| Literature DB >> 32265893 |
Maria Hoffmann1, John Miller2, David Melka1, Marc W Allard1, Eric W Brown1, James B Pettengill2.
Abstract
The largest outbreak of Salmonella Agona in the United States occurred in 1998. It affected more than 400 patients and was linked to toasted oat cereal. Ten years later, a similar outbreak occurred with the same outbreak strain linked to the same production facility. In this study, whole-genome sequence (WGS) data from a set of 46 Salmonella Agona including five isolates associated with the 1998 outbreak and 25 isolates associated with the 2008 outbreak were analyzed. From each outbreak one isolate was sequenced on the Pacific Biosciences RS II Sequencer to determine the complete genome sequence. We reconstructed a phylogenetic hypothesis of the samples using a reference-based method for identifying variable sites. Using Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) analyses, we were able to distinguish and separate Salmonella Agona isolates from both outbreaks with only a mean of eight SNP differences between them. The phylogeny illustrates that the 2008 outbreak involves direct descendants from the 1998 outbreak rather than a second independent contamination event. Based on these results, there is evidence supporting the persistence of Salmonella over time in food processing facilities and highlights the need for consistent monitoring and control of organisms in the supply chain to minimize the risk of successive outbreaks.Entities:
Keywords: PacBio; SNP analyses; Salmonella; dormancy; outbreak; whole genome sequencing
Year: 2020 PMID: 32265893 PMCID: PMC7104706 DOI: 10.3389/fmicb.2020.00478
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Microbiol ISSN: 1664-302X Impact factor: 5.640
Isolates information for the Salmonella Agona included in this study.
| CFSAN000449 | 1999 | United States | Cattle | N/A | N/A | 454 FLX | 4.9 | AYDT00000000 |
| CFSAN000451 | 2005 | United States | Soybean meal | JABX01.0050 | N/A | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYCL00000000 |
| CFSAN000452 | 2008 | United States | Environmental | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0339 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYDF00000000 |
| CFSAN000453 | 2008 | United States | Environmental | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYDE00000000 |
| CFSAN000454 | 2008 | United States | Environmental | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYDD00000000 |
| CFSAN000455 | 2008 | United States | Environmental | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYDC00000000 |
| CFSAN000456 | 2008 | United States | Environmental | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0338 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYDB00000000 |
| CFSAN000457 | 2008 | United States | Environmental | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | MAOW00000000 |
| CFSAN000458 | 2008 | United States | Environmental | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.6 | LXTN00000000 |
| CFSAN000459 | 2008 | United States | Environmental | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | LYVG00000000 |
| CFSAN000460 | 2008 | United States | Environmental | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | LXTO00000000 |
| CFSAN000461 | 2008 | United States | Environmental | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | MAOV00000000 |
| CFSAN000462 | 2008 | United States | Environmental | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | MAOU00000000 |
| CFSAN000463 | 2008 | United States | Environmental | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0341 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | MAOT00000000 |
| CFSAN000470 | 2008 | United States | Cereal | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYDH00000000 |
| CFSAN000471 | 1998 | United States | Cereal | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0013 | Pacbio | 4.7 | CP015024 |
| CFSAN000472 | 2008 | United States | Puffed wheat cereal | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYCS00000000 |
| CFSAN000473 | 2008 | United States | Puffed wheat cereal | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYCR00000000 |
| CFSAN000474 | 2008 | United States | Puffed rice cereal | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYCQ00000000 |
| CFSAN000475 | 2008 | United States | Puffed rice cereal | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYCP00000000 |
| CFSAN000476 | 2008 | United States | Puffed rice cereal | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0340 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYCO00000000 |
| CFSAN000477 | 2008 | United States | Puffed rice cereal | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | Pacbio | 4.7 | CP011259 |
| CFSAN000481 | 2008 | China | Mussels | JABX01.0556 | N/A | 454 FLX | 4.8 | AYCW00000000 |
| CFSAN000482 | 2009 | China | Baby clams | no pulsenet # associated | N/A | 454 FLX | 5.0 | AYCV00000000 |
| CFSAN000486 | 2007 | Mexico | Herbal tea | JABX01.0225 | N/A | 454 FLX | 4.8 | AOZV00000000 |
| CFSAN000501 | 2008 | United States | Clinical | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYDV00000000 |
| CFSAN000502 | 2008 | United States | Clinical | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYDW00000000 |
| CFSAN000503 | 2008 | United States | Clinical | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0035 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYDX00000000 |
| CFSAN000504 | 1998 | United States | Cereal | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYDK00000000 |
| CFSAN000505 | 1998 | United States | Cereal | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0013 | 454 FLX | 4.7 | AYDL00000000 |
| CFSAN003041 | 2008 | United States | Puffed rice | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | Miseq | 4.7 | SRR949597 |
| ERR178928 | 2005 | Ireland | Environment | AgoX63 | N/A | Hiseq 2000 | 4.8 | CARE01000001 |
| ERR178921 | 1987 | Austria | Clinical | AgoX76 | N/A | Hiseq 2000 | 4.8 | CARL01000001 |
| ERR178919 | 2008 | Scotland | Clinical | SAGOXB.0066 | N/A | Hiseq 2000 | 4.8 | CARN01000001 |
| ERR178910 | 2008 | Ireland | Pork | SAGOXB.0066 | N/A | Hiseq 2000 | 4.7 | CARV01000001 |
| ERR178902 | 2009 | Ireland | Environment | AgoX67 | N/A | Hiseq 2000 | 4.8 | CASB01000001 |
| ERR178895 | 2002 | Germany | Aniseed | SAGOXB.0010 | N/A | Hiseq 2000 | 4.8 | CASH01000001 |
| ERR178894 | 2000 | Scotland | Clinical | SAGOXB.0020 | N/A | Hiseq 2000 | 4.8 | CASI01000001 |
| ERR178887 | 2008 | United States | Clinical | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | Hiseq 2000 | 4.8 | CASO01000001 |
| ERR178886 | 2008 | United States | Clinical | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | Hiseq 2000 | 4.7 | CASP01000001 |
| ERR178885 | 1998 | United States | Clinical | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | Hiseq 2000 | 4.8 | CASQ01000001 |
| ERR178878 | 2003 | Germany | Fennel | SAGOXB.0002b | N/A | Hiseq 2000 | 4.8 | CASW01000001 |
| ERR178871 | 2006 | Ireland | Poultry | SAGOXB.0066 | N/A | Hiseq 2000 | 4.7 | CATD01000001 |
| ERR178861 | 2005 | Ireland | Clinical | AgoX3 | N/A | Hiseq 2000 | 4.9 | CATP01000001 |
| ERR178884 | 1998 | United States | Toasted oats cereal | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0001 | Hiseq 2000 | 4.8 | CATX01000001 |
| SL 483 | 2003 | United States/WI | Clinical | JABX01.0001 | JABA26.0005 | 3730xl DNA analyzer | 4.8 | CP001138 |
FIGURE 1Circle plot showing the similarity between three closed Salmonella Agona isolates associated with the cereal outbreaks. The reference Salmonella Agona CFSAN000477 is associated with the 2008 outbreak, Salmonella Agona CFSAN000471 is associated with the 1998 outbreak and Salmonella Agona SL483 is associated with a sporadic case in 2003.
FIGURE 2Phylogenetic reconstruction of the 46 Salmonella Agona isolates investigated herein. The tree was constructed from a SNP matrix obtained with the CFSAN SNP Pipeline within which the isolate Salmonella Agona SL483 was used as the reference. The program GARLI v2.01.1067 was used to infer the tree. The heatmap to the right is ordered according to the tips of the tree and shows the pairwise SNP distances among isolates (e.g., the first two columns and last two rows represent the two most basal isolates in the tree that are very different from all other isolates but similar to one another).
FIGURE 3A minimum spanning network constructed with popArt (http://popart.otago.ac.nz/) showing the genetic similarity among 46 Salmonella Agona isolates. Input for the network was the SNP matrix constructed with the CFSAN SNP Pipeline. Edge labels represent the number of SNP differences between nodes.
FIGURE 4Histogram showing the counts of mutations found within each protein type (COG category) between the outbreak clade and all samples.