herein, we first summarize a timely survey
on how to efficaciously utilize visible light and IR light for triggering
CO2 photoreduction. In other words, we overview the visible-light-driven
CO2 photoreduction realized by narrow-band-gap photocatalysts
with appropriate CB and VB positions. In addition, we outline that
the photoresponses for the photocatalysts with satisfied band edge
positions could be extended from UV into visible light regions by
introducing defect levels and dopant energy levels within the forbidden
band. Then, we review that more negative CB and more negative positiveVB
positions for simultaneous CO2 reduction and H2O oxidation could be acquired by establishing Z-scheme heterojunctions
in photocatalysts. Also, under the circumstance of meeting the theoretical
redox potentials of coinstantaneous CO2 reduction and H2O oxidation, we highlight that the photoabsorption of a semiconductor
photocatalyst could be expanded into the IR light range by the introduction
of an intermediate band, while we summarize that the IR light response
could be achieved by virtue of the possessive partially occupied band
of a conductor photocatalyst. Finally, we present a brief conclusion
and an outlook concerning more potential strategies for sufficiently
utilizing solar energy to realize CO2 photoreduction and
wider application fields of broad-spectral-response photocatalysts.
Strategies for Realizing Visible-Light-Driven
CO2 Reduction
As is well-known, the conventional
wide-band-gap photocatalysts
such as TiO2, ZnO, and ZrO2 normally have the
abilities for coinstantaneous photocatalytic CO2 reduction
and H2O oxidation thanks to their suitable CB and VB positions.[17,18] However, their large band gaps unfortunately limit the solar energy
utilization efficiency, which accounts for the low photocatalytic
activities. In this case, many strategies have been developed to expand
the photoabsorption of these wide-band-gap semiconductors from the
UV light into the visible light range under the situation of maintaining
their appropriate band edge positions, with effort to realizing the
visible-light-driven CO2 reduction into valuable fuels.
Visible-Light-Driven CO2 Reduction
Realized by Narrow-Band-Gap Photocatalysts
Given this aspect,
the narrow-band-gap semiconductors, possessing a visible light harvesting
ability as well as proper CBs and VBs, may be the potential photocatalysts
to realize visible-light-driven CO2 reduction (Figure A). To this end,
Yu et al. have fabricated the Eosin Y-functionalized conjugated organic
polymers (PEosinY-N, N = 1–3)
through the Sonogashira–Hagihara cross-coupling process, in
which the structural formulas for Eosin Y and aromatic alkynes of
A1, A2, and A3 are shown in Figure B.[19] As uncovered by the
UV–vis spectra in Figure B, all the PEosinY-N photocatalysts
displayed the visible light responses from 400 to 600 nm, while their
band structures in Figure C implied their capacities for simultaneously realizing CO2 reduction and H2O oxidation. Benefiting from the
narrow band gaps and the suitable CB and VB positions, all the PEosinY-N photocatalysts could achieve the photoreduction of CO2 into CO under visible light illumination (Figure D). Analogously, both the SnS2 atomic layers and CuIn5S8 single-unit-cell
layers with befitting CB and VB positions as well as intense visible
light absorption also exhibited the performances of CO2 reduction into CO under visible light irradiation.[20,21] As a result, developing more narrow-band-gap photocatalysts that
possess strong visible light absorbance and well-matched band edge
positions is the simplest and most effective strategy for realizing
visible-light-driven CO2 reduction over a single photocatalyst
without any sacrificial agent.
Figure 2
(A) Schematic illustrating the band structures
of narrow-band-gap
semiconductors for CO2 photoreduction. (B) UV–vis
spectra, (C) scheme of the band structures, and (D) CO and H2 yields for Eosin Y and PEosinY-N (N = 1–3). The inset in part B denotes the structural formulas
for Eosin Y and aromatic alkynes of A1, A2, and A3. Reproduced with
permission from ref (19). Copyright 2019 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
(A) Schematic illustrating the band structures
of narrow-band-gap
semiconductors for CO2 photoreduction. (B) UV–vis
spectra, (C) scheme of the band structures, and (D) CO and H2 yields for Eosin Y and PEosinY-N (N = 1–3). The inset in part B denotes the structural formulas
for Eosin Y and aromatic alkynes of A1, A2, and A3. Reproduced with
permission from ref (19). Copyright 2019 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Visible-Light-Driven CO2 Reduction
Induced by Defective Photocatalysts
To date, some works have
affirmed that the narrow-band-gap photocatalysts could realize visible-light-driven
CO2 reduction into carbon-based fuels, whereas the strict
standard of appropriate CB and VB positions immensely limits the selection
of narrow-band-gap photocatalysts. Recently, defect engineering has
been considered as a vigorous approach for realizing visible-light-driven
CO2 reduction. For instance, Shi et al. have demonstrated
that the introduction of nitrogen defects in graphitic carbon nitride
nanosheets could account for their expanded visible light absorption
and hence realized visible-light-driven CO2 reduction.[22] Also, Liu et al. have fabricated the oxygen-deficient
TiO2 nanocrystals with different exposed facets, and all
of them showed the increased visible light absorbance as compared
to the corresponding perfect TiO2 nanocrystals, thus achieving
a promoted performance of CO2 reduction under visible light
irradiation.[23] That is to say, as for the
wide-band-gap photocatalyst with satisfied band edge positions for
coinstantaneous CO2 reduction and H2O oxidation,
introducing a new defect level within their CB and VB levels could
expand its photoabsorption from the UV into the visible light region
(Figure A). Given
this, our group has created the oxygen vacancies on BiOBr atomic layers
by continuous UV illuminations, in which the BiOBr atomic layers with
the highest oxygen defect concentration were obtained after 480 min
of UV irradiation.[24] The UV–vis
spectra in Figure B illustrated that the created oxygen vacancies endowed the BiOBr
atomic layers with an intensified photoresponse in the visible light
region. In addition, the calculated density of states in Figure C revealed that introducing
oxygen vacancies in BiOBr atomic layers could lead to the generation
of some new defect levels within the CB and VB levels, which accounted
for the extended visible light absorbance and hence boosted the property
of visible-light-induced CO2 reduction into CO. Similarly
with the new defect levels aroused from defect engineering in photocatalysts,
the extra energy levels produced by dopants in photocatalysts could
also contribute to strengthening the visible light response of the
photocatalysts.[25,26] For example, Wang et al. reported
that introducing chromium (Cr) in mesoporousCeO2 (M-CeO2) photocatalysts resulted in the formation of a dopant energy
level within the band gap of CeO2 (Figure D).[27] Meanwhile,
UV–vis spectra in Figure E showed that the presence of the dopant energy level
enabled their visible light harvesting ability, thus exhibiting superior
CO and CH4 formation rates for visible-light-driven CO2 reduction relative to the M-CeO2 photocatalysts.
Consequently, the introduction of new levels in wide-band-gap semiconductors
could extend the photoabsorption from the UV light to visible light
region and hence realize visible-light-driven CO2 reduction.
Figure 3
(A) Schematic
illustrating the band structures of wide-band-gap
semiconductors with and without defects for CO2 photoreduction.
(B) UV–vis spectra for BiOBr atomic layers after UV illumination
for dozens of minutes. (C) Calculated density of states of oxygen-deficient
BiOBr atomic layers. Reproduced with permission from ref (24). Copyright 2018 John Wiley
& Sons, Inc. (D) Schematic illustrating the CO2 photoreduction
of mesoporous Cr-doped CeO2. (E) UV–vis spectra
for the M-CeO2, M-5CrCeO2, M-10CrCeO2, M-15CrCeO2, and M-20CrCeO2, in which M represents
mesoporous, and 5, 10, 15, and 20 represent the doping contents of
Cr (5%, 10%, 15%, and 20%). Reproduced with permission from ref (27). Copyright 2019 Elsevier.
(A) Schematic
illustrating the band structures of wide-band-gap
semiconductors with and without defects for CO2 photoreduction.
(B) UV–vis spectra for BiOBr atomic layers after UV illumination
for dozens of minutes. (C) Calculated density of states of oxygen-deficient
BiOBr atomic layers. Reproduced with permission from ref (24). Copyright 2018 John Wiley
& Sons, Inc. (D) Schematic illustrating the CO2 photoreduction
of mesoporous Cr-doped CeO2. (E) UV–vis spectra
for the M-CeO2, M-5CrCeO2, M-10CrCeO2, M-15CrCeO2, and M-20CrCeO2, in which M represents
mesoporous, and 5, 10, 15, and 20 represent the doping contents of
Cr (5%, 10%, 15%, and 20%). Reproduced with permission from ref (27). Copyright 2019 Elsevier.
Visible-Light-Driven CO2 Reduction
Realized by Z-Scheme Heterojunction Photocatalysts
Based
on the aforementioned analyses, it is still very challenging to construct
single-component photocatalysts with broad-spectral response and appropriate
band edge positions for CO2 photoreduction. Also, the single-component
photocatalyst usually suffers from the low separation efficiency of
electron–hole pairs, which causes damage on the photocatalytic
performances. In this respect, a Z-scheme system constructed by two
photocatalysts would help to concurrently address these two issues.[28,29] Compared with the conventional heterojunctions, the charge transfer
of a Z-scheme system undergoes a stepwise pathway. Taking the Cu2O/WO3 composite as an example,[30] the electrons can transfer from the CB of Cu2O to the CB of WO3 via the conventional mode under visible
light illumination. That would sacrifice their strong redox abilities
of charge carriers, which is detrimental to the CO2 photoreduction
(Figure A). By contrast,
the electrons can transfer from the CB of WO3 to the VB
of Cu2O via the Z-scheme mode (Figure B), which is not only conducive to acquiring
more negative CB and positive VB positions but also accelerating the
charge carrier separation efficiency. Besides, the transient photocurrent
responses in Figure C confirmed the lower charge-carrier recombination rate of Cu2O/WO3 Z-scheme composite as compared to that of
the single Cu2O or WO3 photocatalyst. Thanks
to the negative CB of Cu2O and the positive VB of WO3, the Cu2O/WO3 Z-scheme composite could
concurrently realize CO2 reduction into CO and H2O oxidation into O2 under visible light irradiation, whereas
there was no detectable product during the CO2 photoreduction
by the single Cu2O or WO3 photocatalyst. Similarly,
Bian et al. have reported that the zinc phthalocyanine/BiVO4 nanosheet (ZnPc/BVNS) Z-scheme composite can act as an effective
visible-light-response photocatalyst for CO2 reduction
into CO and CH4.[31] As shown
in Figure D, the photogenerated
electrons in the ZnPc/BVNS Z-scheme composite could transfer from
the CB of BVNS to the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) of
ZnPc under visible light illumination, which favored the carriers’
separation with respect to the BVNS photocatalyst, verified by the
surface photovoltage spectroscopy (SPS) in Figure E. Benefiting from the promoted carrier separation
efficiency, the ZnPc/BVNS Z-scheme composite exhibited higher CO and
CH4 formation rates for visible-light-driven CO2 reduction than the BVNS sample. Furthermore, Di et al. have fabricated
a Z-scheme g-C3N4/SnS2 photocatalyst that showed more excellent CH4 and CH3OH evolution rates than the single g-C3N4 or SnS2 photocatalyst,[32] while Wang et al. have prepared a Z-Scheme α-Fe2O3/Cu2O heterostructure, which also
achieved the property of CO2 reduction into CO under visible
light irradiation.[33] As a consequence,
building a Z-scheme heterojunction in photocatalysts can not only
contribute to obtaining more negative CB and positive VB
positions for realizing visible-light-driven CO2 reduction
but also enhance the carrier separation efficiency.
Figure 4
Schematic illustrating
the band structures and charge transfer
via (A) conventional mode and (B) Z-scheme mode in Cu2O/WO3-001 composites for CO2 photoreduction. (C) Transient
photocurrent responses of the Cu2O, WO3-001,
and Cu2O/WO3-001 Z-scheme composites, in which
WO3-001 represents WO3 with dominant (0 0 1)
facet. Reproduced with permission from ref (30). Copyright 2018 Elsevier. (D) Schematic illustrating
the band structures and charge transfer in the ZnPc/BVNS Z-scheme
photocatalyst for CO2 photoreduction, and (E) SPS spectra
for 1ZnPc/BVNS and BVNS, in which 1 is the mass ratio of ZnPc to BiVO4. Reproduced with permission from ref (31). Copyright 2019 John Wiley
& Sons, Inc.
Schematic illustrating
the band structures and charge transfer
via (A) conventional mode and (B) Z-scheme mode in Cu2O/WO3-001 composites for CO2 photoreduction. (C) Transient
photocurrent responses of the Cu2O, WO3-001,
and Cu2O/WO3-001 Z-scheme composites, in which
WO3-001 represents WO3 with dominant (0 0 1)
facet. Reproduced with permission from ref (30). Copyright 2018 Elsevier. (D) Schematic illustrating
the band structures and charge transfer in the ZnPc/BVNS Z-scheme
photocatalyst for CO2 photoreduction, and (E) SPS spectra
for 1ZnPc/BVNS and BVNS, in which 1 is the mass ratio of ZnPc to BiVO4. Reproduced with permission from ref (31). Copyright 2019 John Wiley
& Sons, Inc.
Strategies
for Realizing IR-Light-Driven CO2 Reduction
Many
researchers have already demonstrated that the photoresponse
of a photocatalyst could be expanded from the UV light to visible
light range for CO2 reduction,[34−36] whereas the
IR light that accounts for ca. 52% of the solar spectrum can not be
effectively utilized. This is mainly attributed to the fact that IR-light-response
photocatalysts normally possess extremely narrow band gaps, which
gives rise to the inapposite CB or VB position for coinstantaneous
CO2 reduction and H2O oxidation.
IR-Light-Driven CO2 Reduction Induced
by Intermediate-Band Photocatalysts
To solve the unsurmountable
contradiction between the effective utilization of IR light and the
performance of CO2 reduction, introducing an intermediate
band within the CB and VB of a semiconductor would be an efficient
strategy for gaining the IR light absorbance under the guarantee of
satisfying the theoretical redox potentials of CO2 reduction
and H2O oxidation (Figure A). Taking the oxygen-defective WO3 atomic
layers as an example,[37] the density functional
theory (DFT) calculations in Figure B disclosed that introducing a certain amount of oxygen
vacancies can lead to the generation of an intermediate band in WO3 atomic layers. Also, the synchrotron radiation photoelectron
spectroscopy (SRPES) valence-band spectra in Figure C unveiled that the introduction of oxygen
vacancies in WO3 atomic layers resulted in a peak located
at 0.63 eV, certifying the existence of intermediate bands in both
the oxygen-defective WO3 atomic layers. More importantly,
the UV–vis spectra in Figure D verified that the light responses of the Vo-rich (Vo refers to oxygen vacancies) and Vo-poor WO3 atomic layers were largely extended to visible
light even to IR light with respect to the WO3 atomic layers.
Benefiting from the efficient IR light harvesting caused by the defect-induced
intermediate band, both the Vo-rich and Vo-poor
WO3 atomic layers realized IR-light-driven CO2 reduction to CO, while the CO formation rate of the Vo-rich WO3 atomic layers was approximately 1.8 times higher
than that of the Vo-poor WO3 atomic layers.
Accordingly, the presence of intermediate bands induced by defect
engineering in photocatalysts could help to extend the photoresponse
into IR light region, thus effectively making use of IR light for
CO2 photoreduction.
Figure 5
(A) Schematic illustrating the band structure
of the intermediate-band
semiconductor for CO2 photoreduction, in which IB represents
the intermediate band. (B) Calculated band structure for the oxygen-defective
WO3 atomic layers slab, in which the concentration of oxygen
vacancies is ca. 7.3%. (C) SRPES valence-band spectra, and (D) UV–vis
spectra for Vo-rich WO3 atomic layers, Vo-poor WO3 atomic layers, and WO3 atomic
layers. Reproduced with permission from ref (37). Copyright 2018 Elsevier.
(A) Schematic illustrating the band structure
of the intermediate-band
semiconductor for CO2 photoreduction, in which IB represents
the intermediate band. (B) Calculated band structure for the oxygen-defective
WO3 atomic layers slab, in which the concentration of oxygen
vacancies is ca. 7.3%. (C) SRPES valence-band spectra, and (D) UV–vis
spectra for Vo-rich WO3 atomic layers, Vo-poor WO3 atomic layers, and WO3 atomic
layers. Reproduced with permission from ref (37). Copyright 2018 Elsevier.
IR-Light-Driven CO2 Reduction Realized
by Conductor Photocatalysts
Defective photocatalysts with
intermediate bands have been attested to successfully realize the
IR-light-driven CO2 reduction; however, the typical demerits
of these semiconductors including sluggish carrier mobility and limited
intrinsic carrier concentrations still lead them to suffer from the
poor carrier transfer efficiency and the slow redox reaction kinetics.
By contrast, conductor materials could be regarded as appealing photocatalysts
thanks to their extra-high carrier concentrations and electric conductivity,
which are approximately some orders of magnitude larger than those
of the traditional semiconductors.[38−40] More importantly, their
near-zero band gaps endow their broad photoresponse expanding to IR
light ranges, affording the prerequisite requirement for IR-light-driven
CO2 reduction. Furthermore, compared with the semiconductors,
the crucial partially occupied band in conductors also enables a transition
process to generate plentiful charge carriers to participate in CO2 photoreduction. As exhibited in Figure A, the transition process mediated by the
partially occupied band, such as the individual transition process
(I and II) and the sequential transition process (III and IV), can
not only ensure the IR light response but also endow the suited band
edge positions for coinstantaneous CO2 reduction and H2O oxidation.[41] To this end, our
group has fabricated the metallic CuS atomic layers, whose metallic
nature could be verified by the incremental electrical resistance
accompanied by increasing temperatures (Figure B), while their strong IR light response
was confirmed by UV–vis spectra in Figure C. Actually, the CuS atomic layers realized
IR-light-induced CO2 reduction into CO with an evolution
rate of 14.5 μmol g–1 h–1, whereas the CuS bulk did not show any IR-light-driven CO2 activity. This might be attributed to the fact that the CuS atomic
layers could undergo both the intraband and interband transition processes,
in which the electrons generated in the lowest unoccupied band (B1) could realize CO2 into CO under IR light illumination,
whereas the CuS bulk cannot acquire the interband transition from
the Fermi level in the CB to B1 band owing to their large
band gap. To further pursue other conductor photocatalysts for realizing
IR-light-driven CO2 reduction, our group also synthesized
the metallic CoN atomic layers,[42] whose
metallic character was affirmed by the incremental electrical resistance
accompanied by increasing temperatures and the density of states crossed
Fermi level in Figure D. Moreover, the UV–vis spectra in Figure E showed their effective IR light harvesting,
and hence, the CoN atomic layers also achieved the performance of
CO2 reduction into CO under IR light irradiation. On the
basis of the above analyses, the IR-light-response conductors are
the potential candidates for CO2 photoreduction.
Figure 6
(A) Schematic
illustrating the band structures of conductors, showing
several possible phototransition processes during CO2 photoreduction,
in which I and II represent the individual transition process, and
III and IV represent the sequential transition process, while B–1 and B1 are defined as the highest fully
occupied band and the lowest unoccupied band, respectively. (B) Temperature-dependent
resistivities for CuS atomic layers. (C) UV–vis spectra for
CuS atomic layers and CuS bulk. Reproduced with permission from ref (41). Copyright 2017 American
Chemical Society. (D) DFT calculations and (E) UV–vis spectra
for metallic CoN porous atomic layers. Reproduced with permission
from ref (42). Copyright
2020 Elsevier.
(A) Schematic
illustrating the band structures of conductors, showing
several possible phototransition processes during CO2 photoreduction,
in which I and II represent the individual transition process, and
III and IV represent the sequential transition process, while B–1 and B1 are defined as the highest fully
occupied band and the lowest unoccupied band, respectively. (B) Temperature-dependent
resistivities for CuS atomic layers. (C) UV–vis spectra for
CuS atomic layers and CuS bulk. Reproduced with permission from ref (41). Copyright 2017 American
Chemical Society. (D) DFT calculations and (E) UV–vis spectra
for metallic CoN porous atomic layers. Reproduced with permission
from ref (42). Copyright
2020 Elsevier.
Conclusion
and Outlook
In this Outlook, we summarize the strategies
for realizing visible-light-
and IR-light-driven CO2 photoreduction over broad-spectral-response
photocatalysts in aqueous solutions/H2O vapors without
using any sacrificial agent. For instance, we describe that the narrow-band-gap
PEosinY-N photocatalysts with befitting CB and VB
positions realize CO2 reduction into CO under visible light
irradiation. Also, we outline that the defect levels induced by oxygen
defects in BiOBr atomic layers and the dopant energy levels caused
by Cr dopants in M-CeO2 photocatalysts expand their photoresponses
from the UV light into visible light region and hence achieve visible-light-driven
CO2 reduction. Then, we see that more negative CB and positive
VB positions for simultaneous CO2 reduction and H2O oxidation as well as the accelerated charge carrier separation
efficiency are acquired by the establishments of Cu2O/WO3 and ZnPc/BVNS Z-scheme systems, which helps to enhance the
photocatalytic CO2 performance under visible light irradiation.
Moreover, under the guarantee of satisfied standard potentials for
CO2 reduction and H2O oxidation, we also review
that the intermediate band induced by oxygen defects in WO3 atomic layers leads to the expansive photoabsorption of IR light,
thus realizing IR-light-driven CO2 reduction; meanwhile,
we highlight that the partially occupied band in the conductor photocatalyst
of CuS atomic layers enables their strong IR light harvesting and
hence realize the property of CO2 reduction into CO under
IR light illumination.Although lots of enormous
breakthroughs have been made in CO2 photoreduction triggered
by wide-spectral-response photocatalysts,
there are still many strategies to be developed. For example, the
integration of plasmonic metals (Au, Ag, Cu, etc.) with the wide-band-gap
semiconductors may be an effectual strategy for realizing visible-light-
and even IR-light-driven CO2 reduction. This is mainly
ascribed to the fact that the hot-electron-injection effect caused
by localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) could lead to the transfer
of electrons from the Fermi level in plasmonic metals to the CB of
the semiconductors, thus extending their absorption spectrum range.
It is also worth expecting to combine the LSPR effect with the multiple
light scattering and reflecting effect in photocatalysts, which helps
to increase the efficient optical path-length of a photon and the
possibility of photoabsorption and hence boost the visible-light-
and IR-light-driven CO2 reduction. Moreover, the upconversion
nanomaterials, constructed by introducing some particular ions such
as Ln3+, Er3+, Yb3+, and Tm3+ ions into the wide-band-gap photocatalysts, may sufficiently make
use of the IR light for CO2 reduction. That is to say,
these particular ions could absorb the IR light and then emit the
UV or visible light to excite the wide-band-gap photocatalysts to
generate reductive electrons for CO2 reduction. Furthermore,
it is indispensable to deeply probe the internal mechanism for the
transition of photoexcited carriers by means of advanced characterization
technologies, which contributes to developing more new approaches
for achieving the extended photoresponse of photocatalysts. In this
respect, the ultrafast transient absorption spectroscopy could be
employed to explore the charge-carrier dynamics, which is closely
related to the photoabsorption and the band edge positions of photocatalysts.
More importantly, the theoretical prediction of wide-spectral-response
photocatalysts with appropriate band edge positions for CO2 photoreduction still remains in the infancy stage. In this case,
the machine learning technique would be a powerful tool to predict
the CB and VB positions as well as the light absorption capacity of
photocatalysts through regulating the calculation conditions and parameters.
With the help of the machine learning technique, one can highly efficiently
choose the potential wide-spectral-response photocatalysts to realize
CO2 photoreduction. Accordingly, it is believed that more
wide-spectral-response photocatalysts will be designed and fabricated
for CO2 reduction on the basis of some other novel and
yet-to-be discovered principles in the future. Last but not least,
the wide-spectral-response photocatalysts can not be just applied
in the field of CO2 photoreduction, but they can also be
utilized to enhance the efficiencies of other photocatalytic systems
including water splitting, pollutant degradation, nitrogen fixation,
and molecular activation.
Authors: Peipei Huang; Jiahao Huang; Sebastian A Pantovich; Alexander D Carl; Thomas G Fenton; Christine A Caputo; Ronald L Grimm; Anatoly I Frenkel; Gonghu Li Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2018-11-15 Impact factor: 15.419