Carol Sanchez1, Saamia Shaikh1, Brianna Dowd1, Radleigh Santos2, Mark McKenney1,3, Adel Elkbuli4. 1. Division of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery, Department of Surgery, Kendall Regional Medical Center, 11750 Bird Road, Miami, FL, 33175, USA. 2. Department of Mathematics, Nova Southeastern University, Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA. 3. University of South Florida, Tampa, FL, USA. 4. Division of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery, Department of Surgery, Kendall Regional Medical Center, 11750 Bird Road, Miami, FL, 33175, USA. Adel.Elkbuli@hcahealthcare.com.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Although safeguards requiring emergency care are provided regardless of a patient's payor status, disparate outcomes have been reported in trauma populations. The purpose of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to determine whether race/ethnicity or insurance status had an effect on mortality and to systematically present the literature in the adult and pediatric trauma populations during the last decade. METHODS: An online search of PubMed, Cochrane Library, Google Scholar, and SAGE Journals was performed for publications from January 2009 to March 2019. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guidelines were used. The GRADE Working Group criteria were utilized to assess the evidence quality. A meta-analysis was conducted to compare mortality between insured/uninsured and Caucasian/non-Caucasian patients. RESULTS: Our search revealed 680 publications that qualified for evaluation. Of these, 41 were included in the final analysis. Twenty-six studies included adults only, nine studies included pediatric patients only, and six studies evaluated both. Twelve studies evaluated the effects of race/ethnicity, 18 examined insurance status, and 11 investigated both. Uninsured patients had 22% greater odds of death than insured patients (OR 1.22; CI 1.21-1.24). Non-Caucasian patients had 18% greater risk of death than Caucasian patients (OR 1.18; CI 1.17-1.20). CONCLUSION: Both the adult and pediatric trauma populations suffer outcome disparities based on race/ethnicity and insurance status. Overall, patients without insurance coverage and minority groups (i.e., non-Caucasians) had worse outcomes, as measured by odds of death and all-cause mortality.
BACKGROUND: Although safeguards requiring emergency care are provided regardless of a patient's payor status, disparate outcomes have been reported in trauma populations. The purpose of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to determine whether race/ethnicity or insurance status had an effect on mortality and to systematically present the literature in the adult and pediatric trauma populations during the last decade. METHODS: An online search of PubMed, Cochrane Library, Google Scholar, and SAGE Journals was performed for publications from January 2009 to March 2019. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guidelines were used. The GRADE Working Group criteria were utilized to assess the evidence quality. A meta-analysis was conducted to compare mortality between insured/uninsured and Caucasian/non-Caucasian patients. RESULTS: Our search revealed 680 publications that qualified for evaluation. Of these, 41 were included in the final analysis. Twenty-six studies included adults only, nine studies included pediatric patients only, and six studies evaluated both. Twelve studies evaluated the effects of race/ethnicity, 18 examined insurance status, and 11 investigated both. Uninsured patients had 22% greater odds of death than insured patients (OR 1.22; CI 1.21-1.24). Non-Caucasian patients had 18% greater risk of death than Caucasian patients (OR 1.18; CI 1.17-1.20). CONCLUSION: Both the adult and pediatric trauma populations suffer outcome disparities based on race/ethnicity and insurance status. Overall, patients without insurance coverage and minority groups (i.e., non-Caucasians) had worse outcomes, as measured by odds of death and all-cause mortality.
Authors: Joshua B Brown; Mark L Gestring; Nicole A Stassen; Raquel M Forsythe; Timothy R Billiar; Andrew B Peitzman; Jason L Sperry Journal: Ann Surg Date: 2016-02 Impact factor: 12.969
Authors: Krista L Haines; Benjamin P Nguyen; Cory Vatsaas; Amy Alger; Kelli Brooks; Suresh K Agarwal Journal: J Surg Res Date: 2018-10-26 Impact factor: 2.192
Authors: Valerie K Scott; Zain G Hashmi; Eric B Schneider; Xuan Hui; David T Efron; Edward E Cornwell; Lisa A Cooper; Adil H Haider Journal: J Surg Res Date: 2013-05-21 Impact factor: 2.192
Authors: Brian R Englum; Xuan Hui; Cheryl K Zogg; Muhammad Ali Chaudhary; Cassandra Villegas; Oluwaseyi B Bolorunduro; Kent A Stevens; Elliott R Haut; Edward E Cornwell; David T Efron; Adil H Haider Journal: Am Surg Date: 2016-03 Impact factor: 0.688
Authors: Adil H Haider; Paul Logan Weygandt; Jessica M Bentley; Maria Francesca Monn; Karim Abdur Rehman; Benjamin L Zarzaur; Marie L Crandall; Edward E Cornwell; Lisa A Cooper Journal: J Trauma Acute Care Surg Date: 2013-05 Impact factor: 3.313
Authors: Caitlin W Hicks; Zain G Hashmi; Catherine Velopulos; David T Efron; Eric B Schneider; Elliott R Haut; Edward E Cornwell; Adil H Haider Journal: JAMA Surg Date: 2014-07 Impact factor: 14.766
Authors: Andrew J Kerwin; Elliott R Haut; J Bracken Burns; John J Como; Adil Haider; Nicole Stassen; Philipp Dahm Journal: J Trauma Acute Care Surg Date: 2012-11 Impact factor: 3.313
Authors: Harrison Dickens; Uma Rao; Dustin Sarver; Stephen Bruehl; Kerry Kinney; Cynthia Karlson; Emily Grenn; Matthew Kutcher; Chinenye Iwuchukwu; Amber Kyle; Burel Goodin; Hector Myers; Subodh Nag; William B Hillegass; Matthew C Morris Journal: J Racial Ethn Health Disparities Date: 2022-03-28
Authors: Emily Grenn; Matthew Kutcher; William B Hillegass; Chinenye Iwuchukwu; Amber Kyle; Stephen Bruehl; Burel Goodin; Hector Myers; Uma Rao; Subodh Nag; Kerry Kinney; Harrison Dickens; Matthew C Morris Journal: J Trauma Acute Care Surg Date: 2021-12-20 Impact factor: 3.697