| Literature DB >> 32257161 |
Beniamino Cislaghi1, Ann M Weber2, Geeta Rao Gupta3, Gary L Darmstadt4.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Women's and men's health outcomes are different. Some differences are biological, related to male and female sex, while others are related to their gender. Sex- and gender-related issues require different solutions, but policy makers lack straightforward heuristic strategies to identify gender-related health inequities.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32257161 PMCID: PMC7101083 DOI: 10.7189/jogh.10.010701
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Glob Health ISSN: 2047-2978 Impact factor: 4.413
Figure 1Top-15 disability-adjusted life year (DALY) causes with the largest female:male ratio (15-49 years).
Figure 2Top-15 disability-adjusted life year (DALY) causes with the largest male:female ratio (15-49 years).
A hypothesis of whether causes of DALY disproportionately affecting women and men are primarily driven by sex, gender, or both
| Cause of DALY | Primary driver of the disparity | Example from the literature |
|---|---|---|
| Breast cancer | Sex | “In the case of cancer it is obvious that only men can get prostate cancer and breast cancer occurs predominantly in women” [ |
| Rheumatoid Arthritis | Sex | “RA is a heterogeneous disease with variations in phenotype. Sex-associated factors influence disease severity as well as disease pattern” [ |
| Headache disorders | Both or currently difficult to assess | “The nature of women’s pain experiences, their involvement in multiple role responsibilities, and differences in coping strategy utilization likely affect some of the observed sex and gender differences in perception of and responding to pain” [ |
| Depressive disorders | Both or currently difficult to assess | “Generally, only limited evidence exists for gendered risk factors to be specific for depression [but] findings from cross-national studies suggest a temporal trend of a converging gender gap in depressive disorders in countries with less traditional gender roles” [ |
| Trachoma | Gender | “Women and girls are the primary caregivers in most societies in developing countries. Proximity to children exposes women to repeated infection more than men and is likely a primary reason for the greater effect of active disease” [ |
| Eating Disorders | Gender | “Eating disorders are more prevalent in the female because more of them are dieting to lose or control weight. Their greater dysphoria, poorer self-image and body concept, and role confusion during adolescence also appear to contribute to the risk of developing an eating disorder because these factors intensify their pursuit of thinness” [ |
| Mesothelioma | Sex | “The differential expression of steroid hormone receptors between sexes … may be suspected to play a role in the cancer biology of peritoneal mesothelioma” [ |
| Bladder Cancer | Sex | “Difference in bladder cancer incidence is independent of differences in exposure risk … the activity of the sex steroid hormone pathway may play a role in bladder cancer development, with demonstration that both androgens and estrogens have biologic effects in bladder cancer in vitro and in vivo” [ |
| Gout | Both/Difficult to assess | “Gouty arthritis occurs more frequently in men at younger ages than in women and is regarded as a result of interplays between genetic, metabolic, and environmental factors.” [ |
| Autism spectrum disorders | Both/Difficult to assess | “Accurate and early diagnosis of autism in both sexes is essential, not only for understanding sex differences in ASD, but also for providing appropriate resources and services. Accurate diagnosis and identification of autism-like features is also necessary for lifelong support of women whose impairments may be traditionally under recognized. These advancements will require further research and scientific study” [ |
| Interpersonal Violence | Gender (sex might predispose men) | “Physical dominance and violence are easily accessible resources for structuring, negotiating and sustaining masculinities, particularly among men who because of their social positioning lack less dangerous means” [ |
| Alcohol use disorders | Gender (Sex disadvantages women) | “Presented review of the contemporary evidence supports the presence of both gender- and sex-related differences in alcohol use… Gender-specific differences in alcohol consumption … are driven by … perceived differences in traditional gender roles in different countries and among different generations… Differences in alcohol consumption, elimination, and distribution volume, result in higher blood alcohol concentrations in women, which also tend to persist longer compared to men” [ |
DALY – disability-adjusted life year
Figure 3Female:Male disability-adjusted life year (DALY) ratio for eating disorders.
Figure 4Male:Female disability-adjusted life year (DALY) ratio for road injuries.