| Literature DB >> 32337361 |
Françoise Remangeon1, Ghizlene Lahlou1, Lauranne Alciato1, Frederic Tankere1, Isabelle Mosnier1, Olivier Sterkers1, Nadya Pyatigorskaya2, Daniele Bernardeschi1.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the surgical results and complications in a cohort of patients operated on to repair a tegmen bony defect using either transmastoid approach with obliteration using S53P4 bioactive glass granules (TMA-O), or the classic middle cranial fossa approach (MCFA). STUDYEntities:
Keywords: bioactive glass; cholesteatoma; meningitis; meningoencephalocele; middle ear; tympanoplasty
Year: 2020 PMID: 32337361 PMCID: PMC7178447 DOI: 10.1002/lio2.374
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Laryngoscope Investig Otolaryngol ISSN: 2378-8038
Figure 1Intraoperative view of a right ear undergoing transmastoid obliteration repair of a large tegmen bony defect. A, Visualization of the edge of the bony defect (black line). B, A piece of cartilage (black star) is placed over the tegmen defect. C, Complete mastoid and epitympanic obliteration is then performed using S53P4 bioactive glass granules (black arrows)
Figure 2Repair of a tegmen bony defect in a right ear through a middle cranial fossa approach. A, After visualizing the bony defect (black arrow) and the meningoencephalocele (white arrow), reconstruction is performed with a shell of bone (black star in, B). B, The gap between the bony defect and the bone graft is sealed with bone dust (black arrow)
Figure 3A, Preoperative coronal high‐resolution CT (HRCT) image showing a large defect in the mastoid tegmen (black arrow) associated with a meningoencephalocele following multiple surgical procedures for cholesteatoma removal. This patient underwent surgery to repair a tegmen bony defect and rehabilitation of the canal‐wall‐down mastoidectomy using S53P4 bioactive glass granules. B, Postoperative HRCT image showed the stability of the reconstruction (white arrow) during the follow‐up
Patient demographics and characteristics
| TMA‐O (n = 17) | MCFA (n = 7) |
| |
|---|---|---|---|
| Age (years) | 49 ± 14 | 53 ± 17 | .568 |
| Sex (male) | 12 (71%) | 5 (71%) | .085 |
| Previous otologic surgery | .021 | ||
| 0 | 3 (18%) | 5 (71%) | |
| ≥1 | 14 (82%) | 2 (29%) | |
| Etiology | .259 | ||
| COM | 17 (100%) | 4 (57%) | |
| Idiopathic | 0 | 2 (29%) | |
| Post‐traumatic | 0 | 1 (14%) | |
| Preoperative PTA | |||
| AC‐PTA | 51 ± 19.3 | 45 ± 18.3 | .078 |
| BC‐PTA | 21 ± 11.8 | 26 ± 12.3 | .831 |
| ABG | 30 ± 12.8 | 19 ± 9.9 | .012 |
| Preoperative CT scan | 17 (100%) | 7 (100%) | |
| Size of the defect (mm) | 6 ± 3.8 | 6 ± 3.5 | .970 |
| Discontinuity of the ossicular chain | 15 (88%) | 1 (14%) | .001 |
| Preoperative MRI | 8 (47%) | 7 (100%) | |
| Cholesteatoma | 5 (29%) | 0 | .272 |
| Meningoencephalocele | 4 (50%) | 6 (86%) | .009 |
Abbreviations: ABG, air bone gap; AC‐PTA, air conduction pure tone average, BC‐PTA, bone conduction pure tone average; COM, chronic otitis media; MCFA, middle cranial fossa; PTA, pure tone average; TMA‐O, transmastoid approach with obliteration.
Student's t test.
Fisher's exact test.
ANOVA test.
Preoperative symptoms
| TMA‐O (n = 17) | MCFA (n = 7) |
| |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vertigo | 1 (6%) | 0 | 1 |
| Hearing loss | 17 | 5 (71%) | .076 |
| Otorrhea | 13 (76%) | 3 (43%) | .167 |
| Otalgia | 1 (6%) | 1 (14%) | .507 |
| Meningitis | 1 (6%) | 1 (14%) | .507 |
Abbreviations: MCFA, middle cranial fossa approach; TMA‐O, transmastoid approach with obliteration.
Per‐operative data
| TMA‐O (n = 17) | MCFA (n = 7) |
| |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tegmen bony defect location | |||
| Mastoid | 6 (35%) | 0 | .130 |
| Antri | 4 (24%) | 1 (14%) | 1 |
| Tympani | 5 (29%) | 0 | .272 |
| Tympani + antri | 0 | 5 (71%) | <.001 |
| Antri + mastoid | 2 (12%) | 1 (14%) | 1 |
| Size of the defect | .668 | ||
| >5 mm | 10 (59%) | 5 (71%) | |
| <5 mm | 7 (41%) | 2 (29%) | |
| Discontinuity of the ossicular chain | 15 (88%) | 1 (14%) | .001 |
| Cholesteatoma | 11 (65%) | 0 | .006 |
| Meningoencephalic herniation | 7 (41%) | 7 | .018 |
| CSF leak | 2 (12%) | 4 (57%) | .038 |
Abbreviations: CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; MCFA, middle cranial fossa approach; TMA‐O, transmastoid approach with obliteration.
The published articles most relevant to this study
| Source (date) | Number of cases | Etiology | Surgical approach | Recurrence | Complications | Follow‐up (months) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mosnier et al. (2000) | 15 |
COM 60% Cholesteatoma 33% Iatrogenic 7% |
CA 73% MCFA 27% | 0 | 0 | 24 |
| Hoang et al. (2005) | 30 |
Cholesteatoma 10% Traumatic 10% Spontaneous 80% |
CA 17% MCFA 83% | 1 CSF leak |
3 facial paralysis 4 wound infections | 8.5 |
| Bodénez et al. (2008) | 42 |
COM 24% Cholesteatoma 76% |
CA 67% MCFA 19% TMA 14% | 0 | 2 postoperative temporary CSF leaks | 43 |
| Sanna et al. (2009) | 133 |
COM 21.8% Iatrogenic 45.9% Traumatic 7.5% Spontaneous 24.8% |
CA 3% MCFA 27.8% MEO 41.4% TMA 27.8% |
1 CSF leak 2 MEH |
1 meningitis 1 extradural hematoma | 38.4 |
| Kari and Mattox et al. (2011) | 56 |
Iatrogenic 29% Traumatic 12% Spontaneous 59% |
CA 9% MCFA 7% MEO 9% TMA 75% | 1 CSF leak | 0 | 54 |
| Grinblat et al. (2018) | 262 |
COM + Cholesteatoma 47.7% Iatrogenic 20.9% Traumatic 8% Spontaneous 23.4% |
CA 1.9% MCFA 19.1% MEO 46.2% TMA 32.8% | 4 CSF leak 4 MEH |
3 persistent CSF leak 1 extradural hematoma 1 meningitis 1 profound hearing loss | 39.9 |
Note: None of published article described the obliteration technique in the management of a tegmen bony defect. Sanna et al4 and Grinblat et al12 used the middle ear obliteration technique (subtotal petrosectomy with blind sac closure of the external auditory canal) in a significant percentage of patients.
Abbreviations: CA, combined approach; COM, chronic otitis media; CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; MCFA, middle crania fossa; MEH, meningoencephalic herniation; MEO, middle ear obliteration; TMA, transmastoid approach.
Figure 4Management of a bony defect at the tegmen of the temporal bone. Proposed flow chart to decide on a surgical approach. MCFA, middle cranial fossa approach; TMA‐O, transmastoid approach with obliteration using S53P4 bioactive glass granules